Kaitlyn is on a Thursday podcast?! Wuh? Yeah, believe it, yo. Drew and Kaitlyn wishes they could emit the same energy and swag as Robbie "Strikeout King" Ray did in Wednesday's start versus the White Sox. Fanning 14 batters on a playoff-bound team might earn you some extra dough if you're Robbie Ray. Right? The duo poses the question "should Toronto re-sign Robbie Ray or Marcus Semien" (assuming you can only re-sign one of the two)? Is Semien willing to remain at second base in the future? Why have timely hits eluded the Jays? Plus, which catcher should start after Danny Jansen returns from his rehab assignment?

Follow Drew on Twitter: @DrewGROF
Follow Kaitlyn on Twitter: @kaitlyncmcgrath
Save 33% on an annual subscription to The Athletic by visiting: theathletic.com/spinrate
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices