Everand Logo

Welcome to Everand!

  • Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

    Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

    Discourses on Livy
    Discourses on Livy
    Discourses on Livy
    Ebook549 pages9 hours

    Discourses on Livy

    By Niccolò Machiavelli

    4/5

    ()

    Read preview

    About this ebook

    The strategies Machiavelli developed and endorsed in The Prince made his name an enduring synonym for the ruthless acquisition and use of power. Discourses on Livy, published in 1531, is equally essential to an understanding of political theory. Both treatises compare the government of ancient Rome to that of the Italian Renaissance. The Prince, however, offers advice on maintaining a monarchy; with Discourses, Machiavelli considers the structure and benefits of a republic.
    Inspired by Titus Livy's monumental history of Rome, Machiavelli discusses the internal structure of a republic, methods of conducting warfare, and the defining qualities of individual leadership. His explorations of the concept of checks and balances, the strength of a tripartite structure, and the superiority of a republic to a principality keep this book as relevant today as it was five centuries ago.
    LanguageEnglish
    PublisherDover Publications
    Release dateMar 14, 2012
    ISBN9780486138534
    Discourses on Livy
    Author

    Niccolò Machiavelli

    Niccolò Machiavelli (1469-1527) was an Italian diplomat, philosopher and writer during the Renaissance era. Machiavelli led a politically charged life, often depicting his political endorsements in his writing. He led his own militia, and believed that violence made a leader more effective. Though he held surprising endorsements, Machiavelli is considered to be the father of political philosophy and political science, studying governments in an unprecedented manner that has forever shaped the field.

    Read more from Niccolò Machiavelli

    Related to Discourses on Livy

    Related ebooks

    Philosophy For You

    View More
    View More

    Related podcast episodes

    Related articles

    • Article

      The Ethics Of Political Power

      Jul 30, 2018

      The Ethics Of Political Power
      3 min read

    • Article

      Niccolò Machiavelli

      Feb 28, 2020

      Hailed as the father of modern politics, Niccolò Machiavelli has long been synonymous with everything bad about the political sphere. His name, turned adjective as ‘Machiavellian’, conjures up images of a cunning, sly and manipulative figure, hell-be

      5 min read

    • Article

      The Great Morality Scam

      Jul 30, 2018

      The Great Morality Scam
      5 min read

    • Article

      War-war Leads To Jaw-jaw

      Aug 26, 2021

      THE CONVENTIONAL VIEW OF historians has been that the proliferation of written constitutions in recent centuries around the globe was primarily the result of a tendency towards democracy. Linda Colley offers a starkly different interpretation and ram

      4 min read

    • Article

      A Rising Star

      Mar 2, 2020

      A Rising Star
      6 min read

    • Article

      The Togate People

      May 30, 2022

      The Togate People
      5 min read

    • Article

      Rise Of The Equites

      Feb 14, 2022

      Rise Of The Equites
      9 min read

    • Article

      The New American Empire

      Jan 24, 2019

      The New American Empire
      5 min read

    • Article

      Cohen Corner

      Aug 2, 2022

      Home Rule in a Nutshell was first published in November 1911 by Sealy Bryers & Walker of Dublin. It was a “a pocket book for speakers and Electors,” prepared by Jeremiah MacVeagh, an Irish nationalist politician, who was elected for the Irish Parliam

      5 min read

    • Article

      Documenting History

      Mar 18, 2021

      Documenting History
      4 min read

    • Article

      Richard The Radical

      Nov 26, 2020

      Richard The Radical
      10 min read

    • Article

      The Court Of King Boris

      Jun 24, 2021

      The Court Of King Boris
      5 min read

    • Article

      Caesar Vs The Senate

      Sep 12, 2019

      Caesar Vs The Senate
      12 min read

    • Article

      Interview / Penelope J Corfield

      Jan 20, 2022

      Rhiannon Davies: The subtitle of your book is The Deeds and Misdeeds of 15th-Century Britain. Can we call the actions of the past “misdeeds”? Penelope J Corfield I certainly don’t think, as historians, we should be patting the past on the head and sa

      9 min read

    Related categories

    Reviews for Discourses on Livy

    4/5

    128 ratings7 reviews

    What did you think?

    Tap to rate

    Review must be at least 10 words

    • 3/5
      Duidelijk een herhaling, aanvulling en uitbreiding van Il Principe, maar rijper en meer gestoffeerd. Maar van de andere kant ook minder synthetisch, cfr zeker derde boek is secundair en fragmentair. Nog meer dan in vorige boek een stevig pleidooi voor republieken en de wijsheid van het volk.
    • 3/5
      Duidelijk een herhaling, aanvulling en uitbreiding van Il Principe, maar rijper en meer gestoffeerd. Maar van de andere kant ook minder synthetisch, cfr zeker derde boek is secundair en fragmentair. Nog meer dan in vorige boek een stevig pleidooi voor republieken en de wijsheid van het volk.
    • 4/5
      Titus Livius or Livy {59 BC- AD 17) was the author of A History of Republican Rome originally stretching to 142 books of which only 35 have survived. Machiavelli set out to write a commentary on these gems from antiquity; that were understood by men of the Italian Renaissance to be significant examples of the legacy of classical culture. The myth of classical culture was all pervasive in Florentine intellectual circles of which Machiavelli was an important figure. His aim was to prove that renaissance Florence particularly its republican element could do no better than learn from the lessons contained in Livy’s histories He was preaching to the converted as the humanist movement was based almost entirely on these precepts.Machiavelli suffered following the overthrow of the Florentine republic and the re-introduction of the Medici family to the positions of power. He was forcibly retired from politics and sought refuge down on his farm. Not being able to finds favour with the new ruling class he sat down to write about his beloved antiquity and said:“When evening comes, I return home, and I go into my study; and on the threshold, I take off my everyday clothes, which are covered with muck and mire, and I put on regal and curial robes; and dressed in a more appropriate manner I enter into the ancient courts of ancient men and am welcomed by them kindly, and there I taste the food that alone is mine, and for which I was born; and there I am not ashamed to speak to them, to ask them the reasons for their actions; and they, in their humanity, answer me; and for four hours I feel no boredom, I dismiss every affliction, I no longer fear poverty nor do I tremble at the thought of death; I become completely part of them.”What may have started out as a commentary on Livy’s histories, soon developed into a comparison between the events in classical republican Rome and more recent events in Florence and from this a treatise on the best way to govern a republican state. There are three books containing 142 fairly short chapters with each chapter heading serving as a discussion point for the following text. The chapter headings themselves give the modern reader an idea of some of the tortuous logic that Machiavelli can employ to make his points for example “Conquests made by republics which are not well organised, and which do not proceed according to Roman standards of excellence bring about their ruin rather than their glorification”“Whether the guardianship of liberty may be more securely lodged in the people or the upper classes; and who has more reason to create an uprising, he who wishes to acquire or he who wishes to maintain.”Many of the chapter headings are a lot less complicated but the above examples give an idea of the general direction of the Discourses. One thing remains constant; the examples of classical antiquity should serve as guidelines for all people that wish to be successful leaders in politics and in war.Familiar themes expounded in The Prince are explored here in more detail; Machiavelli’s deep mistrust of human nature, his ideas that Politics are conflict and conflict is beneficial to the body politic, the way that religion should be used to pacify and encourage the masses and how a ruler or leader in war should not hesitate to be ruthless when necessary. What emerges more particularly from the Discourses is Machiavelli’s belief that republicanism is the best form of government and as such is a tract for how it can work in practice. Machiavelli with his experience in public life became very knowledgeable and cynical about human nature, which is probably an essential requirement for a politician , he says“…..because men in general live as much by appearances as by realities; indeed, they are often moved more by things as they appear than by things as they really are…….”Machiavelli also writes about his contemporaries in Florence. He takes quite a sympathetic view towards Savonarola, but can be damming about his own boss Piero Soderini, whom he accuses of being too soft, too soft to deal with the envious men around him. Machiavelli’s dictum was always that if you can rule by love or by fear, it is safer to choose fear. In a book of this length there is much of interest and much to enjoy, but there is also some pretty turgid stuff. Machiavelli often repeats himself and the continuous use of the same examples from Livy’s histories can get a bit wearing. If you have previously read Machiavelli’s The Prince then the Discourses are on very similar lines and so unless you have an interest in the period, political history, or in Machiavelli then it is probably not necessary to slog through it. The Oxford World Classics edition translated by Julia and Peter Bondanella reads well and gives a flavour of Machiavelli’s syntax. There is a good introduction and some excellent explanatory notes
