Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

A History of Ambiguity
A History of Ambiguity
A History of Ambiguity
Ebook883 pages13 hours

A History of Ambiguity

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars

()

Read preview

About this ebook

Ever since it was first published in 1930, William Empson’s Seven Types of Ambiguity has been perceived as a milestone in literary criticism—far from being an impediment to communication, ambiguity now seemed an index of poetic richness and expressive power. Little, however, has been written on the broader trajectory of Western thought about ambiguity before Empson; as a result, the nature of his innovation has been poorly understood.

A History of Ambiguity remedies this omission. Starting with classical grammar and rhetoric, and moving on to moral theology, law, biblical exegesis, German philosophy, and literary criticism, Anthony Ossa-Richardson explores the many ways in which readers and theorists posited, denied, conceptualised, and argued over the existence of multiple meanings in texts between antiquity and the twentieth century. This process took on a variety of interconnected forms, from the Renaissance delight in the ‘elegance’ of ambiguities in Horace, through the extraordinary Catholic claim that Scripture could contain multiple literal—and not just allegorical—senses, to the theory of dramatic irony developed in the nineteenth century, a theory intertwined with discoveries of the double meanings in Greek tragedy. Such narratives are not merely of antiquarian interest: rather, they provide an insight into the foundations of modern criticism, revealing deep resonances between acts of interpretation in disparate eras and contexts. A History of Ambiguity lays bare the long tradition of efforts to liberate language, and even a poet’s intention, from the strictures of a single meaning.

LanguageEnglish
Release dateMay 14, 2019
ISBN9780691188775
A History of Ambiguity
Author

Anthony Ossa-Richardson

Anthony Ossa-Richardson is a Leverhulme Early Career Fellow at Queen Mary, University of London.

Related to A History of Ambiguity

Related ebooks

Philosophy For You

View More

Related articles

Related categories

Reviews for A History of Ambiguity

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars
0 ratings

0 ratings0 reviews

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

    Book preview

    A History of Ambiguity - Anthony Ossa-Richardson

    Q^book_preview_excerpt.htmlrW-+1$͒I]oHKPbW4ܙBdD*S*S>փf}OATE5=Kr;(];VG }sOW7>;zͫ_>z{e'O٣Wǯ_6{4{Uvɉ}`ٓ ٲBU4au}/PVټٻ>Y_k|kywYjB=g6kCQ~M .t2[aIb; Z/ס;ߝW*4?P~#?M^nQuMòZf,ͻe/eWuV˺-&/__'9Mۺm<WYQ6ۄfoZ~~vS4E6KmمgM.~DV^>MX]doBn\&E_YɎS!)j>d]xes<1V eR']ysYnx׾*CTaѨu\uYw}rm{y^|r׋aYAҭ[m,\ 0{9]h~U8%ȫl]+7xg<,xVy֮~W}+\,yg5e좝+_r!-yG j8Ȃi./SK^eGFTt(jɏ򤫠ӝ"mЬ9eր]ɵRf" 5ޕoO igK/ĽE"3n%~nP9]."\ogїym4-^9߻{ش:?u hEDP"m>ބ.)|l|߽~Z8r#L# X.r$;#2 yy[<wVEDǴ[=楜eodf=y+ խ&Y)K7&d{W:{T0o\ɲB$WS< .u2k,`wxhBM\M6r\^,鶭=i8} }ڇ!Zn&O9iא gBӺ8;rtrN}GoO?o6M-됭kkūG/A m>&j!oAYAYmbs5,DgQ{fUu["k* :9^fPUESU3cQT4Ab!S3}$0L$+,NSKLjk.=n{DŽ.]a/'h;Blff* [ʶ.K` FyZk;kNCw[h/,dBα:rW(ioͨn{WjC%|Hy[\kg̅Ď_n=1+p&`SX0v+Z[m'uhAEu ^3Wn޽Sw^"T.P$`.E%GqvGS-x\Y'7o+1(5hbD #jxP+9#lC rB٪_5٤eFj^c+ [JM[J.3h}YL(v9 s.L6H>^#+ 6; Kȡ sFV85V'UC((zͰ\>x?&$yDw%h.$u믊!MM7{woz٪.:DJv*魄+J3 3QqźZ (Uit/fbyN8@>&?4`Q{D"FqmD^ "ʣNg#gq/D;xn}CeVs.eRGO`օ9~񸟇Wŭ!'hEQ#7SK&hF6{;#_,/aU]%e) 9PXUR䥬OJ^{S ݢgّ2[F߫-`Pr\C$־*׽3T d*Ods=K7$oC>Q"4GG.Cx~Eue]|bJ Ndb (tWВE1gvIfu.,>2?dhd[2U-#  q <^9L&_-: D_X$؇_>fa!;c{!T](">/!L {!&B;?N^k;FGN|+w=~V tO6?:_=rJ֖uWˬWUWne$Œ_,Mu$ZWpu{0BTeQDu;gXnc*X~rT꾕fVU*UuܕU(7]1<%^gkq1e4o۞6/٧} oয়|wn3SYacڡ"!@;4K yB /Tm}Qax24D?̜b&@\T?ip !`ӊ>wE,s"D(ĆE50ȊPii/ Ja!N0&cZBScs1z?yD^xM'GHw+uOL#(64 Q\Qׁ`#桹5C@jX]A*3֌xrDy܎ +7)k/M㯻Qr\*5$S|ldYUr2!