Everand Logo

Welcome to Everand!

  • Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

    Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

    Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage: An Essay on Free Will
    Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage: An Essay on Free Will
    Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage: An Essay on Free Will
    Ebook244 pages4 hours

    Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage: An Essay on Free Will

    By Nomy Arpaly

    ()

    Read preview

    About this ebook

    Perhaps everything we think, feel, and do is determined, and humans--like stones or clouds--are slaves to the laws of nature. Would that be a terrible state? Philosophers who take the incompatibilist position think so, arguing that a deterministic world would be one without moral responsibility and perhaps without true love, meaningful art, and real rationality. But compatibilists and semicompatibilists argue that determinism need not worry us. As long as our actions stem, in an appropriate way, from us, or respond in some way to reasons, our actions are meaningful and can be judged on their moral (or other) merit.


    In this highly original work, Nomy Arpaly argues that a deterministic world does not preclude moral responsibility, rationality, and love--in short, meaningful lives--but that there would still be something lamentable about a deterministic world. A person may respond well to reasons, and her actions may faithfully reflect her true self or values, but she may still feel that she is not free. Arpaly argues that compatibilists and semicompatibilists are wrong to dismiss this feeling--for which there are no philosophical consolations--as philosophically irrelevant. On the way to this bittersweet conclusion, Arpaly sets forth surprising theories about acting for reasons, the widely accepted idea that "ought implies can," moral blame, and more.

    LanguageEnglish
    PublisherPrinceton University Press
    Release dateAug 15, 2009
    ISBN9781400824502
    Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage: An Essay on Free Will
    Author

    Nomy Arpaly

    Nomy Arpaly is Associate Professor of Philosophy at Brown University and the author of Unprincipled Virtue.

    Related authors

    Related to Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage

    Related ebooks

    Related podcast episodes

    Related articles

    • Article

      The Charmed Life of Frank Wilczek

      Mar 17, 2021

      Nobel laureate Frank Wilczek’s new book, Fundamentals: Ten Keys to Reality, is both a way of thinking about the abundance that characterizes our exterior and interior worlds, and a kind of alternative to traditional religion, a way of being “born aga

      13 min read

    • Article

      Steven Pinker Has His Reasons

      Nov 17, 2021

      A few years ago, at the Princeton Club in Manhattan, I chanced on a memorable chat with the Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker. His spouse, the philosopher Rebecca Goldstein, with whom he was tagging along, had been invited onto a panel to discuss th

      19 min read

    • Article

      Let’s Be Rational

      Oct 3, 2021

      Let’s Be Rational
      8 min read

    • Article

      Jamie Wheal Meaning 3.0

      Jul 17, 2022

      Jamie Wheal Meaning 3.0
      18 min read

    • Article

      This Essentially Meaningless Conflict

      Sep 22, 2017

      MARILYNNE ROBINSON’S accomplishments are impressive by any standard: she has won the National Book Critics Circle Award for Fiction, the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction, and the National Humanities Medal, among other honors. But perhaps a better measure o

      8 min read

    • Article

      The Bugs in Our Mindware: Many obstacles lie on the path to rational thought.

      May 7, 2015

      Three baseball umpires are talking about how they play the game. The first says, “I call ’em as they are.” The second, “I call ’em as I see ’em.” And the third says, “They ain’t nothin’ till I call ’em.” Most of the time all of us are like the first

      17 min read

    • Article

      View From The Cosmos

      Dec 11, 2022

      View From The Cosmos
      10 min read

    • Article

      Yes, Determinists, There Is Free Will

      May 16, 2019

      It’s not just in politics where otherwise smart people consistently talk past one another. People debating whether humans have free will also have this tendency. Neuroscientist and free-will skeptic Sam Harris has dueled philosopher and free-will def

      10 min read

    • Article

      B.J. Hollars Explores the Midwest’s Strangest Corners

      Aug 27, 2019

      Mysteries aren’t something to be solved, but something to be embraced. We don’t need to conquer; we just need to be curious. For me, that’s where the revelation lives—in the not-knowing. The post B.J. Hollars Explores the Midwest’s Strangest Corners

      10 min read

    • Article

      Quantum Physics for Mothers

      Dec 15, 2020

      Quantum Physics for Mothers
      10 min read

    • Article

      Think Yourself Better: 10 Rules Of Philosophy To Live By

      Feb 4, 2023

      The thing that separates human beings from other animals is our extraordinary capacity for complex, abstract thought. This is what has given rise to our diverse cultures, our scientific achievements, our ability to envisage the future and, hopefully,

      9 min read

    • Article

      Stanford Scientist, After Decades Of Study, Concludes: We Don't Have Free Will

      Oct 19, 2023

      Before epilepsy was understood to be a neurological condition, people believed it was caused by the moon, or by phlegm in the brain. They condemned seizures as evidence of witchcraft or demonic possession, and killed or castrated sufferers to prevent

      8 min read

    • Article

      The Stranger Up Ahead

      Oct 28, 2019

      The Stranger Up Ahead
      4 min read

    • Article

      Humans Are Wired for Goodness

      Aug 22, 2019

      Nicholas Christakis and I are on the same page: We would definitely sacrifice our lives to save a billion strangers, perhaps even several hundred million, plucked at random from Earth’s population. But, for sure, not a thousand strangers, or a millio

      15 min read

    • Article

      Overturning Assumptions

      Nov 5, 2020

      Who You Really Are And Why It Matters Jeffrey J Kripal Penguin 2020 Pb, 239pp, £8.99, ISBN 9780141992563 The significance of anomalous experience is increasingly a matter for serious study in the humanities, and the author of this book has been one o

      4 min read

    Related categories

    Reviews for Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage

    0 ratings

    0 ratings0 reviews

    What did you think?

