Let's Argue About "The Rise of Skywalker"

FromAlienating the Audience

Start listening View podcast show

Let's Argue About "The Rise of Skywalker"

FromAlienating the Audience

ratings:

Length:

86 minutes

Released:

Jan 2, 2020

Format:

Podcast episode

Description

Alright, it's been a month--let's discuss "The Rise of Skywalker"! Is it the franchise-busting wompa scat critics panned it as, or just a situation of haters gonna hate? Nick Sperdute joins to analyze the film.

Released:

Jan 2, 2020

Format:

Podcast episode

Titles in the series (100)

Andrew Heaton and an army of nerds plunge deep, deep into films, books, and TV shows to ask: what's science fiction really about? What is The Twilight Zone really exploring? What are the underlying themes of Star Trek? What is the worldview of Star Wars? Also sometimes Heaton performs comedy on other planets.

Skip carousel

P2 The Economics of "Dune": Spice is a metaphor for oil. Arrakis is the Middle East. Ben Brockshmidt joins Heaton to discuss all things dune--the economic, political, and historical influences which shaped Frank Herbert's scifi universe. by Alienating the Audience
63 min listen
Battlestar Galactica & The War On Terror: Battlestar Galactica kicked off just three years after the 9/11 attacks, and tackles everything from theocratic warfare to stem cell research and waterboarding. Comedian Andrew Young joins Heaton to discuss the series, it's relentless tension and fear... by Alienating the Audience
74 min listen
P6 Regarding Batman's Political Affiliation: Is Batman a Libertarian (wealthy, gizmos, works outside the law) or something else? Which superheroes would be Democrats? Any Republicans afoot? Comedian and Marvel aficionado Megan Sass joins Heaton to discuss. by Alienating the Audience
37 min listen
The Ethics of Holodeck Sex Romps and AI in Star Trek: What's Star Trek's take on Artificial Intelligence, and how do Aristotle's virtue ethics govern Data? Also if the holodeck can summon AI's, and they are indeed sentient, is it ethical to sleep with them? John Krikorian of "Trek Profiles" and Alexandra... by Alienating the Audience
87 min listen
P1 What Bladerunner Is Actually About: Ben Domenech joins Heaton to discuss "Bladerunner," "Bladerunner: 2049" and the book which inspired both, "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep" by Philip K. Dick. by Alienating the Audience
48 min listen
Turns Out, We're All Probably Martians: Robert Zubrin is the head of the Mars Society and author of "The Case for Mars." He joins Heaton along with special guest co-host Andrew Mayne to discuss how to get to the Red Planet using existing technology, and the implications of finding life once... by Alienating the Audience
104 min listen
Stop What You're Doing and Watch "Picard": The long-awaited "Picard" series is out now, starring Patrick Stewart and following the exploits of Jean-Luc Picard two decades after we last saw him in "Nemesis." Nicholas Sperdute comes on to analyze the pilot, predict where the plot will take us,... by Alienating the Audience
53 min listen
P7 Star Trek vs. The Orville: Former Congressman Dan Maffei joins Heaton to discuss: Is the "The Orville" more Star Trek than Star Trek, or just a knockoff? by Alienating the Audience
42 min listen
Reptoid Aliens Shouldn't Have Nipples: Dr. Erin Macdonald is an astrophysicist and science fiction consultant who advises major Hollywood productions on what they're screwing up in scripts. She joins Heaton to discuss the physics pitfalls science fiction constantly blunders into, from... by Alienating the Audience
75 min listen
P3 Cold War Kirk vs. Picard the Moral Relativist: Tim Sandefur joins Heaton to discuss the philosophical differences between Star Trek TOS and Star Trek The Next Generation. Gene Rodenberry and his contemporaries lived through World War II and the Cold War, and believed in clear right and wrongs.... by Alienating the Audience
52 min listen
How They Made Mystery Science Theater 3000: Mary Jo Pehl wrote and acted in MST3K, a comedy show which dug up old (terrible) sci fi flicks and then pelted jokes at it. Over the course of its run, MST3K pioneered a new comedic medium, and rose from a local access program, to a Comedy Central... by Alienating the Audience
66 min listen
Should We Be Worried About the Lack of Aliens?: Fermi's Paradox brings up a troubling issue: if even a small fraction of stars have planets with intelligent life, much of it should be more advanced than us--so why have aliens never come by to say hello? Do civilizations all blow themselves up? Are... by Alienating the Audience
74 min listen
$Should We Be Worried About the Lack of Aliens?: Fermi's Paradox brings up a troubling issue: if even a small fraction of stars have planets with intelligent life, much of it should be more advanced than us--so why have aliens never come by to say hello? Do civilizations all blow themselves up? Are...$
The Twilight Zone's Nostalgic Cold War Bunker: Tim Sandefur joins Heaton on the podcast's kickoff episode to dissect The Twilight Zone, and how Rod Serling's fascination with nostalgia, the Cold War, collectivism, and totalitarianism made the most iconic scifi/horror show in American history. by Alienating the Audience
68 min listen
P4 The Politics of Star Wars: Stephen Kent is the host of "Beltway Banthas" and joins Heaton to discuss the politics of Star Wars. by Alienating the Audience
49 min listen
If We Met Aliens Could We Even Communicate?: What would first contact with an alien civilization look like? Could we handle it? If we could, would it even be possible to communicate with a vastly different (or superior) intelligence? Peter Boghossian, Professor of Philosophy at Portland State... by Alienating the Audience
78 min listen
How to Build a Colony Ship: If we had to send a spaceship to start a colony on another planet, how many humans would we need to get the party started? How do you avoid inbreeding, and what's a stable amount of people to maintain purpose on a multi-generational mission? Rob... by Alienating the Audience
86 min listen
When Darwin Meets Star Trek: Dr. Mohamed Noor is the author of "Live Long and Evolve: What Star Trek Can Teach Us about Evolution, Genetics, and Life on Other Worlds," and is the head of Biology at Duke University. He joins the show to talk about the origins of life, and why... by Alienating the Audience
67 min listen
Robert Heinlein: Individualism and Free Love on the Moon!: Robert Heinlein, author of "Stranger in a Strange Land," "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress," "Starship Troopers," and dozens of other novels, is at the tippy top of science fiction's pantheon of writers. Andrew Mayne joins the show to discuss Heinlein and... by Alienating the Audience
78 min listen
The Meaning of Spock: Mr. Spock is the most captivating character in Star Trek lore, and the embodiment of logic in popular culture. John Champion, host of "Mission Log" Star Trek podcast, joins Heaton for a deep dive into the character and meaning of Spock. by Alienating the Audience
49 min listen
The Tarkin Doctrine and Imperial Apologists: How would Emperor Palpatine's Press Secretary describe the Galactic Empire? How would Grand Moff Tarkin spin the destruction of Alderaan? Jonathan Last of "The Bulwark" joins Heaton to describe why he believes the Empire was a good thing--an imperfect... by Alienating the Audience
75 min listen
Isaac Asimov's Robots are Smarter than Whales: What do we learn about humanity when gazing through the optical sensors of a robot? Did Isaac Asimov write a novel where the end of humanity begins on a planet full of Libertarians? Ryan McGary joins for a full-throttle Isaac Asimov discussion, from... by Alienating the Audience
72 min listen
P5 Varys is the best Game of Thrones character: Grant Carlisle joins to discuss the power dynamics and political themes underlying Game of Thrones. by Alienating the Audience
44 min listen
Religion's Two Treatments in Science Fiction: Science fiction has a more complex analysis of religion than either "good" or "bad." Yonatan Huber and Josh Jennings join Heaton to discuss how scifi authors tackle it, and how the nature of religious critique has changed between centuries. by Alienating the Audience
72 min listen
Are We Living in a Computer Simulation?: The central premise to The Matrix is that we're actually living in a computer simulation, as well as think piece episodes from Star Trek, Black Mirror, and even Rick & Morty. Jay Mutzafi, host of "The Last Turtle" philosophy podcast joins Heaton... by Alienating the Audience
118 min listen
Let's Fight About "The Undiscovered Country": If "Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country" is about the end of the Cold War, what's it's position on the Soviet Union? Tim Sandefur challenges Heaton on the underlying morality of the movie and whether or not it's a commie apologism, leading to a... by Alienating the Audience
65 min listen
Star Trek Conspiracy Theories include "The Transporter is a Murder Box": Picard never left the Nexus. We caught the wrong Khan. Star Trek fandom is full of theories casting doubt on characters and plots as we know them. Brilliant or ridiculous, fan theories at least make us look at the franchise in a different light. John... by Alienating the Audience
88 min listen
The Last Policeman by Alienating the Audience
51 min listen
Let's Argue About "The Rise of Skywalker": Alright, it's been a month--let's discuss "The Rise of Skywalker"! Is it the franchise-busting wompa scat critics panned it as, or just a situation of haters gonna hate? Nick Sperdute joins to analyze the film. by Alienating the Audience
86 min listen
How to Build a Giant Robot: Today we speak with physicist Stephen Granade about robots! How to build giant arm-swingin' robots, how we can automate them, and where we stand on Mind Machine Interface technology in case we want to pilot said robots ourselves. by Alienating the Audience
58 min listen
Who To Kill or Not Kill if You've Got a Time Machine: Brian Dunning, host of the Skeptoid Podcast, joins Heaton to talk about all things time travel--the best films, TV shows and books, plus how to get around pesky time travel paradoxes, if we should try to go back and kill Hitler, and the most... by Alienating the Audience
79 min listen