$ʯ VCHI>-̬+,f HԤ ˜–-GI k>=JeJԢʐhCXϘ bEPtAe yDU LWZY {?|={ Kgy<Jgef !/g12udPF 6жiCr=W('2Nk&ˊgaBm hD XS"1vV㏖"L s&yZZzֈʘo Ɗi J] 5Ph :C]R$<Th YM8|>7=vo0 ~<z ]X:wv߫i,DEr'=b /YUsM&.#_ CD<S؇uVtCY4z=噩&jDw[J"sQ܋]h,LڍI{VVK{G?Cee^gM9~8 i,-X\ɰyh΂3oL042xrZھ;/`A1MXTgr*̉3x>t2 PHTn"G%LϽvƢBN0X4Ϻ5xKPg4)zXja}3xE]#lss[FŖ4m41zP7D[3{01'fxsE˝ >hE@`8˓M_jxQ!&AiҌGmME9eKfDh˼r+CeYi1Y:9G| -F"[̀%_0[K+Ct|4r> [)KH G̕xZPܕpT.)2σ:Z %9CmJAf7@U==" "}a7V7U{% ƽ6XeZx RgؑUКϨ)lpөFX96HX9Ӵμ] (+Yib# CT4 C>15WD8ȉ;WrJ ~N'\+I+1Tj.`oh% )#$Gt:"v-h)p؏' aeFCmt[?!Gs8(NTN_M-(ض ]7S=`ăoܳ6fEgQf,[۸ALS)ǔ+TIk(!m(ޗ_P肮 "D=Ǽ1N@eR&'߸!gj[>]lKP8z yiWr/uk߾3)*tESCFVW/u@aѴN;yвj(ِCMXǎleЙ1X<C|`烢ߪaRr8etС0'ͨ].M6ulVG-eP.U @%F!bm;:M1EP}[Z8 Vus{#qyf{NĦ.؇(;;qnpF{3 OGJ8MQ^og!kb(f4U`E\Vj6Nx!"NP,KMo9y[+5VVܜRl3m.Q(?do$pϞs5e~BrB;#&?T$T,Q5gBrFckv!#[Y ۃzTXBHB0g@ʏ%Yy=_yL3Ej?DwaՆQ(5r+ȅm3*Dy̷s:2ܾf=wڳTt4B{T<|1*B8tQCыfK[*)}˘6.,XX5ߨ}<"K)3K:+#'Li:_+]J_@g[JlddΟuQcǧ6|b,Շף9.ugd[{OB7$D:bɂQ A)Jb^,Z 2y@7 F'l{ι*D4U<4C?IH"vYݮA ZY7R1m-'Vqy$\#pͭm@gh*^ŲO'ѡoPEW:_a0֣ 0P;OZvgVfP_<,ѯ&bju]O//&%Wa_ Zԓz#_ =Ě7A|qRvjcd&z$w+?n?ȠIɡ,KgZQ9a#ƅ]ʗaEo\>T;A]sE8B#Tx IGω izl-})Zk<߻ 35.l"o2ynsZYW16ԣ8 QaفzarxAbHZZ |MB)2JB䚇&u98v;[ ' (hȊ5y5Yĥ&&qA;'HA,Y~۾2LU L{{6Bj:VXjޢ77iδ,#0xeQw9<'S! lV%O{j nzKKטZҷX7G<"ġ_*rttmExNǁr%qjˆ0keHgjn#1BJHӷPQQ/b#˪MVd*D k{$3J=31;˻KJ(X9JEk.ݽT5D^6MP&84]5Cbwٔ +ʗ7űNX]F ڐJy:IJ+4a FĨ\l1R*2m:%0#6 Cȧy}DiY٫q LsWgkWc8mc f[폊]dux g< %B'^_ DA@281!F4h]红`mn>*R Y ZWWI(5Ek`|~mQl]*1^0YYٟKzD0VEnXp*F |?ޓpa3{"~D/<ߊ?,>-ͱ9iIL|.`rLB\qֲg2¿CV뉧IP b =!aq%~st>Ӣ2E9xRC1%B}6a Rϲ7\ԠEdiaDlRhzbpxzl'MT? >CyU jRc$Dp#)4'uWѿ e""&DY-Ң) B ts*[|,&M[bqFYΊףWrVl\v|FЊ"wՠmRpC,#@Dy4e#[rwMSO՞SQ8[ 79#-DUPvII lʓg ]Өݯj<وbG-%^Dܲ{Sۂƶ-?FQ@"=Dv?tv8P˼N9c3qS*ǃӆC3xuϥ?y@{M cw{tE{v2Zϧ"SS)7T9ؿw:j⟃C͎?PjBX4 иduuhGU<\&FsF5xZײp&Dc9Rv pV-ѷoB6@ Fi"]Ú(f:|uxZ9q.CH*1@Bu-@e_Q*C>Q`r>\jíA' l0SV\* LϡMV51-ܓۖt* KC EH?mm SŵXqR:&1۸]i3jiL٭|X (fbu ֶyd8FᓂiSPrs8BcUU) re&-P*4@7f Sp}A}1i?G=3ހzo\7be "cM/1ŧf,bc'ړ( Rqؔ&ԋ,ɷPVśsVh/om?Of {+ّ.MnxYjC8W܊'Or3BY-5tгU}cSN-dnQ&LB,^3\;W_8Iq36TƳzbET).hP|SXZGw#9#σ w4fƟX9ڕ04 VkS)݀FـcBt:5« ѭX/5]&\<ք_ef&PtCˇC7J(N3y)Qn LAu<3wN5thQq7.+n)f5p&%)ȀTfVDz6M#vSվoc=^G}^Qgkt0k$i^CvS!PaR8|sҹwC >Y!y(۟_ǂXw1:@ʶ'Dfz.ȳg1T_;cR+Kh~KK;n@BgnxH8zgԆGT+Ы2_e E1w[[bj,Aa Y>g5e7^&33ֹlnY24f=|z\d?/o?ǿ}S4Dқ9+X64*tВ6+yX~vro*K^me ٚ,, q")N7yD;N#΁AÚx %w/;Jd[NjMC0c9eڵ.'E2CD*B~aй,zy!VȜ RӬTc:śP3Q$o ȏ&h|zH!q %6p`h=\X sm MspM4񗱽ջc9j7K7"K3\3 s#].q_CQx_˩ NHn|@^R0GK]E#6;wła#svzcT:xcFzfƀDM#5 %e\P^vnfK,]aF(xSƚ-zjinmp-#f&Q)q5C<@ԩGi/c3Wò`p_S!=ETDS9ԜkFgmU#M3$Fŗ^ -$Ώ}\O/oW55zy/ oCgٗڍ4O壶%d1Dz fUo?OqCkw*94hМ6/{1]' E+lZDN׬0T"(DO,Yv7}>kO*k>ga8Q4kg+ru#egȇЊ1D#R+s i"A"@$HDϥ?ktF[\;Q {DYF? p we&yq WJZ!!5R>h~ZC~rM<+nREr4 Vt.6JVQ3Akv-WC,w иOO̫X@ke]L+RD)X_A҅j[kטeO5c(o6N"gk0>-fM )ųE#'^>)*ʤթdӨlnY'){ݰͪhFϻN/rV RqT䁥(2lNƀ8 MQR2Б^۳5Qtk/SJf2qEqP!<'+Է2;k,žpؚ]2bX sS4ZFiŊ@<:@3xbih㘵61͂`m  t8t\b憱[rɟXZȫj;Qncļ]i_ յ|]K!22UBȃ<1D) ]nj Y[ <&^ܒ\Ǩ;׏)%? ۜ5ܱpJpݭ;ώhN޹l5:[S<μ:r.t .#V]/Aƪ/;zqjE( ƩOh$!riR|1P61GT'9H89?W8H;Zyj ,+⑯+mM!x;lx1 k3&xEPbdKC 9#UǘӺvf)OЈPzxIie*{J8L] +\E0JadG1tN-.Xh&>P{i-rkt^ǓghQ_>V2Qm.,lSZb:b mY=NYԕyD&YL!7Ѩ m##]YvNX6PwV*:>#J(&N6k%xC֥ܤ]!`.# %4 rĭCƲ SU9|WdWbHowjUX]PZs3invG!-)>\+kdNU F $מ*{ { /zY])ڱe@Uz? e)y|)SY\AaP 3*hOɄw)6BH N5TB6+ðJS, dr5GpYmP{@ B\j$aJ=H4';JWp+mk["Aj73]i~} ] 3/Y鰸y\ y_vQH8lRyI64(Y91U:-?嵮R' .Q+Iu$ sSG*^yg~5701|18E~ t'o|;i/doe=97 _ ԝ,e<_(@Ҙ~|CWT[)Ba Or^ cBWn:OuePYD"'+ZLX.ne>sZ4\DOՁ_?F_fW|Nji߲=dzZW4I0S(ze<RV>*ʹHHdDb幄|CY{1d4rųeѲ6|?vl'0|[OVv"6MژHsn ~k=An}V_iOc!