Cook's Illustrated

A New Way with Lemonade

When I was a kid, my family made lemonade the old-fashioned way: We fetched a small cardboard canister from the freezer, peeled away the plastic tab, pried off the lid, and squeezed until a semisolid cylinder of concentrate dropped into the waiting pitcher with a satisfying schloop. After whisking in three cans’ worth of water, we were ready to pour it over ice and enjoy.

I was nearly an adult before I learned that there are methods for making lemonade that involve fresh fruit, and that good from-scratch versions boast a sweet-sour balance and faint bitterness that make lemonade not just refreshing but also complex. But until recently, I’d never made a batch that delivered on that nuance. Most of my previous attempts tasted either one-dimensional or excessively bitter.

It wasn’t until I literally took apart a lemon and tasted each component that I understood what accounts for the Goldilocks balance I sought (turns out there’s some

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Cook's Illustrated

Cook's Illustrated5 min read
Equipment Corner
The ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE is our favorite instant-read digital thermometer. Its backlit display, durable construction, and quick and accurate temperature readings make it a reliable choice for any cooking project. ThermoWorks also sells the Therm
Cook's Illustrated8 min read
The Fruit-Lover’s Cream Cake
This is the story of two cakes that have long been beloved in East Asian baking traditions—and how I merged those traditions into an airy, downy-soft, cream- and fruit-festooned marvel that’s perfect for any celebration. The first is one many will im
Cook's Illustrated6 min read
Kitchen Notes
If you’re peeling a potato and see green under the skin, keep peeling until there’s no more green. While the tint itself isn’t a problem, the color indicates the presence of a toxin on the potato flesh. Here’s what’s going on: When a potato is expose

Related Books & Audiobooks