Timestamps:

00:00 - Introductions and start of episode
01:35 - Finished introductions, starting episode, talk about what the episode is about
02:00 - Randomdudeman taking about his introduction to anime
03:40 - Bacon talking about his introduction to anime
06:20 - Dylan talking about his introduction to anime
08:30 - Smurf talking about his introduction to anime
10:50 - Becker talking about his introduction to anime
11:40 - Kaverik talking about his introduction to anime
13:15 - Some talk about Monogatari series
14:30 - Bacon asks a question about Death Note
17:06 - How did taste change over time?
17:37 - Smurf talking about his shit taste
18:40 - Bacon doesn't know what Shoujo is (some Shoujo talk)
20:00 - Dylan talking about his taste changing
21:33 - How did Dylan decide to watch HunterxHunter
22:33 - Bacon talking about his taste changing
25:50 - Becker talks about his taste changing
27:00 - Discussion about long running shows
28:52 - Kaverik talking about his taste changing
31:35 - Randomdudeman talking about his taste changing
33:25 - Hate on Randomdudeman
33:50 - Talk about using MAL to find new anime
35:00 - SAO Spoilers
35:10 - End of spoilers
36:30 - Talking about transition from action to romance
37:55 - Talking about shows that involve fighting
40:00 - Talking about how we rate shows now
40:35 - Becker talking about how he rates shows
41:10 - Smurf talking about how he rates shows
42:20 - Asking about cliffhanger shows
44:37 - Kaverik talking about how he rates shows
47:00 - Dylan talking about how he rates shows
48:44 - Bacon talking about how he rates shows
52:46 - Randomdudeman talking about how he rates shows
54:10 - Talking about dropping shows
56:20 - Talking about getting hooked on shows