Cook's Illustrated

How to Make Pro-Caliber Ice Cream

When we think about ice cream, we usually think about flavors such as chocolate, vanilla, coffee, and strawberry. But what makes or breaks great ice cream is texture—how smooth, cold, and refreshing it feels in your mouth. Getting it right hinges on two main factors: controlling the water in the base and freezing that base as quickly as possible.

MIX UP JUST THE RIGHT BASE

Ice cream is mostly water, which freezes during the churning process and thickens the base so that it becomes solid and refreshing. The key is controlling the size of the ice crystals that form as the water freezes and that can continue to grow over time in the freezer. When ice cream is grainy, it’s because the crystals are noticeably large, while smooth, high-quality ice cream contains ice crystals so small that our tongues can’t detect them.

Each ingredient in the base influences the properties of the water

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Cook's Illustrated

Cook's Illustrated3 min read
Just Add Water
When I do live cooking demonstrations, I like to bring a volunteer on stage to carry out a particular experiment. I present the person with two small pots of hot liquid, one containing vegetable oil and the other water. Both liquids are being held at
Cook's Illustrated8 min read
The Fruit-Lover’s Cream Cake
This is the story of two cakes that have long been beloved in East Asian baking traditions—and how I merged those traditions into an airy, downy-soft, cream- and fruit-festooned marvel that’s perfect for any celebration. The first is one many will im
Cook's Illustrated5 min read
Why We Love Gyuto
The gyuto (pronounced “GYEW-toh”) is best described as the Japanese version of a Western-style chef’s knife. It was developed in the 1870s, during the Meiji Restoration. Japan had recently ended its policy of isolationism and had opened its borders t

Related