The Threepenny Review

The Real Carnage

Carnage, directed by Roman Polanski, 2011.

TOWARDS THE end of Roman Polanski’s Carnage, a woman drops her husband’s phone into a beaker of water. That is the extent of damage any character perpetrates in a film with such a grisly-sounding name. No one is killed in Carnage. Two middle-class New York couples meet in one of their apartments to resolve a fight between their children that took place in Brooklyn Bridge Park: the movie is the duration of their meeting. Watching it again the other night, however, it seemed to me a tremendously violent film. The violence is inflicted by the viewer, I thought, as we watch the couples argue and shout.

Regardless of whether one thinks of watching itself as a complicit act, we seem to, we are all jittery and wide-awake, unmindful of everything else, impatient to keep watching.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Threepenny Review

The Threepenny Review1 min read
The Threepenny Review
Editor and Publisher: Wendy Lesser Associate Editors: Evgeniya Dame Rose Whitmore Art Advisor: Allie Haeusslein Proofreader: Paula Brisco Consulting Editors: Geoff Dyer Deborah Eisenberg Jonathan Franzen Ian McEwan Robert Pinsky Kay Ryan Tobias Wolff
The Threepenny Review6 min read
Contents Under Pressure
Henry Taylor: B Side, at the Whitney Museum, New York, October 4, 2023-January 28, 2024. IN 1946, intoxicated during his stay at a Los Angeles hotel, the saxophonist and jazz revolutionary Charlie Parker set fire to his bedsheets and ran naked throug
The Threepenny Review8 min read
The Self, Wherever She Is
Grand Tour by Elisa Gonzalez. Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2023, $26.00 cloth. “WE MEET no Stranger but Ourself”: Emily Dickinson's haunting pronouncement on the plight of the individual consciousness may be cited less often than the bit about her head f

Related Books & Audiobooks