Why Do Evangelicals Become Catholic? | Chris Castaldo

FromUpstream

Start listening View podcast show

Why Do Evangelicals Become Catholic? | Chris Castaldo

FromUpstream

ratings:

Length:

64 minutes

Released:

Apr 16, 2024

Format:

Podcast episode

Description

The beauty, the tradition, the sense of authority and certainty about doctrine—these are some of the many reasons evangelicals join the Catholic Church. But are they making a fully informed decision? Shane welcomes Chris Castaldo, co-author of Why Do Protestants Convert? to offer a surprising answer.

Released:

Apr 16, 2024

Format:

Podcast episode

Titles in the series (97)

There are no ordinary things. We can meet God in the most surprising places…if we only know how to look. Go Upstream, discover a world charged with the grandeur of God—and learn to live in that bigger world.

Skip carousel

Understanding Christmas Through the Old Testament | Alastair Roberts: On the road to Emmaus, the risen Jesus explained how the whole Bible foreshadows Him. As we begin Advent, Shane welcomes Dr. Alastair Roberts to help us see how the birth of Christ fulfilled all of God’s promises to Israel—and to us. by Upstream
68 min listen
What's Liturgy Got to Do with My Christmas? | Heidi White & Heather Peterson: Shane welcomes Heidi White and Heather Peterson for a conversation about the ways in which this time of year excites joy, and how the wisdom of Christianity's past can enrich our Advent fasts and Christmas feasts. by Upstream
52 min listen
Were the Pilgrims Nuts? | Glenn Sunshine by Upstream
49 min listen
Epiphany, Orthodoxy, and Seeing Christ All Year | Frederica Matthews-Green: Shane welcomes author Frederica Matthews-Green to give an Eastern Orthodox perspective on the feast of Epiphany/Theophany, and to explore how Christians differ on liturgies and traditions meant to reveal Christ in worship. by Upstream
63 min listen
Further Upstream - Men and Women Really Are Different: Do the differences between men and women go deeper than physical strength? Shane welcomes Tim Padgett to reflect on the conversation with Anthony Esolen, and to ask how our culture’s assumptions make it tough for us to see what people throughout... by Upstream
47 min listen
Further Upstream - Feminism, Women’s Bodies, and the Blank Slate: Shane and Tim continue the conversation about Abigail Favale’s book, The Genesis of Gender, and explore feminism’s fatal mistake of fighting for women’s rights without bothering to define “woman.” by Upstream
37 min listen
Further Upstream - God Wrote the Bible—and History: Tim Padgett joins Shane to reflect on the conversation with Alastair Roberts on biblical typology and the birth of Christ. They dive deeper into the counterintuitive story God wrote on the pages of Scripture and history—a story in which small and... by Upstream
34 min listen
You (Probably) Won’t Change the World in Your Twenties | Nathan Rittenhouse: Nathan Rittenhouse joins Shane to explain why, as his grandfather put it, “no one takes you seriously until you’re thirty,” and why for Christians who want to impact the culture for Christ, that’s very good news. by Upstream
59 min listen
Further Upstream - Which Statues Should Topple?: Shane welcomes the Colson Center’s Kasey Leander to talk about what it looks like to be “stuck in the present,” and how a careful study of history can keep us from either uncritically idolizing or demonizing those who came before us. by Upstream
41 min listen
Further Upstream - No, Orthodoxy Isn’t a Conspiracy: Tim Padgett joins Shane to reflect on the conversation with Trevin Wax about his book, The Thrill of Orthodoxy, and to dispel some myths and misconceptions about how we confess the great creeds. by Upstream
47 min listen
Moral Metanoia in Christmas Stories | Jessica Hooten-Wilson: Ebenezer Scrooge, George Bailey, the Grinch, Imogene Herdman … so many characters in beloved Christmas books and movies experience a dramatic change of heart. Why does this theme resonate at this time of year? Shane welcomes author and literary... by Upstream
57 min listen
Good Doctrine Should Excite Us! | Trevin Wax: The creeds of Christianity summarize the most paradoxical and surprising story the world has ever known. So why do so many find them boring? This week, Shane welcomes Trevin Wax to explain why the core truths of our faith are an invitation to... by Upstream
63 min listen
Singing the Psalms—Even the Ones About Dragons | Brian Sauvé: In the center of the Bible is a giant, divinely inspired song book. What would happen if we sang it? Shane welcomes pastor and musician Brian Sauvé to talk about his new album of psalms set to original music: "." by Upstream
72 min listen
How to Watch Movies Well | John Ehrett: Christians can fall into two opposite errors when it comes to entertainment: We either tally up curse words or try to read everything as a biblical allegory. But film is more complex than that. Shane welcomes Spectator World movie reviewer John Ehrett... by Upstream
64 min listen
What Are Children For? | Shane Morris: This week, we’re sharing a talk Shane gave at the Association of Classical Christian Schools regional conference in Lakeland, Florida. Shane suggests four reasons why God gives us children, and makes a countercultural call to raise and educate those... by Upstream
61 min listen
Further Upstream - The Pilgrims, Religious Liberty, and America by Upstream
41 min listen
The Protestant Case Against Abortion | Steven Wedgeworth: Catholic opposition to abortion is well known, but what about Protestants and evangelicals? Shane welcomes Steven Wedgeworth, contributor to the new book, “Protestant Social Teaching,” to tell the complicated and surprising story of the... by Upstream
71 min listen
Rooting Your Worldview in History | David George Moore: Affluent, modern people are too often “stuck in the present,” dismissing the past as benighted and bigoted. Shane welcomes author David George Moore to explain why Christians must be students of history, and how to appreciate the people we meet... by Upstream
65 min listen
The Reason for Liturgical Seasons | Ken Boa by Upstream
58 min listen
Further Upstream - Why Christians Differ on Liturgy, Smells, and Bells: Shane and Tim reflect on the conversation with Frederica Mathewes-Green in light of historical Protestant objections to church holidays, liturgy, and traditional rituals. How should we think about these disagreements in a way that shows love for one... by Upstream
41 min listen
How Gender Is Destroying Sex | Abigail Favale: What is a woman? Shane welcomes Dr. Abigail Favale, author of The Genesis of Gender, to discuss how feminism, postmodernism, and bad philosophy made that question impossible to answer, and to show how the Christian vision of sexed embodiment dignifies... by Upstream
64 min listen
Further Upstream - Were Humans Made for Twitter?: Shane and Tim reflect on the conversation with Samuel James about how the internet has changed our behavior and speech. As digital platforms come and go, Christians must reemphasize timeless virtues to stay rooted in reality. by Upstream
33 min listen
The Gospel Creates Unity in Diversity | Richard Lints: America’s motto is e pluribus unum, “out of many, one.” Yet the modern obsession with diversity and inclusion has left us a nation where citizens have little in common. Shane welcomes Richard Lints to explain how the Church’s mission and very... by Upstream
62 min listen
The Mystery of Music | Jeremy Begbie: Few art forms have the power music has to move us and enrich our lives. But what gives it that power? Shane welcomes theologian and musician Dr. Jeremy Begbie to reveal how music can voice deep theological truths in a way words can’t. Special thanks... by Upstream
61 min listen
Further Upstream - Diversity Without Unity Is Chaos: Shane welcomes Tim Padgett to discuss whether the modern notion of diversity and inclusion has lived up to its promises, and whether it’s possible for very different people to live together in a nation or worship together in a church. by Upstream
45 min listen
Further Upstream - You’re Doing Philosophy Right Now!: We may not agree with every answer Greek philosophers gave, but we do have to answer the questions they asked. Shane welcomes Kasey Leander to talk more about Plato, metaphysics, Scripture, and the conversation with Dr. Hans Boersma. by Upstream
45 min listen
Further Upstream - Where Did All These (Neo) Calvinists Come From?: Shane welcomes Kasey Leander to ask and answer some important questions about Abraham Kuyper, Herman Bavinck, and where their theology fits into the big picture of Christian history and thought—and why they matter today! by Upstream
50 min listen
When God Plays ‘Hard to Get’ | Adam Mabry: What happens when tragedy, sorrow, or frustration strike and God seems not to hear our prayers? Shane welcomes Adam Mabry, author of When God Seems Gone: Finding Hope When Nothing Makes Sense to encourage faith in the midst of (apparent) Divine absence. by Upstream
61 min listen
Further Upstream - C.S. Lewis and the Mystery of the Cross: Is there one right theory of how Christ’s atoning work saves us, or does the Bible reveal something more complex and mysterious? Shane welcomes Kasey Leander to reflect on the conversation with Hal Poe about C.S. Lewis and the Gospel message. by Upstream
44 min listen
No Plato, No Scripture? | Hans Boersma: Do we need philosophy to read the Bible well? What happens if we ignore Athens in our study of Jerusalem? Shane welcomes Dr. Hans Boersma, who argues that everyone does metaphysics whether they know it or not, and that Plato’s thought is... by Upstream
58 min listen

