The Texas Observer

The Dissenter

“We have all these laws out there and they sort of give us this illusion of justice, but in many cases, justice wasn’t really happening.”

ELSA ALCALA BEGAN HER LEGAL CAREER IN THE HARRIS County DA’s office, joining a prosecutorial machine famous for cranking out death sentences. Three decades later, she’s a prominent critic of the death penalty.

Alcala, a Republican, says serving as an appellate court judge opened her eyes to systemic inequities in the criminal justice system. During her seven years on the Court of Criminal Appeals, Texas’ highest criminal court, she became known for lengthy dissents that challenged other judges, particularly in high-stakes appeals from death row. In one 2016 dissent, she questioned whether the death penalty in Texas is

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Texas Observer

The Texas Observer1 min read
Editor’s Note
Dear Observer Community, Short-term rentals—for which companies like Airbnb serve as brokers—are sucking up housing inventory across Texas, driving up prices for renters and home buyers alike. For longterm residents whose neighborhoods have been take
The Texas Observer9 min readLGBTQIA+ Studies
‘Drag Is So Healing’: Austin’s Queens Defy Ban
In an orange prison jumpsuit and chains, a tall, lean drag queen writhed to a cover of “War Pigs” by Brass Against, which sounds like someone swapped Black Sabbath’s lead singer for a woman and added a highly caffeinated marching band. As she lip-syn
The Texas Observer2 min readCrime & Violence
Braving ‘La Bestia’
Forty miles south of Ciudad Juárez, protected from the glaring desert sun by a blanket tied to a ladder, a mother nurses her nine-month-old son as the sun rises on their fifth day aboard the train known as la bestia—the beast. The mom has stuffed cot

Related Books & Audiobooks