The Diversity Project: Accelerating progress towards an inclusive culture in the investment and savings industry

By Steve Butler

Diversity is not only our social obligation. It is a business imperative.

In early 2016, a group of leaders in the investment and savings profession met and concluded that future success for their clients, members, employers and shareholders requires a diverse and inclusive culture and that the sector was lag

• Language: English
• Publisher: Steve Butler
• Release date: Mar 30, 2021
• ISBN: 9781914078927

Book preview

The Diversity Project

Accelerating progress towards an inclusive

culture in the investment and savings industry

Steve Butler

Copyright © 2021 by Steve Butler

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in any form of retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means without prior permission in writing from the publishers except for the use of brief quotations in a book review.

In early 2016, a group of leaders in the investment and savings profession met and concluded that future success for their clients, members, employers and shareholders requires a diverse and inclusive culture, and that the sector was lagging behind others in reflecting our society.

That led to the creation of The Diversity Project: a cross-company initiative whose purpose is to champion and accelerate progress towards a more inclusive culture. This book recounts the progress made to date, discusses the progress that still needs to be made and sets out practical ways to achieve it.

The Diversity Project Manifesto

We believe that we have an extraordinary opportunity to press the reset button in our industry: to recruit, nurture and retain the first truly diverse generation of investment and savings professionals.

That generation will themselves perpetuate diversity in our industry; we are looking to break one cycle and create another. If we are successful:

Our businesses will better reflect both society at large, and the individuals who trust us with their money.

Our people will create better financial outcomes to benefit our diverse savers and investors.

We will attract more interest in the industry, with a pipeline of diverse talent.

Diversity is not only our social obligation. It is a business imperative.

All the interviews for this book were conducted in the spring and early summer of 2020. For the most recent developments by the Diversity Project please visit www.diversityproject.com

Foreword

by Baroness Helena Morrissey DBE

Five years ago, the Diversity Project set out to achieve what seemed quite a simple ambition: to accelerate progress towards a more inclusive culture and greater diversity of talent in the rather traditional asset management industry. It’s been quite a journey already! And it’s now abundantly clear that the mission is not so simple after all. Culture is hard to change and diverse talent is hard to recruit and retain.

At the same time the case for a more modern, more diverse investment industry has never been stronger or more accepted. It’s now widely acknowledged that we need diversity of thought to reach the right answers to complex problems and diversity of talent to connect better with clients and future proof the industry. Over 70 firms, 40 partner organisations and 400 people are committed to the Project, including thirty CEOs who form the Diversity Project’s Advisory Council.

And momentum is building.  Awareness of the issues facing Black, other ethnic minority, LGBTQ+ and neurodiverse investment professionals is higher than ever, with networks and mentoring circles created and flourishing. Firms have come together to diversify their early careers recruitment via the Investment Industry Springboard, as well as supporting after-school clubs for disadvantaged and ethnically-diverse students. The cross-company Returners programme is attracting hundreds of applicants each year from those (mainly women) who have left the industry and are seeking to return. We are well on our way to reaching the goal of 1000 LGBTQ+ role-models and allies throughout the industry. And we’ve been sharing best practice and developing guidance for inclusive recruitment, smart working, line management, allyship and building back more equally post-COVID.

The pandemic has created both opportunities and threats for diversity and inclusion efforts but with our lives turned upside down and working practices changed overnight, there is now a bigger moment to seize. With the scale of participation and level of commitment, I feel more optimistic than ever that we can and will continue to make progress. 

I’m incredibly grateful to Steve Butler for taking the time to compile this book to showcase the Diversity Project’s efforts to date. You’ll read the personal stories of many of the leaders involved in the Project, which bring the issues alive. Their practical suggestions will help you if you’re considering either a similarly comprehensive project or narrower efforts to address specific areas of diversity. You’ll get a sense of the breadth of the Project – we are tackling every dimension of diversity and at all career stages. You’ll see that the actions are mounting up. This is a work-in-progress but a great lesson in how a group of people determined to make change are making it happen.

I hope you enjoy reading it and seeing how much more can be achieved over the next five years!

Best wishes, Helena

Contents

Foreword

Chapter 1 Introduction

Sarah Bates

Jane Welsh

Alexandra Haggard

Helena Morrissey

Chapter 2 Gender Equality

Helena Morrissey

Chapter 3 Ethnicity

Gavin Lewis

Chapter 4 Age Diversity

Shruti Khandekar and Emma Douglas

Claire Black and Sascha Calisan

Chapter 5 Neurodiversity

Meike Bliebenicht

Chapter 6 LGBT+

Colette Comerford and Matt Cameron

Chapter 7 Disability

Katy Halliday

Tim Roberts

Subira Jones

Chapter 8 SMART Working

Ana Maria Tuliak

Emma Stewart

Chapter 9 Harnessing the data

Jo Livermore

Chapter 10 The Asset Owners perspective

Helen Price

Chapter 11 Build Back Better

Jayne Styles

Chapter 12 Call to Action

Linda Russheim

Appendix The Diversity Project Charity

About the Author

Chapter 1

Introduction

As an industry, the investment and savings industry is not representative of the population as a whole. In London, where the majority of fund managers are based, 18.5% of the population is Asian and 13.3% is black. Yet, in the fund management industry, 10% of individuals identify as Asian and only 1% identify as black.

While female employment rates across the board in the UK are not that far behind their male counterparts (72.4% in October - December 2019 compared with 80.6%¹), the proportion of female fund managers in the UK has stubbornly hovered around 10% over the past four years - and just 4% of money managed is run exclusively by women.

That pay gap between men and women within fund management is actually the second largest of any sector in the UK, with only investment banking registering worse figures.

Despite all of the educational, demographic, social and cultural shifts we have witnessed in recent years, for anyone to rise to the top in the financial services sector it remains far more difficult if you do not come from a narrow band of the population: white males, privately educated and from a select group of Universities.

Why does this matter?

Apart from the inequality of opportunity and unfairness this represents, it means that the sector is missing out on a huge talent pool, one that offers the life experiences and cognitive diversity that can tap more directly into the way other parts of the population live and think. That diversity of thinking can not only help businesses design new products and services which better meet the needs and ambitions of their clients; it also allows the industry as a whole to meet challenges in a way less hidebound by the group think that – arguably – led to the worst excesses of the last financial crisis.

Then we must look at the compelling fact that every business has to concern itself with where the next generation of talent is going to come from. In my 2019 book Manage the Gap², I set out some of the many ways in which younger people coming into businesses or rising through the ranks see the world very differently than previous generations.

They increasingly demand equality of opportunity - regardless of background, gender, ethnicity, disability, or orientation. They expect to be allowed to strike a work/life balance that allows them to have a family and a personal life. They want the company they work for to embody ideals and social purpose that align with their own. And, if the employer they are with can't deliver that, they will take their talents elsewhere.

If the investment and savings sector fails to woo today’s graduates, where will tomorrow’s leaders come from?

Investors and clients – who are increasingly global – also expect the people who manage their money to have socially fair work practices in place, and to reflect themselves and the world they live in. The days when investors were primarily white males from a wealthy background, comfortable with someone who echoed their own background to handle their business, are long gone.

The solution?

So, what is the investment and savings industry doing to ensure they keep pace with the progress we are seeing in the rest of society, and that the sector is fit for purpose for the future?

In early 2016, a group of leaders in the investment and savings profession recognised that future success for their clients, members, employers, and shareholders requires an inclusive culture and decided to take action to accelerate progress towards this.

That initiative led to the Diversity Project which has since made huge strides in raising awareness of the issues and galvanising support for their aims. However, as this book makes clear, there is still a long way to go.

By exploring the Diversity Project and offering practical ways forward, the purpose of this book is to provide helpful guidelines on how senior and middle managers, if they are genuinely intent on making their businesses more diverse and inclusive, can establish and foster a culture that will make sure that (like the lettering in a proverbial stick of rock) everyone within the company is on-board with the mission of being truly diverse and inclusive.

The book is based upon the vision of the Diversity Project, which was set up specifically to address the challenges I listed above and grounded on the powerful personal stories and experiences of some of those leading the various workstreams.

The Founders

The Diversity Project did not spring fully-formed out of the ground: it was forged by the experiences of a small group of people who were determined to make sure that life as part of a minority group would be easier for the next generation than it was for them. And while its roots were in gender diversity, it soon became something far wider-reaching. I asked Jane Welsh, Sarah Bates, Alexandra Haggard, and Helena Morrissey what inspired them to found the Diversity Project. Here are their stories.

Sarah Bates

"I still think we’re not great at working out how different people can contribute to a group and tend to be rather conformist when recruiting new people, making it harder for some to break through. In part, and this is the bit that worries me, as we have tried to make the process more objective, we have given recruitment some systematic bias."

— Sarah Bates

I’m a Manchester girl. I went to State school – although it was a direct grant Grammar School – and then Cambridge. In 1980, when I graduated, there were very few jobs going. But it was just at the time when UK brokers were looking for research analysts. No one in my family had ever worked in anything to do with finance but it sounded interesting, and off I went.

I got a job as an analyst at a firm called Simon & Coates, at the time when Gavyn Davie was the Economist there. It was one of the early research-based firms, and guess what they asked me to do? Food retailing. I moved over to fund management in 1982, to what was the National Provident Institution.

Interestingly, when I joined, there were no established career paths in the broking, savings, and investment business… it was rather more eccentric than that; less stratified. You didn't have to have read the city pages of whatever newspaper from the age of 12, have had work experience in lots of grand firms, or have joined the City Club at University. So, arguably, in some ways, it was more open to certain groups than it later became.

The Mercer survey³, which looked at diversity within