Automated Peer Review

FromData Skeptic

Start listening View podcast show

Automated Peer Review

FromData Skeptic

ratings:

Length:

36 minutes

Released:

Jul 31, 2023

Format:

Podcast episode

Description

In this episode, we are joined by Ryan Liu, a Computer Science graduate of Carnegie Mellon University. Ryan will begin his Ph.D. program at Princeton University this fall. His Ph.D. will focus on the intersection of large language models and how humans think. Ryan joins us to discuss his research titled "ReviewerGPT? An Exploratory Study on Using Large Language Models for Paper Reviewing"

Released:

Jul 31, 2023

Format:

Podcast episode

Titles in the series (100)

Data Skeptic is a data science podcast exploring machine learning, statistics, artificial intelligence, and other data topics through short tutorials and interviews with domain experts.

Skip carousel

[MINI] Noise!!: Our topic for this week is "noise" as in signal vs. noise. This is not a signal processing discussions, but rather a brief introduction to how the work noise is used to describe how much information in a dataset is useless (as opposed to... by Data Skeptic
16 min listen
Practicing and Communicating Data Science with Jeff Stanton: Jeff Stanton joins me in this episode to discuss his book An Introduction to Data Science, and some of the unique challenges and issues faced by someone doing applied data science. A challenge to any data scientist is making sure they have a... by Data Skeptic
37 min listen
[MINI] Experimental Design: This episode loosely explores the topic of Experimental Design including hypothesis testing, the importance of statistical tests, and an everyday and business example. by Data Skeptic
16 min listen
Advertising Attribution with Nathan Janos: A conversation with Convertro's Nathan Janos about methodologies used to help advertisers understand the affect each of their marketing efforts (print, SEM, display, skywriting, etc.) contributes to their overall return. by Data Skeptic
76 min listen
[MINI] Bayesian Updating: In this minisode, we discuss Bayesian Updating - the process by which one can calculate the most likely hypothesis might be true given one's older / prior belief and all new evidence. by Data Skeptic
11 min listen
[MINI] type i / type ii errors: In this first mini-episode of the Data Skeptic Podcast, we define and discuss type i and type ii errors (a.k.a. false positives and false negatives). by Data Skeptic
11 min listen
Data in Healthcare IT with Shahid Shah: Our guest this week is Shahid Shah. Shahid is CEO at Netspective, and writes three blogs: Health Care Guy, Shahid Shah, and HitSphere - the Healthcare IT Supersite. During the program, Kyle recommended a talk from the 2014 MIT Sloan CIO Symposium... by Data Skeptic
57 min listen
[MINI] Cross Validation: This miniepisode discusses the technique called Cross Validation - a process by which one randomly divides up a dataset into numerous small partitions. Next, (typically) one is held out, and the rest are used to train some model. The hold out set can... by Data Skeptic
1 min listen
[MINI] Ant Colony Optimization: In this week's mini episode, Linhda and Kyle discuss Ant Colony Optimization - a numerical / stochastic optimization technique which models its search after the process ants employ in using random walks to find a goal (food) and then leaving a... by Data Skeptic
15 min listen
Personalized Medicine with Niki Athanasiadou: In the second full length episode of the podcast, we discuss the current state of personalized medicine and the advancements in genetics that have made it possible. by Data Skeptic
57 min listen
[MINI] Decision Tree Learning: Linhda and Kyle talk about Decision Tree Learning in this miniepisode. Decision Tree Learning is the algorithmic process of trying to generate an optimal decision tree to properly classify or forecast some future unlabeled element based by... by Data Skeptic
13 min listen
[MINI] Partially Observable State Spaces: When dealing with dynamic systems that are potentially undergoing constant change, its helpful to describe what "state" they are in. In many applications the manner in which the state changes from one to another is not completely predictable,... by Data Skeptic
13 min listen
Data Science at ZestFinance with Marick Sinay: Marick Sinay from ZestFianance is our guest this weel. This episode explores how data science techniques are applied in the financial world, specifically in assessing credit worthiness. by Data Skeptic
31 min listen
[MINI] Selection Bias: A discussion about conducting US presidential election polls helps frame a converation about selection bias. by Data Skeptic
15 min listen
[MINI] The T-Test: The t-test is this week's mini-episode topic. The t-test is a statistical testing procedure used to determine if the mean of two datasets differs by a statistically significant amount. We discuss how a wine manufacturer might apply a t-test to... by Data Skeptic
17 min listen
Streetlight Outage and Crime Rate Analysis with Zach Seeskin: This episode features a discussion with statistics PhD student Zach Seeskin about a project he was involved in as part of the Eric and Wendy Schmidt Data Science for Social Good Summer Fellowship. The project involved exploring the... by Data Skeptic
33 min listen
[MINI] p-values: In this mini, we discuss p-values and their use in hypothesis testing, in the context of an hypothetical experiment on plant flowering, and end with a reference to the Particle Fever documentary and how statistical significance played a role. by Data Skeptic
17 min listen
Jackson Pollock Authentication Analysis with Kate Jones-Smith: Our guest this week is Hamilton physics professor Kate Jones-Smith who joins us to discuss the evidence for the claim that drip paintings of Jackson Pollock contain fractal patterns. This hypothesis originates in a paper by Taylor, Micolich,... by Data Skeptic
50 min listen
$Jackson Pollock Authentication Analysis with Kate Jones-Smith: Our guest this week is Hamilton physics professor Kate Jones-Smith who joins us to discuss the evidence for the claim that drip paintings of Jackson Pollock contain fractal patterns. This hypothesis originates in a paper by Taylor, Micolich,...$
Introduction: The Data Skeptic Podcast features conversations with topics related to data science, statistics, machine learning, artificial intelligence and the like, all from the perspective of applying critical thinking and the scientific method to evaluate the... by Data Skeptic
4 min listen
[MINI] Is the Internet Secure?: This episode explores the basis of why we can trust encryption. Suprisingly, a discussion of looking up a word in the dictionary (binary search) and efficiently going wine tasting (the travelling salesman problem) help introduce computational... by Data Skeptic
26 min listen
[MINI] Value of Information: A discussion about getting ready in the morning, negotiating a used car purchase, and selecting the best AirBnB place to stay at help frame a conversation about the decision theoretic principal known as the Value of Information equation. by Data Skeptic
14 min listen
Game Science Dice with Louis Zocchi: In this bonus episode, guest Louis Zocchi discusses his background in the gaming industry, specifically, how he became a manufacturer of dice designed to produce statistically uniform outcomes. During the show Louis mentioned a two part video... by Data Skeptic
47 min listen
Guerilla Skepticism on Wikipedia with Susan Gerbic: Our guest this week is Susan Gerbic. Susan is a skeptical activist involved in many activities, the one we focus on most in this episode is Guerrilla Skepticism on Wikipedia, an organization working to improve the content and citations of... by Data Skeptic
70 min listen
The Right (big data) Tool for the Job with Jay Shankar: In this week's episode, we discuss applied solutions to big data problem with big data engineer Jay Shankar. The episode explores approaches and design philosophy to solving real world big data business problems, and the exploration of the wide... by Data Skeptic
50 min listen
[MINI] Monkeys on Typewriters: What is randomness? How can we determine if some results are randomly generated or not? Why are random numbers important to us in our everyday life? These topics and more are discussed in this mini-episode on random numbers. Many readers will be... by Data Skeptic
3 min listen
Contest Announcement: The Data Skeptic Podcast is launching a contest- not one of chance, but one of skill. Listeners are encouraged to put their data science skills to good use, or if all else fails, guess! The contest works as follows. Below is some data about the... by Data Skeptic
12 min listen
ContentMine: ContentMine is a project which provides the tools and workflow to convert scientific literature into machine readable and machine interpretable data in order to facilitate better and more effective access to the accumulated knowledge of human kind.... by Data Skeptic
53 min listen
[MINI] The Battle of the Sexes: Love and Data is the continued theme in this mini-episode as we discuss the game theory example of The Battle of the Sexes. In this textbook example, a couple must strategize about how to spend their Friday night. One partner prefers football games... by Data Skeptic
18 min listen
The Ghost in the MP3: Have you ever wondered what is lost when you compress a song into an MP3? This week's guest Ryan Maguire did more than that. He worked on software to issolate the sounds that are lost when you convert a lossless digital audio recording into a... by Data Skeptic
35 min listen
Data Myths with Karl Mamer: Black out baby boom | Subliminal messages | Beer and Diapers by Data Skeptic
48 min listen

More Episodes from Data Skeptic

Skip carousel

Behavioral Genetics: It’s almost impossible to think about animal behavior without thinking of dogs! Our canine friends are a subspecies of wolf that has been co-evolving with us for tens of thousands of years. The transition from wolf to pet has required intense... by Data Skeptic
47 min listen
Signal in the Noise: In this episode, we are joined by Barbara Webb and Anna Hadjitofi. Barbara runs the Insect Robotics lab at the University of Edinburgh, and Anna is a PhD student at the School of Informatics at the university. She is interested in studying and... by Data Skeptic
42 min listen
Pose Tracking: Many researchers and students have painstakingly labeled precise details about the body positions of the creatures they study. Can AI be used for this labeling? Of course it can! Today's episode discusses Social LEAP Estimates Animal Poses (SLEAP), a... by Data Skeptic
51 min listen
Modeling Group Behavior: Our guest in this episode is Sebastien Motsch, an assistant professor at Arizona State University, working in the School of Mathematical and Statistical Science. He works on modeling self-organized biological systems to understand how complex patterns... by Data Skeptic
41 min listen
Advances in Data Loggers: Our guest in this episode is Ryan Hanscom. Ryan is a Ph.D. candidate in a joint doctoral evolution program at San Diego State University and the University of California, Riverside. He is a terrestrial ecologist with a focus on herpetology and... by Data Skeptic
36 min listen
What You Know About Intelligence is Wrong (fixed): We are joined by Hank Schlinger, a professor of psychology at California State University, Los Angeles. His research revolves around theoretical issues in psychology and behavioral analysis. Hank establishes that words have references and... by Data Skeptic
42 min listen
Animal Decision Making: On today’s episode, we are joined by Aimee Dunlap. Aimee is an assistant professor at the University of Missouri–St. Louis and the interim director at the Whitney R. Harris World Ecology Center. Aimee discussed how animals perceive information and... by Data Skeptic
37 min listen
Octopus Cognition: We are joined by Tamar Gutnick, a visiting professor at the University of Naples Federico II, Napoli, Italy. She studies the octopus nervous system and their behavior, focusing on cognition and learning behaviors. Tamar gave a background to the kind... by Data Skeptic
38 min listen
Optimal Foraging: Claire Hemmingway, an assistant professor in the Department of Psychology and Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at the University of Tennessee in Knoxville, is our guest today. Her research is on decision-making in animal cognition, focusing on... by Data Skeptic
38 min listen
Memory in Chess: On today’s show, we are joined by our co-host, Becky Hansis-O’Neil. Becky is a Ph.D. student at the University of Missouri, St Louis, where she studies bumblebees and tarantulas to understand their learning and cognitive work. She joins us... by Data Skeptic
49 min listen
OpenWorm: On this episode, we are joined by Stephen Larson, the CEO of MetaCell and an affiliate of the OpenWorm foundation. Stephen discussed what the Openworm project is about. They hope to use a digital C. elegans nematode (C. elegans for... by Data Skeptic
34 min listen
What the Antlion Knows: Our guest is Becky Hansis-O’Neil, a Ph.D. student at the University of Missouri, St Louis, and our co-host for the new "Animal Intelligence" season. Becky shares her background on how she got into the field of behavioral intelligence and biology. by Data Skeptic
42 min listen
AI Roundtable: Kyle is joined by friends and former guests Pramit Choudhary and Frank Bell to have an open discussion of the impacts LLMs and machine learning have had in the past year on industry, and where things may go in the current year. by Data Skeptic
51 min listen
Uncontrollable AI Risks: We are joined by Darren McKee, a Policy Advisor and the host of Reality Check — a critical thinking podcast. Darren gave a background about himself and how he got into the AI space. Darren shared his thoughts on AGI's achievements in the coming... by Data Skeptic
39 min listen
I LLM and You Can Too: It took a massive financial investment for the first large language models (LLMs) to be created. Did their corporate backers lock these tools away for all but the richest? No. They provided comodity priced API options for using... by Data Skeptic
24 min listen
Q&A with Kyle: We celebrate episode 1000000000 with some Q&A from host Kyle Polich. We boil this episode down to four key questions: 1) How do you find guests 2) What is Data Skeptic all about? 3) What is Kyle all about? 4) What are Kyle's thoughts on AGI?... by Data Skeptic
40 min listen
LLMs for Data Analysis: In this episode, we are joined by Amir Netz, a Technical Fellow at Microsoft and the CTO of Microsoft Fabric. He discusses how companies can use Microsoft's latest tools for business intelligence. Amir started by discussing how business intelligence... by Data Skeptic
29 min listen
AI Platforms: Our guest today is Eric Boyd, the Corporate Vice President of AI at Microsoft. Eric joins us to share how organizations can leverage AI for faster development. Eric shared the benefits of using natural language to build products. He discussed the... by Data Skeptic
34 min listen
Deploying LLMs: We are excited to be joined by Aaron Reich and Priyanka Shah. Aaron is the CTO at Avanade, while Priyanka leads their AI/IoT offering for the SEA Region. Priyanka is also the MVP for Microsoft AI. They join us to discuss how LLMs are deployed in... by Data Skeptic
35 min listen
A Survey Assessing Github Copilot: In this episode, we are joined by Jenny Liang, a PhD student at Carnegie Mellon University, where she studies the usability of code generation tools. She discusses her recent survey on the usability of AI programming assistants. Jenny discussed the... by Data Skeptic
26 min listen
Program Aided Language Models: We are joined by Aman Madaan and Shuyan Zhou. They are both PhD students at the Language Technology Institute at Carnegie Mellon University. They join us to discuss their latest published paper, PAL: Program-aided Language Models. Aman and Shuyan... by Data Skeptic
32 min listen
Which Programming Language is ChatGPT Best At: In this episode, we have Alessio Buscemi, a software engineer at Lifeware SA. Alessio was a post-doctoral researcher at the University of Luxembourg. He joins us to discuss his paper, A Comparative Study of Code Generation using ChatGPT 3.5 across 10... by Data Skeptic
40 min listen
GraphText: On the show today, we are joined by Jianan Zhao, a Computer Science student at Mila and the University of Montreal. His research focus is on graph databases and natural language processing. He joins us to discuss how to use graphs with LLMs... by Data Skeptic
31 min listen
arXiv Publication Patterns: Today, we are joined by Rajiv Movva, a PhD student in Computer Science at Cornell Tech University. His research interest lies in the intersection of responsible AI and computational social science. He joins to discuss the findings of this work that... by Data Skeptic
28 min listen
Do LLMs Make Ethical Choices: We are excited to be joined by Josh Albrecht, the CTO of Imbue. Imbue is a research company whose mission is to create AI agents that are more robust, safer, and easier to use. He joins us to share findings of his work; Despite "super-human"... by Data Skeptic
29 min listen
Emergent Deception in LLMs: On today’s show, we are joined by Thilo Hagendorff, a Research Group Leader of Ethics of Generative AI at the University of Stuttgart. He joins us to discuss his research, . Thilo discussed how machine psychology is useful in machine learning... by Data Skeptic
27 min listen
Agents with Theory of Mind Play Hanabi: Nieves Montes, a Ph.D. student at the Artificial Intelligence Research Institute in Barcelona, Spain, joins us. Her PhD research revolves around value-based reasoning in relation to norms. She shares her latest study, Combining theory of mind and... by Data Skeptic
38 min listen
LLMs for Evil: We are joined by Maximilian Mozes, a PhD student at the University College, London. His PhD research focuses on Natural Language Processing (NLP), particularly the intersection of adversarial machine learning and NLP. He joins us to discuss his latest... by Data Skeptic
26 min listen
The Defeat of the Winograd Schema Challenge: Our guest today is Vid Kocijan, a Machine Learning Engineer at Kumo AI. Vid has a Ph.D. in Computer Science at the University of Oxford. His research focused on common sense reasoning, pre-training in LLMs, pretraining in knowledge-based completion,... by Data Skeptic
31 min listen

Related podcast episodes

Skip carousel

Cyber Nationalism and Regime Support under Xi Jinping: Freeman Chair Jude Blanchette is joined by Rongbin Han, an Associate Professor in the Department of International Affairs at The University of Georgia, to discuss his recent paper, Cyber Nationalism and Regime Support under Xi Jinping: The Effects of the 2018 Constitutional Revision. by Pekingology
37 min listen
The case for reparations for Black Americans: Is it time to pay reparations to the descendants of enslaved Black Americans? That’s the topic of a new Big Ideas paper from the Brookings Policy 2020 initiative, and the authors--Rashawn Ray and Andre Perry--are on the show to discuss it. ... by The Brookings Cafeteria
38 min listen
Magnus Ramage and Karen Shipp, "Systems Thinkers" (Springer, 2020): An interview with Magnus Ramage by New Books in the History of Science
65 min listen
GraphText: On the show today, we are joined by Jianan Zhao, a Computer Science student at Mila and the University of Montreal. His research focus is on graph databases and natural language processing. He joins us to discuss how to use graphs with LLMs... by Data Skeptic
31 min listen
Stephen Crain, “The Emergence of Meaning” (Cambridge UP, 2012): It’s not surprising that human language reflects and respects logical relations – logic, in some sense, ‘works’. For linguists, this represents a potentially interesting avenue of approach to the much-debated question of innateness. by New Books in Psychology
54 min listen
Stephen Crain, “The Emergence of Meaning” (Cambridge UP, 2012): It’s not surprising that human language reflects and respects logical relations – logic, in some sense, ‘works’. For linguists, this represents a potentially interesting avenue of approach to the much-debated question of innateness. by New Books in Language
54 min listen
Modeling Human Behavior with Generative Agents with Joon Sung Park - #632 by The TWIML AI Podcast (formerly This Week in Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence)
47 min listen
Using artificial intelligence and language technology to help clinicians screen patients with mood disorders and suicide risk with Dr. Philip Resnik: Philip Resnik, PhD, joins host Lorenzo Norris, MD, to discuss the use of AI and natural language processing to help clinicians identify patterns in the behaviors of patients with mental illness. is a professor in the department of linguistics at the... by Psychcast
42 min listen
Learning Transformer Programs with Dan Friedman - #667 by The TWIML AI Podcast (formerly This Week in Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence)
39 min listen
What does ChatGPT really know?: By now you’ve probably heard about the new chatbot called . There’s no question it’s something of a marvel. It distills complex information into clear prose; it offers instructions and suggestions; it reasons its way through problems. With the... by Many Minds
55 min listen
Interview with Petra Todd, Econometrician, Labor Economist and Development Economist at Penn by The Mixtape with Scott
60 min listen
Neoliberalism and Higher Education: A Discussion with Frank Fear, Claire Polster, and Ruben Martinez by New Books in Economic and Business History
67 min listen
Jake Vanderplas: Data Science For Academic Research: Jake Vanderplas: Python Data Science Tools And Best Practices For Academic Research by The Python Podcast.__init__
49 min listen
Does ChatGPT “Think”? A Cognitive Neuroscience Perspective with Anna Ivanova - #620 by The TWIML AI Podcast (formerly This Week in Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence)
45 min listen
Transformers On Large-Scale Graphs with Bayan Bruss - #641 by The TWIML AI Podcast (formerly This Week in Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence)
39 min listen
Abstracts: October 9, 2023 by Microsoft Research Podcast
13 min listen
007 Prof. Kristin Persson of the Materials Project – Building a Global Materials Informatics Platform: Summary: This episode focuses on Prof. Kristin Persson’s work directing the Materials Project, where she had her group have built an open-source materials informatics platform that reaches over 75,000 users worldwide. In this episode,... by DataLab: The Materials Informatics Podcast
28 min listen
Aspiring Quantum Chemist with Professor Lin Lin by The New Quantum Era
43 min listen
AI Frontiers: Rethinking intelligence with Ashley Llorens and Ida Momennejad by Microsoft Research Podcast
42 min listen
Are Emergent Behaviors in LLMs an Illusion? with Sanmi Koyejo - #671 by The TWIML AI Podcast (formerly This Week in Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence)
66 min listen
Brennan Klein - Teleology, Perception, Complex Systems by Too Lazy to Read the Paper
102 min listen
E. Michele Ramsey, "Major Decisions: College, Career, and the Case for the Humanities" (U Penn Press, 2019): Ramsey offers a robust defense of Communication and the Humanities as disciplines of study... by New Books in Language
78 min listen
E. Michele Ramsey, "Major Decisions: College, Career, and the Case for the Humanities" (U Penn Press, 2019): Ramsey offers a robust defense of Communication and the Humanities as disciplines of study... by New Books in Education
78 min listen
Neoliberalism and Higher Education: A Discussion with Frank Fear, Claire Polster, and Ruben Martinez by New Books in Critical Theory
67 min listen
James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes, "Arguing with Numbers: The Intersections of Rhetoric and Mathematics" (Pennsylvania State UP, 2021): An interview with James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes by New Books in Science
68 min listen
James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes, "Arguing with Numbers: The Intersections of Rhetoric and Mathematics" (Pennsylvania State UP, 2021): An interview with James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes by New Books in Language
68 min listen
James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes, "Arguing with Numbers: The Intersections of Rhetoric and Mathematics" (Pennsylvania State UP, 2021): An interview with James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes by New Books in Science, Technology, and Society
68 min listen
James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes, "Arguing with Numbers: The Intersections of Rhetoric and Mathematics" (Pennsylvania State UP, 2021): An interview with James Wynn and G. Mitchell Reyes by New Books in Mathematics
68 min listen
Ranthony Edumonds by Count Me In
56 min listen
James Lee: genes and educational attainment: In this episode of Unsupervised Learning Razib talks to , a professor of psychology at the University of Minnesota. Lee is a co-author of a new paper in Nature, . A landmark in the field of cognitive genomics, this publication... by Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning
95 min listen

Discover this podcast and so much more

Automated Peer Review

Automated Peer Review

Description

Titles in the series (100)

More Episodes from Data Skeptic

Related podcast episodes