Los Angeles Times

Thanks to the Supreme Court, California gun cases hinge more on history than modern threats

LOS ANGELES — To best understand California's desire to uphold its bans on assault weapons and high-capacity ammunition magazines, consider recent history. In January, a man armed with a 9 mm MAC-10 with an extended magazine, a gun prohibited under state laws, massacred 11 people and injured nine others at a Monterey Park dance studio where mostly older patrons were celebrating the Lunar New ...
Roger T. Benitez in 2004, when he was a federal magistrate judge in El Centro.

LOS ANGELES — To best understand California's desire to uphold its bans on assault weapons and high-capacity ammunition magazines, consider recent history.

In January, a man armed with a 9 mm MAC-10 with an extended magazine, a gun prohibited under state laws, massacred 11 people and injured nine others at a Monterey Park dance studio where mostly older patrons were celebrating the Lunar New Year.

Assault-style weapons that are banned in California were also used to slaughter 19 elementary school students and two teachers in Uvalde, Texas, in May, and five patrons of a gay nightclub in Colorado Springs in November. Over the last decade, the same sort of guns were used in many of the worst mass shootings in the country, mowing down high school students and teachers, concert-goers and church parishioners, nightclub patrons and county employees.

However, in the high-stakes legal battles currently being waged over California's bans in federal court — where decisions are anticipated soon — America's gruesome modern history with the powerful weapons hasn't been the focus. Instead, lawyers for the state and gun rights groups seeking to overturn the bans have been arguing over the relevance of much older laws governing very different weapons.

In the case over the assault weapons ban, recent filings have focused on a New Jersey law

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Los Angeles Times

Los Angeles Times4 min read
Review: Elisabeth Moss Stars As A Spy Gone Rogue In FX's Thriller 'The Veil'
Elisabeth Moss has acted in more projects than you can remember for more years than you might guess, but it was "Mad Men" in 2007 that made her the reason to watch a show — an impression cemented by "Top of the Lake" and taken for granted by the time
Los Angeles Times7 min read
In Ukraine's Old Imperial City, Pastel Palaces Are In Jeopardy, But Black Humor Survives
ODESA, Ukraine — On a cool spring morning, as water-washed light bathed pastel palaces in the old imperial city of Odesa, the thunder of yet another Russian missile strike filled the air. That March 6 blast came within a few hundred yards of a convoy
Los Angeles Times3 min readCrime & Violence
Sean 'Diddy' Combs Seeks Dismissal Of Revenge Porn, Human Trafficking Claims In Lawsuit
Sean "Diddy" Combs' legal team is pushing back against his accusers in their civil suits as a federal sex-trafficking probe continues. His lawyers are asking a New York court to throw out portions of a sexual assault lawsuit filed by attorneys for Jo

Related Books & Audiobooks