Los Angeles Times

Michael Hiltzik: Did Astros beat Dodgers by cheating? The numbers say no.

LOS ANGELES - The narrative surrounding the Houston Astros' cheating in 2017 and 2018 has become well-established since Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred laid out the details and parceled out punishments on Jan. 13.

The team, Manfred announced, transmitted images from a center field camera to a video monitor to steal signs from opposing catchers, and signaled its batters what was coming by banging on a trash can.

The impression left with the average fan and many pro ballplayers is that this gave the Astros a huge advantage at the plate, enough to propel them to a World Series victory over the Dodgers in 2017.

Though Manfred banned Astros Manager A.J. Hinch and general manager Jeff Luhnow for a year (the team fired both the same day), he stopped short of revoking the Astros' championship.

Nevertheless, the 2017 Series win is hopelessly tainted. Sentiment remains rife in Los Angeles that the Dodgers wuz robbed. At least one opposing pitcher feels that a bad outing against the cheaters ruined his career, and he's filed a lawsuit.

But things aren't that simple. This won't be a popular conclusion in Dodgertown, but new analyses of the Astros' 2017 season by baseball's corps of unofficial statisticians - "sabermetricians," to the sport - indicate that the

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Los Angeles Times

Los Angeles Times3 min readCrime & Violence
Carvalho Faults Alleged Actions Of School Safety Worker Who Failed To Stop Fatal Fight
LOS ANGELES — The Los Angeles school district has removed a campus-safety contractor from Washington Preparatory High School after an adult — who apparently worked for the contractor — refused to intervene before a fight that ended with the death of
Los Angeles Times8 min read
Beyond Erewhon: Inside The LA Grocery Store Where All The Cool Vegans Are Flocking
LOS ANGELES -- On a rainy Saturday afternoon in late March, a block of East Hollywood is unusually quiet but for the corner of Fountain Avenue and North Edgemont Street. There, a line snakes halfway around the perimeter of a little vegan grocery stor
Los Angeles Times3 min read
Commentary: USC’s ‘Security Risk’ Rationale To Thwart Peaceful Protest Is Not Justified
During Vietnam War protests, the Nixon administration called them “outside agitators.” Now my university’s provost prefers “participants — many of whom do not appear to be affiliated with USC.” Beyond Andrew Guzman’s misdemeanor of wordiness, the pla

Related Books & Audiobooks