CA128 No, math does not prove God

FromCounter Apologetics

Start listening View podcast show

CA128 No, math does not prove God

FromCounter Apologetics

ratings:

Length:

35 minutes

Released:

Jan 14, 2024

Format:

Podcast episode

Description

I respond to the wildly popular Redeemed Zoomer video about proving God’s existence with math. To see the open hangout that took place afterwards, you can watch the original livestream (unedited with no postscript) on YouTube Linktree

Released:

Jan 14, 2024

Format:

Podcast episode

Titles in the series (92)

with Emerson Green

Skip carousel

CA57 NDEs (Near-Death Experiences) pt. I: Near-Death Experiences (NDEs) have received much attention in recent years. Are they evidence of an afterlife or merely evidence of our fear of death? *UPDATE* A version of the out-of-body experiment I mentioned around 13:00 has been run. by Counter Apologetics
31 min listen
CA77 Since Matter First Writhed: The Mystery of Abiogenesis: Abiogenesis is the process by which life arises from non-living matter. Though life’s origin is an open question, abiogenesis research is a thriving interdisciplinary enterprise. In spite of this, many apologists have argued that it’s unlikely we will ... by Counter Apologetics
34 min listen
CA69 Why I Am Not A Christian (pt. I): In 1927, Bertrand Russell delivered a now-famous address entitled ‘Why I Am Not A Christian’. We examine Russell’s contribution to one of the most important questions you can ask yourself: should I be a Christian? by Counter Apologetics
17 min listen
CA61 Reformed Epistemology: We discuss Alvin Plantinga’s reformed epistemology, and ask whether belief in god is “properly basic.” We also discuss Cartesian skepticism, the notion of a divine sense or “sensus divinitatis,” and which beliefs should be considered properly basic. by Counter Apologetics
28 min listen
CA58 NDEs pt. II: Today we continue our discussion of near-death experiences. The debate over how to interpret NDEs, on some level, is an argument over substance dualism. As best we can tell, you do not have a brain — you are a brain. by Counter Apologetics
21 min listen
CA64 Exorcism and the Rise in Demonic Possession: Why is the demand for exorcism on the rise? We discuss the belief in demonic possession, the concurrent rise of anti-science attitudes, the cultural role of religious psychology, and the evolutionary origins of demons. by Counter Apologetics
25 min listen
CA74 The Incoherence of God (pt. I): Can we make any sense of the idea of god? God is supposed to be an omniscient, omnipotent, omnibenevolent, timeless, spaceless, immutable, disembodied conscious mind. We begin our series on igtheism by discussing several problems with these divine attr... by Counter Apologetics
22 min listen
CA81 Skeptical Theism: We discuss several reasons to doubt skeptical theism, including Paul Draper’s objection, phenomenal conservatism, divine silence during tragedies, Pandora’s box, and moral paralysis. linktr.ee/emersongreen Subscribe to CA and Walden Pod on YouTube here... by Counter Apologetics
36 min listen
CA60 Christianity vs. Climate Change: Does Christianity, and religion generally, naturally lead to skepticism and apathy towards climate change? We discuss the apocalypticism, otherworldliness, and the just-world belief of Christianity, and their effects on our priorities and beliefs. by Counter Apologetics
27 min listen
H.P. Lovecraft – Halloween Special: This Halloween, we’ll be discussing the life and work of the great horror author, H.P. Lovecraft. Lovecraft’s atheism 00:00 – 07:38 Biography 07:39 – 12:50 Lovecraft’s reanimation and influence on culture 12:51 – 18:02 Lovecraft and the unknown 18:03 ... by Counter Apologetics
53 min listen
CA68 Do Atheists Need Faith? with Ozymandias Ramses II: Ozy and I discuss whether atheists have faith, and whether it’s naive for atheists to hold a reflexively anti-faith position. We also discuss Hume’s problem of induction, external world skepticism, solipsism, properly basic beliefs, certainty, by Counter Apologetics
112 min listen
CA76 The Incoherence of God (pt. III): We complete our trilogy on igtheism and discuss epistemic questions about god’s attributes, the historical development of god’s nature, the experience of god, god’s relationship with logical truths, absence of evidence, by Counter Apologetics
28 min listen
CA62 Reformed Epistemology, the Sequel: We discuss relativism, Kierkegaard’s “leap of faith,” the argument from personal experience, certainty, and how it all relates to Plantinga’s Reformed epistemology. To those of you who may be wondering why we’re covering Reformed epistemology: Alvin P... by Counter Apologetics
33 min listen
CA84 Why I Am An Atheist: There are five reasons, broadly, why I’m an atheist: I. We don’t need God to explain anything. II. There are few phenomena that are better explained by theistic models than by atheistic models. III. There are many phenomena that are better explained b... by Counter Apologetics
36 min listen
CA63 Slavery in the Bible: Slavery, the practice of owning people as property, is never condemned in the Holy Bible. In fact, it’s endorsed by God personally in Leviticus 25. We discuss the character of Biblical slavery, and respond to seven common apologetics in defense of the ... by Counter Apologetics
20 min listen
CA80 Secular Christianity with Philip Goff: Non-believing Christian Philip Goff joins us to discuss religious fictionalism, literalism, religious language, Jordan Peterson, the resurrection, the spread of Christianity, the transcendent, and Christianity without theism. After the interview, by Counter Apologetics
113 min listen
CA67 Kalam Cosmological Argument: The Nature of Time: We discuss the A and B theories of time and how they relate to the kalam cosmological argument. Listen to our sister show, Walden Pod here Rate the show on iTunes here Support on Patreon here or give a one-time donation through Venmo (@emersongreenpodc... by Counter Apologetics
17 min listen
Condemn the Architect: Hume’s Answer to Skeptical Theists (Bonus Episode): Happy birthday, David Hume! I thought I’d share Hume (or more accurately, Philo) casually destroying skeptical theism in Part XI of Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. His analogy of an architect and a poorly constructed house arose in a discussion ... by Counter Apologetics
7 min listen
Bonus: The EA Show – Interview with Emerson Green: This is the audio from my appearance on The Empathetic Atheist YouTube show. Justin & Andy ask me what I take to be the best argument against god and what I take to be the worst argument for god. I apologize for the audio (as well as the video) quality... by Counter Apologetics
55 min listen
CA83 Hume on the Argument from Design: Today we discuss the evergreen critique of the design argument from David Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. Hume’s skepticism is aimed at the inference to a designer on the basis of our observations of natural objects and their analogy to h... by Counter Apologetics
25 min listen
CA82 What the ‘agnostic atheist’ graph gets wrong: Can you be an “agnostic atheist,” or are those terms mutually exclusive? I try to explain how the famous four quadrant graph misunderstands the nature of belief, knowledge, and agnosticism. the chart in question Joe Schmid on Agnosticism and Justificat... by Counter Apologetics
15 min listen
CA66 Materialism, Consciousness, and Atheism: We discuss the relationship between atheism, consciousness, and materialism after debunking arguments from consciousness formulated by Peter Kreeft and William Lane Craig. We also discuss why it’s important for naturalists to think carefully about thes... by Counter Apologetics
28 min listen
CA89 Why I don’t spend more time on contingency arguments: Arguments from contingency are widely considered to be among the strongest offered in defense of God. The results of the 2020 PhilPapers Survey have cosmological arguments ranked as the strongest family of arguments for theism. by Counter Apologetics
14 min listen
CA75 The Incoherence of God (pt. II): We define our terms, address Graham Oppy’s claim that igtheism is self-defeating, discuss logical positivism and its relationship with igtheism, and present an igtheist divine hiddenness argument. Listen to our sister show, by Counter Apologetics
39 min listen
What is Naturalism? – Walden Pod: Naturalists, according to David Papinau, author of the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on naturalism, urge “that reality is exhausted by nature, containing nothing ‘supernatural’.” Naturalism “has no very precise meaning in contemporary philo... by Counter Apologetics
22 min listen
The Atheism & Mythos of H.P. Lovecraft: This Halloween, we’ll be discussing the life and work of the great horror author, H.P. Lovecraft. Lovecraft’s atheism 00:00 – 07:38 Biographical details 07:39 – 12:50 Lovecraft’s reanimation and influence on culture 12:51 – 18:02 Lovecraft and the unkn... by Counter Apologetics
53 min listen
CA78 Young Earth Creationism & the Distant Starlight Problem: Young earth creationists believe that the earth, humankind, and the universe are approximately six-thousand years old. Scientifically, this is a fringe view, not taken seriously by anyone outside religious circles. However, by Counter Apologetics
49 min listen
CA73 Why Was Jesus Killed?: Why did the Romans kill Jesus? When I was a Christian, I was taught that the Jews were primarily responsible for the death of Jesus. The Romans may have carried it out, but it was ultimately motivated by Jesus’s conflict with Jewish authorities over hi... by Counter Apologetics
23 min listen
7 Questions for Christians: watch the video version here Support at patreon.com/counter or /waldenpod Follow on Twitter @waldenpod Transcript Linktree Answers in Reason – Ten Questions for Theists Braxton Hunter – Ten Questions for Atheists my responses to Braxton and here are l... by Counter Apologetics
6 min listen
CA79 Paul Draper’s Case for Naturalism: In his 1997 debate with William Lane Craig, Paul Draper considers seven lines of evidence and asks if they are more expected on theism or on naturalism. He argues that the meager moral fruits of theism, mind-brain dependence, evolution, by Counter Apologetics
34 min listen

More Episodes from Counter Apologetics

Skip carousel

Losing My Religion – with Fuad Abdullah Harahap (@fubilosophy): I’m interviewed by Fuad Abdullah Harahap (@fubilosophy) about my deconversion, the sad state of Christian apologetics, my issues with the skeptic community, free will, the afterlife, agnosticism, and a few other topics. Fubilosophy Linktree by Counter Apologetics
57 min listen
CA131 What would convince you?: What would convince you of God’s existence? Specifically, the Christian God. What would change your mind and cause you to convert? I name three things: Christian aliens, miracles, and religious experience. That’s not an exhaustive list, by Counter Apologetics
17 min listen
CA130 Am I Agnostic?: The world is religiously ambiguous: It can be interpreted in various incompatible ways, and the interpreters are not necessarily violating any standards of rationality in doing so. As for me, I don’t feel any position being forced on me by the evidence... by Counter Apologetics
25 min listen
CA129 Universalism Debate: John Buck vs. Emerson Green: Returning guest John Buck joins me to debate universalism, eternal conscious torment, and other topics related to hell and the afterlife. My Playlist on Hell Linktree by Counter Apologetics
108 min listen
CA127 What’s wrong with the moral argument?: We wrap up our series on the moral argument for theism, summarize several problems with the argument famously associated with William Lane Craig, and discuss two other moral arguments for God that are not abysmal failures like the standard moral argume... by Counter Apologetics
22 min listen
CA126 Euthyphro’s Revenge: Today, we continue our series on the moral argument for theism. We discuss the Euthyphro dilemma, Hume’s Law, and explore a back-and-forth between William Lane Craig and Michael Huemer on the question, “Why obey God? by Counter Apologetics
58 min listen
CA125 The Moral Argument for God (pt.1): In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth. And morality. The standard moral argument popularized by William Lane Craig and others goes as follows: (1) If God does not exist, objective moral values do not exist. by Counter Apologetics
40 min listen
CA124 Ayaan Hirsi Ali’s Conversion to Christianity: Ayaan Hirsi Ali recently announced her conversion to Christianity. But has she only adopted a form of cultural Christianity? I examine her reasons for becoming a Christian and draw some parallels between Ayaan and another political convert: Andrew Tate... by Counter Apologetics
22 min listen
AMA: I recently asked for your questions, and I posted my responses on YouTube here. We touch on compatibilism, NDEs, aliens, euthanasia, abortion, death anxiety as an atheist, idealism, incest, Islam, Mormonism, subjectivism, psychophysical harmony, by Counter Apologetics
203 min listen
CA123 Christian Universalism w/ Andrew Hronich: I’m joined by Andrew Hronich, author of Once Loved, Always Loved: The Logic of Apokatastasis. We discuss universal reconciliation, eternal conscious torment, annihilationism, and much else! Watch the interview here Linktree by Counter Apologetics
20 min listen
Where New Atheist Epistemology Goes (Very) Wrong – Interview on Adherent Apologetics: Here’s my appearance on Adherent Apologetics to talk about the recent series of Counter Apologetics episodes on epistemology. Where New Atheist Epistemology Goes (Very) Wrong | @EmersonGreen | Ep. #259 5 Mistakes Atheists Make About Epistemology 4 Th... by Counter Apologetics
70 min listen
Debate: Is God Finite?: Alex Strasser (Protestant) and John Buck (Catholic) debate the merits of finite theism, the view that God is limited in power. Theistic finitism is less vulnerable to the problem of evil than perfect being theism, by Counter Apologetics
140 min listen
CA122 Substance Dualism w/ Michael Huemer: Dr. Michael Huemer joins me to defend interactionist substance dualism, the view that the mind and body are composed of different substances and can exert causal influence over each other. Knowledge, Reality, by Counter Apologetics
97 min listen
CA121 Encountering Mystery w/ Dale Allison: Today I’m speaking with Dr. Dale Allison, historian and author of many books, including The Resurrection of Jesus, The Historical Christ and the Theological Jesus, and our subject today, Encountering Mystery: Religious Experience in a Secular Age. by Counter Apologetics
69 min listen
Extraordinary Claims Require Extraordinary Evidence: Today, I defend the controversial idea that ordinary and extraordinary claims don’t require the same evidence. Linktree by Counter Apologetics
6 min listen
