The Significance of Humans in the Universe: The Purpose and Meaning of Life

By Luke VandenBerghe

The singularity of the Big Bang caused the universe.
As far as we know, we humans are the only intelligent species in the universe.
The inanimate universe is the progenitor of life. Humans form an essential part of the universe because we are its consciousness.
We humans are the cognitive part of the universe.

• Language: English
• Publisher: AuthorHouse UK
• Release date: May 21, 2019
• ISBN: 9781728383033

Luke VandenBerghe

After being expelled from university in 1947, because his studies at an English grammar school during the war were not homologated (later well), the author started work at the Belgian Treasury Department at the lowest rank. He became a tax law expert and published many articles on the subject. His main work was a ten-volume commentary on value-added tax (VAT). He ended his career as director of VAT of the province of West-Flanders and as a commander of the realm. When he retired in 1993 at the age of sixty-five, he started studying religion, philosophy, and cosmology. A convinced atheist, in 2014 he published his essay “God, Fact or Fiction”. Immediately afterwards, he started his research for this book.

Book preview

Chapter 1

Death of Goldilocks

In astrobiology, the Goldilocks zone refers to the habitable zone around a star. The Goldilocks principle defined that a planet must be neither too far away from nor too close to a star and galactic centre. Either extreme would result in a planet incapable of supporting life.

The sun ⁸² is the star at the centre of the solar system and is by far the most important source of energy for life on Earth. Its diameter is 109 times that of Earth, and its mass is about 330,000 times that of Earth, accounting for about 99.86 per cent of the total mass of the solar system. About three-quarters of the sun’s mass consists of hydrogen; the rest is mostly helium, with much smaller quantities of heavier elements such as oxygen, carbon, neon, and iron.

The sun is a G-type star or a yellow dwarf. It formed approximately 4.6 billion years ago from the gravitational collapse of matter within a region of a large molecular cloud consisting mostly of hydrogen and helium. The sun may have been triggered by shockwaves from one or more nearby supernovae. The sun is roughly middle-aged and has not changed dramatically for over four billion years; it will remain fairly stable for at least another five billion years. However, after hydrogen fusion in its core has stopped, the sun will undergo severe changes and become a red giant. It is calculated that the sun will become sufficiently large to engulf the current orbits of Mercury, Venus, and possibly Earth.

The sun does not have enough mass to explode as a supernova. Instead, it will become a red giant. The luminosity of the sun will have nearly doubled, and Earth will be hotter than Venus is today. Once the core hydrogen is exhausted in 5.4 billion years, the sun will expand into a subgiant phase and slowly double in size over about half a billion years. It will then expand more rapidly over another half a billion years until it is over two hundred times larger than it is today and a couple thousand times more luminous. This then starts the red-giant-branch phase, whereby the sun will spend around a billion years and lose around one-third of its mass.

After the red-giant branch, the sun has approximately 120 million years of active life left, but much happens. First, the core, full of degenerate helium, ignites violently in the helium flash. It is estimated that 6 per cent of the core, itself 40 per cent of the sun’s mass, will be converted into carbon within a matter of minutes through the triple-alpha process. The sun then shrinks to around ten times its current size and fifty times the luminosity, with a temperature a little lower than today. It will then have reached the red clump or horizontal branch, but a star of the sun’s mass does not evolve bluewards along the horizontal branch. Instead, it becomes moderately larger and more luminous over about 100 million years as it continues to burn helium in the core.

When the helium is exhausted, the sun will repeat the expansion it followed when the hydrogen in the core was exhausted, except this time it all happens faster, and the sun becomes larger and more luminous. This is the asymptotic-giant-branch phase; the sun is alternately burning hydrogen in a shell or helium in a deeper shell. After about 20 million years on the early asymptotic giant branch, the sun becomes increasingly unstable with rapid mass loss and thermal pulses that increase the size and luminosity for a few hundred years every 100,000 years or so. The thermal pulses become larger each time, with the later pulses pushing the luminosity to as much as 5,000 times the current level and the radius of over one astronomical unit.

According to a 2008 model, Earth’s orbit is shrinking due to tidal forces (and, eventually, drag from the lower chromosphere), so that it is engulfed by the sun near the end of the asymptotic-giant-branch phase. Models vary depending on the rate and timing of mass loss. Models that have a higher mass loss on the red-giant branch produce smaller, less luminous stars at the tip of the asymptotic giant branch, perhaps only 2,000 times the luminosity and less than two hundred times the radius. For the sun, four thermal pulses are predicted before it completely loses its outer envelope and starts to make a planetary nebula. By the end of that phase—lasting approximately 500,000 years—the sun will only have about half of its current mass.

The post-asymptotic-giant-branch evolution is even faster. The luminosity stays approximately constant as the temperature increases, with the ejected half of the sun’s mass becoming ionised into a planetary nebula as the exposed core reaches 30,000 kelvins. The final naked core temperature will be over 100,000 kelvins, after which the remnant will cool towards a white dwarf that contains an estimated 54.05 per cent of the sun’s present-day mass. The planetary nebula will disperse in about 10,000 years, but the white dwarf will survive for trillions of years before fading to black.⁸²

Long before the sun becomes a red giant, Goldilocks—the Earth—will have become a cinder not sustaining any life form. What happened to humankind? Did humans perish like all life forms on Earth, or did they evolve from Homo sapiens to Homo superior and dominate the universe? Who knows? Five billion years—nearly an eternity—is a very long way to go!

The evolution of primitive man to the current Homo sapiens took a few million years, which is a trifle in perspective with the universe’s billions of years.

Chapter 2

Nature

Nature, in the broadest sense, is the natural, physical, or material world or universe.¹²⁹

Nature includes not only the living nature (biosphere, fauna, and flora) but also the non-living nature that is purely material (the terrestrial stratosphere, atmosphere, and lithosphere).

The size of the universe is unknown as it is constantly expanding, so the universe may be infinite, though infinity seems to conflict with mathematics.

Matter and energy are subject to certain physical laws, which means that physics is the most fundamental science; it dominates all knowledge. The universe totally consisting of matter and energy is likewise subject to natural laws.

On a small scale, physics governs the quantum mechanics, whereas physics on a large scale is dominated by gravity, which is determined by the general theory of relativity of Albert Einstein.¹ The matter with mass—which is equivalent to energy (M = EC²)—consists of atoms that undergo chemical compounds.

Chapter 3

Origin of the universe

The universe is the description of all matter and energy within the whole space-time continuum in which we exist. The universe is all time and space and its contents.¹³⁰

In 1908, Hermann Minkowski, one of the math professors of the young Einstein, introduced a geometric interpretation of special relativity that fused time and the three spatial dimensions of space into a single, four-dimensional continuum now known as Minkowski space-time. A key feature of this interpretation is the definition of a space-time interval that combines distance and time. Although measurements of distance and time between events differ for measurements made in different reference frames, the space-time interval is independent of the inertial frame of reference in which they are recorded.

Minkowski’s geometric interpretation of relativity was to prove vital to Einstein’s development of his 1915 general theory of relativity, wherein he showed that space-time becomes curved in the presence of mass or energy. Before Einstein’s work on relativistic physics, time and space were viewed as independent dimensions.

The initial singularity, a small change which causes a large effect, was the gravitational singularity of infinite density thought to have contained all of the mass and space-time of the universe before quantum fluctuations caused it to expand in the Big Bang and subsequent inflation, creating the present-day universe.

In mathematics, a singularity is a point at which a given mathematical object is not defined or erratic (infinite or not differentiable). An essential singularity is a singularity near which a function exhibits extreme behaviour.

It is impossible to see the singularity or the actual Big Bang itself because time and space did not exist inside the singularity. Therefore, there would be no way to transmit any radiation from before the Big Bang to the present day. However, evidence for the existence of an initial singularity, and the Big Bang theory itself, comes in the form of the cosmic microwave background and the continued expansion of the universe. In 2011, the astrophysicist and Nobel Prize laureate Brian Schmidt proved the acceleration of the universe’s expansion.

Generally, it is assumed that the universe was created according to the Big Bang theory of the Belgian priest Georges Lemaître, a theory even the Vatican does not dispute. (In 1951, Pope Pius XII declared that the Big Bang was in line with the Catholic concept of creation.) However, the Catholic Church couples the Big Bang with an intervention of God. The Big Bang theory is the prevailing cosmological model of the universe from the earliest known periods through its subsequent large-scale evolution. The model accounts for the fact that the universe expanded from a very high-density and high-temperature state and offers a comprehensive explanation for a broad range of phenomena, including the abundance of light elements, the cosmic microwave background, the large-scale structure, and the findings (Hubble’s laws) by the astronomer Edwin Hubble. If the known laws of physics are extrapolated beyond where they are valid, there is a singularity. Modern measurements place this moment at approximately 13.8 billion years ago. After the initial expansion, the universe cooled sufficiently to allow the formation of subatomic particles and later simple atoms. Giant clouds of these primordial elements later coalesced through gravity to form stars and galaxies.⁸³

The general theory of relativity of Albert Einstein and Lemaître’s Big Bang theory assume that the whole universe has emerged from a very small point. Space and time were created in the Big Bang, and these were imbued with a fixed amount of energy and matter. As space expands, the density of that matter and energy decreased.

The Big Bang theory was proven by astronomical observations by Edwin Hubble and later confirmed in 1964 by the discovery of the cosmic background radiation by the Nobel Prize winners Arno Allan Penzias and Robert Woodrow. That radiation was predicted by the Big Bang theory. According to the current measurements, the universe came into being about 13.75 billion years ago. Physicists remain unsure about what preceded the Big Bang; the possibility of various multiverse is not excluded. The question is disturbing for theists, who are unable to situate God at the time preceding the Big Bang.

In 2007 the German physicist Martin Bojowald introduced a new mathematical model to derive new details about the properties of a quantum state as it travels through the Big Bounce (a mathematical time machine called loop quantum gravity, a state that initially has small fluctuations bounces and develops larger fluctuations), which replaces the classical idea of the Big Bang.⁸⁵ The research of Bojowald reveals that although it is possible to learn many properties of the earlier universe, it will always be uncertain about some of the properties because his calculations reveal a cosmic forgetfulness that results from the extreme quantum forces during the Big Bounce. He considers Einstein’s theory of general relativity, as the basis of Lemâitre’s Big Bang theory, a mathematical nonsensical state—a singularity of zero volume that nevertheless contained infinite density and infinitely large energy. Research in loop quantum cosmology purports to show that a previously existing universe collapsed not to the point of singularity, but to a point before that where the quantum effects of gravity become so strongly repulsive that the universe rebounds back out, forming a new branch. Throughout this collapse and bounce, the evolution of the universe is unitary. This model of the universe is highly speculative, has been extended, but knows no real breakthrough mainly because of the probability effects of some quantum mechanics and particle physics (scepticism evoked by Einstein, Dirac, Schrödinger, Penrose, and Feynman).⁸⁵ If there was a previous universe that collapsed, the discoveries that have actually been made would be probably totally different. However, further speculation on the universe and research is highly necessary for our evolution.

The initial hot, dense state of the universe is called the Planck epoch (cf. infra), a brief period extending from time zero to one Planck time unit of approximately 10−⁴³ seconds.⁸⁰

Thanks to the observations of satellites circling the earth, it was possible to establish the following.

- The oldest light was 379,000 years after the Big Bang

- The perception of the cosmic background radiation has, since the Big Bang, cooled to 2.73 kelvin.

- The stars have arisen earlier than thought—namely, 200 million years after the Big Bang.

- The age of the Earth indeed can be determined to 5 billion years ago (with a margin of +/- 1 per cent).

- The universe is composed of 4 per cent normal matter, 23 per cent dark matter, and 73 per cent dark energy.

- The universe is flat and not curved.

- The inflation theory is confirmed.

- The expansion continues forever, with a critical density equal to one.

The knowledge which we dispose of makes it very clear to what extent science has managed to unravel the secrets of the universe. The knowledge is such that rational man must be convinced that absolutely no deity has intervened in the creation of heaven and earth.

In the course of the Big Bang, different phases can be determined.⁸⁰–⁸²-⁸³In the first phase, the very earliest universe was so hot, or energetic, that initially no matter particles existed or could exist, or perhaps only fleetingly. According to prevailing scientific theories, at this time the distinct forces we see around us today were joined in one unified force. Space-time itself expanded during an inflationary epoch due to the immensity of the energies involved. Gradually the immense energies cooled—still to a temperature inconceivably hot compared to any we see around us now, but sufficiently to allow forces to gradually undergo symmetry breaking, a kind of repeated condensation from one status quo to another, leading finally to the separation of the strong force from the electroweak force and the first particles.

