Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

Ethics for Adversaries: The Morality of Roles in Public and Professional Life
Ethics for Adversaries: The Morality of Roles in Public and Professional Life
Ethics for Adversaries: The Morality of Roles in Public and Professional Life
Ebook466 pages6 hours

Ethics for Adversaries: The Morality of Roles in Public and Professional Life

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

4/5

()

Read preview

About this ebook

The adversary professions--law, business, and government, among others--typically claim a moral permission to violate persons in ways that, if not for the professional role, would be morally wrong. Lawyers advance bad ends and deceive, business managers exploit and despoil, public officials enforce unjust laws, and doctors keep confidences that, if disclosed, would prevent harm. Ethics for Adversaries is a philosophical inquiry into arguments that are offered to defend seemingly wrongful actions performed by those who occupy what Montaigne called "necessary offices."


Applbaum begins by examining the career of Charles-Henri Sanson, who is appointed executioner of Paris by Louis XVI and serves the punitive needs of the ancien régime for decades. Come the French Revolution, the King's Executioner becomes the king's executioner, and he ministers with professional detachment to each defeated political faction throughout the Terror and its aftermath. By exploring one extraordinary role and the arguments that can be offered in its defense, Applbaum raises unsettling doubts about arguments in defense of less sanguinary professions and their practices.


To justify harmful acts, adversaries appeal to arguments about the rules of the game, fair play, consent, the social construction of actions and actors, good outcomes in equilibrium, and the legitimate authority of institutions. Applbaum concludes that these arguments are weaker than supposed and do not morally justify much of the violation that professionals and public officials inflict. Institutions and the roles they create ordinarily cannot mint moral permissions to do what otherwise would be morally prohibited.

LanguageEnglish
Release dateJul 10, 2000
ISBN9781400822935
Ethics for Adversaries: The Morality of Roles in Public and Professional Life
Author

Arthur Isak Applbaum

Arthur Isak Applbaum is Professor of Ethics and Public Policy at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government and Director of Graduate Fellowships in the Harvard University Center for Ethics and the Professions.

Related to Ethics for Adversaries

Related ebooks

Philosophy For You

View More

Related articles

Reviews for Ethics for Adversaries

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
4/5

2 ratings0 reviews

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

    Book preview

    Ethics for Adversaries - Arthur Isak Applbaum

    bbook_preview_excerpt.html}Ksו_əĈlJEQ 1 a${yVUY|,_0;oc?/}GVdǡTeǹ_?mqY|++Ջ}UW/wV~4 Ű/k岒ߋuXwPM+G8ZT؟eՔmGS 7ۺX]ˢUюk+v屠Yzmmz>/_sC6L֧승_bݼ3Y7#"{F=0,/ѭ 苟FWW3U]U_l]'p7v8qM+Vm'P|LQ,c],7n- ym#v YxhXrGCR [m fvS޽%Y ][ n#vXfgוĂ[8V/J.Rl\#`:*ϟc0R-Χ3Zi;%͗qeI[S-+fp2䫟"$zs|adk=_ ]5><;onoW/8/3@//Ϗ="ɾ]]Wu۷cjAdr'?j 5RTW y3 @3njԃXնk@Kzi_LC_5򡎞[]"k9.;ڵ6E !Nw'4$ ،Ѵc]|aE9`!ycȟ?x~Jnl9BrW(r9XacK kLhKؖRUWP9`{#dpz]PA}gʈl:TۋTQ"f'dInE `n(;wˮ˃$ gr;v<Vde@@AdJi e,,VDukޓ`pTU ms1 ]|:} *WT#HgVkj'Z.YpY8l@jMFG wn#|JhdYW5P48.Q.4zXt/( 5 ZAFv55dFt,2UñNQ^ҟ~5$i߀}H]7s` |f,Vd0Q ! q<mpgWoo#zA-e`G >R j {J͍GP9+Q^//o^_<%(Y P&Ds;0ۋ?>-^"M6lG_98x^-xsRm.M~&R i%\[`gDL۫滷חWח7-(Xs0yN1S3/_xs.''&huGl2R0qXJ\zq?n=x`ԻW.o^]~kvP1fVdᛕ[? rnE^QP__]L8 [jP8jAX|&ZV5Vxj+$hd ŀz#ݭPrE!=UȐgR`ʳu[_.[E)=){C®?T!#[BUe[עÓ: OqZAs[֝a `ڵzd uWz1mC3e\^_ sQy^iF˫WcJct堇*Pň6;p@=z~е1p=֟+-%H0_FuHOqqڒ̉q6&u@6aGsB@ |J";§CPSxRG-  lT*0mW8,T*%5:Mk?i-аOUt7H]UO)XR3v$ey  VRB0M%] c"e蜢g*0cQ@3Y&F{! 3L O#T⌳z`+¸ 2]Kc^^ ^c}X2sȱ2`8 @M,*=8@G5#pfg,1J,^$eOO}QeuAAAI(D!*H\U ϊ\3jv1D27B~>aPv N᳀ʈt~+̿ꓻ:`wx}j_IߌtC3-xA`ӉĮEom]ѩ\F4a{@(:IYjŏbݚt?3RY,c|`sg,rcW6A{2Uz} V>Р`\G d?-^@+ox!u&Gb,*wt~/|8"ЪT?* __p<;=y3Yj%V>CAB'!qEa1$Oѓn"{y򆒑 MF9o5m_Sw0-uK:%a:5$Q@ 'Rb ]O,c, Z7&;qet4=D,^G8cNmm P;EXٔp-7Y]7ō2yuU MU;*j\"*V NNN[F $K܁€3)OD7DyM@ ,z%v Qᡧz<%P.F+1B脊E*:s ҏB#=]TMܥ*"{B'D XH1P*JLZcK9k@Ǣ"v4,ۆ>LYR{'8p囲WD(Li1){Z/9 (_E،Z1 )5av y佤8"&# ļMQD`YgG03 8G878 5@.羁C;KxȝQ=|TO]B6-@D]L\(Xpd4j ʂW^Ӽޑ6$@kZfQ#VfdMfr8 ,gkYaBp',s!^O@X N~®"T1SűA0uQG8y\4 /W3 !"`owd\`*4G/qoK0"eBՓ {v!CGFz:'9a4aSQ; VKOyq]GFm \{Q>NCvDWT2|tTIb&P5'K{OUUX>01N#JWQ`+]T1gCG^P^jT$הQ&%&vFK7ehU%Df+D'#5e~#g FD/g)ST`;k` /$'6SXʎou~ҾzWipl{F3&{wee'xgn jE8?hL{h xX 9Sk̒@r0jL퓙2AcY/j'tzV354~|6pȚ%0' OnrDv3!d].)A$OHл\!;Z_䀂MWO#|ؽ뙀ձ-SX좏!-Lg͂1߇`aDrDM߸t0[.r&U}U =.F9в %C/>@hBq ꉅ{UӐQ骀Rb녥 Ncn4Y"["3:掀˖#jU#h`{W CoTN3EE_s[rlAa/'A!kv3)`J"*%ugp}N %Xf %2Nx.3lHVެJ>Ǘe4T碁@6 Vr!y ! +hʺ&$^aRed9k KlӿVn^@DR\fꆑqh 2d_FG1*jw) RTڮk@z* Qd)'5XgiqmnzܖIV@kTQ2TGZs+Db|r-TnZXU?].-wKYe߂cH?WÉ&To`N}‚Mc- BM?oei+/! }q!-coڦ z[ռ3 _klGlݑW6 ~قB |^YXjR/5ΰu= nc#MH(J2ĒKmeXf{AumQFd@  0'{zQk2/V X2=Ahvdi9D s44vn@]V(jBGy%*zY ȑ02[#'І+YHR*Xc H *>WEse;3&Cu( <3Acv|v"*P5qtlp~Wb"BY^ތ&LrVD*8, q]7Y.r#,ʢMr] 2Orh~I^֗:Z^FB,[ `S jT@v-? gs MXXبI1ƴWV_6㡓UtEV!j|r8". ^ .EQNxZo;Pum4Еn6о]zixr릭ەmWgCNP oN@덕@ҥ\2rzT[/w2ơB}fҮִ 96 09)@ {&|/qS#Z^m֎"WUϽRw(C0dg2eDwCᔓfNT 4ȗJ:*\0jX%@ ؚe;碒ap42UXPRx oa2JVO`/r;Lӣ[i4s0 [2&kʉʶ)|9j!քJyς@môGH^e2\Z% U2YS%kq vƇ*fMHԞ MV+˱MejRm<!1,W5c~Ff덟Ik:O'Dǃ*$՟'w짣<#qP;:s'BV4;wQq(>7N,[co.}bz!ӻf6τi?fz |ib!tTpL͋LG馷i"s,Fj:r>+\Kg1o_+S,6UX -~6夺1m:qVzBxmgz).WcxzFN}]l]^LO`F[ ]bUK`j o4bA^``EbݴȖg2("v'\cĝ5ZX^nh |č2Kg&d MgWLwϼѪĊ$M(e`F0`΄E*όThɸjS I37ԝv4k85̓'T Uc.ԟeL"&LPa|VSxroG޴MĤz\фyLY-8%o7$Ċ(&Tr%dlQ߲V6+B#ƭ 'rB4W 2Uv3r!M3Y*}XEЂk/b%6D'+ "nGY1aI5j{Pzz!es ٞ !PM $L=r52kPƳ Aύ)ɑ)-_p2^1ML\:IjnXe,{`X;,њG:3;<KWF ,&Dv؉` ^!Mx*Y=x~vU3'U#*׿ˌK^MQAZoY GfZG[qUbY"ܼv] of5M/V߱d&:[ٱ.2xzok{:f '0TX-}؝'gPi&v@2:N3jgSOUD2qjHd.WKdД픢TOyAYj96T,9**Pcnt~|>2EvQz)V1:(96WD5oRbrFtɓX;2޴e"k>),303׆؅N$ڧU^GU=Lw r`j%,E-pPDZJJM0?8#tP,ОTؘҀx蒏Me>JQNlV?P '$ DX/RMF B*H&:W56v }(DW(" Zj\kW^`ɢ狨AJ1z`۽jS3sDdCoCCgSW͋1B"|8:CzKkYyS>kug:X2m1uDLMoC;!4 r+1ݬ%keaYkhc=,|ʸ0hgVt ܫe m6yVLM0%(3N?'v<e;K4T=lK9-?ὁM(NN/И)GE[I,yDMFkYcSInNl=+[hmf0]ƙz+.̚Nn,@\f\SW|b(8$\("5yel~)«пnc/\bb#])H~Vц։8^a⬉~6f?C8 9<(s/cYBCf|yU5ehGB`>b]48{M9M*$ ܃)lE?gF˵!,F;ӪδaUY%/Cߋ 1v3Mڅ(nˎłs jFQ ܃ <1`{  lHoتu+INah溭Պ#xv_65Ɉ1YO۲CǦuSPBUhm1n?t6w=D&Xz_zca!BWbmh{aR35֤Ap=Xt/ .ZhDyn6P; >Fâʔ䓶ۥ\p%HoSHVD ̉vR)linAF?[[d3bTDF6kP>złf HP̓O>l]]31<❬3P&O?|8tS:Y<.ciS1&%Y~bt̡Cof6&|J]|34etI]LFꔡd@[b%1pkd/9ޜ1P|'?"VtX)R+ߜ;?uJ!ϡ$ڧw >J.`y| w`Zq59(lo@6g&[ڸxVkDV*ypsi ś/pqq40GH,dwX3;u3PN񃣛xfɓǧ=Ҩ~ A[w1"! L(zr[dh1SWlȅUvCGr hȆ i9m&J`^R<9qȐ8->{LjhDxO-plDs 5:VEC)קŋD3npgF=Ϟ(5׿=#cK[Q Ҁ)E2tݝ{`!?~Ơ钴WI]ܧ7sTP1(=|M}~lnq_kL}+I;8]%Pj/fi_2St#cK`1p%!_;œGh_¾[g[_fսz/y@7UXY;6r;'4*X=# h*WsfǠ/|i0];V:6׮Wj" gTf}X$JԷCPzqqssyUk^D/pq݁oϮ/7ވ.:vѰ^8&m}2auVDnFiN&O1=jGU~{jյOm~4q%Lإ׸rlaxJ/d5f=,y:i>ӕQ]hȽ׻2+ۢS=Mc D 8gXQkbX x-= EPM$axXӪ|bikK] dWL& >X ^zG6xp?7԰ani|qֻ;N;,a|# igEpy<̨:!p3!?cv!gDVg Rg^i0\m6WU,^59x.aӱٱ;h䷺$-JtHsDkxVc1g4$luɻYǔJ ؋qY5ע1, HN:e&j1W31IPβ?+& ^|6o8?^.,(Z/eCXA$OaE7j - Э ״jC 6e u,NlR0hgяc!RDcbڌ1o*&Հ ǚvb, "":ɢQDZ~N2 -LdL@Jgtj%aH ;._|s]K $ދ1hKu"^K!oXIi8,Lni @{I:*OO3Vj̭r(KV6q Zz~r O;!n 4U#BX15,?)x& ) ]J Srk%M9¯am%r|( 60(W Ow/78 'uHܨ6١6詜An f.=d&)dZ3Ӆ^-K4qTTc`jD#%V't׋ ysv?OK ¿Ĺ>xX,_)zzM͈]wS $eL7S! 6=kR(˚
    Enjoying the preview?