More Episodes from Alienating the Audience

Skip carousel

The Zen of Robots: Season Finale! In which we talk about how to use sci-fi robots for helpful psychological thought experiments. Support the show! ATA Survey: by Alienating the Audience
32 min listen
Much Ado About Garak: Star Trek Deep Space Nine's Elim Garak is a simple, unassuming character. But also a spymaster. Why is he so beguiling, and what's his character arc? Andrew Young joins to discuss. by Alienating the Audience
61 min listen
Doublethinking George Orwell's 1984: Is 1984 prophetic, or merely a terrifying dystopia? What makes this haunting book so engaging on a literary level? Josh Jennings returns to discuss. by Alienating the Audience
97 min listen
Why Picard's Last Season Is So Much Better Than The Others: Star Trek: Picard recently wrapped up its third and final season--and the first season Heaton or his guests have enjoyed of it. Scottish sci-fi twins Dickie and Stone rejoin to discuss Star Trek: Picard, and what made its ultimate season likeable. by Alienating the Audience
74 min listen
Super-Intelligent Spiders And A Sleeper Ship: Children of Time: Adrian Tchaikovsky's "Children of Time" tackles multi-generational sleeper ships, uplifiting species, AI, the nature of intelligence, teleforming and more. Richard Amiro rejoins to discuss. by Alienating the Audience
49 min listen
The Corporate Dystopia of Jennifer Government: In this satirical novel by Max Barry, the United States is a corporate wasteland with ruthless businesses and toothless rump state unable to restrain them. John Krikorian of Trekprofiles joins to discuss. Book at: www.mightyheaton.com/goodscifi... by Alienating the Audience
77 min listen
There Are Infinite You's in the Multiverse: How does the multiverse shake out in science fiction? What are the tropes, and what are the implications? Scottish scifi twins Dickie and Stone Lynch join to discuss. by Alienating the Audience
46 min listen
Escaping the Truman Show: In “The Truman Show,” Jim Carey’s character is the unwitting star of a global reality television show–until he decides to escape. Director Henrique Cuoto joins to talk about the iconic film, and the evils of false reality. Henrique’s dog: ... by Alienating the Audience
67 min listen
Snowcrash Created the Metaverse: Neil Stephenson's "Snowcrash" looked at the embryonic Internet and projected a future of VR and avatar onto it. And a world in which nation states had been eclipsed by successor states of corporate "franchulates." Is "Snowcrash" a corporate... by Alienating the Audience
50 min listen
Shrinkage!: In this episode we talk about all the times people get tiny in science fiction, from "Honey I Shrunk the Kids" to "The Fantastic Voyage" to Jonathan Swift. by Alienating the Audience
49 min listen
Meeting Celebrities at Sci-Fi Conventions: Comedian John Robertson is a regular performer, panelist, and celebrity at science fiction conventions. He joins to discuss the community element of conventions, how celebrities should comport themselves, and how fans can best interact with them. by Alienating the Audience
60 min listen
Soylent Green is People!: Charlton Heston stars in "Soylent Green," a film about the terror of overpopulation, urban ennui, and ultimately cannibalism. Based on the novel "Make Room! Make Room!" by Harry Harrison. Scottish scifi twins Stone and Dickie Lynch join to... by Alienating the Audience
58 min listen
The Hilarious Fantasy of Terry Pratchett: At its height, Terry Pratchett's Discworld series accounted for fully 2% of all book sales in the United Kingdom. Over the course of his life he wrote 59 books, achieved knighthood, and created a beloved and hilarious franchise. What was... by Alienating the Audience
48 min listen
Strange New Worlds is the Star Trek We Deserve!: Captain Pike commanded the USS Enterprise prior to Kirk, and the prequel series featuring him, Mr. Spock, Nurse Chapel, and their contemporaries goes back to the roots of Star Trek: exploring weird planets with weird things... but with just the right... by Alienating the Audience
50 min listen
Trapped In John Malkovich: In Charlie Kaufman's weirdest film (and that's saying something) John Cusack discovers a portal that delivers you into John Malkovich's head for a few minutes... so he charges admission. Henrique Couto and Matt Sienkiewicz join to discuss by Alienating the Audience
69 min listen
