Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

Hell and Its Rivals: Death and Retribution among Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the Early Middle Ages
Hell and Its Rivals: Death and Retribution among Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the Early Middle Ages
Hell and Its Rivals: Death and Retribution among Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the Early Middle Ages
Ebook689 pages16 hours

Hell and Its Rivals: Death and Retribution among Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the Early Middle Ages

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars

()

Read preview

About this ebook

The idea of punishment after death—whereby the souls of the wicked are consigned to Hell (Gehenna, Gehinnom, or Jahannam)—emerged out of beliefs found across the Mediterranean, from ancient Egypt to Zoroastrian Persia, and became fundamental to the Abrahamic religions. Once Hell achieved doctrinal expression in the New Testament, the Talmud, and the Qur'an, thinkers began to question Hell’s eternity, and to consider possible alternatives—hell’s rivals. Some imagined outright escape, others periodic but temporary relief within the torments. One option, including Purgatory and, in the Eastern Orthodox tradition, the Middle State, was to consider the punishments to be temporary and purifying. Despite these moral and theological hesitations, the idea of Hell has remained a historical and theological force until the present.In Hell and Its Rivals, Alan E. Bernstein examines an array of sources from within and beyond the three Abrahamic faiths—including theology, chronicles, legal charters, edifying tales, and narratives of near-death experiences—to analyze the origins and evolution of belief in Hell. Key social institutions, including slavery, capital punishment, and monarchy, also affected the afterlife beliefs of Jews, Christians, and Muslims. Reflection on hell encouraged a stigmatization of "the other" that in turn emphasized the differences between these religions. Yet, despite these rivalries, each community proclaimed eternal punishment and answered related challenges to it in similar terms. For all that divided them, they agreed on the need for—and fact of—Hell.

LanguageEnglish
Release dateJun 6, 2017
ISBN9781501712487
Hell and Its Rivals: Death and Retribution among Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the Early Middle Ages
Author

Alan E. Bernstein

Bradley L. Garrett is a writer, photographer and researcher at the University of Oxford. After studying anthropology at the University of California Riverside and working in Australia, Mexico and Hawaii, he became an urban explorer, photographing off-limits urban spaces in both the US and Europe, his exploits have already been featured on TV, radio, GQ magazine, the Guardian and the Telegraph. His latest adventures can be followed on http://www.bradleygarrett.com

Related to Hell and Its Rivals

Related ebooks

Related articles

Related categories

Reviews for Hell and Its Rivals

Rating: 0 out of 5 stars
0 ratings

0 ratings0 reviews

What did you think?

