The Christian Science Monitor

North Carolina seeks to change its judges: rebalancing or constitutional overreach?

Buncombe County Chief District Judge Calvin Hill, shown at the Buncombe County Courthouse in Asheville, N.C. Oct. 25, 2017. As the lone African-American judge in Asheville, Hill next year will have to compete in a newly-drawn district composed largely of white rural and suburban Trump voters, part of an effort by the Republican-led state legislature to redraw the judicial system.

Buncombe County Chief District Judge Calvin Hill has practiced law in Asheville, N.C., for 25 years, rising from one of the city’s first black public defenders to a court appointment to winning three elections unopposed. He was elected to the county’s top judicial job in 2010.

But next year, when he’s up for reelection, the people of Asheville won’t be voting on whether Judge Hill keeps his job.

The lone African-American judge in the liberal mountain city, Hill will have to run in a newly drawn district composed largely of white rural and suburban Republicans, including many of the 55,000 locals who voted for President Trump last November.

“As an African-American who is now in the primarily Republican area, I don’t know how racial gerrymandering as it is applied to me – I don’t know how that’s not clear,” Hill says in a Monitor interview, noting that Gastonia County, a similarly sized conservative enclave, was

'We all stand for justice'Courtrooms as political battlefieldsSeparation or 'sharing' of powers?'Shoe now ... on the other foot''A dot of blue ... in a sea of red'

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Christian Science Monitor

The Christian Science Monitor3 min read
NBA Playoffs Without Curry? James? Durant? A New Guard Rises In Basketball.
LeBron James’ basketball career has always been paradoxical with respect to time, whether it was his rise through the NBA ranks as a teenager, or how he remains one of the game’s great players upon the completion of his 21st season. The way that camp
The Christian Science Monitor3 min read
Stories Of Resilience: Bees Make A Comeback, And How Immigrants Lift Economies
Since 2006, steep winter losses of worker bees have spurred scientists and the U.S. government to try to understand colony collapse disorder. Honeybees pollinate four-fifths of all flowering plants, which makes one-third of the food system dependent
The Christian Science Monitor3 min readAmerican Government
Police Are Begging Lawmakers To Stop Relaxing Gun Laws. Charlotte Shows Why.
From New York to Texas to Alabama, law enforcement officials have warned for years that relaxing gun laws would lead to more violence toward police. The fatal shooting of a local police officer and three members of a fugitive task force in Charlotte,

Related Books & Audiobooks