Reproduction in the Final Frontier: Vulcans, humans, Klingons, Romulans--everybody in the Star Trek universe can easily interbreed! Stone and Dickie Lynch rejoin the show to discuss reproduction in the final frontier by Alienating the Audience
66 min listen
Intergalactic Politics in "The Expanse": The Expanse explores the political and military tension between decadent Earth, militant Mars, and the Belters stuck in between. War correspondent Kristaps Andrejsons joins to discuss by Alienating the Audience
69 min listen
Nixon Selling Pizza on the Moon: What if JFK survived the assassination attempt, and instead of Vietnam, America invested in a moon base? Bill Oakley is a former writer and showrunner on The Simpsons, and award-winning comedy writer, and the author of “Space: 1969” an Audible... by Alienating the Audience
61 min listen
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind: Characters can selectively wipe memories in Charlie Kaufman's "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," but in doing so they lose part of themselves. Chloe Effron and Nick Sperdute join to discuss this trippy... romcom? SUPPORT THE... by Alienating the Audience
61 min listen
If You Leave the Holodeck On Too Long...: Are holograms on Star Trek NPC's, sentient, or in some hellish state of limerence in between? Star Trek aficionados Dickie and Stone Lynch return to discuss by Alienating the Audience
92 min listen
Peacemaker is the Ultimate Loserhero: James Gunn’s “Peacemaker” chronicles a toxic meathead character as he comes to terms with his past, his racist father, and an alien takeover of the planet. He is neither a hero nor antihero. He’s something new, and hilarious: a... by Alienating the Audience
53 min listen
Send in the Clones: How do clones manifest in science fiction? When are they evil, good, or a portent of science gone too far? Scottish scifi twins Dickie and Stone rejoin to discuss. SUPPORT THE SHOW! www.patreon.com/alienating by Alienating the Audience
77 min listen
The Ineffable Planet of Sentient Goo: "Solaris" by Stanislaw Lem follows a crew of scientists trying to understand an utterly alien intelligence--a planet covered by an ocean of (apparently?) conscious goop. How can we communicate with something truly, truly foreign to our evolution and... by Alienating the Audience
79 min listen
Rick And Morty is Hilarious Nihilism: "Rick and Morty" is the funniest science fiction to grace the world sense "Futurama"--if not the best comedy in general. What is it about, and what distinguishes it from other, lesser comedies? Jeff Maurer joins to discuss. (Note: this episode... by Alienating the Audience
48 min listen
The Fifth Element Is Teenage Scifi: "The Fifth Element" starring Bruce Willis and Mila Jovovich is a cult classic. But... does it hold up? Did it ever? To answer that question, we turn to Scottish scifi twins Dickie and Stone Lynch. by Alienating the Audience
84 min listen
Irritating Vulcans in "Enterprise": "Enterprise" is the prequel of Star Trek, exploring the foundation of the Federation of Planets, and the bump, suspicious period when Vulcans and humans get to know one another. Scottish science fiction twins Dickie & Stone Lynch return to discuss. by Alienating the Audience
63 min listen
Lady Terror in "Don't Worry, Darling": There's a subgenre of science fiction we might call "femme fear," exemplified by writers like Margaret Atwood. Olivia Wilde's "Don't Worry Darling" is the latest example. And while it was mostly panned by critics, Heaton enjoyed it. ... by Alienating the Audience
76 min listen
Jesuits in Space!: In , life is discovered on an alien planet, and the first humans to arrive are... Jesuits. The book explores the terrifying consequences of missionaries on a new world, who are there for good reasons--with good intentions--but don't know what they've... by Alienating the Audience
64 min listen
The Sith are Emo Fascists: The Sith are the dark lords of Star Wars. But what do they want? Are they logically consistent antagonists, with clear rationales for their goals and methods, or just mustache-twirling villains with no depth? Stephen Kent and Mike TV join to... by Alienating the Audience
60 min listen
“They Live” is fear of Reagonomics: John Carpenter’s “They Live” is a cult classic about seeing through societal mirage to glimpse the strings of the puppet masters. It’s also a specific and intentional “primal scream” against Reagonomics. Ron Hayden joins to discuss. by Alienating the Audience
58 min listen

