Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

Masada: From Jewish Revolt to Modern Myth
Masada: From Jewish Revolt to Modern Myth
Masada: From Jewish Revolt to Modern Myth
Ebook461 pages7 hours

Masada: From Jewish Revolt to Modern Myth

Rating: 3 out of 5 stars

3/5

()

Read preview

About this ebook

A new account of the famous site and story of the last stand of a group of Jewish rebels who held out against the Roman Empire

Two thousand years ago, 967 Jewish men, women, and children—the last holdouts of the revolt against Rome following the fall of Jerusalem and the destruction of the Second Temple—reportedly took their own lives rather than surrender to the Roman army. This dramatic event, which took place on top of Masada, a barren and windswept mountain overlooking the Dead Sea, spawned a powerful story of Jewish resistance that came to symbolize the embattled modern State of Israel. The first extensive archaeological excavations of Masada began in the 1960s, and today the site draws visitors from around the world. And yet, because the mass suicide was recorded by only one ancient author—the Jewish historian Josephus—some scholars question if the event ever took place.

Jodi Magness, an archaeologist who has excavated at Masada, explains what happened there, how we know it, and how recent developments might change understandings of the story. Incorporating the latest findings, she integrates literary and historical sources to show what life was like for Jews under Roman rule during an era that witnessed the reign of Herod and Jesus’s ministry and death.

Featuring numerous illustrations, this is an engaging exploration of an ancient story that continues to grip the imagination today.

LanguageEnglish
Release dateMay 14, 2019
ISBN9780691186016
Author

Jodi Magness

 Jodi Magness is the Kenan Distinguished Professor for Teaching Excellence in Early Judaism at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and a member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. From 2017 to 2020, she served as president of the Archaeological Institute of America. In addition to Qumran and the Dead Sea Scrolls, her research interests include ancient pottery, ancient synagogues, and the Roman army in the East. She has participated in over twenty different excavations in Israel and Greece, including as codirector of the 1995 excavations in the Roman siegeworks at Masada. Since 2011 she has directed excavations at Huqoq in Israel's Galilee.

Read more from Jodi Magness

Related to Masada

Related ebooks

Ancient History For You

View More

Related articles

Related categories

Reviews for Masada

Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
3/5

3 ratings1 review

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

  • Rating: 3 out of 5 stars
    3/5
    This is definitely a book with more questions than answers.Many people know the traditional tale of Masada: When the Jews rebelled against Rome in 66 C.E., they took many fortresses in the area of Judea and held out there even after Jerusalem and its Temple had been destroyed. Masada, on a high butte that could only be reached by very difficult trails, heavily fortified by Herod the Great, and surrounded by harsh terrain, was the most defensible of them all, and was the very last to be besieged by the Romans. In the end, the Romans built a ramp that would let the legions reach the high plateau, and the garrison committed suicide rather than be taken prisoner.The problem is that, although the Jewish Revolt was real, and Masada was real, and the Roman siege was clearly real (their ramp can still be seen), our only account of the siege of Masada is from Josephus, and he wasn't there. Nor was he always reliable. And so archaeologists, including the famous scholar/soldier Yigael Yadin, have studied the ruins of Masada... and often interpreted it in terms of their own view of history.This book, by an archaeologist who was also a tour guide in the area, tries to clear up some of that confusion. But I'm not sure it succeeds. For two reasons.First, it suffers from its own case of Yadin-ism. This manifests itself in several ways. The one that grated the most, for me, was Magness's history of the Maccabean Kingdom -- the story of the priestly family that rebelled against the Seleucid Empire in the 160s B.C.E., and eventually founded the last independent Jewish state until the founding of modern Israel after World War II, but which quickly fell from its lofty purpose and became aggressive, overly-politicized, bully-kings; the Romans took over the Maccabean Kingdom just about a century after the beginning of the Maccabean Revolt. Our sources for the Maccabean Era are very poor -- for the beginning of the revolt, the books of I and II Maccabees (the former tendentious and the latter just plain unreliable), and after that, nothing but Josephus plus a few scraps from Philo and rabbis and the like. Magness often lands on some particular interpretation, some of which I think are right but none of which are as certain as Magness's presentation. Similarly Magness's comments on the Essenes and their relationship to Qumran. It's a complicated issue that is made too simple.Second, I just don't understand what Magness is giving us that is new. We are told to beware of Yadin-ism, but aren't really presented with a coherent alternative. I can just hear you saying that first I complained about her being too certain and then complaining about not being certain enough. That's fair, but the situations aren't parallel. If Magness wants to tell us that Josephus and Yadin are wrong, or may be wrong, then we need to know what else might have happened. And I don't think that alternative is offered. Some reasons are offered to think that the mass suicide didn't happen, and justifications for why Josephus made it up (though I found those to be utterly inadequate) . There are also reasons to question the reliability of Yadin's excavations, simply because his techniques were rather out of date. But those are just isolated questions.I did learn a lot of things from this book that I hadn't known. But they're mere isolated facts. I feel as if, to really understand this book, you need to already know all about the Maccabees, and Herod the Great, and Qumran and its inhabitants, and Roman history, and Josephus -- and if you already know all that, then you hardly need this book. I'm truly not sure who this book was intended for.

Book preview

Masada - Jodi Magness

 d`book_preview_excerpt.html}r$Gv寄6cY]wiCPTR,<3<3Ydi'4=ۖG%sν=")E7Q@F8_|vMUyzq4w _߼}oO2Ӈ.d`ͷ_ޟp~qݧ/?~Ⱦ.^!ӭ82>~zvVջ&];ywwM(2\ 6]?'Pm Ͳ~}.{/˪3*ojq5xS|75W?>7Ӣ>mɷAO>O=Wivonq](W3|IfQuŋٳ'O=~vrtɽ'3~O;9J hBf¼q.;s+: }b_fڅ _qj+gyv7u2W{u"*cq;ߔ_oê|gŵkOGrʁpcW}PͲ>U_Ûcf[ɮZfgYH6{׺OƕY6u6CёCз٫]wgv[RpDgSvsK2e0jոz{`öo/sgUto 9^ow_j.E<-~}J}W& W~CU( /nv7u8Od*/k\{oXeQ}py"鵯x*mՆOr_DO%Iw_~<_ ljwdɳ7]Nn{E+|t;NO%[?_k;@4zgwݿ`_~md/ GLG_}ZjﲹQw;ݻ㝏6krdeNޱ[wwۖE_6?~pkՇS:Aݏ<V:p`@P!%d/zw铽 VA?>+lI=8]{tSs/ݝvow.v~޽tyӳOt,yV6 mh85ü' 54.Xx)`ڇe `- n _.*Q'j ؂cvR3| qU8pT}u< fǸvG ;<\wEBS8uTNu Nv>s: D'f00r.߄A[5@]S;~l PY?_O]@;Tj`S.U,ltČnntsxtŚTY:K9XLJ/TȟUF @ XuU0VUUZ eK"[. je^m|RMvm&.rgNpFzbo}[p&B<ח^c[Y>58|RW-~oy|-z2'E UImz,9M"2\M6Q7} ?UO̠^fu3_ U>~:(0T8sPݪܹc72oekWR+4$N?=׶;0QZ'8s5Oe'$"kE\Džg~ܯKGq? xy+JgdC3~HMx63) ;wv`(LnvwZ{{Uuv W-EYSV'תȥ4ڄ"tt>}Uʈ/ ?e̪< ]2(У<{hCVjpq /o_v)ƥ@FHMJVxqY;[ [Y [%@"p':AX<ŜcaQN=yx ʓ;a;!KZ 51 Z%<2W :(ږ(zeA &2g/|S] P9kژmEe;ZWB`";Y@Nk  -~sHM{i)dӆ"7؀!x7UofOD=6@u|xBMQ vBR3gLdWӽoĢ@vPpacE&#{2)8N&Ԇ]_Ï?۰0CʪmQr%6Oт8߷&DiE  lX`#Jf/5@`p1<Ƿ1~3kӪHs{n( 4([9*(z3S\aj];B=au]0~)'gX0 tU]$sIJ$@VM>+& $`«x'^%~klcK SE'j'Kb`J:Ba3ΊY};o ^ebz8Efv: !x$?jUGuDU ))/ޓ;36+"*Npb䎣cM2-Lj6lCv5~wHE_ziW٤}7 :o*o6c̫>o]BSQ*f-dV|@XJ'\e_USy&2{W3^㐢] `*jWgq3ei'? 8gN8{2ah 3*B ߄ d{9.M{Rq"~%. BuH%K̈6ɏJB" T+YH^zkɶ~%~6_䊾EXtylAبF.