'It Was a Fantasy': Middle School Teacher Caught Meeting with 13-Year-Old Girl (Full Police Interrogation)

James Rutherford was a 23-year-old middle school teacher in Greensville, Ohio who had a knack for messaging underage girls online. Rutherford was involved in an episode of "To Catch A Predator" with Chris Hansen. Hansen and his team posed as a 13-year-old girl that he was going to meetup with. After Rutherford was caught, he claims there were no plans for anything sexual to take place. Rutherford was then arrested by the Darke County Sheriff's Office. Rutherford initially attempted to fight the charges but eventually pled guilty. Rutherford received 45 days in jail, 36 months probation, and a 10-year stay on the registered sex offender's list. Watch Rutherford's full interrogation.