NPR

A new question for an old religion: Should non-Jews play Jewish characters on-screen?

A new Apple TV+ show, The Shrink Next Door, seems to reflect a trend of non-Jewish actors playing emphatically Jewish characters, which recently caught the ire of comedian Sarah Silverman.
Rachel Brosnahan has received raves for her performance in <em>The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel</em>,<em> </em>but comedian Sarah Silverman says it's part of a trend of non-Jews playing emphatically Jewish characters.

On a new Apple TV+ show called The Shrink Next Door, a depressed and anxious businessman is convinced by his sister to go to therapy.

"He's not a stranger!" she exclaims. "Rabbi Goldberg recommended him!"

Their strong accents reflect who their characters are: New York Jews. But neither of the actors who play them — Will Ferrell and Kathryn Hahn — are Jewish in real life.

Does that matter? It does to comedian Sarah Silverman. On a , she pointed out what she sees as an,and Felicity Jones as Ruth Bader Ginsburg in the movie .

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from NPR

NPR4 min read
Venus And Earth Used To Look Like 'Twin' Planets. What Happened?
Earth, Mars and Venus all looked pretty similar when they first formed. Today, Mars is dry, cold, and dusty; Venus has a hot, crushing atmosphere. Why did these sibling planets turn out so different?
NPR3 min readLGBTQIA+ Studies
Activists Flood Utah Tip Line With Hoax Reports To Block Bathroom Law Enforcement
Activists have flooded the tip line with thousands of hoax reports in an effort to shield trans residents and their allies from any legitimate complaints that could lead to an investigation.
NPR5 min read
Oil Industry Could Help The Biden Administration Tap 'Invisible' Green Energy
The White House wants a twenty-fold increase in geothermal energy production to fight climate change and it's counting on the oil and gas industry for help.

Related Books & Audiobooks