瑠y$SY5xtTy`@U<@Nt F%2./( mREo)8+vpkT &nN'ou0|XlL o[__2(2(pcTtC%pi D 9FhD-εEwmo>[NU`jg[zDL #J1HfWbP")W \}T5ɄEkK8̪[z'i坮a0FEPd,(<[ם罨A]':E@K8VtqN쀎g̲NӃLJ_Ͽ_j[Z7b9rcIȔ or>]DKr>!Cc@ucȳVsmgWe\3]¥,,ﰄ:_WpʎhNPc[Y{Kst׵CWNm+g"i  $R]M˿ 昬f^h1C+@~ى/""&VyT.ngG$c;ya i^[]tص/WļK/6(HCnaj/2ʈ(u ?cx eÔZDoD5_hǞd9ɂV<"1 @h kvȓsR.CB3Mel;!3p[Vʎ1$Hܛ"a urEe/Jz}x)ؐ`)˪1OB48k! *PC-W5Ŋ*ߘ7[͌HQ|cx>\dFϵm*အ VUWoTeng)p"8k^ݜP m€,jrNھ^~h,5e*N)?$ċh@ 0'!I)8ZI-=|(a#CN+: Z÷ͼb.<ʅ;a5;v%NKfM,,8 m~4L )v=yP8'2aKBë`DIo 4eRi[]hҫpȂ /q;Yڸʋ\j "% &+VD^bMK4g yoĈGy瀥*_3λ/+EԖܠ!MFu,)`,bه2lm|MjM|[Wo_,4^j-_/b"oIbI\"HY:k%`AcT"V"1Mw{ێY70ϥZЙ0|8GEq0pGS$VDq9 \F`;NU65ջ>ctk[8jQ|INqu䗪%VL_l>V,%VG.f㨭 Y:"(udN^xK TVx@GG(gL3Sd8Pb/>=qYGSݪGDUb@>(>Yo{PUM310 f(H XK7=V:`zMCɰ;Pլ\sZ6H_V,'랭 y& wr[Fu{9zzlbճ ;H\b_khMgrH롕 qUF_;#O, l1UBO˪Cve ~?3+`r"264N,'M󳛄-ԉMa@==wo|  +m@m[*_No.n#X擷: 0#7U:3QࠒDry-,ŜY9-亻;48:Vɽ3q7qWg=gKb,cWٽ{ pOE_0b^xof඀A}$ՠ+0ybg -!X+cF,U;t  5pGM2dkSZ$()Vf\S` GGqQ:48\VlKj0igd&Yo,0 C q\n0mW5.Ԛ2bk5xD GULz },8{v_ @H%Vd)hE<2l_dcJN"{θHM-Y_;ck@PX9b5!h*1︁b$VH)#=Χ*Ģ34݉僄m:,fIWiVҤHGjk̡e˩ܓ0* n K(_$|Eg-(7xnIUB$&V}VX-ɿg yg zqW˸^&~~ W9*AyW(-K1-t_$eL ~1riIihҦGivNSgp% NP)i5 2i,L (FqQ'1蹷ƶI4G7|LS c)$$^HZ}*e(6C -6Œ3,g^iwU×¼p9It߭D٨~ƥO&<±FgjSB}¢Mc'b:x[]KkAACҸcHّQ^*k,e7eP"IkJ.ɥԶ>T3ļB+ ΔD,^VS prV#z%TʱhBcJRϪ\aJ`1y^ ,4au/# >MU ƒCqb4cBQ֥98t#Ǣc%ȯoH4\]5)F"N]F=N1z߿331껫rO1<۶:7Vgӣ:El s(rR]!IMiܴO~T=[5VpX@bz)h^ݟ Ӏo~X#QSfe iDL1?֚w,Hq:8'9cV"LA:e8t81LIƪmA&.mn]$MG_K Be`Pyq<|/}\DT +YɈKկס4bV$%@8# wss8%lcxv 22~5z6 K&0𺓎}&s owӦtR1 cfú8g.ّua:qU⻝;Vh##~u65x:Sc0r71i_V#itW%;Uo@1hk*AQ;89T&2iD4gHަ@,n#\^?F$ax-6 *RN9&%mٶqP=)RlMֹi$Tv!