In the second phase, the resulting quark-gluon plasma universe then cooled further, and the current fundamental forces we know now took their present forms through further symmetry breaking (notably the breaking of electroweak symmetry). The full range of complex and composite particles we see around us today became possible, leading to a gravitationally dominated universe, the first neutral atoms (80 per cent hydrogen), and the cosmic microwave background radiation we can detect today. Modern high-energy particle physics theories are satisfactory at these energy levels, and so physicists believe they have a good understanding of this and the subsequent development of the fundamental universe around us. Because of these changes, space had also become largely transparent to light and other electromagnetic energy, rather than foggy, by the end of this phase.

The third phase started, after a short dark age, with a universe whose fundamental particles and forces were as we know them. This phase witnessed the emergence of large-scale stable structures, such as the earliest stars, quasars, galaxies, clusters of galaxies, and superclusters, and the development of these to create the kind of universe we see today. Some researchers call the development of all this physical structure over billions of years cosmic evolution. Others, such as more interdisciplinary researchers, refer to cosmic evolution as the entire scenario of growing complexity from the Big Bang to humankind, thereby incorporating biology and culture into a unified view of all complex systems in the universe to date.

Beyond the present day, scientists anticipate that Earth will cease to be able to support life in about a billion years, and it will be enveloped by a greatly expanded sun in about five billion years. On a far longer timescale, the stelliferous era will end as stars eventually die and fewer are born to replace them, leading to a darkening universe. Various theories suggest a number of subsequent possibilities. If particles such as protons are unstable, then eventually matter may evaporate into low-level energy in a kind of entropy-related heat death.

The ideas concerning the very early universe (cosmogony) are speculative. No accelerator (Hadron) experiments have yet probed energies of sufficient magnitude to provide any experimental insight into the behaviour of matter at the energy levels that prevailed during this period of the existence of the universe.

The Planck epoch—named after Max Planck,¹ who was the most respected German physicist of his time—is the era in traditional Big Bang cosmology wherein the temperature was so high that the four fundamental forces (electromagnetism, gravitation, weak nuclear interaction, and strong nuclear interaction) were one fundamental force. Little is understood about physics at this temperature, though different hypotheses propose different scenarios. Traditional Big Bang cosmology predicts a gravitational singularity before this time, but this theory relies on general relativity and could be hampered due to quantum effects; the hindrance was solved by physicist and mathematician Edward Witten.⁸⁰

As the universe expanded and cooled, it crossed transition temperatures at which forces separated from each other. These are phase transitions much like condensation and freezing. The grand unification epoch began when gravitation separated from the other forces of nature, which are collectively known as gauge forces. The non-gravitational physics in this epoch would be described by a so-called grand unified theory (GUT). The grand unification epoch ended when the GUT forces further separated into the strong and electroweak forces.

According to traditional Big Bang cosmology, the electroweak epoch began 10−³⁶ seconds after the Big Bang, when the temperature of the universe was low enough (1028 kelvin) to separate the strong force from the electroweak force (the name for the unified forces of electromagnetism and the weak interaction). In inflationary cosmology, the electroweak epoch ends when the inflationary epoch begins, at roughly 10−³² second.

After the Planck epoch and inflation came the epochs of the creation of particles, quark, hadron, and lepton.¹ Together, these epochs encompassed less than ten seconds of time following the Big Bang. As the universe expands, the energy density of electromagnetic radiation decreased more quickly than did that of matter because the energy of a photon decreases with its wavelength. As the universe expanded and cooled, elementary particles associated stably with ever larger combinations. Thus, in the early part of the matter-dominated era, stable protons and neutrons formed, which then formed atomic nuclei through nuclear reactions. This process, known as Big Bang nucleosynthesis, led to the present abundances of lighter nuclei, particularly hydrogen, deuterium, and helium. Big Bang nucleosynthesis ended about twenty minutes after the Big Bang, when the universe had cooled enough so that nuclear fusion could no longer occur. At this stage, matter in the universe was mainly a hot, dense plasma of negatively charged electrons, neutral neutrinos, and positive nuclei. This era, called the photon era, lasted about 380,000 years.

Nuclear reactions amongst nuclei led to the present abundances of lighter nuclei, particularly hydrogen, deuterium, and helium, through a process known as the Big Bang nucleosynthesis. Eventually, in the time known as recombination, electrons and nuclei formed stable atoms, which are transparent to most wavelengths of radiation. The universe entered with photons disconnected from the case, the matter-dominated era. Light from this period now can freely travel, and it can still be seen in the universe as the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB).

After about 200 million years, the first stars formed. These were probably very massive, bright, and responsible for the reionisation of the universe. Containing no heavier elements than lithium, these stars produced the first heavy elements by stellar nucleosynthesis.

The universe also contains a mysterious energy called dark energy, which energy density does not change over time. After about 9.8 billion years, the universe expanded enough so that the density of the ordinary matter was less than the density of dark energy. It marks the beginning of the current dark energy–dominated era. In this age, dark energy accelerates the expansion of the universe.

Some argue that the chemistry of life may have begun shortly after the Big Bang, 13.75 billion years ago, during a habitable epoch when the universe was only 10-¹⁷ million years old.

Over a timescale of a billion years or more, Earth and the solar system will become unstable. Earth’s existing biosphere is expected to vanish in about a billion years as the sun’s heat production gradually increases to the point that liquid water and life are unlikely. Earth’s magnetic fields, axial tilt, and atmosphere are subject to long-term change, and the solar system itself is chaotic over million- and billion-year timescales. Eventually, around 5.4 billion years from now, the core of the sun will become hot enough to trigger hydrogen fusion in its surrounding shell. This will cause the outer layers of the star to expand greatly, and the star will enter a phase of its life in which it is called a red giant. Within 7.5 billion years, the sun will have expanded to a radius of 1.2 astronomical units (AU)—256 times its current size. Studies announced in 2008 show that due to tidal interaction between the sun and Earth, Earth would actually fall back into a lower orbit and get engulfed and incorporated inside the sun before the sun reaches its largest size, despite the sun losing about 38 per cent of its mass. The sun itself will continue to exist for many billions of years, passing through a number of phases and eventually ending up as a long-lived white dwarf. Eventually, after billions of more years, the sun will finally cease to shine altogether, becoming a black dwarf.

This scenario is possible only if the energy density of dark energy actually increases without limit over time. Such dark energy is called phantom energy and is unlike any known kind of energy. In this case, the expansion rate of the universe will increase without limit. Gravitationally bound systems, such as clusters of galaxies, galaxies, and ultimately the solar system, will be torn apart. Eventually the expansion will be so rapid as to overcome the electromagnetic forces holding together molecules and atoms. Finally, even atomic nuclei will be torn apart, and the universe as we know it will end in an unusual kind of gravitational singularity. At the time of this singularity, the expansion rate of the universe will reach infinity so that any and all forces (no matter how strong) that hold composite objects together (no matter how closely) will be overcome by this expansion, literally tearing everything apart. Believers will have great difficulty digesting what will happen with God’s creation.

Space is one of the few fundamental quantities in physics, meaning that it cannot be defined via other quantities because nothing more fundamental is known at the present. On the other hand, it can be related to other fundamental quantities. Thus, similar to other fundamental quantities (like time and mass), space can be explored via measurement and experiment.

The space-time of the universe is usually interpreted from a Euclidean perspective, with space consisting of three dimensions and time consisting of one dimension, the fourth dimension. By combining space and time into a single manifold called space-time, physicists have simplified a large number of physical theories, as well as described in a more uniform way the workings of the universe at both the supergalactic and subatomic levels.

The four dimensions of space-time consist of events that are not absolutely defined spatially and temporally, but rather are known relative to the motion of an observer. Minkowski-space first approximates the universe without gravity; the pseudo-Riemannian manifolds of general relativity describe space-time with matter and gravity. Georg Friedrich Bernhard Rieman was an influential German mathematician who made lasting contributions to analysis, number theory, and differential (non-Euclidian) geometry, which enabled the development of general relativity. Some areas of theoretical physics, such as string theory, postulate the existence of additional dimensions.

Of the four fundamental interactions, gravitation is dominant at cosmological length scales; that is, the other three forces play a negligible role in determining structures at the level of galaxies and larger-scale structures. Gravity’s effects are cumulative; by contrast, the effects of positive and negative charges tend to cancel one another, making electromagnetism relatively insignificant on cosmological-length scales. The remaining two interactions, the weak and strong nuclear forces, decline very rapidly with distance.

