Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944
FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944
FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944
Ebook617 pages13 hours

FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944

Rating: 3 out of 5 stars

3/5

()

Read preview

About this ebook

“A lucid, highly engrossing account of a fateful but little chronicled episode in American presidential politics . . . featuring a large cast of personalities.” —Richard Kluger, Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Simple Justice

Although the presidential election of 1944 placed FDR in the White House for an unprecedented fourth term, historical memory of the election itself has been overshadowed by the war, Roosevelt’s health and his death the following April, Truman’s ascendancy, and the decision to drop the atomic bomb. Today most people assume that FDR’s reelection was assured. Yet, as David M. Jordan’s engrossing account reveals, neither the outcome of the campaign nor even the choice of candidates was assured.

Just a week before Election Day, pollster George Gallup thought a small shift in votes in a few key states would award the election to Thomas E. Dewey. Though the Democrats urged voters not to “change horses in midstream,” the Republicans countered that the war would be won “quicker with Dewey and Bricker.” With its insider tales and accounts of party politics and campaigning for votes in the shadow of war and an uncertain future, FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944 “deserves a place alongside Theodore White’s histories of how high and low character, fierce ambition, and dumb luck play their part in the nation’s choice of its chief executive” (Richard Kluger).

“Jordan tells the story of the 1944 presidential election, and he tells it very well . . . a clearly written, well-researched narrative.” —Journal of American History
LanguageEnglish
Release dateSep 2, 2011
ISBN9780253005625
FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944

Related to FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944

Related ebooks

Politics For You

View More

Related articles

Reviews for FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944

Rating: 2.89999998 out of 5 stars
3/5

5 ratings2 reviews

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

  • Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
    4/5
    David M. Jordan's "FDR, Dewey and the Election of 1944" is worth a read because the election it studies has often been overlooked. The backdrop of a World War overshadowed the election at the time and since. Yet this was FDR's closest election, and Thomas Dewey was arguably FDR's savviest opponent. Jordan describes the election contest in clear prose and has done excellent research. He highlights the failed and almost delusional effort of Wendell Willkie to regain the nomination, and characters who once were major such as Governor Bricker of Ohio are evaluated again. Jordan also shows the prominence of anti-Communist rhetoric in the GOP campaign; I hadn't realized this previously, assuming that the wartime alliance with Moscow had placed such criticism on hold. Although I'm not usually a big Norman Rockwell fan, Jordan (or his publisher) found a superb illustration for the cover of the book.As with any book on politics, there is always a danger of giving in to your own biases. Jordan clearly favors FDR and paints a picture of Dewey as a somewhat soulless man. On issues of war and peace, he depicts Dewey as a straddler, although I don't think Dewey's practice of politics is that different from politicians through the ages or from FDR's; Dewey's goal was to try to keep his fractious coalition together, and he made compromises not unlike those FDR historically made on civil rights and other issues. Jordan puts context around Dewey's statements by using negative editorial comments (such as saying NY Times "demolished" his arguments in a speech). Jordan occasionally sprinkles in observations such as "If the depiction of Hillman happened to stir up some anti-Semitism, well that might bring out a few extra Republican votes" (news to Jordan: The Republican party wasn't the only one that had anti-semites in its ranks). I wish there had been just a little more balance in the presentation, but Jordan's biases are a small distraction from a generally well done book. I think that Jordan is a little careless in his assessment of GOP rhetoric criticizing FDR for the depression. He repeatedly and unnecessarily repeats that the Depression started under the Republicans instead of trying to understand what Republican politicians meant by such criticism. Were they saying that FDR's policies prolonged the depression? Did their rhetoric appeal to anyone? I had always assumed the GOP just avoided mention of the Depression so it would have been valuable to have a more thorough discussion of why Republicans thought FDR's handling of the Depression was an argument in their favor.A few stylistic flaws to note: I think using FDR's "Fala" speech at the Statler in September 1944 as an introduction to the election was a mistake. I wish it had been integrated into the flow of the election narrative. It was confusing to suddenly have the speech pop up as a done deal halfway through the book's narrative; as I was reading the final chapters, it took me a while to realize that this important speech that commentators are discussing was the one already presented in the introduction. I wish a good editor had broken Jordan of his habit of foreshadowing events with useless phrases such as "remained to be seen". Many of his chapters end with this annoying type of flourish (quick examples: "(Willkie) was not, however, out of the Republican picture, as would become clear in the weeks and months ahead" or "Perhaps some surprises were in store.")
  • Rating: 2 out of 5 stars
    2/5
    The presidential election of 1944 was one that took place under unusual circumstances: for only the second time in the nation’s history, the voters went to the polls to choose a commander-in-chief while the country was at war. Yet as David M. Jordan explains in his history of the contest that year, Franklin D. Roosevelt’s re-election was far from a sure thing. Opinion polls early on showed that, if the war ended before the election, the Republicans would be a slight favorite to win the White House. This made Roosevelt's candidacy an imperative for Democrats, as they believed that even with his increasing health issues victory was possible only with the incumbent at the top of the ticket.

    Jordan's book provides a blow-by-blow account of the campaign as it evolved over the course of that year. From it he conveys to his readers a good sense of the personalities involved, the issues at play, and the course of the campaign through the conventions and during the two months in which Roosevelt and his Republican challenger, Thomas E. Dewey, canvassed the nation in their quest to win the White House. Yet for all of the strengths of Jordan's narrative, there is little in the way of an in-depth analysis of the broader factors at play or an effort to situate the contest among the other political contests that year, save for an acknowledgement near the end of the book of a few notable victories and defeats suffered by candidates in other races. The absence of any deeper exploration of the forces that shaped the campaign or decided the result is a real disappointment, one that limits the value of Jordan's account of a presidential election with enormous consequences for the postwar world.

Book preview

FDR, Dewey, and the Election of 1944 - David M. Jordan

;dbook_preview_excerpt.html}ےIݯ侈M3oROqxnI8KC 3dW"Ko>~`e>D~{\P^I;l=~~g/UW?~ճ/~S'>;_M۶Z᫯j?m|?| ?V8;گC6T;?W9V?Tvm_==ޅ0ʟ:j+7ûp\id0Tϟ;ou144ɋaQWk8U;VmZ۴o ϪPL.yۈWOA~Y}8=c7AЮlQn盪y_*le02^?||+^ֹvZk&^<^`{yw7J؇ںuh=]\>>aՓ4\̓M? >F K?L%pn'ZxijVcN ~/^v؄ AgھyI殩deWrO څUorWY4@JnӶz:U/|6z! 'm+ۡk?A_j"L~H?JOÄG`/:L ac~82`8w naxlXq]+t]!j3@IZ,u~ d?R\t91^.D |Yc͕E >TX44ك5Bn e8.ͮ꽓+QqӡAl<0qVPС 3G;Lx@bϪׁ+R =C+g,;B`v'QsA7⳽̽]F۱CCp)Jt>̝p')fzy0f6]'6Vu;sˆyn xnv"/}6v|qQ2h=ŧJlE= 2V?k/׷٫q'rZ#cqm?rۡÑ`?NKjQk&K#j7ÿXK8{YC7bV_a[T^Ԓ;H:ԞȽF]L*ptčR-vgiedGhƬD1{JB,;L$#lmMo,#@MqYK͈q@6vhWݫ4eDM4!lt0Lt=^3>뾀E/}(BVϴ Ѡ2%-x--vT!EvĮ\PWQ@48Ē5] \bLjDMsy%6nf\$ /t{QC>tYCY@>@֢,0tD*LOPTrpk?