Tap to rate

Review must be at least 10 words

    Book preview

    Hell and Its Rivals - Alan E. Bernstein

    Oabook_preview_excerpt.htmlͽ˒$Ǒ-+.w)H" JP jB[za,{fV7toz/n)|9jfzFdDfA"+j֣o>(N>(>~ߛy=C_}+_׿³Ǐ_C;V}_abjJ~Tw-z'.b?4c3gY[SW_=}㡊~d525]C*TϡǢ9M޻y6)wuf3{p?6};U8~'QHm/,N 6| 6a.e3i%vjVxl_5ۧ}?~&ܵ}NUlzk< N&8du\,w߮߄MѯpN~%ɐqje0'j;^ÐO_bMx/vTW߄1 OZwM3n?qG $õ+tO~Vc>iW]/#"j=GK*6V$O˙otÑo<ͨɹ6r> 1KoۻF{df+7aſy`c9q: $82!(Bl56ЮBQM.C1v:_Ʈ9#bㅬ 1\{\UO}/>j^}vIGQHsDM(딉W5oNm oñ3"ժ:_mZe O(7WIZ^UھxJn0IFVQ(q3rAq'B^$(Oʀ %PH|#6-D$q1H1xU=0#mh9\~@頧<5c?B-n쯸8@-hˍ%*KiUÑ̛ Xc,<uhD2ef#k' ׏rgkBr̛m{QWN,-hKH˩& 6j H.~ϱqdm qh7 8 #3^S~[,G(#1aM!+geQCs drAy iXxVJ&]N8ε,c<qr&^*#[! XHz%7Xί^2S'K&ts@<2Tݐ^]ղ;!T@z.}19D."L\-Lؽ&z*YMr\`z qSykT4^LH6B {ۋe[a59PF3V8hjܵÈov_Л)0(1Q(S~El2CvJ3vYS:+Bsx 'M/Y蕓 ֳ,.]2}d[rh GU1}s:r5 ЧQaw@nqoHH27%mp͖t,Mxg9e1W*Wi2@޵Q' cDV hRɚ4147cb>%7`rw:FDk19{1ADP8͎`NCA*Yu,SSZ*|8 b+Ÿ @Qdu> Ԅ_ ;2(,rkoQg`#vA gpiF(w(GSIrF+`r6+p[¢'h䵇idz׈x ܵ]>.Y^TX=iޜ*lĕʢ4f i V`Üe(k;2Zײ1*7䖵A{ YѕC~h[$- nV [;M_]ey.e+E1U=zDDf"݈)|F 2vzJ0;з~F W҆9H(?5._ƿX~f~*a-K70"/<A$1&Z1J,oa.\6!Z8)ѝ?4B#B B`*͟yeqEFT||? bɮ,9 ,awȌ*}?VK H̨]!vC4)&y ZkL_U؎䌓נ^3cQI"4{-"NG#EPwPW% ; dє3$vӗjϛC&rm{#ڤ:!U_0I6vE &u!Tbd#ɀC$(N =/EP8;u }Rh DsEYK#Wk lFFu'+\EvǮ3,To͓߼7חr2AʯA)&ԛ5=;泀lYڛkoq^i/ADy]UgtFLG`,nҁcNr0E)5;U Dab- CvBiby]PGb"mrI32^hjG9v2wwl$ PY.97;hS]3x栊fn^$+FgWImVJt6b <{{@]\W׿_Ko ܛrN4] pMurz7'_%ޫlja ܃KjWiA%K\vxהb1ǖR8ȟgbZA0ۢTttCrQm?˭ "|jIn pn(_L$@G\p5ݜ!d+8yL[a@j(Y KZҚV*=P h"\C:B[s^e\z&EH k[TV$c\vnZ%xLix1; !`T~HU«QnftU=yWȤe2~u}}{|u~v*95%^q &)%WET,;Bh鵜bdJ&.[ܳ-4&B^ͻV߈}*Ƿ7uu,oNhnvm=)=S@H(j ACH'+ [PՓ'Ozg}ZAFp#ԥ#.zܱňI9P_f:rc/rpឫ.k5/"\7Qc2+, ^<Q3'^Jb3c<ɋ) ү@(B_2d 3zkZEo9QY+,O򱕺h Tqll#._\hj0MѠDUS 5H0RPn͋Aw4T 3M衣K-PQłR RjkH7oߔs,QBncv1D}.eɽN@39 )!F v Q0,@'O ICWڗdMz*|b rĘۜz۩?