CA119 Intuition, Lacktheism, & Charity: We close out our series on atheism and epistemology with the epistemic value of intuition, the issue of lacktheism, and whether or not I’ve been charitable to my fellow atheists throughout these episodes. Linktree by Counter Apologetics
16 min listen
CA118 Testimonial Evidence: Can we really trust the testimony of others? Does testimony provide any evidence or justification for a claim? I defend the idea that we should trust testimony, and that the epistemic value of testimonial evidence is supported by induction, by Counter Apologetics
16 min listen
CA116 Mistakes Atheists Make About Epistemology: “There is no evidence for God.”: There are a number of slogans one hears in the online atheist community, some of them purporting to be epistemic principles or rules of thumb. Unfortunately, many of them are only correct if we interpret them very narrowly and often not in the way they... by Counter Apologetics
17 min listen
CA115 Post-Debate Interview w/ Justin Schieber of Real Atheology: Justin Schieber joins me for a lighthearted breakdown of his debate with Eric Hernandez on the existence of God. We critique the arguments put forward by Eric, discuss the evidence presented by Justin, and talk about a few of our favorite moments from ... by Counter Apologetics
77 min listen
CA114 Animal Suffering is Evidence Against God: Is the kind, degree, and distribution of animal suffering evidence against theism? We discuss why teleological evil, the scale of suffering in evolutionary history, and the moral randomness of animal pain is strong evidence against the existence of God... by Counter Apologetics
11 min listen
Debate: Is Animal Suffering Evidence That God Does Not Exist? w/ Perspective Philosophy: Perspective Philosophy and I recently had a friendly debate about the problem of evil, metaethics, the contingency argument, and how he maintains his worldview as a catholic and vegan. The Conversation Post-debate debrief – Patreon Linktree by Counter Apologetics
107 min listen
Unknown Arguments For & Against God: Two Catholics (Dry Apologist & John Buck) and two atheists (Emerson Green & Chris Rhodes) talk about lesser-known arguments for theism and against theism. Chris joins us a little later, but he makes it in time to rack up several casualties on the battl... by Counter Apologetics
104 min listen
CA113 God’s Personality Change?: Is there any moral clash between the depiction of Yahweh and Jesus Christ? Catholic Answers recently responded to a question I had originally asked when I was 19. On Twitter, I’d recounted an experience I had with Frank Turek when I was struggling to ... by Counter Apologetics
20 min listen
Bonus: Mormonism is More Defensible Than You Think (w/ LDS Philosophy & Thoughtful Faith): I was recently invited on Thoughtful Faith’s channel to share my thoughts about why LDS theology may have a few philosophical advantages over more mainstream versions of Christianity. For example, Mormons reject perfect being theism in favor of a limit... by Counter Apologetics
4 min listen
CA112 What’s the Best Explanation of Psychophysical Harmony? w/ Philip Goff & Dustin Crummett: Philip Goff and Dustin Crummett debate psychophysical harmony, God, axiarchism, pan-agentialism, natural teleology, and explore some neglected terrain between theism and the hypothesis of indifference. What are our options in explaining the fine-tuning... by Counter Apologetics
20 min listen
CA111 How to Be a Christian When You Don’t Believe It’s True w/ Randal Rauser: I’m joined by Dr. Randal Rauser to discuss his new book, The Doubter’s Creed: How to Be a Christian When You Don’t Believe It’s True. We discuss the uniquely creedal character of Christianity, the credibility of doxastic voluntarism (the view that we c... by Counter Apologetics
20 min listen
CA110 Addressing Popular Forms of Theism vs. the Best Forms: Should we address popular versions of theism? Or should we address the best, most defensible versions of theism? To pursue the question of God’s existence, we must engage with the best forms of theism, not the worst. As Michael Huemer put it, by Counter Apologetics
20 min listen
Miracles Panel: linktr.ee/emersongreen Subscribe on YouTube Listen to our sister show, Walden Pod here Music by ichika Nito & Whalers. Used with permission. Follow on Twitter @waldenpod Consider supporting the show on Patreon here or Walden Pod here by Counter Apologetics
20 min listen

Discover this podcast and so much more

CA128 No, math does not prove God

CA128 No, math does not prove God

Description

Titles in the series (92)

More Episodes from Counter Apologetics