More Episodes from Upstream

Skip carousel

Is Philosophy for Christians? | Ross Inman: In Colossians 2:8, the Apostle warns us not to be taken captive by hollow and deceitful philosophy. Does this mean Christians shouldn’t seek wisdom outside or alongside of Scripture? To answer, Shane welcomes Dr. Ross Inman, author of Christian... by Upstream
57 min listen
How Christ Can Redeem Environmentalism | Andrew Spencer: Evangelicals are often suspicious of the environmental movement because of its fatalism and worship of the earth. But what if Christianity is the best foundation for environmental stewardship? Shane welcomes Dr. Andrew Spencer, author of Hope for... by Upstream
66 min listen
Defy the Elites, Get Married | Brad Wilcox: Whether from pop culture or politicians, corporate executives or mainstream journalists, Americans are bombarded with the message that marriage is outdated, inconvenient, and joyless. But statistics tell a very different story. Shane welcomes... by Upstream
59 min listen
The Hope and Joy of the Colson Fellows | Michael Craven: Something happens to Christians who join the largest worldview fellowship in existence. Confusion turns to confidence, fear turns to hope, and they discover how their lives fit into God’s grand story. This week Shane welcomes Michael Craven, dean of... by Upstream
61 min listen
How Pro-Life Can Win | Scott Klusendorf: The overturning of Roe v. Wade was the beginning of a new phase in the fight for life. But every time abortion has been on the ballot, pro-lifers have lost. Shane welcomes Scott Klusendorf, who thinks most Americans have never truly... by Upstream
65 min listen
How Is A Human Like a Tree? | Joy Clarkson: Some of our go-to figures of speech are mechanistic. We compare ourselves to computers that need to “recharge,” “process,” and “update.” But what if the Bible (and nature) offer better metaphors? To make that case, Shane welcomes Dr. Joy... by Upstream
58 min listen
Does My Job Fulfill the Great Commission? | Jordan Raynor: Our divide between “ordinary jobs” and “ministry” and “mission” reveals a hidden assumption about the size of the gospel, and what Christ expects His people to do on this earth. Shane welcomes Jordan Raynor, author of The Sacredness of... by Upstream
59 min listen
How Feminism Unleashed Gender Chaos | Abigail Favale: What is a woman? In this best-of episode from 2023, Shane welcomes Dr. Abigail Favale, author of The Genesis of Gender, to discuss how feminism, postmodernism, and bad philosophy made that question impossible to answer, and to show how the Christian... by Upstream
66 min listen
Worshiping Yourself Will Make You Miserable | Thaddeus Williams: You are basically good, and meaning comes from looking within and conforming reality to your feelings. This is the message shouted at us from every direction, but it leads to confusion and despair. Shane welcomes Dr. Thaddeus Williams to point us back... by Upstream
64 min listen
The Year That Made Us Modern | Andrew Wilson: In 1776, America became an independent nation. But that year also saw the beginning of trends that would de-Christianize the West. Shane welcomes Dr. Andrew Wilson to tell the story of how this transformation took place, and to prepare Christians to... by Upstream
54 min listen
The ‘Aha’ Moment: Christianity Matters for All of Life | Christopher Talbot: The concept of “engaging the culture” from a “Christian worldview” has been talked about for decades. But what does it mean, exactly, and how do we teach it? What are the benefits and potential pitfalls of “worldview talk?” Shane welcomes... by Upstream
56 min listen
Finding Jesus in All of Scripture | Alastair Roberts: On the road to Emmaus, the risen Jesus explained how the whole Bible foreshadows Him. As we celebrate Christmas, Shane welcomes Dr. Alastair Roberts to help us see how the birth of Christ fulfilled all of God’s promises to Israel—and to us. by Upstream
69 min listen
The Neglected Theology of Food | Andrew Brumme: From the tilled earth to the family table, every step of growing and preparing food was intended by God to teach us spiritual truths. Yet many of us have forgotten how to taste and see. Shane welcomes documentary filmmaker Andrew Brumme to reintroduce... by Upstream
60 min listen
How Handel’s Messiah Brings God’s Promises to Life | Joel Clarkson & Gabriela Morris: A German composer’s 1742 oratorio about the life and work of Christ has captivated audiences for centuries. But what makes Handel’s Messiah so powerful and unforgettable? Shane welcomes composer and writer Dr. Joel Clarkson, plus a special... by Upstream
62 min listen
What If We Truly Prayed Without Ceasing? | Douglas McKelvey: Christ is sovereign over every square inch of human existence, but what about every moment of time? What would it change if we dedicated everything we do to Him in prayer? Shane welcomes Douglas McKelvey, author of the Every Moment... by Upstream
67 min listen
Is Theology Boring? | Trevin Wax: The creeds of Christianity summarize the most paradoxical and surprising story the world has ever known. So why do so many find them boring? In this best-of episode, Shane welcomes Trevin Wax to explain why the core truths of our faith are an... by Upstream
65 min listen
Thanking God Without Idolizing His Gifts | Joe Rigney: We gather at Thanksgiving to enjoy food, to count our blessings (including family and friends), and to express our gratitude to the Giver. But is it possible to love God’s gifts too much? Shane welcomes Dr. Joe Rigney, author of The Things of... by Upstream
57 min listen
Christ’s Presence in Our Pain | Joni Eareckson Tada: What is the secret of contentment in all circumstances? The Apostle Paul knew it, and so can Christians who acknowledge God’s presence and seek His face. Shane welcomes Joni Eareckson Tada, herself no stranger to suffering, to share insights from... by Upstream
33 min listen
Do We Treat the Holy Spirit Like God? | Costi Hinn: He’s been described like a genie in a bottle, treated like The Force from Star Wars, and is sometimes simply forgotten. But the Holy Spirit is God, and learning to worship Him and recognize His work is central to Christianity. Shane welcomes Costi... by Upstream
61 min listen
A Jerusalem Pastor on the War in Gaza | David Pileggi: The world is still reeling from the events of October 7, when Hamas terrorists attacked Israel and slaughtered over a thousand civilians. As war rages, confusion reigns in academia and politics over who is to blame and what should be done. This week,... by Upstream
68 min listen
Should Christians Tell Haunting Stories? | Ben Garrett and Brian Sauvé: The world is filled with tales of ghosts, vampires, sea serpents, and all manner of mythological monsters. The secular mind dismisses these as superstitions, but should Christians? This week Shane welcomes Ben Garrett and Brian Sauvé, hosts of The... by Upstream
70 min listen
Are We Souls? | Joshua Farris: For most of history, nearly everybody has agreed that human beings survive the deaths of our bodies. But somewhere along the way, materialism rose to dominance, and we became nothing but bodies. What’s the truth? Shane welcomes Dr. Joshua... by Upstream
60 min listen
What is it About Music? | Various Guests: Music has been a favorite theme on Upstream. Guests like Andrew Peterson, Jeremy Begbie, The Arcadian Wild, and David Radford of The Gray Havens have explored the mystery of music from artistic and academic perspectives. This week, we bring you the... by Upstream
68 min listen
What Critical Theory Gets Wrong—and Right | Neil Shenvi & Pat Sawyer: Between Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s "I Have a Dream" speech and the modern social justice movement, the definition of "justice" changed. But critical social theories are based on important truths, even if they mix them with lies. Shane welcomes Drs.... by Upstream
63 min listen
Why Are Churches Dying? | Michael Graham: We're in the mist of the most significant religious shift in American history. Millions are abandoning organized Christianity, but there is little clarity about why they're leaving, or how to stem the exodus. Shane welcomes Michael Graham, co-author... by Upstream
60 min listen
Why Does Believing in God Feel Like Work? | Joseph Minich: Atheists like to tell a story in which religion declined because of scientific evidence and arguments. But what if unbelief became a plausible option because of the way modern people work, live, and relate to the world, and the way these changes make... by Upstream
64 min listen
The Five Lies Coming for Your Church and Your Children | Rosaria Butterfield: Homosexuality, “spirituality,” feminism, transgenderism, and more; an alternative creed is making inroads into Christianity and false claims on young lives. Shane welcomes Dr. Rosaria Butterfield, someone who once believed and lived those lies, to... by Upstream
59 min listen
What Has the Internet Done to Our Brains ... and Souls? | Samuel James: Christians often think of technology as morally neutral, but a closer examination shows that assumptions about the world and humanity are built into inventions like the internet. These “liturgies,” or repeated patterns of formative behavior, shape... by Upstream
66 min listen
God Is Speaking ... If We Will Listen | Os Guinness: A dandelion, a song, a mother’s love, even the reality of evil; God has used all of these to pierce the godless worldviews of real men and women. In this Upstream re-air, Shane welcomes Dr. Os Guinness to tell their stories using his... by Upstream
58 min listen
When Girls Decide They’re Boys | Katie McCoy: We’re witnessing an unprecedented epidemic of teenage girls who want to change their gender and think transition will make them happy. What’s really going on, and how can Christians respond? Shane welcomes Dr. Katie McCoy to answer these hard... by Upstream
62 min listen

Related podcast episodes

Skip carousel

Why Study Systematic Theology: Most modern Christians have a disconnected, isolated, and unsystematic approach to Scripture. This, for many reasons, causes serious problems. In this episode of Real Christianity, pastor Dale Partridge explains why Christians should work to develop a systematic view of Scripture. by Real Christianity
25 min listen
Paralympian Gold Medalist Dan McCoy: Chris sits down with Dan McCoy, a Paralympian gold medalist, to discuss faith, his life, and more. Help us share the truth and beauty of the Gospel and reach Catholics worldwide. Become an Augustine Institute Mission Circle Partner. Join the Mission Circle today! by Chris Stefanick Catholic Show
37 min listen
In an Age of Shrinking Wafflers by Eric Ludy Sermon Podcast: Church at Ellerslie
61 min listen
Fr. Gary Selin, “Priestly Celibacy: Theological Foundations” (Catholic UP, 2016): One of the particular markers of the Latin rite of the Catholic Church is priestly celibacy. How did this discipline develop there? Why did it develop? What does it mean? Since it is a discipline that can be changed, should it be made optional? Fr. by New Books in Religion
53 min listen
What is a relic? by Catholic Saints
20 min listen
Ep. 60 - Why Baptism Can't Save You by The Living Waters Podcast
44 min listen
Should We Abandon Organized Religion?: Kyle Worley and Rebecca McLaughlin have a conversation about how people view organized religion, what tends to replace it in peoples lives, and why it is important for believers. by The Confronting Christianity Podcast with Rebecca McLaughlin
35 min listen
#528 Can Catholics Fix Feminism? - Carrie Gress by Catholic Answers Focus
20 min listen
AMAZING & Wide Ranging Interview with Bishop Schneider by Avoiding Babylon
66 min listen
Episode 284: Pot Churches and the Wall of Separation Between Church & State: Should cannabis churches that claim marijuana is a sacrament be protected by the law? Why are megachurches so white, almost all led by men, and very unclear about their stance on LGBTs? Phil, Skye, and Christian unpack new research. Plus, Skye... by The Holy Post
68 min listen
10. Caitlin Crosby - Self Identity is KEY: Includes a Mantra and Serenity Prayer. CEO/Founder and all around wonderful human, Caitlin Crosby, joins DENTalks to share her remarkable story of starting her own business, the Giving Keys. Prepare to be inspired by this humbling conversation about... by DENtalks powered by DEN Meditation
45 min listen
All Roads Lead to Schism - w/ Kennedy Hall by Avoiding Babylon
82 min listen
Day 131: The Communion of the Church: The Catechism further unpacks the communion of saints and shows us how the Church lives in communion with those members who have passed on to eternal life with Christ in heaven. If you’re listening to this podcast and you’re not Catholic—or if you still have questions about the communion of saints—Fr. Mike has a word for you. This is your family, interceding on your behalf that you might receive the fullness of Faith here on earth. Today’s readings are from Catechism paragraphs 954-962. by The Catechism in a Year (with Fr. Mike Schmitz)
16 min listen
Bishop Strickland Doubles Down While Pope Francis Rigs the Synod by Avoiding Babylon
216 min listen