Related podcast episodes

Skip carousel

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Pregame Show: We're less than 24 hours until Episode 9: The Rise of Skywalker is out worldwide. We're bringing you our last-minute predictions and thoughts on our Star Wars Pregame Show. Stay tuned for our full review to drop Thursday night! Become a VIP and get... by Mad About Movies
57 min listen
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (with Chetan Puttagunta, General Partner at Benchmark) by ACQ2 by Acquired
99 min listen
Conversations About... Episode 9 Rise of the Rasco Brothers and Return of Star Wars Talk. by Conversations About...
117 min listen
"Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker": For this week's main podcast review, I am joined … by Next Best Picture Podcast
99 min listen
New Tenet Trailer, David Ayer's Suicide Squad & Space Force Reviews: We break down a ton of news from the week, including Christopher Nolan's jaw-dropping new Tenet trailer. by ReelBlend
106 min listen
I Bought Anakin Skywalker's Lightsaber Master Replicas 2005: Today let's unbox a new addition to my collection: Anakin Skywalker's lightsaber from Star Wars The Revenge of the Sith by Master Replicas. This was crafted in 2005 back when George Lucas owned Star Wars and Revenge of the Sith was released in theatres. Revenge of the Sith is my favourite Star Wars movie as it shows the final moment of Anakin Skywalker's journey as he transitions into Darth Vader. His pivotal decision to save Padme at the advice of Palpatine was what ultimately killed her and locked his future into the palms of Darth Sidious. That is...until his son, Luke Skywalker would come to save him. by Star Wars Theory
19 min listen
Movie News Roundup: Venom 2 trailer, Knives Out 2 casting, Weekly Recommends & more by Mad About Movies
46 min listen
The Rise of Shocker: Movies That Make Us by Movies That Make Us
37 min listen
Episode 33: The Worst First Impression: If real-life news is bumming you out, it's a good time to be a video game fan; what's usually a slow period has quickly turned into an avalanche of great releases. After spending the last week diving into Resident Evil 7 in VR, senior reporte... by Waypoint Radio
42 min listen
Episode #93: The Witcher Review & Chris Nolan's Tenet Trailer by ComicBook Nation
61 min listen
Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse by Mad About Movies
69 min listen
Pet Sematary: It’s the last of our Halloween Horror Month picks. Gav’s choice is Pet Sematary. Is this a terrifically scary film or is it destined for the litter tray? by Films on Trial
72 min listen
Ep 177: Revisiting The Rise of Skywalker by The Living Force
97 min listen
Episode 103.2: Star Wars: The Last Jedi: A Very In-Depth (Spoiler Ridden) Discussion with Spencer Howard: The definition of the word 'divisive', Star Wars: The Last Jedi has been tearing families apart for the last week and we're here to digest it audibly. Joining us today is Spencer Howard, the chief reviewer and creator of the Film Dispenser network and lover of all things Star Wars. We dive into the details - supported by Spencer's encyclopedic knowledge of the world - and bring our perspective to this new chapter. It's a must listen... as long as you've already seen the film. by Master of One Network
