We’re now officially in the latter, less mainstream half of Josh Hartnett’s career, and this week we encounter the strangest movie he’s made yet: the Asian art house crime thriller I Come With the Rain. Patrick, Jake, and Matt dig deep into the movie and discuss everything from Josh’s detective skills to the origin of his current facial hair. Also discussed: Jake’s recent wedding, Patrick’s problems with Iñárritu, and which Hogwarts house we would each be sorted into.