Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence: Al-Shīrāzī’s Insights into the Dialectical Constitution of Meaning and Knowledge
Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence: Al-Shīrāzī’s Insights into the Dialectical Constitution of Meaning and Knowledge
Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence: Al-Shīrāzī’s Insights into the Dialectical Constitution of Meaning and Knowledge
Ebook613 pages5 hours

Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence: Al-Shīrāzī’s Insights into the Dialectical Constitution of Meaning and Knowledge

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars

()

Read preview

About this ebook

This monograph proposes a new (dialogical) way of studying the different forms of correlational inference, known in the Islamic jurisprudence as qiyās. According to the authors’ view, qiyās represents an innovative and sophisticated form of dialectical reasoning that not only provides new epistemological insights into legal argumentation in general (including legal reasoning in Common and Civil Law) but also furnishes a fine-grained pattern for parallel reasoning which can be deployed in a wide range of problem-solving contexts and does not seem to reduce to the standard forms of analogical reasoning studied in contemporary philosophy of science and argumentation theory.

After an overview of the emergence of qiyās and of the work of al-Shīrāzī penned by Soufi Youcef, the authors discuss al-Shīrāzī’s classification of correlational inferences of the occasioning factor (qiyās al-'illa). The second part of the volume deliberates on the system of correlational inferences by indication and resemblance (qiyās al-dalāla, qiyās al-shabah). The third part develops the main theoretical background of the authors’ work, namely, the dialogical approach to Martin-Löf's Constructive Type Theory. The authors present this in a general form and independently of adaptations deployed in parts I and II. Part III also includes an appendix on the relevant notions of Constructive Type Theory, which has been extracted from an overview written by Ansten Klev. The book concludes with some brief remarks on contemporary approaches to analogy in Common and Civil Law and also to parallel reasoning in general.

LanguageEnglish
PublisherSpringer
Release dateJan 13, 2020
ISBN9783030223823
Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence: Al-Shīrāzī’s Insights into the Dialectical Constitution of Meaning and Knowledge

Related to Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence

Titles in the series (1)

View More

Related ebooks

Philosophy For You

View More

Related articles

Reviews for Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars
0 ratings

0 ratings0 reviews

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

    Book preview

    Inferences by Parallel Reasoning in Islamic Jurisprudence - Shahid Rahman

    Zbbook_preview_excerpt.html}Kɑ_IaX]@?ꁁh4&1`78cl,2*Y|tpF&Mԁ: [ )&e~̑ '?xeVU`2#<<gw>)f[+;gwrL絪M'"70ujhfU9O貚amub=Mnn^N{xB&Eu;PI5ϋGKUN""m 5NBxʬFCqaw?qgZU75ͼVgi Ε0.QQ4I<3D1f "ȔUv6e(1iSSU0b$pJdX{G/SY6'_{<;"EsP4za'3MDCTv|>-[s/ƈ $H5հ4<`hiA6dmIEʢh!*%I~Q4C=oOfd֝ ||綞9GQ6 cJDv:"*SS?mJCi4z7 <پmN޾.߾z5yeƓ q;MUɘ6uT±VS"зW$ue[ۛo~~~($5mQX}Q JyqwOCCs'޾%?'!` IpvzI12?+;~o1Ɂ'n':3cSQl-IV2FOl1zU?=}lmmlܺ7⿷?ȸ#}ܺqsc{Ս훛1[-]WZ~Ql^o^zʲw<M(/cwP&E\ؗdTBSn};\Qk=a>&,휅i)g&+&2 ա" p.njlaJ3(0*36,ʽ0"f6B |r,(VymӒU2 -r"%׷&_{q'c>d* $\Mrl2+ŽgjL?mC벹gD#r h#doidq3OMUN=cK=6q.É!OUuO!M%@̀ZD歛;ɀ "O)~"ݸ NLټ"y&dZN%* s@klcd[4}7ݗɷݗ߽_}oY;3#l4k5zJf!"ȯO!fs8ECk%a%V&C/$WIS՜{(ʆ`sbL{]x"1xgMIWeZm\ɷv~ 5Cg_sԉ+}$r Ľ(N5Nrr /PbpFLʢ^3epk9$B3GHԋaεVd*g}K2(LТ/t2!"h:kd8u*80 (3ਊcDw X2É-#DTz[ZbKv/[)q + ;Q@]-qqҺtve!YVfe-X_dD3'۠Ț85wH`old,/o eIV":9abA{?#7 τQM:+Y9iߩk7 Cܦ) Gj pK`3c͉xw@S5CL$N8r ~pq\czFNU严$Ț7SdiUq3:ezpGӒ9솱:>("rLE]p*#D:6(,]h0eM0!f\aXzNՖH?#(9,S Vv!慶ˑp^% q^i18AC#ح:|I8c(76ֻD#t40's0wDjA=ǯY/@4v4 hS~Q5lt5sɣllzXUKeO\ӄ$Gw0%z]IwfSyB&OxD$*Xjck[ʴ'VHC3Wb0r,SԏY߾v,ο Y5PmV%Ԏō ٰ݊++*PAl%L+Fp`ɘ"ci~EcZ1g5D"1t_0&5 CkxfND\;s aVpk#3dG2cYsoa4ֻ ƖP6lۨ%io)Ol0d-U~+qB~mu:" /߀fG45 _RbBk"%ї FpvM [E`NW]Lpء%0JdDBE$/X)J|-8Tï@G8l!y8dzh=y?hU2!G'8d)֩:t)6dt(spx a@˰̴^4r?6O}b!ԙϡ|]%>[Wݡbi?[/׀gy^0u6keuvUA#k*† ӳ']PX 5G(/~E^rıJ,:A+0 T#A1f^~ ] fyxg I"REk|u]H/J˝dL369T6Afd"kP''){9wŧ䎵Qb/^Gw'"{dan/-Dqf)Fe:qSڪ `Js9 `:t=9´(ZKowuBglbZ [$B"jh \=ƌm^"M;0[dyiɕ^#K2 rvHPmS@h?lmY&f 9XHۑR4R (8T 9-4v!Ik9^Zн/cd 2:ƀ~-ATdYo/1j8oCK( pwbNVI !zhYx$h@un7MUUΕ}Q1>jZ˾97 !#}7e)rQZ]m h%楶$e8&#;^ba?q'b  S!PoOQHl!{VdBVjwm12X<|㻴sّ [mw9\n_y~Ǫ X<4R*c2\mcT XzMs|km+Wn';7㏛cżĦ|NҞ:M&1OCx%[8|gß^jh{&}HUQ3UTފckdqj'kel^< 3΋ qy^ZkkQ6ol|&^5OPl(u(s Uiӱ%ell֯'`AXޤ:ьY(XNhvRY+:܊KZxV#[%Sl:Z- N!X]#onDUt#-(w:5#%\suTaˁ6V/ r"&ǝ%qdZK)Wa6d5Sb.}e[R8WQjE=A;#v?GFfJJn[kc8(PY`!jڭ:F[CQ2Z N8Gs-g+.?ps8wbY>>SQ*8B_)ei:sElUpb* SԄj5%ZLrv_>M!N,"f&5Sf mx%4u%Bi(o6PCbkF "'l*91LEW\Sjv iV-;6\+Vف-%NbN853銮ROVFUFYwiop#4f'[EA/]E3\ozSynG*?|ӻ^`]k|FpZ+!Lj#, ѬRhbnۂ,wm'8D47._Ȝ[qֱp[uϢ=.2{6%Ҭxw!YH\ ;5/&D!5ȥd+:]H &uX,bl8dR>eM UA>Rz*g;xy/WEolVtM i$TX^ ˭7E)v:(<@<[W]lB(l% ?O58vN+u΃r%]HF~B\@Ԃ2w^LQ{酏`:OM-#t9^쪙A ˫# .t+ ^ tk$@m=A81}m_b-z|' LefyUv.xoe\#%g&q4T"v߁gqɾ5B޾i7^{G2?{9WcӘb fI{r3r1K79/ Rrd:ly>$ҳln֏- =)@e*p`"*ݞtqţnUH.