    • 5/5
      There is far more depth in this book than in The Prince, and it should be considered by any individual interested in understanding how Republics do and do not function. Though there is some faulty reasoning (usually based on accepting premises that are inaccurate), most of the book is very logical and empirically-oriented, and the way Machiavelli makes use of the ancients is outstanding.
    • 5/5
      Considering the social and cultural landscape of the contemporary West, one cannot help but wonder whether we can pull out of our downward slide, and what are the odds of doing so.An interesting analysis of this issue is provided by Machiavelli, in his "Discourses" (1517). In this deeply insightful book, a commentary on the work of the Roman historian Titus Livius (Livy), Machiavelli examines the ebb and flow of the Roman republic, applying its lessons to the affairs of his own era, and to the life of nations in general. (Note that this is the republican period of Rome, c. 510 - 44 BC, before the advent of the great emperors.)Let's start with the bad news. Machiavelli is not particularly optimistic about a country's ability to adapt to new circumstances:"There are two reasons why we are unable to change when we need to: In the first place, we cannot help being what nature has made us; in the second, if one style of behavior has worked well for us in the past, we cannot be persuaded we would be better off acting differently. The consequence is that one's fortune changes, for the times change, and one's behavior does not. Another consequence is that cities are destroyed, for the institutions of a republic are never modified to suit changing circumstances...Change comes too late because it is too difficult to accomplish."If that weren't enough of an obstacle, we are also subject to the whims of fortune; i.e., to circumstances that are beyond our control:"If you will think sensibly about how people's lives are shaped, you will see that often events and accidents occur against which the heavens were determined we should have no protection. Seeing this sort of thing happened to the Romans, who were so skillful, pious, and well-organized, it is not surprising that it happens much more often to cities or regions who lack these advantages."Machiavelli goes on to relate Livy's account of Rome's near-demise following an invasion from southern France, which wasn't repelled until the barbarians were threatening the Capitol itself. The Romans, at that time still relatively vulnerable, could not pull together until their very heart was threatened:"Fortune, in order to make Rome all the greater and build her up to the power she eventually attained, judged it necessary to give her a nasty shock...but did not want, at this point, to destroy her completely...In order to bring [change] about, the whole society must feel endangered; it is not enough for just one individual to change his mind."It doesn't require much imagination to apply this wisdom to the contemporary West. Consider the mass immigration from the Third World, leading, in some European countries, to a now-foreseeable usurpation of the native population and culture. It is likely that only a shock of great magnitude would be capable of stalling this locomotive. One can only hope that, as was the case with the Roman republic, "fortune" does not intend to destroy us completely.There are, still, many things that can be done to stave off ruin, says Machiavelli. It is not inevitable. But the task is great, and can only be accomplished by the clarion call of first principles. This is the subject of the chapter entitled "On how, if you want a movement or state to survive for long, you must repeatedly bring it back to its founding principles." Here, we read that"there is nothing more essential in any form of communal life, whether of a movement, a kingdom, or a republic, than to restore it the reputation it had when it was first founded, and to strive to ensure there are either good institutions or good men who can bring this about, so that one is not dependent on having some external intervention before reform can occur...it is so dangerous there are no circumstances in which one should hope for it."Machiavelli also emphasizes that to be successful, our behavior must be adapted to the era in which we live. Bold, impetuous action may be perfect at one moment yet disastrous at another. When the Roman army was broken and demoralized, General Fabius avoided defeat against Hannibal by being cautious. Later, when a bold strike was needed, the daring Scipio was appointed to the task. The switch, a fortuitous adaptation, could be accomplished because"a republic can adapt itself more easily to changing circumstances because it can call on citizens of differing characters. Someone who is used to proceeding in a particular way will never change."We certainly possess "citizens of differing characters." But will the right ones be called upon at the right time?
    • 4/5
      A fine translation with a good deal of backcround information. Mansfield is a first rate Machiavelli scholar.
    • 3/5
      The work is easy to read and a instructive about power and civics. He discusses the effect of the type of government, religion, and corruptness of the citizenry on the success of a nation, complete with many simple examples involving historical figures.