ɓ K"1@Wxۤa>klHM^jSOlS4 G~L R.³Dbnc&;qA:91?;0فM#,bB/Mۨӷ_v ˾2&XfC;H ͮȃ U/ڼ4)-w ^40#H-(gQ#K?x2hbaw>&}SK!NRKfaAȡ,7{jRP4ϋכbf~m 6(m/]4JOBȘ;G4,H<̺sp [«%ʤlj4&uSz(HMFSu"Š]j,_ nB}_H簢KKq ٕ>A5 0>\*;O<RH:mk$͡b'?a+nZnZT?ڢ̼ ̬Gaɍ!eR]җgRs 8XL\"ٕ4T|loM݃xM;|<64E^?b7c w"|/[Ϟa 'A~Q9H ~6L> )#,2]n5t#d`_:F#<=s N3dyS#p%lQT|w;uNI"iTR=2J ܒLXxĒY t3C)LbB?7U*4ghz0UaZ5e[s1/kQӤ ES|*B g H-eθ1v_s*ʩe%c݌sICXF\e Ӕr3*ֱn< GI?#_0T\\OߣS׵jDH(hG 9X@uurBԼb3.T MH`R𞛘!P+F0Y &څuV oQtb9G@zr$@P .D!mԬ:zXf y9bKY+ub(CGd[u 'O$k}Xȴ2I"@fj ޯ699SBT:%^\ apZ'1mK]ŀJ,PlQ/eݺRIR;kd`g]`.ML#Nw3)->Ke- 'R !rBEbKL7X3B7ADO_bIתcgOkjfd˒|a o-dzIdK:[x*yx'|Ce3hbXVR; iz7>PH>0fQYF+>5t Vi)(D!:ZޱQX7X/~5D*) \ ;GO^;02#RmC 2WXÛM C4k/1vLZVOea./"RD$J?Po.@ooK7t8e)&Mz7a 5]HMB>$c0VIjvK#S 57K_~UjpL搝{-Ҍs|{Ǖh/IFXI|iZӑy6_-Zm) 0N߼쭾N#Ȇ$WPy ?Ye("qfYYǡ e8h8J9Wf}# jtElf2)ύ+%f%; 5uB? L :UDeL[V Pr;#P#eʕ= m.&/Z[q) DyT vSp*kGO98b_LR e'E; Uf#4y h zOVȆ= ,jg(&Gecô'D)_{Q]v", Vl]B5c9̅HsC 33u^gaDa\t4l[؊PJ7!7TRK%{M`bˉzu>作 ќ_53K"BfCu76+DMqan+&Hc|NOB#"JrPxL܉oɪ%cpu2%qħp[`rIPʉX$yH.5^M($%XH7苳!CaAbn e>19?Yy(HQzf==|GD|uPJek3Q;>YjVX:xS8s4xDZ})[v}nH7U%A^"Sy{:$:.TN=OnYl dHԯm8u{qz:e1NIһRܟ"wq8ÏؐoY&u,Ks!C <isMfy20;5+!h%S!OoV1pL{ o-ȥ5:m ymv$)2k9k ^]WM)9ꔞWw^g/͓L]4[,ix#l|>E!QQ3b T-Y Z^A*0HmAF'S!ܼ e)1fCMoe]Dy$MP*V),UDTk sۡʃ&glު} dE;ßXh0N vPQv u< 3 $5[u08,tniBF4B8="탣Xp@Y !jDFni3{J)`%9Rӻ-*Yø<;:s_sacnc0kgebPMg;+6Ziۣ&Su xK?)Bֿo] &rA+,0@ x"&Gya#s`ņQꆁJ^h~N$Oz[UQuX*ɧ " O gJYMTJ=Ω;Q6Y݆՞"ըi|KM+/>%gBgm`Z)©UYʔ#ҲE#U8*Nuid CyÔ"niRFT7+k۟p1 V&3]hsRb2s0N,Փ+Tk?/ 1AН2]s4fAb ]5^]kܠҬw?L>&^s9-ݨCS;C Ig"bI&h[ܵxqlry9}{/{[^`/AbӅ y& 9Ww>'KKAs`Zݑmp|e-j0LsNh/1#e+ @/]J:x(j&kT\  ,d,JҪY!ˬH]{߿,<7_ ]ƽ7pˁ IWigsߜ2Wa2ou 2%DR%m] }?a>'77Jjj(MOթg%G2# _Rder 4AeɹvNTSh v Jc94N-izDTzhB"|$ 9wB|o{e?CQg P v/3@} ]kC"4{>(X'$":<�,^{FZ; [t&eUb[u(o`Zmg@Fmӌa?8$R,фmV%+;KPsrQ3$l#t79[ĸ)sPb 4O#i9#ڧOKUg MU}yεBVrz;llxbuOB1 4$Ep9LFN="3D ιĴWdx4rP8@hSH)a)Iw=YxsՅbgtu>[k",U|FGn 5KFD!,7Qx:#ILO?)p='/@uIaCHx)( <K*.