Incredible Mysteries Unsolved Disappearances Vol. 4: True Crime Stories of Missing Persons Who Vanished Without a Trace

By Julian Hawthorne

Step into the enigmatic world within these pages, a journey that spans not only the physical dimensions but also explores the shadowy recesses of the mind and the hidden depths of the mysterious. Here, you'll encounter some of the most perplexing and chilling disappearances in human history. This collectio

• Language: English
• Publisher: Incredible Mysteries
• Release date: Apr 17, 2024
• ISBN: 9798869327277

Book preview

Julian Hawthorne

Incredible Mysteries Unsolved Disappearances Vol. 5

Copyright © 2024 by Julian Hawthorne

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise without written permission from the publisher. It is illegal to copy this book, post it to a website, or distribute it by any other means without permission.

First edition

Contents

Mary Ann Switalski

Bob Harrod

Jessica Garino

Florence Okpealuk

James Martin Roberts

Johnathan Lee Hamilton

Sarm Heslop

Jamie Valdez

Danny Goldman

Charles David Hope

Jennifer and Adrianna Wix

Savannah Spurlock

Matthew Weaver Jr

Erica Fraysure

Lily Aramburo

Evelyn Hartley

Paresh Patel

Hang Lee

Christopher and Lisa Mae Zaharias

Angela Hamby

Mary Ann Switalski

On a calm autumn day, September 14, 1946, the city of Chicago witnessed the birth of Mary Ann Switalski, a name that would later echo through its streets with a mixture of nostalgia and mystery. Mary Ann, the elder of two daughters, grew up in a modest but loving home located in the 6200 block of West Cornelia Avenue. Her parents, Matilda and Eugene Switalski, nurtured a warm and caring environment for Mary Ann and her younger sister, weaving a tapestry of family values and togetherness.

As Mary Ann blossomed into a bright and diligent teenager, she found herself navigating the halls of Notre Dame High School as a junior. Her academic journey was marked by dedication and achievement, earning her the reputation of being a conscientious and committed student. Her life, however, wasn’t confined to the boundaries of her school. Mary Ann was a beacon of youthful energy and ambition. She had already started investing in her future, having put down a deposit on her senior yearbook and class ring, symbols of her impending transition from student life to the wider world.

Outside the classroom, Mary Ann’s life was a blend of responsibility and community involvement. She took up a part-time job at a neighborhood store, demonstrating her burgeoning sense of independence and work ethic. Additionally, she was a familiar and trusted face in the local community, often seen babysitting, which not only earned her extra money but also deepened her connections with those around her.

The date was July 15, 1963, a day that began like any other but would soon leave an indelible mark on the community. Mary Ann, along with a group of friends, decided to attend a carnival, a much-anticipated event held at St. Priscilla Catholic Church. The church, located just over a mile from her family home, was a familiar and comforting landmark in the area. The carnival, with its vibrant atmosphere and the promise of an enjoyable evening, was an irresistible attraction for the local youth.

As the evening progressed, filled with the laughter and chatter of friends enjoying the carnival’s offerings, the clock inexorably moved forward. It was at 10:15 p.m., under the carnival’s colorful lights and amidst the fading echoes of festivity, that Mary Ann Switalski was last seen. Her departure from the carnival marked the beginning of a profound and unsettling mystery that would engulf her family, friends, and the entire community.

In the simmering summer of 1963, an unexpected and cryptic correspondence broke the silence in the Switalski household. On July 17th, Matilda and Eugene Switalski, their hearts heavy with worry, received a letter that carried with it the faint hope and deepening mystery surrounding their daughter Mary Ann’s disappearance. Postmarked from Oak Park, Illinois—a familiar suburban tapestry of Chicago where the family often mingled with the bustle of shopping—the letter was a perplexing blend of reassurance and mystery.

The words of Mary Ann, penned with a mix of vagueness and intrigue, described her current state as an educational experience, strange yet enlightening. She assured her parents of her well-being and promised to send them money soon. Yet, the letter was shrouded in secrecy; she withheld her location, fearing interference, and hauntingly mentioned that while she might make a phone call, she might never reunite with her family or friends.