The universe seems to have much more ordinary matter than antimatter, an asymmetry possibly related to the observations of CP-violation. In particle physics, CP violation (CP standing for charge parity) is a violation of the postulated CP-symmetry (or charge conjugation parity symmetry): the combination of C-symmetry (charge conjugation symmetry) and P-symmetry (parity symmetry). CP-symmetry states that the laws of the universe appear to have much more matter than antimatter. Physics should be the same if a particle is interchanged with its antiparticle (C symmetry) and when its spatial coordinates are inverted (mirror or P symmetry). The discovery of CP violation in 1964 in the decays of neutral kaons resulted in the Nobel Prize in physics in 1980 for its discoverers James Cronin and Val Fitch. It plays an important role in the attempts of cosmology to explain the dominance of matter over antimatter in the present universe, as well as in the study of weak interactions in particle physics.

The universe appears to have no net electric charge, and therefore gravity appears to be the dominant interaction on cosmological-length scales. The universe also appears to have neither net momentum nor angular momentum. The absence of net charge and momentum follows from accepted physical laws (Gauss’s law and the non-divergence of the stress-energy-momentum pseudo-tensor, respectively), if the universe were finite.

The shape of the universe is related to general relativity, which describes how space-time is curved and bent by mass and energy. The particle horizon, also known as the light horizon or the cosmic light horizon, is the maximum distance from which particles can have travelled to the observer in the age of the universe. The horizon represents the boundary between the observable and the unobservable region of the universe. The existence, properties, and significance of a cosmological horizon depend on the particular cosmological model.

Observational data suggest the cosmological topological of the universe is infinite in extent of finite age, supported by the so-called Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker (FLRW) models. These FLRW models of space are consistent with the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) and Planck maps of cosmic background radiation, thus supporting inflationary models and the standard model of cosmology, describing a flat, homogeneous universe dominated by dark matter and dark energy.

According to a restrictive definition, the universe is everything within our connected space-time that could have a chance to interact with us and vice versa. According to the general theory of relativity, some regions of space may never interact with ours even in the lifetime of the universe, due to the finite speed of light and the ongoing expansion of space. For example, radio messages sent from Earth may never reach some regions of space, even if the universe were to exist forever: space may expand faster than light can traverse it. Because we cannot observe space beyond the limitations of light or any electromagnetic radiation, it is unknown whether the size of the universe is finite or infinite.

Distant regions of space are taken to exist and be part of reality as much as we are, yet we can never interact with them. The spatial region within which we can affect and be affected is the observable universe. The observable universe depends on the location of the observer. By travelling, an observer can come into contact with a greater region of space-time than an observer who remains still. Nevertheless, even the most rapid traveller will not be able to interact with all of space. Typically, the observable universe is taken to mean the universe observable from our vantage point in the Milky Way Galaxy.

The proper distance—the distance as would be measured at a specific time, including the present—between Earth and the edge of the observable universe is 46 billion light years (14 × 109 parsec – 3 0857x10¹³km), making the diameter of the observable universe about 91 billion light years (28 × 109 parsec). The distance the light from the edge of the observable universe has travelled is very close to the age of the universe times the speed of light, 13.8 billion light years (4.2 × 109 parsec), but this does not represent the distance at any given time because the edge of the universe and the Earth have since moved since farther apart. For comparison, the diameter of a typical galaxy is 30,000 light years, and the typical distance between two neighbouring galaxies is 3 million light years. As an example, the Milky Way Galaxy is roughly 100,000 light years in diameter, and the nearest sister galaxy to the Milky Way, the Andromeda Galaxy, is located roughly 2.5 million light years away.

Over time, the universe and its contents have evolved. For example, the relative population of quasars and galaxies has changed, and space itself has expanded. This expansion accounts for how it is that scientists on Earth can observe light from a galaxy 30 billion light years away, even if that light has travelled for only 13 billion years. The very space between them has expanded, and that is one of the tools used to calculate the age of the universe. This expansion is consistent with the observation that the light from distant galaxies has been red-shifted; the photons emitted have been stretched to longer wavelengths and lower frequency during their journey. Analyses of type Ia supernovae indicate that the spatial expansion is accelerating.

The more matter there is in the universe, the stronger will be the gravitational pull of the matter.