Indianapolis Monthly

COZY CABINS

DUNLAP HOLLOW COTTAGE

If you want a newly renovated site that is over 100 years old, the Dunlap Hollow Cottage is the perfect spot. Originally built in the 1920s and recently fixed up, this cabin combines rustic charm with modern amenities in a natural setting. Inside, guests have a hot tub, television, Wi-Fi, and other contemporary offerings. Outside, guests can enjoy a hiking trail in the cabin’s backyard, rugged cliffs, caves, seasonal waterfalls, and so much more within driving distance.

Dunlap Hollow Cottage is less of a romantic spot (although couples will still love the charming style) and more of a family destination. After dinner, families can gather around the firepit or hang out on the porch’s hammock swings. And when it’s time to call it a night, parents will appreciate the separate bedroom with a queen-sized bed, while the kids have their own lofted space with two single beds.

Rockbridge, OHIO

DRIVING TIME

3.25 hours

STARTING RATE

$350/night

BOOKING

Airbnb

DON’T MISS

The hiking trail directly behind the cabin for an al fresco adventure

THIS CABIN IS FOR

Families who love the outdoors, but don’t want to abandon modern comforts

FOREST HAVEN–OTIUM

You’ll have to earn your stay by trekking down a flight of stairs and through the woods to reach Otium, one of two properties built into locally sourced shipping containers nestled into a quiet Ohio forest clearing halfway between Columbus and Cleveland. Your reward is the sight of a breathtaking one bed, one bath tiny-home accommodation rising up out of the wilderness like some sort of magical oasis. Inside, the color palette and finishes blur the lines between indoors and outside through natural tones and textures to mimic those you’ll see through the floor-to-ceiling window. The outdoor shower gets shut off once temperatures dip below freezing each fall, but the al fresco tub is a popular year-round highlight. Be prepared to fully switch off while you’re there—cell service is spotty, and there’s no Wi-Fi.

Millersburg, OHIO

DRIVING TIME

4.5 hours

STARTING RATE

$210/night

BOOKING

Airbnb or dwellbox.com/forest-havens/

DON’T MISS

You’ll be near family-owned Hillcrest Orchard of Walnut Creek—pit stop to stock up on fresh-pressed cider, apples, and kettle corn

THIS CABIN IS FOR

Single travelers or couples who don’t mind sharing a small space; no kids allowed

Hocking Hills, OHIO

DRIVING TIME

3.5 hours

STARTING RATE

1-bedroom cabins are $350/night; larger family cabins are $550/night

BOOKING

Airbnb

DON’T MISS

Hocking Hills State

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Indianapolis Monthly

Indianapolis Monthly1 min read
(contributors)
Though she’s written about Indy’s real estate scene for years, contributing editor Jeana Harris never tires of the subject. She loves searching for gems among the listings and was thrilled to come across a crown jewel like the Hibben House in Irvingt
Indianapolis Monthly1 min read
Moveable Feasts
“We just get the two eggs, potatoes, and rye toast. It’s always the same. And it’s the kind of place where if you comb your hair, you’re overdressed.” “Like many locals, we just love the burgers here. It’s an absolute classic in the Indy food scene.”
Indianapolis Monthly2 min read
The Rest Is History
AN ICONIC Irvington home has changed owners after remaining in the same family for three generations. The Hibben House is a classic, charming Tudor built in 1926 for Helene Hibben, an accomplished artist who was well known for her sculptures (bas-rel

Related Books & Audiobooks