The Independent Review33 min read
The Political Economy of Rising Defense Costs
Defense costs in the United States have been on the rise for the past several decades. The price index used to measure defense costs has outpaced inflation in the overall economy (as measured by the GDP deflator) by a factor of 1.3 from 1947 to 2020.
The Independent Review8 min read
"For a New Liberty" after Fifty Years
When For a New Liberty was published in 1973, it soon became one of the key books of the libertarian movement, and it has retained this status ever since. Why is this so? The principal reason is that Murray Rothbard, the book’s author, set forward in
The Independent Review4 min read
Better Money: Gold, Fiat, or Bitcoin?
By Lawrence H. White New York: Cambridge University Press, 2023. Pp. xi, 236. $29.95 paperback. Larry White has written another fine book on monetary economics. Better Money would make a great textbook for an advanced undergrad or master’s class and
The Independent Review22 min read
Seeing The State Through "For A New Liberty"
The central chapter of Murray Rothbard’s For a New Liberty is “The State.” The central moment of that chapter is when Rothbard tells us that “if you wish to know how libertarians regard the State and any of its acts, simply think of the State as a cr
The Independent Review14 min read
"Time On The Cross" At Fifty
A strong case can be made that the golden age for the discipline of economic history occurred in the third quarter of the twentieth century, and that the ultimate manifestation of its importance in the world of ideas and the broader society came with
The Independent Review19 min readAmerican Government
Conservation, Ecology, and Growth in "For a New Liberty"
Published in 1973, Murray Rothbard’s For a New Liberty is one of the earliest and most influential attempts to provide a comprehensive theoretical and philosophical basis for libertarianism. Rothbard worked to apply the principles he outlined to a wi
The Independent Review4 min read
The Monetarists: The Making of the Chicago Monetary Theory Tradition, 1927–1960
By George S. Tavlas Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2023. Pp. xviii, 632. $50 hardcover. There has been a longstanding debate about the existence of a “Chicago school” of economics that emphasizes free markets and limited government (Steven G.
The Independent Review16 min read
Privatize the Public Sector: Murray Rothbard’s Stateless Libertarian Society
Murray Rothbard’s For a New Liberty, originally published in 1973, remains one of the most significant books on libertarianism, in large part because he explains how market institutions can replace everything government does, and do it better. After
The Independent Review7 min readPolitical Ideologies
Following Their Leaders: Political Preferences and Public Policy
By Randall G. Holcombe New York: Cambridge University Press, 2023. Pp. xv + 200. $34.99 paperback. Some scholars criticize the Public Choice approach for being too pessimistic about government (generally) and democracy (in particular). But James Buch
The Independent Review6 min readDiscrimination & Race Relations
Out Of The Melting Pot, Into The Fire: Multiculturalism In The World’s Past And America’s Future
By Jens Heycke New York: Encounter Books, 2023. Pp. xi, 271. $30.99 paperback. Jens Heycke’s Out of the Melting Pot, into the Fire tells a story of human suffering and survival that I’ll never forget: a woman survives the Rwandan genocide, and yet to
The Independent Review12 min read
A Vision of a Productive Free Society: Murray Rothbard’s "For a New Liberty"
As Robert Higgs (1995) explained, revolutionaries “need to understand the nature of the beast they aim to bring down, but they need inspiration, too, because lovers of liberty seek not just to destroy unjustified state power but to build a productive
The Independent Review21 min read
Libertarianism, Oversimplified
Fifty years since its initial publication, Murray Rothbard’s For a New Liberty continues to have a transformative impact on readers. For many, the book produces a complete paradigm shift in their thinking about politics. Starting with just a few basi
The Independent Review11 min readWorld
Concepts before Measurement: A Rejoinder to Ryan Murphy on the Developmental State
Ryan Murphy, who is a coauthor of the Economic Freedom of the World (EFW) index, through the use of statistical and quantitative evidence, insists that Singapore does not exhibit a high degree of state intervention, either when “developmental state c
The Independent Review15 min readCrime & Violence
Murray Rothbard on War and Foreign Policy
For Murray Rothbard, matters of war and foreign policy are central to a free society of equal people. These issues are important because they influence the existence, or absence, of individual autonomy and peaceful social cooperation, both domestical
The Independent Review14 min read
Yoram Barzel: Property Rights, Political Economy, and the Reorganization of Economic Analysis
It is a distinct privilege, yet one taken with deep regret, to honor the economist Yoram Barzel, who died on December 22, 2022. His impact as both teacher and scholar has been felt by the generations of students who have learned from his work, includ
The Independent Review38 min readFinance & Money Management
What Is in the Federal Reserve’s Doomsday Book?