(my{ Zr cj@G_.IgX2A"KªS<ۛsNJHtM!a֋:QoE):a˲kjqjWύ+^ÄGL/9߱@REfYe#'$,{svՓf`wʸVZQ#ưm2ycǣ@e Uf9ׂa6a<Ҙg@Fæ0c»(_\kx }X>A*PIh(Z^4*dK 6Iѣm KN,vNtwAb-h.. 8L"0$\N!9m,b3&펪3>wŮ;S/QFa["؟et^_3{=a맥>\-a {!] 2).D}ޯy|qyg0V֗ uiNWx:HM5oQ4=!VF`0^ĠyXt8_r]9d1Nd,36| o|ҭ7wv%FJ[WYۯBBMlSCFVGƗp1E/<f` QOEق;Y뾿R|.5J4,m2lLVnfL!XY 3)p {#UB#X ҇h `?hVLwCP<1c؏/`j 3ؓu6Ņ6Gë́T!cn(RGT3n/:ͯo^׮OM]~/Gm`\t UpKHS)8x^# >FW4xK{aJ6vi:kc/oЮbGRsKsjEœS;Skb/X7-wr(jR_#$VeFWCGhUт^ۖ>E<:N1\ȚWɱ$-o \,0e'3*#We`.^daѬכ$+ ɳO8LKb ,Sjζv'sg*^lkc$#~m5e}HL7@Hrp|ƥngNk FDQBTlJdTY 6SdT ȝ Sӌ*LQ}.z/;2-PIbXjD+KD$3jNw'ǠdUMu8$nP8x5yv EG%&p^dMy٘9!h2 @l\q-On<< ¸>~TNþd|r]}?ou?пb;'z3R:JH++aЖ#6JzESfZ[y3ƃ2JQ Go iqy,{Ek[9ᄯU11cHmaQ,b^(Ր7ZFJe6YX# :]=tWBs~PNXtZ#w w Ivd:G,͔K+6aS? uGX^wU#ê eK97,e*:iz2cxC裠}N62+!yibr4RHBS4œ3y^Al;usx.N9βgWYbs߻}&CAt17?S&|A8 b/y~fwɇ)'!|}buo7lc |`.r˭D SVSe:@-sI^NAD+ ~I5O,qmyi f?2ӢL~tR iy}ѩ]n֍#:GU޹bѻ-GhHZ ػ8\%ýs,ȡ6{\q@ @\?y*ted-x}&6("-r|hW6#pBJc)@)!G~m'V6'>-E[sj[qOQ"\d-\ Z ~ Λ[v.\KK ]9*FzS^)yEeN |S._ ^Z"QC 6O6KP?əORVKz!i*$:iCD8> r},4D&'yRimу^.UC7nǷLEd\*+A#*doNQELy+)YRyaw֫L/uZ%`Yj͚T5Y+}Ѭ_/s$k%烞13[T]#9?Q=oC]0˝ /pîeF~agfUː;b=Tw#P@mM¬E<nۧH7>%}7Ѕ໹5U)!=Slg6nέ>4>ߵ<@ܟT~"r ~EΥF8g@U6uz7 sEp)+ gmLVfC)! ɭU(@Mf )A)e,+\$=jyR幸#E `чN=acægMr:K5 "2'\[?Xnuޝ 7ML5CV'yfMO?:ryO Zo FmVO"{Ή: Q\3_,Ga%|C(#rvw2;ZTPNw9lSCuk @ P Rfܴ7s3"C}7퟼XmE6* x`#`dd1Ng\l=To}ƹ3+j0-q;d$BOɢp٪fԚ;Yĩا@2s+%ΟZkm?w'vUkdsWҋ/WR5WfA$.Mˉ&YU!t[uu?(-J [Qc:F_XcGZ~:-|Q.;%\A*3'#X277E uvK}Cm =l}wCz#,Hu ("\N~q+!?;idH%DqFQzm%˙ h J) g53)('Lq,8#:EY_=s5M 6.