    Book preview

    Discourses on Livy - Niccolò Machiavelli

    b` ^book_preview_excerpt.html}M3qU0ƴQcM}3"&@HV"̟WZ "N2sD}Mь HdFFx?w׿ȷMS~}gc߼Lp}vo?}k|c/>-w̩y=O񼻥N]~nwns>qwüg5 >nμ815ͻ8Ka7>:ͫ=.xwi8l#wø-}%{mv<3&yܥuyn&;Ѧᱷ庳{uؿeh׭>i.G^v|N; >3>.v.̸[cbv'V+{\ɮ:Ҁavs>.;[1 6 ڄ]:6#6#D7␡qw-t}p3a&&j,yO\yɡ1#6 i&LvΘz8@uYr7mHmy1|}ſsƿ~7&5);Y86uJ|t_xٯC>&6cthיޱRuV$Ŕz<ؖWnɴ04ԛ1YO)BL!dG[b/9𭯣^^s7.aAC<дd .Y{ލUף~rl#'{_U]WmўlJJD?>{ո0}6'{—p>%,m#M>{mI{ەm0Ō1˪v lf{7dh e؏62^fȦqiҕ'jy=FѠ֪\$ĻoV޳Q?C{W'`S-Ѵh柒B#мs6fV>yj Qh%ɐ~DH_եkJǕ),>/a@oI` U5_o!_~s8lVm\'Ŵ3R_=۬%G&$h 9A ;(Ez|>TYJ9A6=|5xz*  F0`^;%lTIL֪ڍn/DH-uL9;7 0sgut]FUL5Ġ@0s",dh ڧS6b{anvo*;Wp8_y&͒W\`˸@zP{,K|b+ǁ i^|ܴ8|l}̋ e;LU``vÅš?_N6ԆTi)|JS_ߏ+@(=Uu(>ǔ~2s:zQwErVl!tf,(ekrM8L#cRyt Yص=U>R{j%z#p"3F~Tbv/I ['8`0 ?z >6 R~CfY>0o;ء=$;"M'TTnXôv7G6#6]m2Ou[qhF-Bp< T%'h_' lݽ,b35z:/t+lFB֮'v2gBw>MEr;O2a1̲bks89w;te3zS0wK!ll+h8R4 '+|^/6uw:+:VCݧLb0^ǂ3ՀAOǟ] T\8s4&X"mBD:`5LwaxkAW?^6=A 1OV#8Jɝ|w:Ƀ-ьICM{ľ8 @~MkO*fZfЩϚN}7s&d QiC5su-[ e?~ :|R L"Ykg6Hu= E ރLna_ۺ_p0&Zx9b#e~6,a}_7{RXHDda/a.7.@Qk]lMFqA5qE (\Bq2RDGw/aC0yͲ)CW)t^{;^ -Ә[O}ɆmcXsע8 Z@ 5|TJ>/k&59gM4_ !jgyLĨh~dܞ 1}tmrxpfP?*}H^%&̆):l${OJ,ƍؐу[^S!a*#vNNT}܌p~!MG&?)8Fd&dn⦌VpiZI 08Rαa\#Do{c'hyT軿T}s*pBw0ݭCԧ8ٶ?ZynMsf(]2cjԿ{w6 3ҎP"ᮏ;:TelS!l47|2lt/tܞ"Fm޷4ǘ#TE4`q;gsH3m|qك ?l_F"R.7FY61Bd m:? %?9&TM 0& NObt&iៃ"e>lNg>ko>${6Ibvn Yd1e!Eǐ)79)mIH_rE[NTk9mjZ/psI인/Źx/P<*耑t{n}^U6,2L6 !z"pG u9fxJjUY /& ^Q$,a4)0<D6m5CJ2E]\CѶZӰ*eۯ-+gq "@4>x\׽t M< 52;]1@U`dDb4уm{! \+]g]MFeD=b;3/0G^T@1Ն3I{}Uy"pWnm<"*7fG-b$ ?:'C|]o?M#f[1iW&ĘB}$%3fH@i6xk c];v+wT}d"GA\d4GhsWC?Z;v߿뜼OT $A8o~MԸIM'j'"q<'h-^J3Țr; P@ ө8-e"s1}amS~Uu7i~pBp+D}޳27;PJcWA=pGVo3S>AC3ipy!\L;x:f\-8ލ[(- d%EFF_W FwWT0<:7~bpʛPmk1AXAXDq)kNzh+EH=ꙃ55:+DIQΗK 1Ia-xijm|8=ͫ0#f@OM,.URM+z{Zw`@E r}K8$T sK/2P i{`V73 VOmXCQF~hqAi!j> 7j2L.ZMFէjl?A9JҐק)ϣ}j Js@0Kjpa*1}u%9W|ۮoB24i}bQ*'$-D]+7A6Q 59z[> #l8zW&͟\zK&*r@jxTP;TIzbe넠d}geiT&-)GYć|nl/Am~$m'vW83&2.sZK,56d*V6a\(p$!Ĭyvi KMkxa҇ =+'w4KKu/dlXD+L2_n4KX8r3#[BLQZğpLU&w5 O#hң1 #Wt~Y2(rE 7s]n ~ KK+9h; 3jh~KD1Z`qCpf?,K6Ή@7ݶ3` zwJMނpCLC2/Y'P3:iP^E84_{@A}"{js‚؍h8T>z)-,yCƛ\4T} uG*>І2uJY)(SZUL?. ʝ'a+R}. wthx2i)[ªpfq3P$.]ґ.1/@K@!o*+_PT1X,?V̓lZq)CD"dA“k>W%exRVП_K*;>tL"mjMT 9qt5{*&-ajk%^?aR.È[>[q[ EOUO݆/0>42{7Իu76[V@XȠWOk09$N#ÐOrtL?ȿݗ={Q:[Da=# "JW̜F^| |Q&&FTleȴ@ch3gBX+m[d ߑK"Y%ikO];g} l8IǮ0TZ }(sR7'@r C],wG.tg}UQuDԕT`Fo%l4[sY[iOU/(CsE2ٴW4DX2yaKc c$@:Z; ȂCw8>8fku=wĒBԠk ETRGT ]%c(3`W\`*o s"{͝-z<rk f/Hu6Qйotv!NPMkb]2O'AHS\Eb*oŤݻ@˂Vwe0>){wؖ- %vp^S+$kX)ijTGM HOIAO\;PeUdM;\ߧe+JKJ E]7L''e7| ;y$Itbة+4*[r"n![}:jנv,jذ9:}T^"PѮ[q,O6qB&ڛԙX1a ff G˲%rY{=h$e4E!n]=ow"~Tv6>Hz}MtJj'Xuue uUǟZì`SC%f&cUC@>y&ʅ0N{P1HD[b"w"U¬xCm`i9 :Ožaˮ%T$Hrw&.BI@R-}bCq95dp&Y&֗ڡ! FR0 (nJKBkhm{e0t?K]bIb%8"^IcR6WvH`Ix6%`׹K`7TJ<.w:ŌB %w4H"*FcP$$ф,r, D^v u!=͎.ʒ NՈ њi&8VHNT Q?#cלqVM|`vۿ'I[g0}Zm솫r\$ TI lcV 5ʼtw?mQdY[К3VLkM8(j[˙5/<}5{Fyރcs"iِ9Qd_e 7tFM'sً̒M,#/Z*Uۇ=d&WfeApBÂvB"pU;U[(ʼnB٨6x7 73}vu6'<4;;E<݊ş~Cblx NSelٛ[аrK+L`cq5"J+HJ[8Pߥ1(*J 6[;S\A⡕j)pq9} q 8Ka=;ET?yAfMY˻Q8St+IJʹ \3ifaݪ&" |dAR5(󮥿NvZ]W,5/%07f :W2y3kcn(9a) ^QB\7d߳׫V啸Bw3g| 3;rl{m/&_>{sD#i{/cm?4/] -VieF^:te"Rp{S\r(ʐ5\GBu*yofUv"t?