Chicago Tribune

Commentary: Antonin Scalia and the uncertain future of legal conservatism

Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia waits for the beginning of the taping of "The Kalb Report" on April 17, 2014, at the National Press Club in Washington, D.C..

During her 2010 Senate confirmation hearings, centrist-liberal Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan famously allowed that “we are all originalists.” In a 2015 interview at Harvard Law School honoring her then-colleague Justice Antonin Scalia, Kagan proclaimed that “we are all textualists now.”

However, in a dissent opinion to the West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency decision, which gutted the Clean Air Act, Kagan wrote: “Some years ago, I remarked that we’re all textualists now. ... It seems I was wrong. The current Court is textualist only when being so suits it.”

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Chicago Tribune

Chicago Tribune4 min read
‘Fallout’ Review: Walton Goggins As A Swaggering, Post-apocalyptic Cowboy
If fears about “the bomb” permeated life in the mid-20th century, the video game “Fallout” takes that premise to its worst conclusion. In a post-nuclear wasteland, some survivors have been recreating their 1950s-era idyll underground in elaborate bom
Chicago Tribune3 min read
Musician Steve Rashid Plans Chicago-area Concert At Studio5 Venue He Helped Create
CHICAGO — The creative life can be, to borrow some words from the musical “Annie,” a “hard knock life,” or, as writer Maya Angelou once put it more gently, “You can’t use up creativity. The more you use, the more you have.” Few people I know have mor
Chicago Tribune3 min read
‘Dead Boy Detectives’ Review: Hardy Boys For The Supernatural Realm
A pair of teenage ghosts solve mysteries for their supernatural clientele in “Dead Boy Detectives” on Netflix, an eight-episode season that sits squarely in the YA genre. Picture something like “The Hardy Boys,” but British. And dead. Edwin (George

Related Books & Audiobooks