Judgementalism

FromOn Becoming a Healer

Start listening View podcast show

Judgementalism

FromOn Becoming a Healer

ratings:

Length:

26 minutes

Released:

Mar 22, 2021

Format:

Podcast episode

Description

Physicians are neither judges nor God, and yet we seem prone to judge our patients...and ourselves. Saul and Stefan discuss.

Released:

Mar 22, 2021

Format:

Podcast episode

Titles in the series (49)

Two physicians, through dialogue and interviews, take a critical look at medical training and the culture of medicine and explore how interpersonal boundary clarity and the capacity to fully engage are essential to effective medical practice, mentoring, medical education, and a nourishing career. This podcast builds on Dr. Weiner’s book, On Becoming a Healer: The Journey from Patient Care to Caring about Your Patients (Johns Hopkins University Press, 2020). Hosted by Saul J. Weiner MD, and Stefan Kertesz MD MSc

Skip carousel

Part 1: Pursuing a Dream and a Calling: Dr. LaMenta Conway shares what she experienced and learned growing up in an economically and socially marginalized community in Chicago, pursuing a dream to become a physician. by On Becoming a Healer
44 min listen
Part 2: “This is what I trained for.”: In Part 2 of our interview with Dr. John Scala, hear how an experienced primary care physician in solo practice responds to the pandemic, particularly as he thinks about the physician-patient relationship, the well being of his staff, and personal... by On Becoming a Healer
28 min listen
Patient Abuse: A very bright physician scares a patient from a marginalized community out of the ER with a nasty prank -- and "I laughed too." How does this happen? Saul Weiner reflects on a moment from residency. by On Becoming a Healer
17 min listen
Airplane Guy: What's a better way to pick a student for medical school: High MCAT scores or seeing them help a vulnerable stranger when it's inconvenient and they think no one's watching? Reflections on healing as an organizing principle. by On Becoming a Healer
20 min listen
Introducing: On Becoming a Healer: How not to become a burned out "task completer" by On Becoming a Healer
3 min listen
The "Difficult" Patient: A patient got labelled as "difficult" who really wasn't so difficult, and it cost him his life. Where did things go wrong? Details changed to assure patient confidentiality. by On Becoming a Healer
24 min listen
Part 2: Hope and Healing for Those Who Follow: Dr. Conway responds to violence and hopelessness in her community, traumatized by systemic racism, by establishing the I Am Abel Foundation as a haven and resource for young people aspiring to careers in medicine. by On Becoming a Healer
37 min listen
Judgementalism: Physicians are neither judges nor God, and yet we seem prone to judge our patients...and ourselves. Saul and Stefan discuss. by On Becoming a Healer
26 min listen
Asking patients "Why?": What should a doctor do when a patient behaves in a way that doesn't seem to make sense? Saul and Stefan discuss a case. by On Becoming a Healer
16 min listen
Forced Opioid Taper: A middle aged man had been on a high but stable dose of opioids for years for chronic pain. His provider decides to wean him. He says "I'm not sure I can handle it," but they keep going. Is this what a caring or evidence-based physician... by On Becoming a Healer
16 min listen
My Learning Disability: Stefan interviews Saul about his experiences becoming a doctor with a learning disability, leading to questions such as: Does struggling with multiple choice tests mean you won't be a good doctor? How do grades shape our self image and the culture of... by On Becoming a Healer
22 min listen
Part 1. International Medicine: "Putting myself outside my comfort zone" by On Becoming a Healer
40 min listen
Part 1: Meaning and Joy in Solo Practice: A primary care physician describes why he's loved being a solo doctor, mostly avoiding corporate medicine. His patients love him too. Learn how and why this kind of practice is still possible. by On Becoming a Healer
56 min listen
Healing Interactions: What are they made of?: There are two qualities we may experience in others who comfort and ground us when we feel vulnerable and lost. First that they engage with us, meaning that they are fully present with a sense of shared humanity. Second, that they respect our... by On Becoming a Healer
28 min listen
Opioids and the physician-patient relationship: What are we getting wrong?: The opioid crisis was precipitated by physicians overprescribing opioid pain medication, egged on by the pharmaceutical industry, contributing to suffering and death from addiction and overdose. Now, many physicians are forcibly cutting patients off... by On Becoming a Healer
