Competing narratives and fictionalized accounts make it hard to say what exactly happened in the house at 112 Ocean Avenue after the Lutz family moved in. Maybe the Amityville house truly was haunted — after all, it was the site of a near-complete family annihilation. But what if what happened to the Lutzes had nothing to do with the house at all?

To view this episode’s full list of sources, please visit parcast.com/supernatural
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices