YOU'RE THE JUDGE!
When the police arrived at the house in Florida, on 18 October 2019, the scene they walked in on was a gruesome one.
Matthew Trussler was lying in a pool of blood, his body stabbed multiple times – his girlfriend Melissa Turner was similarly stained in red.
It was Melissa herself who had called the police, telling the operator that she had found her fiance's cold, bloody body on their back patio and had tried desperately to revive him.
She had no idea what had happened to him.
Matthew had moved to Florida from Massachusetts a couple of years previously and, after getting together with Melissa, they'd bought
