The Plot Is Murder

By V.M. Burns

The small town of North Harbor on the shores of Lake Michigan is about to have a new mystery bookshop. But before the first customer can browse, the owner becomes a real-life murder suspect . . .
 
Samantha Washington has long dreamed of owning a mystery bookstore. And as she prepares for the grand opening, she’s realizing another dream—penning a cozy mystery set in England between the wars. While Samantha hires employees and stocks her shelves, her imagination also gets to work as her heroine, Lady Penelope Marsh, long-overshadowed by her beautiful sister Daphne, refuses to lose the besotted Victor Carlston to her sibling's charms. When one of Daphne's suitors is murdered in a maze, Penelope steps in to solve the labyrinthine puzzle and win Victor.
 
In the meantime, however, the unimaginable happens in real life. A shady realtor turns up dead in Samantha’s backyard, and the police suspect her—after all, she might know a thing or two about murder. Aided by her feisty grandmother and an ensemble of enthusiastic retirees, Samantha is determined to close the case before she opens her store. But will she live to conclude her own story when the killer has a revised ending in mind?
 
“A promising debut with a satisfying conclusion.”
—Publishers Weekly
 
“Cozy mystery readers and historical novel aficionados will adore this warm-hearted,
cleverly plotted new series.”
—Kings River Life

 
 

• Language: English
• Publisher: Kensington Books
• Release date: Nov 28, 2017
• ISBN: 9781496711823

V.M. Burns

Valerie (V. M.) Burns is a mystery writer whose novels and short stories have been finalists for the Agatha, Anthony, Edgar, and Next Generation Indie Book Awards. She is the author of the Mystery Bookshop, Dog Club, RJ Franklin, and Baker Street Mystery series. Valerie is a member of Sisters in Crime, Crime Writers of Color, Mystery Writers of America, and the Crime Writers' Association. She is also an adjunct professor in the Writing Popular Fiction Program at Seton Hill University in Greensburg, PA. Born and raised in northwestern Indiana, Valerie now lives in the southeastern United States with her two poodles. Connect with Valerie at VMBurns.com.  

Book preview

reality.

Chapter 1

North Harbor, Michigan

Victor Carlston, don’t you think it’s wicked to sit here enjoying yourself while your dearest relative lies at death’s door?

That’s a good start, I said out loud, even though there was no one to hear. Although, I don’t know about Carlston. It doesn’t sound British enough. Maybe Worthington? Weatherby? Or Parkington? I think I like Worthington. I rolled the name around in my head and scrolled back up to make the change, reading aloud as I made the edits.

Victor Worthington, don’t you think it’s wicked to sit here enjoying yourself while your dearest relative lies at death’s door?

Hmmm . . . I wonder if Worthington is too British. Maybe I should go with something simple, like Brown. I was about to try out yet another surname on my hero when the doorbell rang. My toy poodles, both moments earlier curled up sound asleep on an ottoman, barked and raced downstairs to greet our visitor.

I peeked over the stairs and saw my sister Jenna’s reflection in the glass. I considered ignoring it and sneaking back into my office until my cell phone started vibrating in my pocket. My family and the Borg from Star Trek had a lot in common. Both demanded complete assimilation and resistance was definitely futile.

Darn it.

My sister wouldn’t leave me a moment of peace. It was just a matter of time before she tracked me down like a bloodhound.

I girded my loins, tramped down the stairs, and opened the door.

Like a blustery autumn wind, Jenna Rutherford blew through the doorway and marched up the stairs, talking a mile a minute.

Have you talked to your mother? She stopped at the top of the stairs, turning, and looked at me. What’s taking you so long? Do you have any tea?

Resistance truly was futile. I closed and locked the door and went upstairs. She already sat at the breakfast bar, waiting for her tea. I stepped behind the bar, grabbed the kettle, and filled it with water from the sink.

Hello, Jenna.

Your mother. When is the last time you called her?

It was always "your mother" when Mom was annoying.

I talked to her this morning, I said slowly and deliberately. I knew where this conversation was going.

Oh. Well, your mother called me all upset.

Hmm. Little input was needed on my side of the conversation. She was on a roll. I placed the kettle on the stove and took tea bags from the cabinet.

Sam, it’s been six months. You’ve got to snap out of this, she droned on.

This was an old song I’d heard before, but that day something snapped.

Six months. Is that the deadline? Anger rose. Leon and I were married for thirteen years. He was my best friend.

Perhaps Jenna sensed we were on dangerous ground when my voice got softer and each word became more pronounced. Unlike most people who got louder as they got angrier, I tended to get softer and I enunciated each and every syllable.

Is six months really the cutoff for mourning? I took several deep breaths to regain my composure. Jenna, I know you mean well. Everyone means well.

What neither my well-meaning sister, nor the rest of my family, understood was that mourning was actually comforting.

The first month after Leon died, I don’t think I felt anything. The shock was so painful, I was in a daze. Afterward there were so many things to do. Decisions had to be made. I didn’t have time to think. I barely had time to breathe. I definitely didn’t have time to grieve. I paced behind the counter while I talked.

Thankfully, Jenna sat and listened, something she rarely did where I was concerned.

After the shock wore off, the pain started. It felt like a part of my body had been cut off. It’s only now, six months later, that I feel like I can mourn. I have finally allowed myself to feel again and the heaviness, the grief is actually comforting.

The look on her face said she didn’t understand.

I know it sounds crazy, but it’s like when your foot falls asleep. At first you can’t feel anything, so, you keep shaking it to wake it up. Eventually, you get the prickly tingles right before your foot wakes up completely.

She stared, but at least she wasn’t talking. I shouldn’t be angry with her. None of it was her fault.

Jenna, I’m fine, I said calmly.

Her skeptical expression was enough for me to backtrack.

"Okay. I’m not fine. I sighed. But I will be."

She looked into my eyes as if the truth was there behind my irises. Who knew, maybe it was.

"Okay. But we care about you and we’re all worried, especially your mother."

I know, and I’m sorry. I don’t want you or Mom to worry.

The kettle whistled and I poured the boiling water into the mugs and handed my sister the box of raw sugar she liked, which I kept in the cabinet especially for her.

Anyway, what were you doing? Jenna asked.

I perched on the stool next to her and sipped my tea.

Writing, I said shyly. The fact that I was actually attempting to write a book was a deeply held secret I shared with very few people. Until recently, my sister and my husband were the only people I’d entrusted with my precious dream. Talking about it was still scary.

Leon and I were both huge mystery fans. We met in the mystery section at a chain bookstore. Leon liked hard-boiled, private detective stories and I was more of a British cozy person. Regardless of the types of mysteries, we both loved the genre. Even our dreams revolved around mysteries. I fantasized about becoming a successful mystery writer, while Leon dreamed about owning a bookstore that specialized in mysteries. We spent countless hours talking about our dreams—dreams that seemed light years away. Leon worked as a cook at a diner and I was an English teacher at the local high school. We worked hard but lived hand to mouth and paycheck to paycheck. We knew our dreams were just that—dreams.

By the time the doctors found the cancer that caused the pain Leon complained about for more months than I could count, it was too late. With only a few weeks before he died, he made me promise I would buy the brick brownstone we walked past weekly and talked about "one day or when we hit the lottery" how we would fix it up and have our bookstore. He made me promise I’d take the insurance money and buy the building and write my book.

I sold the three bedroom home we’d purchased and renovated over a decade ago. It held too many memories. Every room was a story about our life together. My family and friends tried to talk me out of making major changes. Maybe I’d regret selling the house one day, but Leon suggested it. He knew me so well. He knew I’d never be able to move forward as long as I continued living in the past.

Earth to Sam.

I pulled myself off memory lane. I’m sorry. What did you say?

I asked how the writing was going. Jenna took a scone from the tiered plate on the counter and inspected it.

I knew what she was looking for. Don’t worry. There aren’t any raisins in that batch.

She spread clotted cream and strawberry preserves on her scone, took a bite, and moaned in delight.

The book is coming along pretty well, but I’m just getting started. I have a long way to go. I have my main characters, Penelope and Daphne Marsh and Victor Carlston—or Worthington. I’m not sure which name I like best.

I like Carlston, Jenna said with a mouth full of scone.

I like it too. Maybe I’ll keep it. I reached for my fourth scone of the day.

And when is the grand opening?

Supposedly in two weeks.

Why ‘supposedly’?

I’m still waiting for the last set of bookshelves. I’ve got boxes and boxes of books that have to be inventoried and shelved and my new point-of-sale system isn’t working yet. I also haven’t gotten the final okay from the health department to open the tea shop.

Well, the tea shop can wait. You don’t have to do everything at once. You could get the bookstore opened first. Then once it’s open and running, you can open the tea shop later. My sister always adopted a condescending tone when she talked to me. It annoyed me. The fact that she was right made it even more annoying.

A couple of scones and two more cups of tea later, she left. I loved my sister, but spending time with her left me emotionally drained.

I wasn’t exactly in the mood for more writing. I sat at my computer and reread what I’d written so far, hoping it would help me get back to a relaxed frame of mind.

Wickfield Lodge, English country home

of Lord William Marsh—1938

It seems wicked to sit here enjoying yourself while your dearest relative lies at death’s door.

Victor Carlston might have taken Daphne’s statement more seriously if he wasn’t laughing uncontrollably. Lord William Marsh was the dearest relative, who was, according to Daphne, a breath away from death. Not a callous man, Victor didn’t laugh at Lord William’s ill health, which placed him at death’s door once every three months. He always pulled through. His illnesses always followed a night of rich food and extensive enjoyment of the fruit of his vineyards. No, Victor laughed at Daphne’s dramatic manner. She fussed and fidgeted as if she was about to go into hysterics. He’d read of a fellow who kissed a girl to stop her from hysterics. Maybe this was his opportunity.

Daphne was bewitchingly beautiful, and he’d barely had two seconds alone with her all night. That obnoxious American, Charles Parker, kept popping up. The slippery Parker was confident, cocky, and overdressed in tails. Daphne didn’t appear to mind.

Speak of the devil. Parker’s How about a dance, Daphne old girl, was more a statement than a question. Before she had a chance to reply, Parker pulled her to her feet and into his arms and spun her off to the dance floor set up in the parlor of Wickfield Lodge.

Damn it! He’d missed another opportunity, and there Daphne was, dancing and laughing as though whatever Parker whispered in her ear was the most hilarious thing she’d ever heard. Where was her concern for Lord William now? Victor sat in brooding silence and smoked.

Perhaps if you weren’t so obviously in love with her, she might take you more seriously. Victor hadn’t noticed Penelope in the seat recently vacated by Daphne, until she spoke.

Am I that obvious?

Even a blind monk could see you’re in love with her.

Penelope held out a cigarette, which Victor lit. For a few seconds they smoked quietly until Penelope broke the silence.

You know what your problem is, Victor?

No. Do tell.

You make your love too easy. There’s no challenge.

Challenge? Victor laughed. You talk of love as though it was a game or a battle to be fought in war.

It is a game and a battle. Haven’t you heard? Penelope leaned back and looked at Victor through lazy, dark eyes, with a smug smile.

He stretched his legs in front of the fireplace. I was never good at playing games. The stretch felt good. He’d been sitting far too long and the knee he’d injured in the war was stiffening up.

If you want Daphne, or any woman, for that matter, you’ll have to learn to play the game.

Perhaps you can enlighten me on the rules. He swallowed the lump that had developed in his throat when Daphne and Parker glided out of the room onto the terrace behind the parlor.

Wickfield Lodge, the ancestral home of Lord William Marsh, had a lovely back terrace with magnificent sweeping views of the rose garden, hedge maze, fountain, and the wooded copse below. At this late hour, none of the grounds were visible by moonlight. Obviously, Parker wasn’t interested in admiring the foliage.

Victor, you’re tall, dark, and handsome. You’re rich, which is always a plus, and you’ve got brains. That’s more than I can say about most men your age.

He raised an eyebrow at the backhanded compliment and stood, performed a sweeping bow, and sat back down.

Don’t be an ass. Penelope spat the words.

Given the qualities you mentioned, one would expect me to be the one out on the terrace with the beautiful Daphne, instead of sitting here with . . . He stopped, but not quickly enough.

Penelope knew what he was going to say. He could tell by the way her eyes flashed and the flush that went up her neck. For a moment, he thought she’d cry, but Lady Penelope Marsh was made of sterner stuff.

A moment was all it took for her to regain her composure.

I’m an ass! I’m terribly sorry. I didn’t mean—

Penelope held up her hand. Yes, you did mean it, and it’s okay. It’s true. Everyone knows Daphne is the beautiful one in the family. Golden hair, blue eyes like sapphires, and skin like cream. She’s a goddess. I’m not stupid. I know my sister got the beauty and I the brains. It’s all right.

Victor tried again. I’m really sorry, Penny.

No need for apologies. Penny gazed at him. I’m going to put my brains to good use. I’ve decided to help you.

Puzzled, it took a few moments to grasp what she’d said. Eventually he’d recovered enough to ask, Help me? What are you going to do, drive a stake through Charles Parker’s heart? That’s the only thing that can help me. Victor tossed back his drink and brooded.

I’m going to help you win Daphne’s heart. Penelope accepted a drink from a nearby waiter.

And how do you propose to do that? I gave my heart to Daphne a long time ago. He grabbed a drink from the waiter and took a sip. His desperation echoed in his ears. He winced.

Exactly. No woman wants something that’s given so easily. Daphne knows she has but to snap her fingers and you’ll come running. You are the ever faithful, ever loyal, always to be relied upon, Victor Carlston.

Tossing his cigarette into the fireplace, he tried to hide his anger, but there was an edge in his voice. You make me sound like a dog.

Exactly my point. Why should Daphne waste her youth and beauty on someone who’s always here? She can have you any time she wants. A woman wants a challenge.

Victor laughed.

Why are you laughing? Penelope perched on the edge of her seat like an eagle.

You have such a way with words. You make love sound like a battle.

It is a battle. What other challenges does a woman of Daphne’s station, breeding, and class have? She can’t go to war. She can’t work. And there are only so many cushions a well-bred lady can stand to embroider.

Something in her tone made Victor wonder if there was more to Penelope Marsh than he’d seen before. He looked at her as a woman, and not simply Daphne’s sister. You sound like you’ve thought about this a lot.

What else do I have to do but think? I have no talent for sewing cushions. Penelope’s eyes flashed. Perhaps it was the firelight or her anger but, for an instant, mousy Penelope exuded a passion that transformed her dark eyes and complexion. In that moment, Victor Carlston made a decision that would forever change his life.

That’s enough for one night. I closed my laptop. It was getting late, and I had a busy day coming up, the last day of school, for the children and for me. I would leave the stable security of a regular paycheck, insurance, a pension, and the union that had dictated my life for the past twelve years to embark on a new adventure.

Following your dreams sounded like an exciting journey, but for a widow in her mid-thirties, it was a bit scary. As a society, we were encouraged to work hard, invest for retirement, and make sound financial, practical decisions. Maybe it was my working class upbringing, or maybe it was the Midwestern work ethic. Whatever the reason, I found myself waxing nostalgic about the daily grind of teaching our nation’s youth. On the wall hung the motto from Henry Ford that Leon liked to quote,

If You Always Do

What You’ve Always Done,

You Will Always Get

What You’ve Always Got.

I knew what I had to do. Change was scary, but if Leon’s death taught me anything, it was that life was short, sometimes too short. Tomorrow wasn’t promised. I needed to do this for Leon and for myself. I consoled myself with the knowledge I could teach nights at the community college if I truly needed money.

I’d been very frugal with both the insurance money and the money from selling the house. In our original plan, Leon and I envisioned converting the upstairs of the bookstore into living space, which we could rent out to help pay the mortgage. Near the end, when Leon thought I needed a clean start, the idea of my living in the space took shape. The upper level of the soon-to-be bookstore was a large, open loft with beautiful oak hardwood floors, brick walls with seventeen foot ceilings, and windows stretching from floor to ceiling. The renovated 2,000-square-foot space contained a nice kitchen area, living room, two bedrooms, and two bathrooms. Track lighting and skylights made the space bright and inviting. I enjoyed the space more than I imagined I would. My new home was just right for me. There was even a detached garage at the back of the lot, which I accessed through an alley. I’d had a fence installed and created a small courtyard perfect for my dogs, Snickers and Oreo.

I decided to turn in. I needed all of my mental and emotional strength to get through yet another change.

Chapter 2

I parked my Honda SUV in the staff parking lot of North Harbor High School. The message board outside the school not only proclaimed the prowess of the North Harbor Wildcats and congratulated the graduating class, but also wished me a fond farewell. It wasn’t often you got to see your name in lights. So, I reached into my purse and grabbed my cell phone to take a picture of my name scrolling across the sign and a tissue to wipe away the tears I couldn’t blink back. A quick look in the mirror showed the tear tracks were ruining my makeup, and my mascara was already gone. It was going to be a long and difficult day.

Inside, signs from grateful students covered the walls.

GOOD-BYE, MRS. WASHINGTON—WE’LL MISS YOU

. My favorite was

PARTING MAY BE SWEET SORROW, BUT IT STILL BITES

. There was a picture of our mascot, Willie the Wildcat, taking a bite off the bottom of the sign.

The principal was waiting for me when I walked through the door and walked me to the gymnasium. Streamers, balloons, and confetti decorated the large room and the bleachers were full with students, teachers, janitors, and secretaries. Even the cafeteria staff was there with their hairnets and smocks. Everyone stood and cheered as I entered. I got misty eyed thinking about my students. They were truly the best group of young people I’d had the pleasure of teaching. I’d miss the entire tattooed, pierced, and multicolor-haired bunch.

The day was filled with cupcakes, cookies,

Reviews for The Plot Is Murder

[carlathelibrarian · Rating: 3 out of 5 stars]

This is the first book in a new cozy mystery series. This series is a bit different from other cozies I have read. Samantha Washington, the protagonist is also a budding author. When she is stressed, she works on her book to relax. Because of this, there are two different short mysteries going on simultaneously. I did not have a problem following them, but I am sure some readers might. It is an interesting premise though.

Samantha (Sam) loves a good mystery. She and her husband Leon had always wanted to open a bookstore, but she became a teacher in order to have a reliable income. Now that Leon has died, she is able to retire from teaching to finally follow her dreams. She has purchased a building in North Harbor, Michigan and restored/renovated it as a bookstore/cafe/apartment. The purchase did not go as smoothly as possible as her real estate agent tried to derail the sale after contracts had been signed. It was no secret that Sam did not care for him at all. She is almost ready to open when he comes knocking on her door late at night. She does not let him in and goes to bed. The next morning he is found dead, a stabbing victim, in her courtyard. Of course she becomes the prime suspect. Her grandmother, Nana Jo, moves in to help her with her investigation. This is where the humor comes in. Nana Jo lives in a retirement community that caters to active seniors. She and "the girls" become involved in the investigation as well as introducing Sam to the casino, some happy hours and other things that she is surprised they are involved in. The final clue the police latch onto is her manuscript. It appears that the murder in her story is somewhat similar to the real one.

This was a relatively quick read with the book made up of two short stories. I am not sure if this is something I will enjoy as you really do not get to know the characters well. I was confused about the characters in her manuscript as it was not the complete book and there was not much information about those characters. The characters in the book are interesting and I can see them becoming favorites of mine if they are fleshed out and continue in the books. I will give the next one a try before I decide about this series. The publisher generously provided me with a copy of this book via Netgalley.

[bah195 · Rating: 5 out of 5 stars]

V.M. Burns' new book The Plot Is Murder has a very unusual concept for a cozy. Not only does the reader get the main mystery but they also get a second completely different story when the main character, Samantha, writes her own mystery book.I had my doubts when I first started reading the two stories. I thought it would me confusing but the author did a wonderful job meshing the two stories. It's very clever.This book is the first in the new Mystery Bookshop series and I see from the sneak peek at the end of the book the the author will be continuing the concept in the next book.I highly recommend this book to all cozy mystery readers. It's a wonderful change from the usual cozies.

[kris_anderson-1 · Rating: 3 out of 5 stars]

The Plot is Murder by V.M Burns is the first book in A Mystery Bookshop Mystery series. Samantha “Sam” Washington and her husband dreamed of owning a mystery bookstore. Before Leon passed away, he made Sam promise to carry on with their dream. Sam is just days away from opening Market Street Mysteries (not the best name) and has already started her second dream of writing a British historical mystery. After enjoying her last day of teaching, her family and friends throw her a party. The next morning when Sam lets her dogs outside, she finds Clayton Parker, the listing agent for her brownstone, dead on the patio. Detective Brad “Stinky” Pitt is assigned the case and he quickly zeros in on Sam. Nana Jo (not your average senior citizen) moves herself in with Sam (to keep her safe). Nana Jo has little confidence in Detective Pitt’s ability to solve the case. She rallies her friends (the Sluething Seniors) and Sam to investigate the victim’s death. Can they uncover the killer before he (or she) strikes again?The Plot is Murder is not what I expected. I discovered that over half the book is taken up with the manuscript being written by the main character (Sam). I did not enjoy these sections and felt they detracted from the story. There is a mystery in the manuscript that is simple. I would have preferred the author had centered the story around the mystery bookstore (who wouldn’t love a mystery bookshop in their neighborhood). I did like most of the characters especially Nana Jo. She was feisty, smart, and very active. I admit that she overshadowed Sam in the story (and I hope to be half as active when I am her age). I wish the author had fleshed out Sam as much as she did Nana Jo. I found the detective to be cliched and overdone (the name, attitude, how he got the job). I am giving The Plot is Murder 3 out of 5 stars. The mystery has some good components. However, the guilty party can be identified early in the story (one tiny detail gives it away). I kept hoping for a twist so I would be surprised. The majority of readers will figure out the solution long before it is revealed. The investigation is light with most of the work done by the Sleuthing Seniors. I was never fully drawn into The Plot is Murder. With the book divided into two, I feel the author did the main story a disservice.

