Los Angeles Times

LA criminal court program diverts mentally ill offenders from prosecution

LOS ANGELES — The defendant talked about her struggle overcoming anger and accepting her need for mental health treatment. When she was done, the judge led the courtroom in applause. Then, further undoing the hierarchy of courtroom decorum, Judge Theresa R. McGonigle stepped down from the bench, wrapped the defendant in a hug and posed with her for photos. Five times that day, McGonigle and ...
The defendant appears before Judge Maria Lucy Armendariz with his public defender, Caroline Goodson in Dept. 48, Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center, in Los Angeles.

LOS ANGELES — The defendant talked about her struggle overcoming anger and accepting her need for mental health treatment.

When she was done, the judge led the courtroom in applause. Then, further undoing the hierarchy of courtroom decorum, Judge Theresa R. McGonigle stepped down from the bench, wrapped the defendant in a hug and posed with her for photos.

Five times that day, McGonigle and two of her fellow judges repeated that ritual, offering personal salutes to accused lawbreakers who had chosen to go through treatment for their mental illness rather than face prosecution.

After completing their court-ordered mental health programs, each had walked out of the courtroom free — charges dismissed and criminal case expunged from the record.

Even the prosecutor was complimentary.

"It was a pretty harrowing incident that took place," Deputy City Attorney Andre Quintero told the young woman about the crime she was charged with. "I'm not going to repeat it because it's not you."

The five defendants that day were graduates of the , an initiative in Los Angeles Criminal Court that is making a small dent in the in the L.A. County Jail population.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Los Angeles Times

Los Angeles Times3 min read
At KTLA, Sam Rubin Was A Local Morning News Pioneer Who Covered Hollywood With Zeal
LOS ANGELES — KTLA entertainment reporter Sam Rubin was at the center of a local TV news revolution. Rubin, who died Friday of a heart attack at 64, became a central member of "KTLA 5 Morning News" soon after its launch on July 8. 1991. The early mor
Los Angeles Times4 min readAmerican Government
Jackie Calmes: Our Elections Have Integrity. These Politicians Do Not
Here they go again. Six months before election day, for the third straight presidential contest, Donald Trump and his Republican lickspittles are sounding alarms about virtually nonexistent voting fraud, laying the groundwork to claim that he wuz rob
Los Angeles Times4 min readCrime & Violence
Commentary: This Tough-on-crime Proposal Won’t Solve California Retail Theft, But It Would Crowd Our Prisons
California’s Proposition 47, a milestone in criminal justice reform, is under threat. The proposed Homelessness, Drug Addiction and Theft Reduction Act, which seeks to undo important aspects of Proposition 47, would take us backward to prioritize pun

Related Books & Audiobooks