    Tap to rate

    Review must be at least 10 words

      Book preview

      Merit, Meaning, and Human Bondage - Nomy Arpaly

      `cbook_preview_excerpt.html\۲ƕORu;̌J%|Itfl;Gh M?#yͧKfTRD}ٽk_/|ơ/_mS5+^|O^|_޾)oS?/|]?}/|e|՗cS|Q6:~Pbξc_X +Tæ8SQAa, ǩ}ۺڗk\F8f[7a+m\[#vw$͢6P3 {n tb4;B>! wa`c|eCP:R^D;IK3w}ā\.XNa;e}FBcL#0v˗ng]CícZyN`m' |$Ps|ְf|#Ḯ"?5cૃ)O>JT3aӈ6%{V,YƖ 4 _*kcmiC:l5D0Y =@B$tlrg4gaa)idĩe% TӠzL+=@jQPti֕0Dqe\վ!|JuwR֊ova)IWL69K(eul1tpj niI R3aOKX(NABA5]ڜ 178h5a*Wrvʦ:P ) 1n2Iʾy1X3RJļsfc4<Qv[YJ8`0*>2Խç1d"ĵvc϶nsR2Q<őc-i|: "D >@yY "#0/yn k{xzcsk\)%M,z͕9=Ж*k=3 b9y's^)Xf /ʕ1\ s.U'6x(fr7xN ^9u^%hu b#!qW:WCkwsCń1o2BvL#Pzb19шŒ aHw$(Jg118h-.iR#Ev4A8UuJq;c~`daŁ?1]O"c;Tx8 ߟcF!|Lt Lۚ8]\ú+p=9M.x74Suge`iMYSXf>@[a.G}c)9#Kad",.uץ̘hgIV=V?9ŶEV&)lOھSܩR@8'p2v_ v!a'OF2]>ДTz9`NIn4#=St7SWr]8Yͧ~ ;x@$#4=?= cWm㥈dYSd q-}SssXz6'pAÒ5LĤ e&,rF:z؇zNE*Gx tHH) |I<ﮜFuB_hJ`XYGϡr"A${֛_SzFe|g7l7=i761 س<0W:7ŷ1٬b3BӰ a2>CtJs4X+FPBq9krwz ?aj 9?~WVwR}'{| |k[6wKLbf4dCYVina- ղ'ۿˆUMSj[BcN"Q&g 32anQs3\ҧ3'SXeR6c늙M)l-#SΝ*haCjh L"( 3r3Q_ ų ~(1{ g8f1ޘ:}숃Z#A1ZͅMڕ-vUY" "zgBt2(Pm6(| n(Y/X- k3!'rɘbwSջH$%OdVKT+IdHjA߿eC# \Hj\h8OϬm"VXdCye)^njIؐ1ye)}lXF"}M q;Ɇ҉יjK70w/X4&~8N#gB"* I3\bR}"J!qXЊ^3[QSBsU_Qœ)ol$n?.褰D˙caQN d@Q`zDoVed19Ғw,)#jίre2Q ;˰&!=-ElNKqgS ͥi)UK〈8QnуvӬDAS[1YЫ[K oSzV?\zNHM Y糷uWeە3g$54-sȬ,!O#Q0ׄ(ٺH L(v,mÿ7 WV{RXfpc*= ^5Иsĝ>arMB? q~) A JPB %OYʋS'S8R+c]?| de#_vd.:~b`751.X!6SfJ 3?+ėe>ZÈ\{;/?% 'O >fKã5`̺D>'jb>EE>~q~Gr BxՑĞ`kK2s&T 7Ā=i?xD2d۰LiZ'5CRK`,9UT 2&1S"K74ES{lލLtƁj\W!26'Wt]$沠qVC/;J`/֞ϑgLM(r!O.f x~]8)5# )/SRYo S]i,˒N-Kqʅ sO2 0pƷ~Tz`.Oꕧ g9]1S*`Դ0V!X,4?qnϗ jL~|bs4mt+n/ABP$`BEe]݁. {ՔʦrGi&@?"2/Q*CI /f,#fcNG,}羶,[>"mҲ%S$ǐH%f\T1Yvk+to9:CAWY#vi=R|˚J]C/1HH^vcs!skoœ#yLD[š$ht,[*u dVgE;̖pXi[\09:uW1q.MÕ~_+SKdAia׭0QCu)7u;͢ߧ~r938`)3r. F>Y~>HMˮuMmF 1ڤ:$k=u!r\Mjh^7P +ܫbF}U e&3VYۙ=a*'bk?D3 }>]T.7xO!Zhn26'p(ݦJM%!p$xT}_ds4io)F\m֜Nhܻ5CT[1Wy_ RGuFrut&t]4jjXMv50p6%\?f-UDNSGOsk cngKPɿxR0e@ҭ&T\inou;dNW; >;ūl\Ww.{^V~n60mD*%tSwyeg\ac62<ZBFU}b Z*A9J?2G+r }7.߂ u+kOBW,D8Wc-6.h|K^=9-'2v'O,y}_ 0?$e8Hl3=2jM;!^B}*P]IDZ`j- 1Sі Ψ%*b9Yh8*>?XۨP
      Enjoying the preview?
      Page 1 of 1