This letter, a fragile thread of connection, was the last the Switalski family ever heard from Mary Ann. The silence that followed was profound and unsettling.

The local community, previously oblivious to the gravity of Mary Ann’s disappearance, woke to the news on August 7, 1963, when the first media report painted the town with a tinge of sorrow and intrigue. This report marked the beginning of a prolonged, heart-wrenching quest for answers. Years rolled by with Matilda and Eugene placing ads in newspaper personal columns, casting a wide net of hope, but their efforts echoed back in the void, unanswered.

In a poignant attempt to ignite a spark of hope, Mary Ann’s mother took on a part-time job to raise a reward fund—a fund that remained untouched, a testament to the lingering enigma. Her parents grappled with the unanswerable question: Why had Mary Ann vanished? They were unaware of any turmoil or shadows lurking in her seemingly tranquil life.

The twist in the tale came with the revelation from investigators that Mary Ann had joined an organization involved in door-to-door magazine sales, a group that was journeying towards California at the time of her disappearance. In 1965, a glimmer of insight emerged when the couple heading this group was interrogated by the FBI. Their statements, however, muddied the waters further: the wife claimed Mary Ann had left the group shortly after joining, while the husband insisted she never ventured beyond Chicago.

Four years after her disappearance, on June 17, 1967, a new character emerged in this unfolding mystery—Allen J. Silver of New York, apprehended at a motel on charges of conspiracy to commit robbery. Silver’s name resonated with both the family and the police, as he had led a magazine sales group in Chicago around the time Mary Ann disappeared. A retired detective, once dedicated to Mary Ann’s case, speculated that this might be the group Mary Ann had joined, though the connection between Silver and the previously interviewed couple remained shrouded in uncertainty.

Decades have since passed, with Mary Ann’s whereabouts an enduring enigma. Despite numerous attempts to match her DNA against unidentified individuals across the United States, the puzzle of Mary Ann Switalski remains unsolved, a haunting tapestry of hope, mystery, and undying longing for answers in the hearts of those she left behind.

In the ever-evolving and often shadowy realm of cyberspace, a myriad of theories and speculations swirl around the enigmatic disappearance of Mary Ann Switalski. Each theory, a thread in the intricate web of possibilities, offers a different perspective on her fate, a testament to the enduring fascination and deep concern for her well-being.

One prevailing sentiment among online sleuths and amateur detectives is a hopeful one: the possibility that Mary Ann is still among us, leading a life marked by normalcy and anonymity. This theory is buoyed by the absence of any concrete evidence to suggest her demise. Proponents of this view imagine her having slipped away from the shackles of her past life, perhaps now living under a new identity, embraced by the love and laughter of a family she made her own. This version of Mary Ann’s story, albeit optimistic, paints a picture of a woman who managed to navigate the turbulent waters of her youth to find solace in a quiet corner of the United States, far from the turmoil and mystery she left behind.

The primary theory, however, casts a darker shadow over the narrative. It centers around the couple who helmed the magazine organization Mary Ann joined. The air of suspicion around them is thick, with conjectures ranging from sinister to downright nefarious. One grim hypothesis posits that Mary Ann might have been ensnared in the underbelly of a sex trafficking ring, a fate too cruel and heartbreaking to fathom. Another theory, perhaps less ominous but equally distressing, suggests that she was abandoned or cast aside for failing to meet the ruthless sales targets of the organization—a practice alarmingly common in similar groups. This theory paints a picture of a ruthless and uncaring world, where the value of a human life is measured in mere sales figures.

The final, and perhaps most chilling, theory is that Mary Ann Switalski’s disappearance is the result of foul play, leading to her untimely demise. This theory, shrouded in the darkest hues of human nature, suggests a tragic end to Mary Ann’s story, where her light was extinguished through malicious intent. The haunting aspect of this theory lies in its unverifiability; without concrete evidence or leads, it hovers in the realm of conjecture, leaving a cold trail in the hearts of those seeking answers.

As time marches on, the mystery of Mary Ann Switalski continues to captivate and confound, a puzzle that remains unsolved, each theory a reflection of the hope, fear, and relentless pursuit of truth by those who refuse to let her story fade into oblivion.