$ժ, ta[wUkVxދ9Eڹe\|! Ϊ熽 -M䐙 bWedDxXڮmU` 4˕ APL؟VX)ա݌'? }X./}?4v OfAFy`eyٚs8gyr!Adp,/o5cD/޼@ldyBl1b(TbyQx*J۝h^Az9Ԫ#i1sG9 ڲ4 i}Y:s'Bއ];ibbU:g|5 +Yڐã4f9gbzׅtNSu0i(hVa邓rLPiq ˣGvDŒMmB]{&TЉ'D?Ʊ^ =F- u@~t]@ф@h|˫>s?=2 Ϧb p8uڝ7^ 1I%Vg.ܵQ &C 涖pΩy;˰͢B ad>@?D\TwXj䧈C/ף64@7U-1*ŽQb22#v<)8Vy;D m E~ - 6&8H A-,ө=!_# $fd!FAMhy1zS)*ݞ4EUWY0T ), -RҘDˈL/L>;O0sa x#cB Nd8&vfwL;z$² &>F(F9 @裇X5ReD,fo'p%[-&E$CȈ=||Q]`zs/xp[كW .V$H~7P o"w8篃h 5;ߋ-N[Пp,>llė^|z9cB8:_c|-T+qR|ō~^ȱyڽM)TFSݴb-dn %cz'8V7""x|dcC>=JVVG Y_^A50oJ{?z8ey.ç}~mCfTa'D,f.Ŀny|vyGG tx8B#OqwaEHc!cIl@]H" ;ǵFS ϵhyxTT1=7QUY 1^'.y3$r6ug$HA NPzvHE.' &;/Y)UΔΛWo^eo_?aLnzv{b&uQ?{zTg-X\mz}!jcn~'KM4 i䣡|/8[ȹ neDTD؄鱮.z,h|QQxH3_MBoX:"/F3ƚ wc"}`f>2f ζZ`:5DM}}!HTqob\Dc(Z6$[`a51BAoʊ}}""yOHx`)nq-ro/ay3k5'bo/gڋc8B& k#%$[8ŋ3[AC;j]NZcQk2wJG=2r v$s~mo5x$/-ᴭ[W9><>+wm6Ŵ@ *AAaYBO;Grf50`6ι ?!]Fb<d"(*^@-TSʆ.Aʌٶ;qxde˖C`NB4=;DYfN$o=ybA%!7L|X< pFS~{*'n1ۜ=^i6KB 5wpuS.o˄-!B%.bl:FDo__: CDP5ޜmdc#zX(S uϪP [O ϴ5 8Z b!'}vRB)%ߊl,%_ yD+EٸOk NB1`~ۘ!%*I񚜦S` _S!PG b=G1yOz(5DZ %Ͻ@X"^/a|Pz䓕 2(؛wLb!,%l{ty k 3(9HT9g2P31KlgL!\N'KնR v{?;g5cqsfgm#* | Ie*-1Ǔ\f6I>/;*T-ldnCpY, J{7RXRˡBz?=ZV%Zt#9FbG3zȉl =#%:-;*-+αkdkTb{S+Nֵ&T;H<אF!I$cxB[+Źoïf8!XWc(&1wYK$D]q͢s7Fk.׮.)?*x`D(1?TEaȳsbHѷi k3~#` X;N{6<ͽhjI2qg x'Vu/DC$/aM*?*hAx _髹O@SWS ֲ =*sPF1i / [@RW/;ْo|̷4FKP#}ژ @ i=9tG{:7@%f$}CVQn<)6;[,Yz7td,㩰w9pn6t4"X뿢՟n`6[jVqд荺zb Uŏh,L[b S:jX D~tDVsl)/w-WřTj s"JSC4, "<t7qHHLԥ),c]X" Mc_͢@bWOavISC>C n0)X썳R_vr⹻Q= B_!//9: n~W.lu&"\J?fi"v^[b" D&zqjS*ҙӠe ;I";sAJxdb)ki6zb/4O<%!Q^#0MC>ͦ*/ x%ď7(K1)Cې#Ux,{D#BXYc$? VsN"o #K% Ra0ye {y9ģOyoыӞz? 4:7ҵOS葁Io[̀!@#v+K!!DWrgA\*bNG♬P^t"LDnwFPe씼&/,˟鼪c`9A7P!JGӣ1ӰT Q*N3(C/ L:2#ѥ/FSܩfňX6 jJ%B賣.q ޶D&y#HbaƚUJTRˁ,Wzww?ͅṆ̀dv}=S7ż5h+zaĠ̂gwOdQq/sFk?ɪvxMN#%KՍ{L= s?Dm }(>Z3xiDh2 r88NQJ.(~D!S +Q]AX[[+ޙc)^y;qTb>s>F 94_"sZ[r/GW1Z?2,}-k gP W'p<4|iAI>1|oeKS)U0ŗwlz P+7{{H7mF@h M-G$ch)1w~RC O^i^$ƣ֋9}T2F# 1'nhʓ{9)pcS%3D^֧'O$AQO Fw.Ⱦh)sg".5rnXQ"jHchz@yҝ,O= H3 qHWTHwPrk|yke~), R1>fv"?>th.1x1Ow",4‚tjEVg1& _|G=~{%4 L sȠ3lsl q/-ANr3a#$MP'=B=Dbs$R fYThndH>:YEkvZL[6_=j/_ɻ(+'V0!SUlD'9ٚ;[< d6ːc?A9 a [@U2ieKbiYFTf(|&+1V~CKfͺIQ/A.b4bU̹v"ӌϥڷcdRp3:{53r]#,sX?4^g",zo#ҧym,t0`@"b]qfH? rA@6PcOjJC8221Bu}f9;@x\-cssJvPm &$kYx5e ž\F#|F$;z()m` ̕)`5Wz\1C b5U0,?m_:}qh"UK<`%w"C|*F߫XgE@]Y͝)IC 84W@WYݰ `CorT1:WTXwĐ Q3Q[UƌXRÏ س G~坾Ro_遼1*LR&ՠ2v#YgS}qfW@u.m-j̑GZj`pZn:z4Qʋ.q &1׸8(2ě$?O_%yRw 1:t 3e3#v,FgU03wZ@7Hsvy3,Uٖൺa네;cK`܈ьGpJPmqήb6e-' *:kǀo:MKFՙ^:!i㓼)"NSTo[ru* |xM'TZĬWUX$9gP04rs\1 j1* n=˚Th y15~z'-@.8E?1`L֯zhY9o<+@{zAsgBKTwv-xW6D֊s [=+Zk_~SFuS5lC|6S nzyymh#i0CTQ*l Pf?NdAGuٜw^ 5-hU)w.X@ܑD- LhĊ11'i|URnXAΏ4M&k3[o%ؚPsW&}seK$#^y?͝黀x(ݒ$u}DV4yYńUߏp*4ɚꦆH3jĝ+/׸A,&m@&=XǭR+Q($@$Aflgmpdg9^02>Eύ^'aHأD\ebx(#z,Hˍ ' bY+4:R*m吱_h(^2ekQP+n bOE촛',UfIVRj-v,<10Z;=іRZ#]'@9WЏW4XӖo;#ro4"웪aefJ\{,3ێ-SnYFddj|kxE5<XF"@W3ެ~<%>hUؿI7q,bo;^3BdA6) BTMWӢh"!j}NRsQTu%h0Fo|;E._*2~%kVPGRpEʳ9!*XA˴0hPLĴgۨT:`*_}E s.WۊixH|G)%Lg4t#7z]]Ue'B -Lİ PCrl*j )acqBW qnz4L]&JLd䥷ӃBkAwWҤ|F&zhlJm )U# dڌ-N3E.Xo@7 A}P%Su=R&HXK>;ICdVsWP {OEx1-N|*ΝY2͋] &NʞgҞWzzQawjb?ΓAImܩGT$겛qU# vL"߬e Q"x?ZHQނR]8Zx&t6bY`\dNQno{x#>Adr$5"OJ̪7,hfyY3%#hb dL" n+ROTlyVם_ŨhE>k kz!$ݴD~dGthƤF4jϴXs<;p- g$-'j>sc?8dtV.({V_1Qust"Gs4"Qܢ3Ɉ?T ~$>E7ƍI☉r[o,6+*!2x!Y%kut(^T0GLJ;phDdy VvY+PjQS3*3T= 1']ėxΔ,Im4rF T1% }|IJ-ifoZhLRqjT='e: kc O /Qӿm6.͙/ ƀ17b\8)z1n{LeĄ @서1C̢/rN߰PoY@[s%(7xd d?j-rɰ`vkDtv`OMnGtȄ^ZRӲwHf5w-Ѵ.+ 0̫[.Vtʭ0QhU|Q iU,KmBf &>8G-:]r۹Y$ z9:y!vbZB#eNKhEí]Va mBTעhdXKK9"Ε[7P+l#}Ymdr `*&xF^{3vۡK4o7ov/qkPWVŹ\*GS iY>։( zMR Ќ/];ZO/kHqƹz-Eb|s_y{86R'Vha {.o<'rV[^[|/ڤ+^ܡ Nhߪ$diZoc"wj'1A;\>JȎu N%/#2O ϫlOF⠵`0%V"=|:|,h@9CT̷~ʴpKmil4:}繤y|+NW1=63$D=QtEƭ"3.F-Uoɣr% k"ܣtwK,™X¾?A 'vCƚVUW.A<2kX_[|F0x!$J}5ZYlCcbﲚUOgn Xm3-s-'B~H6/ IΦpqdr[l Bp.}E;+cF_+F56l}+n$@*pg_ՠ7RTftnx6smDR6NKرܦ" [ɖ#>a~޹ SZVqrR'Rҋp>M s[,8f`:?OsQ JḰIa|8e{;Y,߹:3""괙F.n^m@Gjd~&3m yk׌ 奬)X3ze| ;TXlxQ2 p;fw%ъHO!;TWڇGt< RFs~N)ɩ`%vpgs˄-b;"58 h3¼Foa3-7޳s1L-r <;-\cI_o&Y(sN1[H]0 , a;N[e (z2"y^,N=3K#ja¢z/ZEƄ@[P6/͡3ΰڱhϝI˭zl`&stHװ^hHtzn7:s5PCv:cQJ=z2R,r?ovp3R" {qQϵ?2 >3Ə=p'};I?k{Dڹž}K 6|;H͓:Gh0d)kfb~$wLb2ƨqv$1צ f Um̨n$w(6i|k, ߄l)Ѻr/P'wh ; 띦4zc|){]X =?cog_S V ݄tC3iE o_Hw O.{Da /]^m6hiBp FP8<@CDž y}S+vZ^@N#cp?ee^#WzXB,[Fq ĂlC 䤶"ܙZ|% =;ۡ0kxk5i'QkQ;W IlX6F H,6loibcP0 -U|֐whw\zѾJ7ނlqYEWVɓnX࿌ /E^0) YJ,v>#`7k')@n& D ~iLt d?jV pI/Ɣ@Ո\jC3i)fJP{4[Ì#[znPlDC| [qN*q;p,NtZZSU*)jRtE+c)xSLvMi6HщzqPF'𱭅r474Q&֖]=>DEUjY᪮+'9/E:=;o1?1ݖc6dԇIԖaN2v{FI\ݜܶ>s%_=E*`Ɏ#-\c/Cxw,ԝТ:}V{2A%J(ry_…)fTKrwop ŴQګX[vZx4b ~  xB\w[9:0b#+nZaHp[.*Ѽl ђrf>#ZU!WzPxH,$I.҂W +2 HfQcܥ"vF_f;ܤ[KbÏvBϡLVuۏ3zw\a[ṄvuO^0T*؅[ug?S׈U+/&Ԟ2僽3%&gM OθEƸtY#V5wXDʡ7>9Rg @wen.NFeCBXc xwYQX<zsy*ھCQ8T0 fa!TX0/匄\b[nEQ|PtJ%'Yr㗯?`;k}co6W}Ba] ƃIb,1F*6)ce=ۓXa罉wl|z> _LݠbiwBC袏Ш͟WH!VW,- AC  [[UD(TX&IS+]h[c +nI-F=rˇ(hG6ڼsHn}O31Ѻ3piCM3EiEgbPuwdy& W%OrA,w3멈h T.ypz ۯexv.KoL?HBhƅd  kZAn]4n1;sB 6zvq_Ԑa_C = o1[ ذ0WˋP yJQ ɢιz]67wS|StDXTtlRveA]2N8 5 aKm* Zo~ŶGޅpbXE9Q/&@8Dd 뵟:zL^ρ:\Mp=dSo-ƣlx<{r7#i,\xe%g$# 񈷪Kވd=NԨ\OO|bS,2/NfSD*EE)(beY GLڋ7ocTnBF^%ѮiDN?eZc;H;9z<0bKpoZxmE2Cgo5ZƚUn{O3b(vߜc_*ܚu?;W{1\DPwWZG2s~.VlH`R۫v~X=;KvĒsՉ>Q#_/W1˗=bdi]XZ RW^l,'ܲF_C[\N0T1Բ B{+[[T#B|d&/pLclW17/KMO{~O@sp()Чl酲? ٶ~OȋvkKkY>,-6gU!6 :y+r>7鵹ʬa؃.q.pg'z|}2QYShWu`'P+J;N0ha*GxHp/wꊠء&3#|VXБ+T C(U)=$8bQQY 4+˧!.}+PGůyØsb++&kj/Y(]2}gk{4^Cds)1<#Rx/]aO (cx޻c60-`.8[nYu'w;oHtتg/v'ejj>:Q)Ejuq@kX4Xknxc+1vW4[ȘȀu+:<$1{̸lSk dٽe]o`8[1wvZnvKdڨ;?$OlA,##ZĽ}~3 FY',KIЖZcM#8_Q E41XӣE_uC*A@T9p/08&7YqVz"
Enjoying the preview?
Page 1 of 1