`B#ֹ,E7lMG ap: khn 3/lFk?OQU,&h>Gxr4C%p"Aó<;2g Ր [q7l>{}6aVGkjf/@>w)2'N#5 zנCuQwu$BApʝz~c+hu ^mUǂ\-NjaV7Q 0ccZ)D'HZҼI7 @s$KB.u3S,1^ǬXzR\=Zd) Jq 4)U`iQjdӀMDvq=_3^CYw! ʮfZM %t<Nٍ6fҸ:cPq~%as̭U4#!3*Ea_7~fK9&;ktoXXiKn5[rc8,"y*]%Eb՞uB0:a[ǜV4mqR^boQ EʢJ%l47Uэ~NmpqxǾ:2g ?zB/v)ۙwavD}>jǴ/* ζ6B8n L9nqz m9xRDuŔ6uxrRzWv3.2>$3~Nv` Տ,/U~i'%EVQ) {8,Ӽ6UC/̻;tt!*+-Fy-XI<b:7:=PhY.*-"hXǘI/ ¡7vUQa^7=|* On/Su\!S`\m, ygs04פt^=9ȪΝ:2%)۲&{+>(јbe"~ t{?X,mK|M$gz~S=B^Dk?㛘C%mc,%bt6WIZP `⡃dOoF! %6IF]G!>g`rfyږux@|hcE~i?1*a~D3.2LlXFT*.pG( BrzŞ !]Syg%B`-L̻ {i[98,X4zMEP^.:k^he V/u9hum,% b 29%Qٽ85~N l֨: g~"Ce+B98KecA~$L@^ LBG3>Yc]=Ք}B@FKE(Rhje^&HCELX01gZI*)8,3L()?!@EJ @DHYt/T[)Х0y{GNb昅=38tVS`_xص$=fOs&5kRZ( @RK4[p>)uN"3HX(=X RVIu ~ٗپS^xD#VAkB^OVQnρ<*"Z(5EXlR :`Y~Y9gպ$-\Im?2e <ݯ(R PE 0Z+K}d~)qsҝ\?kf ,P6{ǒUN wGr: Esq|V ų狤e)w1o/tT$w(sD:+mKY`Y^g b\`>Ex EvʂB*2AqT;IW%D-@Jg?Ua7x\]`: ϥ ~Zp[OBPz #Ԗ;G 4?ǽ!I%(|9 'MSƘ4֗Pp 5/gϗTyMzYzƪuP]U9cMSlj&f$h]m&ҳY3#f;e`a< iLctFel4Vۨ빺$pgX$pPiϭ;n'Vy׬l$KrH]fبg8) a.Ni@-г92=rֲ"(y}e&wzgYn{7/=.Ѯ/&GpEɕLnxѹhN-i]jlV 5gXq) 4ѢFm0Xѝ8=9LYR Cbjg)w ,.D jHkQ EhEzOI.4wLN413( |̩pS^P/z x /a8FVh36|ii)&By.ͦ9N+͎xRjK}i{k|~ЂI]U_{kSFIT ?9@Q / P^yze^Hߓʥ`7LFaeea>3º,~'ؚ_C!,*603ðGͳXvM5v5sCU$p?s3enX\Z>tuȚ⤽',O:+XԙirUe1NDg6E-Dߣm_aZpiޱKJgTѸvC%3_j(P!*JQ9@z /yU47<У)2үkQ2'.^wyJ4=`iIɔ 械^uTl|)RQ~pHXܭO #aB~ 859"3e_aTȷa 1ֺH od Bfl*pQKyZ;wx؈9~sKjWiBƠ3سL7!.AnPe{ͭ%n:WywrGP| (ԁP16^kh"8)&f1Kȶ>\2Ͼi;VI9[eH sbCkϭ9Fټ+-+ oH4a-=0[wX(-9j` >Mٜ7Z;, V[vvm /10c74,0MR@s_EGX)+bHl2^d1P~o_2bXYF^םW8Z}ER1-9}Q\r6+R['1LIE̙ne&~.z4`Z,AzΚۈO>x=)ۑaR,IM,Zxj?MkyW`j$y¶ 2zusA{tùG$ࡳs3(PSA]P,F[8#<]꩏^NfmLΠuR`$-JqqT##b&o\a7uvʢ@~hU1QJupO0$ aO O~RhK.ZVaryK})xL`:C\'׿ɺtQ.͗OeOՅve;8b wrc6yu߼{{Dz(^<;QZKj[yiՅf+yjs&t@K4 }`pܞ|@]X5ZW ȗVJкʼnyy ky2_N.͖T,U=M\ښu΍x%y‡,)ү6ZIم`ɱ6R:3m?y Kֶ\g]5: M{s1⹹ST=(,$W@w]y,. 5S0>-#b4x=@b2ٗ9ߢ4oFj;O%%H{צ|Jq7{=c
    Enjoying the preview?
    Page 1 of 1