62 min listen
Uncle Jonesy's Cameras Podcast #68: Two Cameras, Two Lenses, and Twin Lenses: The two Shutter Brothers are talking twos! First, Kevin gets a breakdown from Wayne regarding the pros and cons of various camera pairs for his forthcoming Alaskan cruise in September. Why two? Because Kevin wants to shoot two films, color and b&w... by Uncle Jonesy's Cameras
57 min listen
Napoleon by 16mm Film Crew Podcast
23 min listen
Scream 2 by Polarized
129 min listen
Ep 28 – Caaaan You Diiiig It (Space Travel)?: Here it is! Our first Listener Voted Netflix Rewatch starring the 1979 cult-classic, The Warriors! There’s also a healthy amount of discussion about space travel and the companies trying to make it happen! by Apathetic Enthusiasm
53 min listen
107: The Show Show Show of the Show by Layout
96 min listen
Sean At SXSW & Our Interview with Rupert Wyatt (Captive State): This past weekend Sean headed down to SXSW, and brought back a catalog of movie recommendations. He and Kevin saw Us, Jake reports his thoughts on Shazam!, and we are joined by director Rupert Wyatt to discuss is latest project, Captive State. by ReelBlend
75 min listen
"Star Wars: The Force Awakens": THIS IS A PREVIEW PODCAST. NOT THE FULL REVIEW. P… by Next Best Picture Podcast
31 min listen
Huge Marvel Snap Announcement and A Look At Some Amazing Artwork! by Infinite Snap - A Marvel Snap Podcast
78 min listen
Falling Down: This week the gang put Falling Down on trial. Is it ascend to the top of the Hit List? Or does it just fall down? by Films on Trial
71 min listen
What If Obi Wan DIDN'T Leave Anakin on Mustafar (FULL "MOVIE") - STAR WARS THEORY: Hey everyone! I have compiled the two part Fan-Fic of What if Obi-Wan Kenobi DIDN'T Leave Anakin Skywalker on Mustafar into one long 'movie' for your enjoyment, uninterrupted. by Star Wars Theory
16 min listen
Mannequin 2: On the Move by The Good, The Bad, and The Sequel
110 min listen
Does Palpatine's Return Ruin Anakin's Story and Sacrifice? - Star Wars Episode 9 Theory: Star Wars Episode 9 The Rise of Skywalker has created more talk than anything. One of the recurring comments I see a lot of, is whether or not Palpatine's return undermines Anakin Skywalker's story in Return of the Jedi when he saved Luke Skywalker from Sidious. Now that The Emperor is back, was it all a waste? Here's what I have to say about it and how it could work. by Star Wars Theory
9 min listen
The Suicide Squad by 16mm Film Crew Podcast
45 min listen
Opening Night (1977): Discussing John Cassavetes and his manipulation of reality in film... by Well Good Movies
103 min listen
The Neon Demon (2016) with Kelechi Ehenulo by Well Good Movies
109 min listen
Candela Obscura: Needle & Thread | Episode 2 | Flesh and Blood by Candela Obscura
232 min listen

Discover this podcast and so much more

Let's Argue About "The Rise of Skywalker"

Let's Argue About "The Rise of Skywalker"

Description

Titles in the series (100)

More Episodes from Alienating the Audience

Related podcast episodes