STAT

Opinion: Make the Step 1 test for medical students pass/fail

Step 1 "cutoff scores" are being used to help medical residency programs choose candidates. That's a misuse of the test, which is a poor predictor of future clinical performance and…

“Are you OK?” a medical school classmate asked when I snuck back into the lecture hall. I had just learned that I bombed arguably the most important test of my life. I was not OK. I was employing every technique I could muster so I wouldn’t break down in public.

I had just checked my score on the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) Step 1 test. The first of three “Step” exams that physicians-in-training must pass to become licensed to practice independently, the computer-based test focuses on the basic sciences. It’s an eight-hour grind done in a single sitting.

This test, once completed in paper and pencil by students en masse and viewed mostly as a tedious hurdle towards licensure, has since become an obsessive focus among medical students due to its elevation in the residency application process, fueling anxieties, ambitions, and evaluations of self-worth.

I will never forget

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from STAT

STAT2 min readChemistry
STAT+: Pharmalittle: We’re Reading About Fake Studies, AbbVie Investing In Psychedelics, And More
Fake studies have flooded publishers of top scientific journals,. leading to thousands of retractions and millions of dollars in lost revenue.
STAT2 min read
STAT+: Pharmalittle: We’re Reading About FDA Dithering On Pharma Patents, WHO Pandemic Talks, And More
When it comes to a crucial controversy over patents for drug-and-device combination products, the FDA has been MIA.
STAT1 min read
Opinion: STAT+: How AI Can Help Satisfy FDA’s Drug, Device Diversity Requirements
To meet the Food and Drug Omnibus Reform Act, companies must rethink their current clinical trial strategies. Including AI and machine learning approaches can help.

Related