The Wrong Twin

By Nikki Hall

Jed meets Anna at the department store that he works at. A week later her twin sister Karen starts working there as well. They're both beautiful and Jed is keen for a date. It's only after he manages a date that he hears from a friend that one of the twins is sexually adventurous while the other is the exact opposite. What happens when you're dating the wrong twin? Should he break up with the conservative twin to pursue the other? Or perhaps things will work out in ways that he never considered possible.

Another hot and exciting tale from Nikki Hall. This one will keep you reading to the end and aroused for the entire journey!

• Language: English
• Publisher: Nikki Hall
• Release date: Dec 20, 2017
• ISBN: 9781370036134

Nikki Hall

Nikki is an Australian author of erotica and aims to provide stimulating, exciting erotica for your pleasure.

Book preview

The Wrong Twin

Nikki Hall

Copyright

2017

License Notes

This ebook is licensed for your personal enjoyment only.

This ebook may not be re-sold or given away to other people. If you would like to share this book with another person, please purchase an additional copy for each recipient. If you’re reading this book and did not purchase it, or it was not purchased for your use only, then please purchase your own copy. Thank you for respecting the hard work of this author.

~~~~~~~

All sexually active characters in this work of fiction are aged 18 years or over

~~~~~~~

Dude, you realise you’re dating the wrong twin, don’t you? Mark said to his friend with a laugh.

What do you mean? Jed asked in surprise.

You seriously don’t know the rumours about the Aspell twins? Mark asked incredulously.

No, I haven’t heard anything at all, Jed replied.

He’d met Anna at his part time job working in a department store. He’d been working there for a while before she’d started. She was gorgeous, and had caught his eye before they’d even been introduced. Once he had been introduced, he’d found excuses to pass through the women’s clothing section where she worked just so he’d have the chance to say hi.

A month after Anna had started, he’d been surprised to find her working in the kitchenware department.

Hey Anna, have they moved you already? he asked.

He received a surly look in return.

I’m not Anna, she replied and clearly his confusion showed on his face. The girl he’d thought was Anna gave a hefty sigh. Sorry, I’m Karen, the girl clarified. I’m Anna’s twin. I kind of knew I’d have to expect some confusion when I agreed to work in the same store as my sister, but every now and then it gets the better of me.

Well, I’m sorry for the mistake, Jed replied, I’ll do my best not to mix you up again.

It’s really okay, Karen replied, now with a friendly smile, You’re not the first and you won’t be the last. It goes with the territory, and I’ve been living with it all my life. I guess I’m a slow learner.

Well, I’d appreciate it if you didn’t hold it against me, Jed replied. He couldn’t believe the hottest girl to start working in the store since he’d been there turned out to have a twin! It doubled the eye candy.

It had taken him another four months to finally ask one of the twins out, and he’d been surprised when Anna said yes. He’d flirted with them both over the intervening time, especially after being asked to attend their joint eighteenth birthday party, which had been a blast. Though there were too many people there to spend much time with either of the girls. Finding the courage to ask one of them out had taken a bit longer. He’d been getting along almost equally well with both, but in the end decided Anna was the one he'd ask out. He’d known her that little bit longer, and there seemed to be just a bit more of a spark between them.

He’d been dating Anna for two weeks, and then Mark had sprung this odd conversation on him.

So what rumours am I supposed to have heard? Jed asked Mark.

So, legend has it …

Legend? Okay, just how full of shit are you? Jed laughed.

Oh, come on, give a guy some poetic license, Mark whined. "Legend has it that as hot and identical as the Aspell twins are, there’s a right one and a wrong one to date. The bards tell us that one of them is a prude and the other has, ever since her eighteenth birthday, experimented with all sorts of wild and kinky sex. Of course that one would be Karen, not Anna. So you’re dating the wrong twin: you should have gone for Karen."

Well I can’t exactly say the sex side of things was a consideration when I was thinking about asking one of them out, Jed laughed. Besides, no matter who’s calling themselves a bard, rumours are just that, and I’ll wait for the truth rather than worry about some third-party speculation.

Well I don’t suppose you get a second shot once you’ve asked one of them out anyway, Mark laughed, So you’re just going to have to hope you can talk your way into the pants of the one you picked.

You’re all class, Mark, Jed dismissed him with a shake of his head.

~~~~~~~

Months later Jed sat at the breakfast bar of the Aspell house, waiting. He’d tried to sleep in, but it wasn’t working. There weren’t any signs of life from the rest of the house, and he hadn’t come up with anything better to do. After all, it wasn’t even his house; he’d stayed the night at Anna’s. The fact that even though her parents were away he’d spent the night in a room by himself, left him thinking back to the conversation he’d had with Mark all those months ago.

The reality was that Anna was amazing to be with, but she was also ultra conservative, just like Mark had reported from his bard’s rumours. Most of the time it didn’t worry him, but every now and then it gnawed.

You’re up early. He turned to see a complete vision, but it wasn’t Anna. After dating Anna for a while he’d learned to tell the twins apart at a glance, but that didn’t stop him staring as Karen walked into the kitchen. Like Anna, she was petite with lustrous brown hair that cascaded almost to her waist. She met his gaze with her sparkling, teasing brown eyes. Her eyes didn’t manage to hold his gaze though. She strolled into the kitchen wearing a stomach-baring white tank top and a pair of black panties that were a cross between a bikini and a thong and she was clearly braless. While neither of the twins were well-endowed, the shape of her hard nipples was well evident through the thin t-shirt, and there was just enough jiggle to give Jed thoughts he probably shouldn’t be having about his girlfriend’s twin.

She walked up to the fridge, opened the door and bent over to retrieve the milk from its bottom shelf. She didn’t bend her knees and Jed found himself staring directly at her ass. The black lacy underwear exposed more of her butt than he’d ever managed to see of Anna’s in all the months they’d been dating. He knew he shouldn’t look, but he couldn’t tear his gaze away.

Want some breakfast? Karen asked, turning to face him and placing the milk on the breakfast counter between them.

Thanks. Whatever you’re having should work, he replied. She gave him a grin that stirred his loins, then turned to the pantry. She had to reach up on tiptoes to pull the cereal out, and Jed again stared at the perfection being presented to him. Her buttocks were like two halves of a perfect peach; tight, round and wonderfully shaped with the bottom seams of her underwear cutting midway across each cheek. He couldn’t help imagining how good they’d feel in his hands. As she pulled the box out, he quickly looked elsewhere before she turned around, not wanting to be busted checking her out. His cock was already reacting more than he wanted her to know about.

Karen poured him a bowl of cereal, then passed him the milk so he could top it off. He munched away, and Karen stood on the other side of the counter, eating from her own bowl.

So did you sleep well? she asked.

Yeah, I did thanks, he replied.

Did my prude of a sister actually make you sleep in the spare room?

Jed blushed and mumbled a noncommittal response.

Oh my God, she’s so mean! Karen laughed. You poor thing. I hope she at least offered you some relief before she sent you away?

Karen, I’m not going to answer that, Jed laughed. If Anna chooses to talk to you about her private stuff that’s fine, but I’m not going to be the one to tell you.

Karen just laughed in response. You’re so cute when you blush, you know.

Hey, how are you both? Anna asked, walking into the kitchen from the hall.

Excellent thanks, Baby, Jed replied, standing up from his stool to greet his girlfriend. Unlike her sister, she was dressed conservatively in a pair of track pants and a t-shirt. She obviously was wearing a bra. Jed sighed. The contrast between the two sisters wasn’t always obvious, but over the months he’d been dating Anna it had become evident more frequently. The current situation, sleeping arrangements and dress code, were just the latest examples.

What the hell are you wearing? Anna asked when she walked around to the side of the counter where Karen was standing.

Pyjamas, Karen replied as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.

You’re half naked. In front of my boyfriend! Anna accused.

"Oh pulease, like he’s seeing anything he hasn’t seen before," Karen replied.

"What’s that supposed to mean?" Anna asked.

Duh, like we’re twins? Like if he’s seen you naked, he’s basically seen me naked too, Karen explained.

Yeah, right. I’m pretty sure that even though we basically look the same, that doesn’t count, Anna said with a loud sigh and matching eye-roll.

Jed just sat quietly watching the two sisters as they worked through their different approaches to life. Again.

I don’t see what you’re worried about, it’s not like I was trying to pick him up or anything, I just offered him some breakfast.

Well maybe next time you could at least dress properly. I mean would you dress like this in front of Dad?

Oh God, fine! Karen said, clearly exasperated. She stormed from the room. "Just to keep your prudish sensibilities in check, I’ll put on some damn clothes!"

God, can you believe her? Anna asked, turning on her boyfriend.

Jed diplomatically said very little and let Anna have her rant until she redirected her aggression toward wolfing down her breakfast.

Once he thought she’d wound down sufficiently, he asked her, So what would you like to do today? in an attempt to change the direction of the conversation.

I don’t know, is there something you’d like to do? she asked.

