This Week in Asia

<![CDATA[Explained: Talks at the Trump-Kim summit 2019 collapsed, so what comes next?]>

The much-anticipated second summit between US President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un was cut short on Thursday with no agreement on denuclearisation, sanctions relief, or peace on the Korean peninsula.

It was a high-stakes meeting for Trump who aimed to get Kim to give up Pyongyang's nuclear arsenal, after critics panned the first summit in Singapore for yielding few results.

But talks in Hanoi collapsed as Pyongyang wanted international sanctions lifted entirely, Trump said.

At a Thursday afternoon meeting with media, he said it was better to "do it right, rather than do it fast".

The chemistry and the place. Both men exchanged smiles, handshakes and pleasantries and promised a "great" outcome when they first met on Wednesday night.

No details of a possible agreement were given but the White House released Trump's schedule late on Wednesday. It showed he would have a one-on-one meeting with Kim at 9am local time, followed by an expanded bilateral meeting at 9.45am, then a working lunch at 12pm local time, a signing ceremony at 2.05pm and a press conference at 3.50pm.

The talks in Hanoi also allowed Trump to use Communist-ruled Vietnam " one of the world's fastest growing economies that expanded by 7 per cent last year " as an example of how North Korea could thrive if it gave up its nuclear missiles.

The first inkling that things were not going smoothly came when the Thursday morning one-on-one meeting ended 10 minutes ahead of schedule. At the second meeting with aides, Trump emphasised there wouldn't be immediate results. Kim, in a rare response to Western reporters, said he would not be in Hanoi if he was not willing to denuclearise. He added: "Can you give us more time [to ourselves]? Even one minute is very important."

Then came a string of updates " first, that lunch was delayed, then cancelled, along with the signing ceremony. White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders then told reporters Trump's press conference would be rescheduled to start two hours earlier at 2pm local time. She later released a statement to say no agreement had been reached.

At the press briefing, Trump insisted the lack of a deal at the "productive" summit did not mean he was on bad terms with Kim.

"I think the relationship is very warm," he said. "And when we walked away, it was a very friendly walk."

Kim Jong-un returning empty-handed from Hanoi wouldn't serve his interests, said Lami Kim, a former South Korean diplomat now teaching at the University of Hong Kong.

North Korean media reports in the run-up to the talks anticipated sanctions relief and "it is hard to believe that [they] asked for full sanctions relief, because I am sure they understand that the US would never have accepted it," she said.

Talks in Hanoi collapsed as Pyongyang wanted international sanctions lifted in their entirety, Trump said. Photo: AP

The North Korean delegation attempted to seize back the narrative on Thursday when they called a rare, late-night press briefing.

Foreign Minister Ri Yong Ho contradicted Trump, saying Pyongyang had made "realistic proposals" and sought only to partially lift sanctions that were hurting its economy and people's livelihood.

Vice-Foreign Minister Choe Son Hui said Kim Jong-un "got the feeling that he didn't understand the way Americans calculate".

Choe added Kim Jong-un "may have lost the will" to negotiate with Trump after the US side rejected a partial lifting of sanctions in return for destruction of the Yongbyon nuclear complex that has nuclear reactors and uranium enrichment facilities.

It was "something we had never offered before", she said.

But on Friday, the North's North's official KCNA news agency described the Hanoi meeting as "successful" and said Kim had promised Trump another encounter.

US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, on his way to the Philippines from Hanoi, said both sides could hold further meetings though there was no plan to do so immediately.

"My sense is it will take a little while. We'll each need to regroup a little bit. But I'm very hopeful that Special Representative [Stephen] Biegun and that team will get together before too long."

" Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) March 1, 2019

He added that both sides had made progress and hoped they could "take another big swing" when the leaders got together.

"But we didn't get as far as we would have hoped ..." he said.

Michael Madden, a North Korea expert at the Washington-based Stimson Centre, suggested that within a month or two, Biegun and his North Korean special envoy counterpart Kim Hyok-Chol, could meet again.

Trump said there were no plans for a third summit but said he was positive there would be a "good outcome" in future.

Experts are doubtful about the prospects for a third summit but agreed both sides would likely continue negotiations to narrow their differences.

Additional reporting by wire agencies and John Power

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2019. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from This Week in Asia

This Week in Asia5 min read
Philippines' Marcos Jnr Has Been Rebranding Himself As A Human Rights Supporter. Is It Working?
Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jnr's efforts at rehabilitating his family image and rebranding himself as more pro-human rights than his predecessor look to be paying off, after Time magazine included him in its list of 100 Most Influential Pe
This Week in Asia4 min readPolitical Ideologies
Indonesia's Prabowo To 'Expand Wings Of Coalition' With 'Attractive Offers' To Former Rivals
After being certified the winner of Indonesia's February 14 polls, president-elect Prabowo Subianto is expected to spend the next few months trying to persuade former rivals to join his political coalition, although a few parties have already indicat
This Week in Asia6 min read
Daigou Were Once 'Make-or-break' For Australian Brands In China - Where Are They Now?
The power of the daigou, personal shoppers for Chinese consumers, was on full display in a recent class-action lawsuit launched against the a2 Milk company, one of New Zealand's biggest milk exporters. Disgruntled shareholders sued the listed company

Related Books & Audiobooks