[kathl33n-1 · Rating: 3 out of 5 stars]

This was a book within a book! The main character was writing a mystery and as a reader you read along as she was writing. At first I really thought I wasn't going to like that, but I ended up actually enjoying both stories. In the main story there was a gaggle of old ladies that, while a bit unbelievable with their clothing choices, were adorable as characters even though I thought they stole the show from the main character in many scenes. In fact looking back at it I remember that group of ladies much more than I do the main character. Overall I found this an enjoyable read and a good start to a new series. Many thanks to NetGalley and Kensington publishers for allowing me to read an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

[cyderry · Rating: 4 out of 5 stars]

This was an interesting start for a new series. There is a mystery within the mystery. Samantha Washington has been recently widowed, retired from teaching, sold her home and is opening a mystery book shop - a dream she and her late husband shared. The real estate agent who sold Sam the building for her bookshop repeatedly has been bothering her but one morning she finds him dead in her backyard. As the police investigate, she works on her book - a mystery. There is a marked resemblance with her mystery to the murder of her real estate agent so the police believe that she may be a suspect.The characters which include Samantha's grandmother and her cronies add a sense of humor to the search for the truth.Great fun!

[gaylebones · Rating: 2 out of 5 stars]

I tend to give cozies and books about bookshops a little slack. I want to like them because I collect books about books, bookshops, writers, libraries, etc. However, I was disappointed in the book and the publisher in this case. I usually find Kensington Books to have higher quality editing than some but could not get past the geographical locations of places as iconic as the Great Lakes and Motor City being described incorrectly throughout the book. I did like the premise of the book and was interested enough to finish it to find out what happened in both stories. I hope the series improves with stronger writing and better editing in future books.

[maydacat_1 · Rating: 4 out of 5 stars]

It was the dream of Samatha and her husband to own a mystery bookshop, and before his untimely death, he encouraged her to do it for both of them. Sam opens her shop, and indulges in her own dream: writing a British cozy. In the fantasy of her story, there is a murder to be solved. In Sam’s real life, she also discovers a murder victim. One story somewhat mimics the other, so much so the police regard Sam as a person of interest in the murder. The author does a very good job of writing both stories, and keeping them true to form. The characters in both tales are interesting, but the award should go to Sam’s grandmother and her cohorts who band together to solve the murder. A good start to an entertaining series.

[kmartin802_1 · Rating: 5 out of 5 stars]

Sam Washington had changed her life since her husband Leon died. She isn't putting off their dreams anymore. She sold the house they renovated, retired from her job teaching English at the local high school, opened a mystery bookstore and is writing her own cozy British mystery. However, her new life runs into a stumbling block when the sleezy realtor who sold her the building for her bookstore and new loft apartment is found stabbed to death outside her store. Detective Brad Pitt, known as Stinky in his childhood, thinks he's found a perfect suspect in Sam. Sam has supporters on her side, too, as she tries to clear her name and find out who killed Clayton Parker. She is assisted by her grandmother Nana Jo and some other senior ladies from Nana Jo's retirement home. These ladies have a quite a network of relatives and friends who help build a picture of Clayton and his family. Meanwhile, Sam is writing her own mystery which takes place at the country home of Lord William March in 1938. When a body is found in the maze and it looks like Victor's almost-fiance Daphne is a suspect, Victor's chivalrous nature makes him step in to protect her. However, Daphne's sister Lady Penelope, who has loved Victor secretly for years, is less eager to let Victor assume the blame. I really enjoyed this cozy mystery within a mystery, Sam's senior friends provided a bunch of information and lots of humor too. I liked the fast pace and the complexity of they mystery.

[Riley Smith · Rating: 2 out of 5 stars]

The side characters were all much more interesting and competent than the main character, who spent most of the time crying and needing everyone’s help to run her bookstore.

I also did not enjoy the judgement about a suicide victim (who was also a dying man that the main character got arrested incorrectly). Suicide is not “giving up” and I did not appreciate that characterization, ESPECIALLY when it was the main character’s fault he got arrested during the last months of his life.

We also had an unrelated bout of domestic violence so that was also not great! I’m not even sure why it was in there. To fill space?

As far as the plot, there wasn’t much here, which is why the extraneous subplots and the story-in-a-story, which was also not very good. Even then, with all that extra stuff, the book was extremely repetitive.

They kept “discovering” the same information over and over.

Pretty dull! It has some of the elements I like in a cozy, but not enough to give this series any more of my time.