The great Charlie Manuel joins Jayson and Doug on Starkville! Charlie reminisces about his tenure as manager in Philadelphia and breaks down the Hall of Fame case for Jimmy Rollins, Ryan Howard, and Chase Utley. What makes each Phillies great a HOF candidate? Of the three, who will actually get in? Plus, a HOF pitching listener trivia question and an injury-riddled Strange But True to start 2022!

Follow Jayson on Twitter: @jaysonst
Follow Doug on Twitter: @dougglanville
Follow Charlie on Twitter: @CMBaseball41
Save 33% on a subscription to The Athletic by visiting: theathletic.com/baseballshow
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices