Guys, what is even happening? We'd love the Joey storyline if it was with anyone but Charlie. We have no idea if Joey even knows that Dawson came to Florida.

We're excited to see Sherilyn Fenn, but man, at what cost? Just not going to mention Jen or Jack in this episode. Overall maybe the worst of Season 5?

Join us for this deep dive into the 90s teen drama Dawson's Creek!

Thank you so much to Killya for our amazing theme song. Find them on Instagram @gofreakingcrazy

Thank you to @camadeclub for our social media awesomeness.

Thank you also to Andrew Bush, who helped guide us on how to do this from our houses.

Find Erin on Instagram at @erin.hensley
Find Julia on Twitter and Instagram @Pesty1079