&AqN4CRip:wy#bRR>[kA=3(6iŜʗC1<}Ѩ!4@U7lJil0Tr2.1i>F Km1o{hD/v2taɆ1&㰼ٙtre5ш ZnYEB+A@W/MoW'ȦRQ9aquɂp "ᓿC  D$MU|D_lun>$f1dldk_ѹ$!:`9:hNP ڨϩ~Nע&8%Ff%z=j7&0@CWBʒK.kªטROuIl-5%wf"{Gg?Z[]H ]$mH.kج@$R[a!Y@$W/述dTQ~ ,fyqa~ZqLq$:n:̼Rr &|URi'Im/V ~Se^ &k 4kl'q\tHvqgbLLIPPtqsFwhԐ{bY-,\E9𰱱/Ӳ\k [IfoC* @0Rfg qr‘G(rd(B#2`QJ JƷJR=5ԗXmK_)5d4Ff_DAݵ׉c M"d 0\@?3B-uvsk +)M܍NP2P}B}p:IC\/HG0.-⧩F0=i[QyX96ckn~~ۋ,-H9DCCÀIQzP7&荐Je;Y`R.VVHf}V;S#-}EUqIcw-xN}9y+$!2V2*#ޅYBsyxsߔv|3~KK@>su2ӚE("RPrqvԖj/@P! C"-uDN0^=Kuچi4>V^Va-C0PVCi>5sg)H%QP6-}YNBYSzʗ6$)R-kJ$ae,E1sM(STmD24 胐F Ig[sP Yu1uUv%@D},:Ց$: ]6ct/)K ὕCI=8,CIu8+%!c㡢:qBGVjH M]Yf%c#3P``I)^ueysBmRMbJ>EZͽhcp,ǃ&>fU~sIr%a6a ؁&A2z{\\q[EC&qk.x:N:,!~#ь]iә{ %z=v {+f5]/Zw>F7HdLvhwQm:H aIqڝ< TYNu~Q6WW5Ѓ7-1Di>ZƵ2E8V~K˫UGYMd6FX/UΫa.wFhFq l$e-QO@|Q!k*^t.];bNƙ,Zb6kΡXN""soά(X}b5 ӽ ;TRw}U*ߴA8%FP\Oa1fRz۾u q0j IE{]B0=I]; `6X%M_^d8);4KBiA9}}&~ 2oj҃ )KW)mtxe5bqRr]])v1:~ԝoGJS2IOG^9g f[ Taռ06p~gGibBX[=1jݒ DJ >Rf*9wjjْ0.K">x57otEuTokzkL?h/ sX.$4*=ՖU"+VT`Z-KPYBj\.'~id ZGy5%`iS:4À{R'zmkBJ!~9S*`k2NPiκ9Ac܅c¯&hBNr3D޺ omV,@MY "9mF- ,笈QdЈɨ!meP;Xw'YfTf@v51\q1|1Ae'q)*YVUaĉ}%- hioDsp;K$g&f]J ΎL]k=ic?8N>܋HkN"Ku5/ugw"hBqp, ] 9!j_z"q!IFA:!Gtq` ڧ8T0LPpxH *BYpvo!,-$d#!-L($a׾]D!)p,xK:dvG0ca˶t"僠71ey5Piʝ@{uTz` Lj"iW(*t\ (xM;r~j$_p:N8Hڪd.yh`4Ǣ{7nEN#i\+ֱ6f%c!+s^OGlRZ?_, :vQ 'wLF |N¡]tRhcN[Va~ FS-],?JJ1\:jFޖ:4C}f8~D)mx2|F$)*`8V"{CT:B V EG
Enjoying the preview?
Page 1 of 1