坶xXFEMu9~Կw*8 #NBtc! 2ڡ6GX!qbZ5('a m);N+k\N\b1cGpD9 eo#qeS5lkq$Ұڦ_ۀI>H$L@?@EU N-1}Y7hnOa`܏TĨbebHupXde͇/ 6{Iu4lL#,Ƭ!?⤻h3S2,c֡Ss!Lds@yKYU3MdV3t̺d4 V@F=7Hjr3A nQَyif{,_MA)@t̴)fo8DHvKiMn~6Uѫ헏^Xn|J4r|&P=NGʷ\Yǧ8 7ilz]Vsk& OTk'Ð^a_I;o_ֆc_g E^9ֺW4ӗ( GHyZ2 @y 툿P0Fų;q~U @!CGp*lN-iORO|PX;Zޖ qm->lzz>Hl M[).!CāX~236kjAFqȲ[U=]xֳmUiKEU>#|{%pII@n\"{DUS?qrwwD& G%g@(l%8ӡbjvd:$`hbYb#7hf}E!J2"x@ }?:q7Ui4a*H.oD0bF+2JCF b#&Kl}ب>#v(+i$2c0nn=T}v='IʒZ+"a\p;s%[x~Q$$b2 #R[NnqDkiX쐦oJ 7صyVv;+1Wq~ VaMp֗Kg',?dlRh[ }%9PͅΫaJq{ߨ(a[o?[1M1_ʳJD |/ՋDYRTҘ%qbܥ~8nI#2qk#M}qAjAA唴)NOnkOޜhuFOH3a@ m1v֙-s \~~1~1KKwsIUKan={C4QA0UFpֻ"gB@t8nѿʾLZ] YѾPM,aw<<(4k# ,Gkm(HBhҴkx  gsXR|Gw` Mn2Z{)dc5ʛ>)quY][{ʋTԳEd7dIjg%QCbD6)U=B>ACu22y'ԆD} S*OvIlQs ҷҗu_Q6.s̕W)b< `Lq/˂tnfd>,Hu:D8N,P~nBrwpr8{m=A6)DA|9V=8~ٳEq GڋA~ VСI"(^u6 ެTވ",na)-=FBqC%&`iʅ8Y2|*I:yeSźktW/AFkH :ob$](3tT'W+"gm^ި'@R"t()X6DQoJ41me~U}t0YSRu7mZ C*f&\ݮnYC"6*nLH%Ք辢3ި  -zOMbu; ͑)8^.V%T%:٦QB6 GyQ=ksG%iI6F&m<|ʹu]?Z%iv؈[vO}LVWa_V qigϨzQNicG`ֲvE– zi)ү`YPOAmA]:6>d,]ODƖVeG{U@Voi9z*͑N?glc^Ɲ|bK?X56, 'i@{8L|+۬=kYroXrFb,d#K 8FK<#$tF[̅N,CY$9zVx| ~Q;ɛL?{dt7#a:q!: k`IwøwX" FyB9=FxI0)D:gxVP)ȹH 9C6Uu;$-ߑ~*!kJ(7焩[#-K] v]):_ڍMD^ ̕u5bZӁԡV5Žށ5yl3h"9NXOXBpxiύ"N_a{јA};f;'@%}n-ctӷ!lN;;\ uy_5[H6o\/ DAY|Mo.2nZHl}*Aʻ_MJتۃ˓7Q^znBvvM{ܟXwbZ㞶IJX[;LZ8l=x [cKY"u#QN=;׽C2L"~?:!!ql4cp?P8{r302u<91Z}F-#śC"|d~ک6;1ZcDF>FiٰswΆx⬶ Mf̵ -Gp2Lj28O)gܹFnKSHYnGQ.- ܋%qȰ!f눠^cs>́x3*]$.ƜPKƼH+rÓ.ZAnܒ ff\6sBސ%X1d"4). ^7V^BxI!-EGW6Y J"4Wޗ.W?,Zʉ#}uqH[ EڃDjpCJ7I]W3aqfSG*=Rj9k%eESy~*6+e XBXo1Gnv uX@vָɌa[|1< " ޸bNRE \%)(QTNgac8>XdvxDxΟ(Y-G3 "!iS#)z#-QI6ܘЋp_ .=TbY ^!$ cqg/q&]՗YkE!;Xco: -oR-*rH)F[ aǪX'7W*4ˢCwQ10J>dl\C'DU0=B/J&NvTR׫\9UZ3ct %/P`޻(_VsEUUJykj9=sU6`l~RhLn/770\C.z0*$LCux6΁$)iF`j{}6H;"F94<9J40n_CApYylYby=IԔ)R1z="EO&• 1fy'PYh0;~]։F`1UTG},je ׀;Tگ +so޿:$qn޸zgS96ubUv\1 *^Uj,69"ws1ڦnvYm/~?{JYFƗT;Un#c 㬺rXNsʋ<N\\ծM~q O&ʂo }=١>]W:pqMLl"t߃Ho??516hf$nDӊ;4!Ge޷%.n`QoX(-7d:LߺIP`H!qY\܀J.FW3q@pR:}öEBݲg%VVsHἸ']uKR+Np~UQ{3żЎ]}Ԯ_ c({.Mr$Ne ?Rs02MkT*O?|O秅"ΖdBݼQ|x4C_%s;tP-A7u_0rԒZ݌H_6[SaUppua!qyO1>i;4/JGIޮ{rd=8@"cd %v5RNһO0gTd9O*琒2=4@(c~uT|,d^揜P?yNn{Cxo4ٿyq?$WJH1n%8 1˻'#.v,;cbOk/Sew:;ke]yiO#X{7nޑuh4{^jhpb=m0"k挵ح &&mw]]+L #nL*\u2^tlm$%dEGFP*ʬS2Y|X"^z6ODF np9 w.ҟK>@.4Lp=X޸'[wūE yw u2#Mr[b7(xUIi' Y[u՟0re#r1O8&X$Oo;6H9t+—H8<쒛|ЪFiC.;:~vXwGq(dVy8ؿ~`T[=z[nwkE-_Se83TT Q@t:t^GzIL0ñmHsxS8TV8Ztf XR~[L@Ż{t!Xqh"}*^uՁ@[inVV2LM@8ć)Fyi{{BGwQԁC8Up-ƂIlE*Cx8 MValc WUBxkЫ#bGa=v.Z0Z<+F 8u׉K1aEܾad0~(鸛:Јﳹd߿wu&<)qѱx)ziҩ:[@T]`W dO_PC3[@ƵE9=В~?u]w D%/DRf?Ⱦ*%@tٛ\ -ms܍h p?a`sz7ok97|\uɫ*w3m)C=i5!k' ␼VZ5$/zF殉{4_Uٿ@e?m, {z8jc/e?9J<š7U,rD!| o$(&&PGmS(AQGg  Ўg@R>,37D_Ȳ U{ݽ9>u rwh> NoNxvK~ Zu|;{ĖQS.w,a mRhF70} 2fnj|DWE.VKԮ&.r~{&Z+#\{E't\|PқP1̬jqvxF7bki v@b0u3p ć'y3#TcU)kaߜꘚG6U$M|\ w#FݿekCU)ʺ'֧9f^7P? tW'a~{탻qu^"dz|LNn-׎ H=eimk/;[ąy7 ^7MQ›)K3*wLb׵)ޭQ[cvK~oH+}0>꽸p)okC]bQgOh'(^.;ZnLƺkTx74.mZ|p|`}-&W~CYiu\Ș>xϋ.@ٿK}šf5x(!G{\_)y_.jxQp7: !j'N{$L+f\|b$yzy:N-7dOQ"[+?%#3d$j14x&a@hFtwLT1E'@$esѝn-A[4)Irm%'U_R7V2=5._x'd_e1qk@ N8P tKݼ'YKbCJKmER+ԗvϭZ q#poܾq>M]2=(=-*T* \P?+I*EikD0$\xyhA޸qw)m-lfR; 8FH2D-e?,kIjI4k,CQ/?J29߬/Ϩũ/G B阄8qR |Dꑑ\x݈KD0S:B^"V(Z1VhUn<S xXz/wH8V:-9OrGWr'.aYʭ^˂C,nXgKE\v(na_x EԕH7+艋.XPB1VmD88i7[.kkF=0xO٬ :14 173y&VZ#BYq=.ҟv|t:TOG~Sla6[ ?{|܁ܽ(K }hc6:f,?`* 6@-t2}mʣI:];"rj0L3/ȁmS3ufõ*>`v |wGWw뾿[ɮ|}Xdrj&ak9&SH>ΚCn|Ɵr2lII ٿYޞsq15Vc{2{޻dSh.u><̜--OD;2rÖ 8o̧T_2iHo^€ p7L{~C
    Enjoying the preview?
    Page 1 of 1