+T9 {9:W-9Kz9f3~ה֫E5>^y ^ۛkj<+mH'%^1iU58Zb#%Y "wVσN9ԶoJ7 ̮DT ݋/yR*@RM#7\·"ZW1POڕ3y%&fh!-r|>/jC͙Sw\"Mb@V*Y+>Bgx#[bl6368zz'|jɽLV&ov0䉝T$K3o̱YDc1&0MU3+\ >>mwV{)v=ǧ}*^ .h:Yss!?R\G"23өhQ k}4AR:0jso<{uZy̵vkk qQAeЭgT B-RRcm# D1s %6nڠ]ʉ}k｀Ή "{ccjD9{-벳zG`iZρkFfFq~LӟVtpɶ3ii$g U74vUO\P5& ;V_u "z;t{Q!6u&6U{_^dt^-:Klof F5:]B9RE/^ŷ}iﻡ'񈦮k=*+vMeۂdn1D[)%JpF񗡷l;8*ax(Q|FbNV'Ds{nā"S%Cv ,Vi[`cE9Ey= IMƸ6 ޡ0#jqr#Ej*t\jaJNMlk|SVz` Tf1]-vެQe3Z9K+܉:((~@L<)JKj\yǥTpĵڸx2hUy<.'ei_Yn79䯔PTlFT>ǟz+\M9Ƭ ?6'6ܫLs3S}[cùȔ59VZ@!0(1D#ͤB5SQtO)'ѳz>fӒuuFl0Ǧ%Dus-D*?P] g|nVNJIN|sX5*P3@zt4dK32U}LA^ރ^&~C@S$L#?Ti7^+rRJkf= FԶͦ#RA OYTJU\Tq]bWTP''\L:-%IG (\olψ] `warȨI< 8]V$75mqCPtcrtSiX6∇4 [o:X'2OJE}΂(Sx)WDzLD+/,Z?D&N=q" ~oǞ7vi!٤kp )AOH)+98ZCX ŗ ."y'ZrF6C~Si|MQԼSATMkj6 3zN2ϙp=Qp<>g:4|L]=)p@zTwg;9ɱL@^cOIP Hey0x5l}ΧH,M\#¨_V~wkw7hMSwk9|uQ[fni^7_&M}=1s"Rg0~c =ުj-R9/6Jgcs>wWmroCs͖4KhjeͻMRϝ0G k'X,nxfj Gfi?J'Vڎ;Oo:gzpgZ?k̗X0ʅ,v@]p !l(&^_Sv=-cw+|q`F/%>GH@t.{`wZ^J!˨[^:a<ŚՏӞ8`'H">7X8i]4h] ~NY?S sg\8ۋ_sV eZ-Ϯ2Qv3ڦ uqWh875zY2~bf=dT$ r~61,iި[guOӸ(k/(ԝ^`y*pc̿4K#Iw ͨU1m$ȣ45Lj8NdtA`DBnMzgL?vq}m7e2BqFY5mu߼ԣ\^nQ6\r(4r t_S>!5jTIqƢ]<ݻ 0N4 cPs"h S9UdxvF酣ͫRwi~v^7:9-^~6A5X s^ޫp .FhӋh:U2.3qUEQgQLr@6IgUIE(3@\t<ðfbzY'X8˩xrBbce ,5RM\saR%qLzYL 7Scb^~h2,-VPoM7/'~h5aD~X6NC926«:}ʇ8/M1/w=0Ѯ͗xH[C`Mס/=|1!i洛R?$EmlFt66K֖xR%DJDJ9;%Ogy``dT=6U8TTHRB '}6QlyOegOz"q.=&(C9Ԕ1r >fv`K%7q[PJfUS7`?/ x5vN*6n}@|mCMbKo:^)k̦6ds{6…cL<}(u6z:5.'/a6#99ՅTZTOVU@%srWi{؏>ښ$OZ!zVT^xsJp'u2F~Mry|FFYNlo_8 _
    Enjoying the preview?
    Page 1 of 1