Chicago Tribune

What's the best pie crust for your holiday baking? We tasted 11 to find out

It's time to start thinking about what you'll be making for your friends and family this holiday season. And what's a holiday meal without pie? As satisfying as it is to say you made an entire pie from scratch, sometimes it's just easier to focus on the filling and lean into the convenience and speed of a store-bought crust.

We all love pie, of course. Or at least 76% of us do, according to Mike Kostyo, trendologist at Datassential. And it turns out, most U.S. consumers eat their pie at home rather than a restaurant - 68% of consumers purchased their last pie at a store or made it from scratch. Of those, 22% used purchased crust or filling. The crust is the most important factor for consumers when choosing a pie to make or eat at home, with 71% saying that they look for a flaky, high-quality crust.

We decided to help you skip the hassle of choosing that crust by trying 11 brands that you can find in the refrigerated section at your local grocery store. This taste test, like our others on

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Chicago Tribune

Chicago Tribune5 min readAmerican Government
House Democrats Advance November Ballot Questions Aimed At Driving Party Turnout
SPRINGFIELD — Illinois House Democrats approved legislation Wednesday aimed at boosting turnout by party faithful in the Nov. 5 election by offering voters nonbinding advisory questions on securing in vitro fertilization, protecting election workers
Chicago Tribune5 min read
Paul Sullivan: Don’t Forget Harry Caray’s Legacy With The White Sox — For Calling It Like It Is
CHICAGO — As Harry Caray’s Chicago Cubs career was celebrated Thursday with the 26th “Toast to Harry Caray” sponsored by his namesake restaurant, his legacy on the South Side continues to be overlooked by his former team. It makes sense that the rest
Chicago Tribune3 min read
Backed By State Incentives, Rivian To Invest $1.5 Billion To Build New R2 EV At Illinois Plant
Rivian’s decision to launch production of its second-generation electric vehicles in Normal, Illinois, rather than Georgia, will bring $1.5 billion in capital investment and hundreds of jobs to its central Illinois factory, the automaker and Gov. J.B

Related