Bob Harrod

Born on June 1, 1928, in the quaint town of McFaul, Missouri, Bob grew up in an era when life moved at a slower pace. McFaul, a small community of just over 400 souls, was a place where everyone knew each other, and the bond among residents was as strong as family ties. The town’s population has dwindled since then, now housing less than 100 residents, but the memories of those days remain vivid.

In the heart of America, during the transformative years of the 20th century, Bob’s childhood was spent in a world far removed from the hustle and bustle of big cities. McFaul, though not a bustling metropolis, offered its inhabitants the unique warmth and camaraderie that only small towns can foster. While much of Bob’s early life remains shrouded in the mists of time, certain pivotal moments stand out, shaping the man he would become.

The spring of 1949 marked the beginning of a beautiful chapter in Bob’s life. It was then that Fontelle Heater, a 15-year-old girl, found herself unwittingly playing a part in a blind date setup that would change her life forever. Her sister’s friend needed a companion for her date’s friend, and Fontelle, young and adventurous, agreed. Her date was none other than Bob Harrod. Recalling their first meeting years later, Fontelle remembered looking into Bob’s eyes and seeing a soul that radiated goodness and integrity. It was a chance encounter that sparked a passionate romance.

Bob and Fontelle’s love story unfolded rapidly, their connection undeniable. They became inseparable, their bond growing stronger with each passing day. Old photographs, cherished mementos of their time together, tell a story of young love full of promise and dreams. In January 1950, Bob, then 21, professed his undying love to Fontelle. With a diamond ring and a heart full of hope, he proposed, and she joyfully accepted. They were ready to embark on a lifetime journey together, but fate had other plans.

In the summer of 1950, Bob’s life took a dramatic turn when he joined the Marine Corps Reserves and was ordered to report to Camp Pendleton in Southern California. The separation was hard on both, but their devotion remained unshaken. Fontelle’s letters to Bob, filled with her deepest hopes and dreams, traversed the distance between them. However, many letters were mysteriously returned unopened, leading Fontelle to suspect that they were intercepted, possibly by the woman with whom Bob was lodging. The strain of distance began to take its toll, and despite their love, practicalities forced them apart.

Bob’s final letter to Fontelle revealed his fears about his future and his reluctance to hold her to a promise he might not be able to keep. They parted ways, and their lives diverged. Fontelle found love again and embarked on a new journey, while Bob, too, moved on.

In 1951, Bob met and married a woman named Georgia. Their union lasted 57 years and blessed them with three daughters: Roberta, Julie, and Paula. Bob embraced his role as a devoted husband and father, dedicating his life to his family. Despite his eventual wealth, Bob lived a modest life, a testament to his humble beginnings and the values ingrained in him during the Great Depression. His career as a contract manager and savvy real estate investments ensured financial security for his family, though he never flaunted his success.

Bob and Georgia eventually settled in Placentia, California, a stark contrast to his small-town roots in McFaul. Placentia, with its tranquil neighborhoods and larger population, offered a comfortable retirement for the couple. Bob, though sociable, was a private man, preferring the quiet companionship of his wife and the serenity of his home.

Tragedy struck in 2008 when Georgia passed away after a prolonged illness. Bob’s world crumbled with her loss. The man who had once been the pillar of strength for his family now found himself navigating the deep waters of grief and loneliness.

The grief he endured was profound, manifesting in a rapid decline in his physical health. His family watched with concern as Bob, a man typically stoic and composed, succumbed to the weight of his sorrow, his robust frame dwindling as he lost interest in food and life itself. His frequent bouts of tears were alarming to those who knew him as a man who seldom displayed such vulnerability.

In this fragile state, Bob became increasingly entwined with Josie, a woman in her mid-40s who had been the barber for both Bob and Georgia. What started as a professional relationship slowly morphed into something more personal, a development that raised eyebrows among Bob’s friends and family. Josie’s growing influence in Bob’s life, given their significant age difference, sparked concern, particularly among his daughters. They perceived Josie’s intentions as less than sincere,