42 min listen
Part 2: International Medicine: "My purpose for being there is not for me." by On Becoming a Healer
25 min listen
About me being racist: A conversation that follows an apology: Saul reached out to a former colleague whom he worked with closely so that he could apologize for something he did many years ago that he now sees as racist. Saul is a white man and his former colleague, a subordinate at the time, is a black woman.... by On Becoming a Healer
43 min listen
Urine Drug Screening: How it can traumatize patients and undermine the physician-patient relationship without helping anyone: Urine drug screening (UDS) is used in the care of patients with opioid use disorder, and for patients receiving opioids for chronic pain. There's no strong evidence that testing helps patients, however, and no consensus on what to... by On Becoming a Healer
38 min listen
Vaccine Hesitancy and the Doctor-Patient Relationship: A primary care doctor in solo practice in a small mid-west city who is deeply trusted by his patients talks about talking about vaccine hesitancy. by On Becoming a Healer
24 min listen
Contextualizing Care: What it means and why it matters: Saul and his research team have listened to and analyzed thousands of audio recordings of medical encounters for clinician attention to the life context of each patient when planning their care. Here is what they've learned. by On Becoming a Healer
27 min listen
Engagement and Boundary Clarity:: The two essential characteristics of healing interactions by On Becoming a Healer
28 min listen
Why Residents Unionize: Many residents are not doing well, psychologically, and sometimes physically -- and with good reason. High levels of mistreatment and harassment, patient care that some experience as moral injury, and a lack of voice in the workplace, contribute to... by On Becoming a Healer
37 min listen
False Positives Traumatize Patients...If Clinicians Aren't Careful: False Positives Traumatize Patients...If Clinicians Aren't Careful by On Becoming a Healer
30 min listen
Pursuing a Medical Career While Black: What it Takes and Why it Matters: Making it into and through medical school is tough even for those who have all the advantages: excellent schools starting at a young age, well-educated parents who may be doctors themselves, lots of role models and…white skin. In this episode... by On Becoming a Healer
56 min listen
Rescuing medical professionalism: Could “cup-of-coffee conversations” do more good than committees and letters-to-the-file?: Medical students may be subject to professionalism review by committees, most commonly for “unreliability” such as not responding to emails, falling behind on compliance requirements, showing up late for assignments and so on. Then they hit the... by On Becoming a Healer
42 min listen
When your patient has a Swastika tattoo: Our guest, a resident physician, describes her reaction and what followed, when she discovered a symbol of hate tattooed on her hospitalized patient's leg. Most of us appreciate that as physicians we don't get to choose who are patients are, and... by On Becoming a Healer
39 min listen
Prescription Opioid Reductions and Suicide: What Should Caring Physicians Do in the Face of Uncertainty?: The narrative that getting patients with chronic pain off opioids makes them safer was reinforced by a recent paper that got substantial media attention showing an association with reduced suicide rates at the population level -- But other data, at... by On Becoming a Healer
37 min listen
When an attending yells at a resident: Our guest, a physician a few years out of residency, describes an experience from her training when an attending yelled at her and hung up the phone when they were discussing a patient. We talk about resident abuse, its impact on patient care,... by On Becoming a Healer
26 min listen
Kind People on Airplanes: Lately we've been hearing about bad behavior on airplanes. Here we discuss an incident in which a passenger unselfconsiously stepped up at an inconvenient time to assist a group of passengers in a tough spot. Saul and Stefan reflect on the qualities... by On Becoming a Healer
20 min listen
The Dartmouth Debacle: Why the culture of medical education needs to change: In a widely reported incident, Dartmouth Geisel School of Medicine accused, suspended and expelled medical students for cheating based on faulty data -- and then retracted the decision amidst a large public backlash. During the episode students were... by On Becoming a Healer
43 min listen

More Episodes from On Becoming a Healer

Skip carousel

“Tough Love” is Not the Answer: A critique of NEJM reporting on student/trainee grievances and educator discontent: A recent NEJM article and accompanying podcast episode (“”) authored and hosted by the Journal’s national correspondent sound the alarm that a culture of grievance among medical students and trainees about the discomforts of medical training is... by On Becoming a Healer
60 min listen
What a James Baldwin story can teach doctors and patients about care amidst suffering: “Sonny’s Blues” is a 1956 story by the author, James Baldwin, about a “sensible” and pragmatic algebra teacher and his younger musically gifted younger brother (“Sonny”), who struggles with heroin addiction. Both of them, raised in... by On Becoming a Healer
63 min listen
How confronting racist ideas I didn’t realize I had is shaping me as a physician and a person: In a 2021 episode that we reran last month, “About me being racist: a conversation that follows an apology,” Saul talked with a former Black colleague after apologizing to her for something racist he had done twenty years earlier that hurt her for... by On Becoming a Healer
56 min listen
About me being racist: A conversation that follows an apology: We are re-running this episode from 2021 because we’re releasing a sequel next month in which Saul reflects on his journey confronting racist ideas he’d absorbed and that became impossible to ignore after he’d acknowledged his role in the... by On Becoming a Healer
43 min listen
How effects of racism were mistaken for “race” in clinical algorithms: What clinicians should know: For years, when physicians order tests to assess lung function, or blood work to determine kidney function, or look up guidelines for managing high blood pressure the results have been adjusted for race. This practice has been based on studies that... by On Becoming a Healer
64 min listen
Drug testing at time of birth: How physicians are co-opted into harming families while thinking they are doing the right thing: The practice of urine drug testing during pregnancy and then often reporting positive results to Child Protective Services triggers a cascade that can result in separation of mother and newborn, with devastating consequence for both. These practices... by On Becoming a Healer
63 min listen
Directly and Covertly Observing Care: How it Can Transform Medical Education and Improve Clinical Practice: Direct, covert observation of health care is a novel and underutilized tool to assess health care trainees and clinicians. In this episode we talk with experts about two such approaches: the unannounced standardized patient and patient-collected... by On Becoming a Healer
51 min listen
"Dire Consequences": When students do not receive appropriate accommodations on the USMLE examinations: In the prior episode we learned that there is no evidence that time-limited testing improves test validity and that, in fact, there is ample research showing that it makes tests less valid and less equitable. In this episode we discuss how, despite... by On Becoming a Healer
44 min listen
Why it's time to remove time limits on tests, like the USMLE exams: There is a widely held perception that being able to complete a test quickly is an indication of mastery when compared with those who need more time. As a result, it is often difficult to obtain accommodations on high stakes examinations, including... by On Becoming a Healer
39 min listen
Running the Gauntlet: My Journey into Medicine with a Learning Disability: Stefan interviews co-host Saul about his experiences becoming a doctor with a learning disability. This episode, first run in 2020, sets the stage for two that will follow – in August and September, with experts on the science of student... by On Becoming a Healer
21 min listen
Why are doctors turning to ChatGPT for help relating to patients?: A recent New York Times article, titled "When Doctors Use a Chatbot to Improve Their Bedside Manner," should raise questions about why physicians are turning to artificial intelligence for help talking with other humans. While GPTChat can generate... by On Becoming a Healer
33 min listen
Prescription Opioid Reductions and Suicide: What Should Caring Physicians Do in the Face of Uncertainty?: The narrative that getting patients with chronic pain off opioids makes them safer was reinforced by a recent paper that got substantial media attention showing an association with reduced suicide rates at the population level -- But other data, at... by On Becoming a Healer
37 min listen
My patient’s in shackles: Can we take these off?: We might assume that a patient who is chained to their hospital bed must be restrained for good reason, but our guest challenges that assumption in a published account of a man in shackles who is intubated, sedated, and paralyzed in the ICU. He... by On Becoming a Healer
40 min listen
From medical student mistreatment to burnout: How can we change the culture?: In this second of a two-episode series on medical student mistreatment, we discuss its impact on burnout with a colleague who is working to change the culture of medical education and practice through research and leadership. by On Becoming a Healer
41 min listen
Medical Student Mistreatment: A Wicked Problem: How is it that a healing profession -- medicine -- has such a deeply ingrained culture of harming its own? And what can we do about it? In this first of two back-to-back episodes on medical student mistreatment we consider the scope of the... by On Becoming a Healer
43 min listen
Uncommon wisdom from a family physician and medical educator: Simon Auster, MD, was a family physician, psychiatrist, and medical educator who had extraordinary insight about practicing medicine but absolutely zero interest in drawing attention to himself. His students and patients had the good fortune of having... by On Becoming a Healer
33 min listen
Challenging Questions to Help Physicians Reflect, Grow, and Find More Joy Practicing Medicine: Medical training and practice habituates physicians to a culture that narrows the possibilities we see for finding joy and meaning in our work. We often become efficient task completers, stuck in routines, and prone to burnout. Saul and Stefan... by On Becoming a Healer
43 min listen
Organic Chemistry and the Questionable Ways We Select and Train Physicians: In October, the New York Times published the first of several articles about an eminent professor at NYU who was dismissed after his students complained that his organic chemistry class, essential to medical school admission, was too hard. Thousands... by On Becoming a Healer
30 min listen
Contextualizing Care in a Nutshell (and a New Study): Today, Stefan talks with Saul about his favorite topic (and life's work), contextualizing care. We're re-releasing this conversation (from January of last year) because Saul's research team has just published a new study -- an RCT, titled "," which is... by On Becoming a Healer
27 min listen
Medical Gaslighting: Why Are We A--holes?: Recent articles in mainstream media about "medical gaslighting" have struck a nerve with thousands of comments on social media platforms. People are complaining about how their doctors are treating them, with women and underrepresented minorities... by On Becoming a Healer
35 min listen
Urine Drug Screening: How it can traumatize patients and undermine the physician-patient relationship without helping anyone: Urine drug screening (UDS) is used in the care of patients with opioid use disorder, and for patients receiving opioids for chronic pain. There's no strong evidence that testing helps patients, however, and no consensus on what to... by On Becoming a Healer
38 min listen
Pursuing a Medical Career While Black: What it Takes and Why it Matters: Making it into and through medical school is tough even for those who have all the advantages: excellent schools starting at a young age, well-educated parents who may be doctors themselves, lots of role models and…white skin. In this episode... by On Becoming a Healer
56 min listen
Rescuing medical professionalism: Could “cup-of-coffee conversations” do more good than committees and letters-to-the-file?: Medical students may be subject to professionalism review by committees, most commonly for “unreliability” such as not responding to emails, falling behind on compliance requirements, showing up late for assignments and so on. Then they hit the... by On Becoming a Healer
42 min listen
Why Residents Unionize: Many residents are not doing well, psychologically, and sometimes physically -- and with good reason. High levels of mistreatment and harassment, patient care that some experience as moral injury, and a lack of voice in the workplace, contribute to... by On Becoming a Healer
37 min listen
Opioids and the physician-patient relationship: What are we getting wrong?: The opioid crisis was precipitated by physicians overprescribing opioid pain medication, egged on by the pharmaceutical industry, contributing to suffering and death from addiction and overdose. Now, many physicians are forcibly cutting patients off... by On Becoming a Healer
42 min listen
False Positives Traumatize Patients...If Clinicians Aren't Careful: False Positives Traumatize Patients...If Clinicians Aren't Careful by On Becoming a Healer
30 min listen
Healing Interactions: What are they made of?: There are two qualities we may experience in others who comfort and ground us when we feel vulnerable and lost. First that they engage with us, meaning that they are fully present with a sense of shared humanity. Second, that they respect our... by On Becoming a Healer
28 min listen
Kind People on Airplanes: Lately we've been hearing about bad behavior on airplanes. Here we discuss an incident in which a passenger unselfconsiously stepped up at an inconvenient time to assist a group of passengers in a tough spot. Saul and Stefan reflect on the qualities... by On Becoming a Healer
20 min listen
When an attending yells at a resident: Our guest, a physician a few years out of residency, describes an experience from her training when an attending yelled at her and hung up the phone when they were discussing a patient. We talk about resident abuse, its impact on patient care,... by On Becoming a Healer
26 min listen
When your patient has a Swastika tattoo: Our guest, a resident physician, describes her reaction and what followed, when she discovered a symbol of hate tattooed on her hospitalized patient's leg. Most of us appreciate that as physicians we don't get to choose who are patients are, and... by On Becoming a Healer
39 min listen

Discover this podcast and so much more

Judgementalism

Judgementalism

Description

Titles in the series (49)

More Episodes from On Becoming a Healer