@irqpy\y"-BfiPRGKAt NI1G5h-,{.p Ufਔ<e3^b;:=+VJ "W:ˢgBE1o|#2C|zlb OM Gx$3JiCv6DKn-7tcKYE\e7.73J+D ̂`Pf'TEDf$ɺEхc4\-FE+ģCK($R#>땠"PK͎å%<OQჍNd7>\p86`cDwI ,A_؎9T 0jx܅Pkn<6[EqdOL6}ry#OsܡVϺ0T7u5YáxzKl  m4fJ lo IQ{[Pe‰ >/3bW\!*Gp^J==>i0 Y-$H1=j\??,j^pb/W;X`B!Sg;Њ t{GڹU'rbQb lJ"1k/ â.v:q`]-[&ؙZ]4Uc-n ,A!BTY~aRإb,Gp dM'8uoW5c"8"򻇼 3k J}55)L\_NX#^>nRHƦ(L|*G9LưP dE%&'gJg7X-=T,wŨa׹lO$sF_r`wNEg+nJCGDz"kz+-, ?r,uSbTf,h,pb^9$,c\5F9&]tI8;|!x$d9m@yzsIᨀ%v}+$$HT=vDeO"tlʡ߶\ܸz]؝[z\+3+d Gc[n9926sHޚTDgtYPyڃ&~ %ڜkw A鲲'/)\C(RxYeI8II!šbf,Jzy6cH[=m"[G},"pv<4nhB6IN/Ii k ӾWfSǙ} O=44r ٣~UnJ"wΡRxWv,Tu+P*~$m,s*-.FD %bƑ00Ha1 B* `Vcё)UȁOFLk`(J*A#5vX`}Qbh*yt&Rw:峬tr{6U#y_Gb߃6kPPҠhy5I0InH4J1uvֹm4I-?) ;񖙊 %H..b3j0`(4 Ijck{[jUqR\U'*W/ 5Z%C+`Gzk97`BsL\}v3&s=[1n,Quu䡞BUO: m1c2Cbf,)5 hX`gV':'Dboy]zZ:/Z e&L[ϥ{+?ngĜ wgc.;9/| a0}}7Ywf(>I3uV*zJ<Ѳ"=w {-5=Q>8<MrKF4/n4WLrE.\CGЧG:Ry)zԶ\z]}Zq4Z"*XQ.-VhMB͓m;rЖwULo_dTs!Xs.5x+gͤV׹_z9{TR>|4y5ڸn*ZФ}bGͅ2.Qs^MpjPz)8B/j}.em9mڔ At=jf`+:)̼y]f^vT:eu1 \ކD 9C!#/U^W6w_~^}WsϋϿ,EXӦi# fjYXՔDC?Uy@ hlMNe=lpB%eXht6ף~G)b5C gCgGcy <;6ʵy◛Wn;}WdL?#?43Itn=$K35,,(s rjo(54;6F&9!a٬lߠ *LH$:c2yT_6d푹WbߐԊ"JT{Įe<ߓ3xl31kin1gJZDaqT탢HyL^7,3{.vEzK>p` Nc#Qc,:ƠӶ#;WwhX1-') wiAs/_8ʀFG|1/b ZK16d DX[Bv: 2zMY؞Lmۨswvs'd!q}%tǎ_bR‚`%"_{4KF{=^2ZD#冾U&&3EO;^U+>"K8j'}M/y$qSv5& f}Ou^JS45IFswD|T>o{CA5 :c'Q/"98|VTFX IKp7,^guJluV 5{䓇e]i܇TE-^SD)d<{7k'.(܃㒮W]Mnrא(*fɣ#&m-[09mbNV#J)4TSʝE,N@:e^<mʁfS:6m "Yҝ\J,I ߬c1Oیmhty8)/.jӰ[7IG@sk ;wdzђS&{ĩh`RV-Ss9DQNHP$S}{B]UZ:=e3!4,@h^ dz X-t>u+QtIJyee8t?vDR GGVGŲ:#v Ió m+Kn[}+RZD7o3:u|9<$ΗٻK{&'v\MBhA8CNZ:?ר =f!&FD >ࢠxݍo^x8oYq{㭛ƐrI9 LrΜPP^ X7QsChmj ѦL%X8׭`Յ:W[YOXy2v )i&4o2qG *7AؼT"G@S צd%"OO6pUF=ݯP|k/*!>`Zc3 ]4$sZcP.ѥ͋p3A7ѥ\R[$`IP.UDlA+W!dok Mf_ g͌$ީ!)Dא x.,aYҬCe`AD$:uLjeI?p8sc/l02Qk]kbn&V'l?U͓!hԱAࢣGhѓٛ8Ttġ ݎ2j ica_vgeDK UF#5$ 芦2'O <jZ=չFi>EN %9'D ԩ~s¨F~ҾB?>60JL?"G#2޹#IuH-,DZ ,k͖-w;RE&Jٌ]Yt1kt}+#ڣ(NY&e;4q\\k(f$.\n[ۢr+!B8bp\|=5R)LQmoܶ,Gz@fsV_ 0>FtwIMBbc[ y -~nZaGtŵ&;~pv3v9wdFuYTF];zvJ\,nYO6k;77eR 痨.=,A؆ax~52+t8),yH$:[仡TʥPň"rJ{Bh};rmPw;rb)1JiV[ tg=@ُ}~̓{i5F,ms{_`r -ڼy4yh+h}]?s/"dK4em%{#Z {Y6_rmZ DriCS)wZThC!#pbO7e5!+pӖ%\]Ů-0Ka]nzϳ>> 'QamT\ȑ҂ӝK!8pcZW4G9ŋq3+wdQ zdaz/p`Qݞޒ¯Qo*ܓ VW|OU-`뒱nuwoG\E5CF6B0o_RJ\|7H>\{)ʗL0>VP̯TLoqٕ۫ۖc|ː~Nmnv%6K H$:, ٶ%2ϳϐ,c^T5,ɊׯNWƶNF Y3M2t䘖!r2`S[?1QuK)]j}U. OB%zzΦtd_lvF$qa]oUBҵ>=`|6}a͛]R؉,Q.}:ϥ zlV mwsyk) yPuB7 d\1.7펩:g9[i$x 'jLVo|DX!_iZW&Dfr} >Cve`r'y&zegP}˺.%kBCTn]]JbV%$D ; '{W{_:{VBtlc{Ukv$yg[] Df={<]2 t)'r<6({t nŃ*%a'ĥ}ATKkH[IAjq׺4՗Eu=~o->+&#'9~V DK AP(_8䎺i|wt':FS?{ҧbRPThI&ݦ$\- on_"ySA{ek#(ECN_F9}on8϶ڌ G@@6H4t{Q}+DCiZR^`s>g7*j
    Enjoying the preview?
    Page 1 of 1