What Happens in Paradise

Written by Elin Hilderbrand

Narrated by Erin Bennett

Spend your winter on sunlit shores in the New York Times bestselling follow-up to Winter in Paradise, as secret lives and new loves emerge under the bright Caribbean sky. 

A year ago, Irene Steele had the shock of her life: her loving husband, father to their grown sons and successful businessman, was killed in a helicopter crash. But that wasn't Irene's only shattering news: he'd also been leading a double life on the island of St. John, where another woman loved him, too.

Now Irene and her sons are back on St. John, determined to learn the truth about the mysterious life—and death—of a man they thought they knew. Along the way, they're about to learn some surprising truths about their own lives, and their futures.

Lush with the tropical details, romance, and drama that made Winter in Paradise a national bestseller, What Happens in Paradise is another immensely satisfying page-turner from one of America's most beloved and engaging storytellers.

• Language: English
• Publisher: Hachette Audio
• Release date: Oct 8, 2019
• ISBN: 9781478947684

Elin Hilderbrand

Elin Hilderbrand lives on Nantucket, has three children and is the author of 27 novels, including SUMMER OF ‘69.  Elin met Dottie in the spring of 2017 at the annual Post & Courier luncheon in Charleston and Elin says, “It was love at first sight.” The two authors proceeded to meet on Nantucket every chance they got and they texted and emailed non-stop. They dreamed of doing a joint cooking show called “Cook the Books,” where they would invite a third author on to make a signature dish for each episode. They also talked about a cookbook called “The Southern Belle and the Gray Lady.” Elin’s summer of 2020 novel, 28 Summers, is dedicated to Dottie and Dottie makes a cameo appearance in Elin’s summer of 2021 novel, Golden Girl. “I will never again have a writer friend like Dottie,” Elin says. “Those of you who knew her understand what I mean, and those of you who didn’t will just have to trust me. They broke the mold.”

Reviews for What Happens in Paradise

[elizabethcromb · Rating: 4 out of 5 stars]

Interesting tale set in American Virgin Islands, Iowa, and Texas. Murder, hedge fund financial crimes and relationships,

[bereanna · Rating: 5 out of 5 stars]

Third in the series. All loose ends are tied up very satisfactorily. These books are addictive, can’t put down chick lit. Great to read as a break from not serious books.

[nyiper · Rating: 5 out of 5 stars]

Wellll....I didn't read the first book but I definitely want the third book because you are sort of left...HANGING at the end of this one! Hilderbrand certainly knows how to tell a story and this one has a variety of characters and problems roaming around, always good for great escape reading.

[jhscolloquium · Rating: 4 out of 5 stars]

Author Elin Hilderbrand’s vibrant, complicated, and endearing characters return in the second installment of her Paradise trilogy. (It is not necessary to read the first volume in order to enjoy What Happens in Paradise, although doing so will provide a richer experience.)

Winter in Paradise focused on exposition. Hilderbrand compassionately detailed the reactions of her characters to the untimely deaths of Russ and Rosie, and their struggles to come to terms not only with losing them, but the shocking news about their relationship. Irene found herself unable to tell any of their friends back in Iowa about her husband’s secret life with Rosie, and their sons, Cash and Baker, grappled with all the things about their father’s life they never knew as they both became acquainted with and enchanted by Avery. Rosie’s beloved stepfather, Huck, the rugged fishing boat captain, remained focused on Rosie’s daughter, Maia, putting her well-being above all else, even as he felt a strong connection to and growing affection for Irene.

The next chapter of their lives is focused on the aftermath of the deaths of Russ and Rosie, as Irene, Cash, and Baker all return to the island. Baker, in the midst of a divorce from his wife who has already moved on to a new romance, decides that his father’s lovely island estate would be an ideal place to raise his young son and works out a shared custody arrangement with the boy’s mother. But Cash’s business in Colorado has failed and there is nothing for him there or in Iowa, so he also decides to take up residence in the home. He jumps at the chance to work on a tour boat with Ayers, determined to convince her that he is the “superior Steele brother” and make her fall in love with him.

Back in Iowa, Irene now finds the showplace home she shared with Russ — which she poured so much time, planning, and money into renovating — dark, overwrought, suffocating . . . and lonely. She abandons the master bedroom in the wake of learning about Russ’s activities — she determines never to sleep there again. As she moves about the house, the recalls “the joy and pride she’d felt in refurbishing” the various rooms but now, “she can’t understand why. The Victorian style seems so heavy, so overdone, so tragic.” Just a few weeks ago, “leaving behind the house would have been unthinkable. . . . Now, of course, Irene sees how blindly devoted she was to the project, how she sweated over the details and completely ignored her marriage.” For her, love had always been “a daily act — steadfastness, loyalty, devotion.” Recognizing her own complicity in the breakdown of her marriage, she also heads back to the island and accepts an offer from Huck to serve as his first mate. To Huck’s delight she is both a highly competent assistant and good company. Irene thoroughly enjoys joining Huck on the fishing charters and interacting with his guests. Their attraction is undeniable, but they wisely proceed cautiously.

Ayers is determined to make her relationship with Nick work. After all, they have a shared history. But she is not convinced that Nick’s affair is over and her feelings for Baker complicate matters.

Ayers continues to be a supportive presence in Maia’s life and agrees to help Huck sort through and dispose of Rosie’s things. In the process, she finds more than the stylish clothing that accentuated Rosie’s natural beauty. One of her discoveries leads to questions that, perhaps, the FBI agents who have descended on the island might be able to answer. Their investigation into the helicopter crash is ongoing and one thing is clear: the crash was not an accident. The damage to the helicopter was caused not by lightning, as originally thought but, rather, by an explosive device.

Ayers also locates Rosie’s diary and takes it with her to read. Through Rosie’s first-person narrative, Hilderbrand reveals the details of her time with Russ, including how they met, what drew her to Russ and vice versa, what she knew about Russ’s business dealings, and how her affair with him impacted her relationship with her late mother. Rosie’s story is a heartbreaking tale of attraction, yearning, joy, and loneliness, particularly when she acceded to a threat issued by her mother. And because of her status as the other woman in Russ’s life. After all, Russ remained married to Irene until his death. Rosie wrote that she was Russ’s “second place, I guess. I live in second place.” Ayers is drawn to “the rawness of Rosie’s desire for Russ and her pain when he leaves,” revealed through Rosie’s journaling. “It’s the spark and the flame that intrigue Ayers. Did two good people do something they knew was wrong because there was some kind of magical chemistry involved? Or was it plain old human fallibility, weakness in the face of temptation?”

Irene works to unravel Russ’s estate. Information received from their attorney about his wishes comes to light. Unbeknownst to Irene, Russ changed his will, making her the executor. Or did she know? Did she just not listen when Russ told her about information she, at the time, would have deemed “unremarkable, even dull. Life insurance; executor. Who cared! It was all preparation for an event, Russ’s death, that was, if not exactly inconceivable, then very, very far in the future.” Russ told him attorney, “Irene is the only person I trust to do the right thing.” Did he assume that Irene would eventually find out about Rosie, Maia, and his villa on St. John? If so, did he believe that Irene would ensure that Rosie and Maia were taken care of financially? Other details about mysterious financial transactions surface. Irene never knew much about Russ’s employment by an old college friend — she wasn’t really interested. She was busy renovating their home and attending to her own career. But what she learns is unsettling and leads her to ponder whether she might somehow be implicated,

What Happens in Paradise proceeds at a fast pace as the characters’ lives move forward. They struggle to find a new sense of normalcy and design futures that differ dramatically from the lives they originally envisioned. Hilderbrand injects shocking plot developments at expertly-timed intervals, with each bombshell revelation posing a threat to the tenuous lives Irene, et al. have established on the island.

The entries in Rosie’s diary, interspersed with the present-day third-person narrative, provide context and are deeply affecting. But each of Hilderbrand’s characters is each uniquely likable and empathetic, and their struggles provide an absorbing and entertaining tale set against a stunning tropical backdrop. All of which make What Happens in Paradise, along with Winter in Paradise, ideal books to read by the pool or on the beach. Be warned, however, that Hilderbrand once again provides a jaw-dropping conclusion to her compelling story that sets up the forthcoming third and final volume, Troubles in Paradise.

Thanks to NetGalley for an Advance Reader's Copy of the book.

[livelylady · Rating: 1 out of 5 stars]

This is the second of a trilogy, but the author claims they stand alone. NOT. I reread the first 45 pages trying to figure out the characters and their relationships. Not Hilderbrand's best, at least out of order. It picks up with an adult woman finding out her husband was killed in a helicopter crash and had another life and a child in St. John's. The story does lend itself to the third in the series. I don't think I will b oth.

[flourgirl49 · Rating: 3 out of 5 stars]

This is the second installment in the Paradise trilogy. It's a typical Elin Hilderbrand book - quick read, frothy, entertaining.

[bookczuk · Rating: 3 out of 5 stars]

I read the first, so had to read the second. Pandemic read.

[dknight0918 · Rating: 4 out of 5 stars]

I loved this sequel. It was a nice escape from reality during this dreadful quarantine time. I am so ready for the next book in the series. I need to know what happens next!

[cherybear · Rating: 4 out of 5 stars]

Second in the "Paradise" trilogy. Irene and her two sons return to the island, each independently of the others, and each for different reasons. As they build lives there, Irene and her new friend Huck become more and more concerned about Russ's (possibly illegal) past and dealings. We also learn more about Russ and Rosie's relationship through Rosie's diaries.
Still many unsolved mysteries from the past, and unresolved relationships in the present. Will they all be resolved and answered in the final book of the trilogy? It's not available yet!

[mchwest · Rating: 5 out of 5 stars]

We all know it will be another year before the next book is out and yet I piled through this one in two days. It was fabulous and I will think about how it will all come together next year at this time!!

[clp412 · Rating: 4 out of 5 stars]

Book #2 in the series develops the characters even more. I like the characters and the underlying mystery. The St. Johns in USVI island lifestyle is also fun! I suggest reading Winter in Paradise first before this one! Thank you to Netgalley and Little Brown and Co. Publisher for the opportunity to read this great book by a fabulous author!