The Moral Authority of Organised Religion: Engaging live debate examining the moral issues behind one of the week's news stories. by Moral Maze
43 min listen
Is the Church Dead? A Millennial's Perspective on Religion with Casper ter Kuile: A dilemma that has gripped the hearts of traditional church leaders and their followers is the trend toward “non-affiliation–” those folks referred to as the “Nones” - who check “none” when asked if they affiliate with any religion or... by For The Love With Jen Hatmaker Podcast
61 min listen
St. Catherine of Siena: Join Dr. Tim Gray and Dr. Elizabeth Klein as they celebrate Catherine of Siena: a nurse and mystic with papal influence who became a saint and doctor of the Church. Consider supporting the Augustine Institute and FORMED by becoming a Mission Circle member by Catholic Saints
31 min listen
The Deconstruction of Christianity: Alisa Childers & Tim Barnett Interview by The Becket Cook Show
36 min listen
A Biblical Response to Church Scandal: What Can We Do?: Many Catholics are feeling bewildered in the wake of horrific revelations about clergy abuse. We must, however, go deeper spiritually and theologically to face the present challenges. In times of sorrow and crisis, Scripture and the Catholic Tradition... by All Things Catholic with Dr. Edward Sri
21 min listen
Keith Nester's Conversion Story: From Protestant Pastor to Passionate Catholic by Avoiding Babylon
127 min listen
February 20,2022: When approaching Orthodoxy, does it require a change of mind? What does the Great Commission mean for Orthodox Christians. Why do women in some churches wear head coverings ? How to discern advice from monastics. Fr. Evan explains the tradition and practice of a house blessing. by Orthodoxy Live
74 min listen
Reconstruction: Catholic Mysticism & Magic by St. Anthony's Tongue
91 min listen
Architecture and the Liturgy: How do the art and architecture of churches contribute to Catholic liturgy? Kathryn Laffrey and Alix Murray discuss the elements of the Catholic church, incuding verticality, permanence, and iconography, highlighting how these features connect the fait... by The Secrets of Sacred Art
76 min listen
For Catechumens in the Orthodox Church - Met. Augoustinos of Florina by Orthodox Wisdom
20 min listen
#306 Satanic Temple for Beginners - Karlo Broussard by Catholic Answers Focus
20 min listen
Daily Mass: Boldness and Belief by Catholic Inspiration
8 min listen
BONUS: Why Scripture and Tradition? (with Jeff Cavins) (2024): In this bonus episode of The Catechism in a Year, Jeff Cavins joins Fr. Mike to share the connection between Scripture and Tradition, and provide the background on the origin, development, and structure of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. by The Catechism in a Year (with Fr. Mike Schmitz)
37 min listen
Religion IRL: Is communal prayer and worship 'in real life' still as important to the faithful? by Beyond Belief
28 min listen
Women's Issues: The Church by Verity by Phylicia Masonheimer
41 min listen
Progressive Christianity | Phylicia Masonheimer | Ep. 89 by Kindled Podcast | Truth and Grace, Boldly
63 min listen

Discover this podcast and so much more

Why Do Evangelicals Become Catholic? | Chris Castaldo

Why Do Evangelicals Become Catholic? | Chris Castaldo

Description

Titles in the series (97)

More Episodes from Upstream

Related podcast episodes