Maybe the beach? Jed suggested.

That sounds like fun, Anna replied with a smile. Let’s do it. They finished breakfast and were packing the dishes away when Karen returned to the room in a pair of athletic tights and a more modest t-shirt. Jed couldn’t help but note she was also wearing a bra.

Happy? she asked her sister as she twirled to display her outfit.

Yes, thank you and, um, I’m sorry, Anna replied. She stood up and embraced her sister. I kind of over-reacted, didn’t I?

I’ll let it slide, but only because you’re mostly okay, Karen teased. I mean besides, we have that whole boyfriend pact thing, remember?

Boyfriend pact? Jed asked.

Yeah, we always used to watch whatever TV shows or movies we could that featured twins, and on one show we stumbled across this idea that twins should never fight over a guy. I think the original concept was that if two twins both liked a guy neither of them would date him, and that way they wouldn’t ever fight, Anna explained.

But we thought it was stupid, Karen cut in seamlessly. "Like, why should we both miss out on some cute guy? So we made up our own version."

If we both like a guy, then it’s simple: the first one of us he asks out gets to keep him, Anna laughed.

So if Karen had liked me and I’d asked her out … Jed started.

"Then Anna would be in my position and you’d be my boyfriend," Karen replied.

So, has it ever been an issue? Jed asked. Like have you ever found yourselves competing against each other to be the first one someone asks out?

Not really, Anna told him. So far, as much as we may have initially thought the same guys were cute, when it’s come down to actual interest, we tend to prefer different people, so it’s been good.

Oh, well, that’s cool then, Jed replied.

What are you two up to today? Karen asked as Anna and Jed started out of the kitchen to get ready for the beach.

We’re headed to the beach; want to come with? Anna replied.

"God yes! That sounds awesome compared with hanging here all day. I’ll get changed and be with you in a sec.

You two sure make up easy, Jed noted to Anna as he sat on her bed waiting for her to collect her things for the beach.

Yeah, well it’s always been like that I guess, she replied. I don’t know if it’s a twin thing or just us, but we fire up fast, then get over it quickly as well. And she was right, the fact she doesn’t mind standing half dressed in front of you isn’t worth my getting all shitty over. As long as I don’t catch you getting any dumb ideas!

Hey, I don’t think I’d ever be brave enough to get between the two of you in a full-on fight, Jed replied.

Good; let’s keep it that way, Anna told him, softening the statement by leaning in to kiss him. Jed slid his hand up the back of her neck beneath her long brown hair and gently massaged the nape before stroking down to her waist.

You two need a room? Karen asked, coming into Anna’s room.

Naah, got one thanks, wanna watch? Anna answered and gave Jed another long, lingering kiss just to tease her twin.

The three teenagers climbed into Jed’s car and he drove them to the beach via his parents’ house, so he could grab swimmers and a towel.

I can’t wait to feel the sun on my body, Karen said happily as Jed pulled the car into a parking space on the esplanade.

You and me both, Anna agreed. They walked down to the sand, at which point Anna asked Jed to carry her across the strip of soft dry sand she knew was going to be searing hot.

And me! Karen quickly added even as she’d been about to step out onto the beach. Jed hunched over slightly and stood ready, and Anna moved behind him and leapt onto his back so he could piggy-back her. She clung to him lovingly and he walked across the sand, trying desperately to act stoic and manly even though the sand was invading his flip-flops and scorching his feet. He kept speeding up, walking faster and faster until he finally reached the safety of the wetter, cooler, compacted sand closer to the waterline. He deposited his girlfriend and turned to look reluctantly back toward Karen who stood waiting.

I should make her burn her own feet, he suggested to Anna.

Yeah, but then she’d be all shitty for the rest of the afternoon and besides, I know you’re too nice to abandon her like that.

With a reluctant sigh Jed took off his flip-flops so he could run across the sand to where Karen stood waiting.

My hero! she greeted him happily as he stood hopping from foot to foot on the grass, cooling his soles.

Yeah, well consider yourself lucky, ‘cause that sand is bad, he laughed. He dropped his flip-flops back on the grass and stepped into them. Karen jumped on his back as her sister had done, and Jed warned her to hold on.

Ooh, nice arms, she said teasingly, running a hand over one bicep while she held onto his chest with the other.

Hey, that’s not holding on, Jed objected, and threatened to drop her. She obediently wrapped the second hand around his chest and he hurried back across the hot sand as quickly as he could manage. As soon as he’d deposited Karen next to her twin he dashed down to the water and stood with his feet in the shallows for a few moments to cool them before heading back up to where the girls were laying out their towels.

Both girls were wearing cut-off denim shorts and light over-shirts, which they immediately removed. As Jed stood watching them undress, he was reminded once again of the difference in their approaches to life. Anna bent over, slid her shorts down and stepped out of them, straightening to look out over the water.