The Doomsday Book is a collection of documents and memoranda compiled by the legal department of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRBNY). The book focuses on financial crises that have prompted an operational response such as emergency loans and
The Independent Review10 min read
The Rival Definitions of Economic Recession: Resolved
This definition captures the generic concept of recession, as applied to any variable or parameter, any quantity, aggregate, or magnitude, economic or otherwise. For many years, including the entire memory of almost everyone reading this piece, there
The Independent Review6 min readHistory & Theory
The Individualists: Radicals, Reactionaries, And The Struggle For The Soul Of Libertarianism
By Matt Zwolinski and John Tomasi Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2023. Pp. x, 416. $35 hardcover. The Individualists is a work of academic philosophy at once remarkably ambitious and highly accessible. Seasoned academics and general aud
The Independent Review45 min readPolitical Ideologies
The East Asian Challenge for Market Liberalism: Toward a Hayekian Context-Sensitive Response
One of the most significant episodes in recent history is the rapid economic growth of East Asian nations in the late twentieth century. Considered alongside Japan and China, the four “tiger economies” of South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Singapore
The Independent Review18 min readWorld
Singapore’s Small Development State
In this issue Bryan Cheang, writing within a lengthy tradition of scholarship, objects to the description of various East Asian success stories, especially Singapore, as exemplars of liberalism. No one within Singapore views Singapore as an especiall
The Independent Review14 min readInternational Relations
Interpreting Atomic Bomb History: A Response to Bernstein
Barton J. Bernstein is a giant on the subject of the atomic bombing of Japan. Any author who receives a lengthy critical reply from this eminent scholar must be honored and nervous at the same time. With all due respect, however, Bernstein’s reply do
The Independent Review10 min read
The Classical Liberal Diaspora
We’ll commence with an Old Testament reading, from the “Book of the Prophet Deneen.” As Deneen (2018, xiii) put it: This is simply wrong, though in an interesting way. In fact, classical liberals have been cast out of their traditional kingdom, which
The Independent Review11 min read
Smith And Cicero On Philosophy In Action
A lthough he is most often regarded as the father of modern economics, Adam Smith’s first work was on moral philosophy. Published in 1759, The Theory of Moral Sentiments centers on the theme of human interaction in society, specifically on what actio
The Independent Review38 min readPoverty & Homelessness
War and European Welfare Exceptionalism
Social scientists have long vied to explain America’s relatively low level of public spending on the welfare state (publicly financed cash and in-kind benefits for citizens) as an aberration from a supposedly high European norm. Many have argued that
The Independent Review42 min read
The Fable of Shareholder Environmental Activism by Government Pensions
Government (public) pensions in the US owned $2.3 trillion in listed equities in 2022.1 The investment rationale for owning equities—the higher expected return arising from the greater uncertainty of equity owners being the residual claimants of comp
The Independent Review43 min read
Interpreting Atomic Bomb History: A Reply to Fuller’s “An Economic Case against the Atomic Bombing of Japan”
Seventy-eight years after the 1945 atomic bombings, Edward Fuller (2023) has offered a new interpretation to contend that the bombing was unnecessary. His is a worthy purpose, and a difficult task. He assembles considerable economic and military data
The Independent Review12 min read
Hayek: A Life, 1899–1950
By Bruce Caldwell and Hansjoerg Klausinger Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2022. Pp. vi, 804. $50 hardcover. Biographies of economists are still rare, especially compared with monographs about them. For F. A. Hayek we could already rely on Cald
The Independent Review28 min readWorld
The Market Process as Nonviolent Action
Market process theory explores the sequence through which the knowledge and expectations of economic actors lead toward coordination and cooperation (Mises [1920] 1935, [1949] 1996; Hayek 1948; Kirzner 1973, 1992, 1997; Boettke and Prychitko 1998). N
The Independent Review35 min read
An Economic Case against the Atomic Bombing of Japan
On August 6, 1945, the government of the United States dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima, Japan. The bomb killed sixty-five thousand Japanese instantly. Another sixty-five thousand inhabitants of Hiroshima perished in the following months. On Augus
The Independent Review23 min readCrime & Violence
Tyranny Reverse Engineered
Pacifists, who oppose the use of deadly force as a means of dispute resolution, have often been caricatured as laughably unrealistic. It seems a matter of common sense to many people that nonviolence is weaker, and therefore less effective, than viol
…Or Discover Something New