Damn she looks hot, Jed thought to himself as he admired her. Her one-piece swimsuit was pale blue with a tropical flower motif. The legs weren’t particularly high cut, the neckline conservative and even the back covered more than half of her skin. She saw him looking, and smiled. He returned her grin, ran over and took her in a hug. As he held her, he looked over her shoulder at Karen.

Karen’s swimwear was a total contrast. She wore a bright pink string bikini. The bottoms were a Brazilian cut that bared even more of her ass than her panties had done earlier in the day. As she bent to adjust her towel the bikini pulled up into the crack of her butt, and Jed had to look away before the sight gave him an erection.

Time for sunscreen, Anna announced.

Bugger that, I want a tan, Karen replied.

Well my skin has only two shades, burnt and pale, so it’s sunscreen for me, Jed replied, pulling his t-shirt off over his head.

Well, you two have fun feeling each other up while I go hit the water, Karen said, bounding down to the surf. Jed had to very deliberately avoid watching the spectacular sight of her departing body.

Wanna go first? Jed asked Anna.

Sure, she replied with a smile. Jed had her lay down on the towel on her stomach, and squirted some sunscreen on the exposed skin of her back. He was finished in short order, and couldn’t help thinking it would have been a different story if he’d been applying it to Karen’s back.

Legs too? he offered.

Of course, Anna replied. He moved down adjacent to her legs, and briefly wished he could kneel between them to apply the cream. He drizzled a run of the white sunscreen down the middle of each leg and enjoyed the resulting squirm as Anna complained about how cold it was.

Relax, you big baby, he said and gently spanked her butt.

Hey! she said, swiping awkwardly at his hand. He let her be and rubbed the cream into her legs. When he started to approach the hemline of her swimwear, she told him he could stop there and she’d take care of the last bit.

Really? It’s okay, I’m more than happy to do it, he replied. He stared at the line the cloth of her swim suit cut across her skin, wanting to touch as close to her ass and pussy as he could.

No, I’ll do it, she insisted, turning over and sitting up. He bit back his frustration even as his burgeoning erection abandoned its endeavours. He couldn’t believe it! He was kind of okay with the no sex thing; after all, he respected her decision to wait until she felt ready, but he’d be a lot happier if he were allowed to touch her even a little bit more intimately, or if she’d just give him a hand job or something once in a while. Most of the time he was okay with it, but some days when his balls were aching he really struggled.

Jed took the sunscreen and rubbed it over his own arms, legs and chest and then asked Anna to do his back for him. The feel of her hands on his back was awesome, and his cock hardened even though she wasn’t touching him anywhere intimate. He knew he should have taken a moment that morning to jack off just for the relief, but now he was going to have to live with it.

Time for a swim, I reckon, he announced when she let him know she was done.

Yes indeed, she replied happily, completely oblivious to the challenge he faced and the effect she was having on him. They headed down to the water together, where Karen was sitting in the shallows, looking out to sea.

How’s the water? Jed asked.

Great, once you get past the initial shock, Karen replied.

Well I’m buggered if I’m taking it slow, Jed said and ran into the water, splashing madly until it was deep enough for him to dive under the surface. He leapt up again, gasping and hollering in glee. He turned back to see Anna inching her way into the water.

Oh come on, don’t be a wuss, Jed called back to her.

I’ll do this in my own time, thank you very much, she replied in prissy tones. Jed spied Karen sneaking up behind her and briefly considered calling out a warning. He decided against it, and instead enjoyed the squeals of outrage and shock that resulted from Karen jumping on her sister’s back and riding her until she overbalanced and they both tumbled into the water. The two girls emerged sputtering and laughing, and Jed was relieved to see Anna taking it well. He went and joined the girls, taking opportunities to enjoy the visual spectacle as they presented themselves. They all played about in the water, and every now and then their boisterous fun would threaten to rip Karen’s bikini from her body. She was constantly retying the straps, much to Anna’s amusement.

Told you you should have invested in something more sensible, Anna teased her.

Yeah, but not all of us like walking around on the beach dressed like old maids, Karen returned.

Are you kidding me? Jed stepped in, turning on Karen. Old maid? Have you seen how fucking hot she looks?

My hero! Anna declared and jumped into her boyfriend’s arms and stuck her tongue out at her sister.

Of course she’s fucking hot, she looks just like me, Karen retorted. I’m just saying if she showed a bit more skin it would be even better. For a start I bet you’d be busting out of your shorts.

Um, yeah, right, so as long as we all agree my girlfriend is a goddess, we needn’t speculate about anything happening in my shorts, Jed joked. He found his mouth suddenly occupied as his goddess kissed him passionately. Unfortunately that caused him to lose his balance and they toppled into the water together.

You two are hopeless, Karen teased, splashing them further as they