Everand Logo

Welcome to Everand!

  • Discover millions of ebooks, audiobooks, and so much more with a free trial

    Only $11.99/month after trial. Cancel anytime.

    The Indicted South: Public Criticism, Southern Inferiority, and the Politics of Whiteness
    The Indicted South: Public Criticism, Southern Inferiority, and the Politics of Whiteness
    The Indicted South: Public Criticism, Southern Inferiority, and the Politics of Whiteness
    Ebook556 pages7 hours

    The Indicted South: Public Criticism, Southern Inferiority, and the Politics of Whiteness

    By Angie Maxwell

    2.5/5

    ()

    Read preview

    About this ebook

    By the 1920s, the sectional reconciliation that had seemed achievable after Reconstruction was foundering, and the South was increasingly perceived and portrayed as impoverished, uneducated, and backward. In this interdisciplinary study, Angie Maxwell examines and connects three key twentieth-century moments in which the South was exposed to intense public criticism, identifying in white southerners' responses a pattern of defensiveness that shaped the region's political and cultural conservatism.

    Maxwell exposes the way the perception of regional inferiority confronted all types of southerners, focusing on the 1925 Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, and the birth of the anti-evolution movement; the publication of I'll Take My Stand and the turn to New Criticism by the Southern Agrarians; and Virginia's campaign of Massive Resistance and Interposition in response to the Brown v. Board of Education decision. Tracing the effects of media scrutiny and the ridicule that characterized national discourse in each of these cases, Maxwell reveals the reactionary responses that linked modern southern whiteness with anti-elitism, states' rights, fundamentalism, and majoritarianism.

    LanguageEnglish
    PublisherThe University of North Carolina Press
    Release dateApr 15, 2014
    ISBN9781469611655
    The Indicted South: Public Criticism, Southern Inferiority, and the Politics of Whiteness
    Author

    Angie Maxwell

    Angie Maxwell is Diane D. Blair Assistant Professor of Southern Studies at the University of Arkansas.

    Related to The Indicted South

    Related ebooks

    Social Science For You

    View More
    View More

    Related podcast episodes

    Related articles

    • Article

      The Classic Book

      Feb 18, 2021

      Everyone should read this book, even if they are not particularly interested in history or indeed the countryside. This is one of those eye opening, revelatory books that overturns myths and centuries of received literary wisdom. It was, and still is

      1 min read

    • Article

      Jan. 6 Panel Faces A Different Legal Test To Refer Mark Meadows For Criminal Contempt

      Nov 26, 2021

      The panel investigating the Jan. 6 attack are taking their time before deciding to pursue criminal contempt against Mark Meadows because it will be a bigger legal test.

      4 min read

    • Article

      Trump Did It Again

      Mar 18, 2023

      Trump Did It Again
      3 min read

    • Article

      Blood and Sugar

      May 4, 2021

      Blood and Sugar
      9 min read

    • Article

      Southern-minded

      Aug 13, 2018

      IT HAS DEFIED A THOUSAND OBITUARIES, THE region that winds from Virginia to Texas, through the Blue Ridge Mountains and the Smokies to the Delta, past the world’s largest peach, the Astroturf grave of Hank Williams and the gates of Graceland. The “No

      3 min read

    • Article

      A Klansman’s Horrific Reign

      Aug 15, 2023

      A Klansman’s Horrific Reign
      12 min read

    • Article

      IDA B WELLS American Heroine

      Feb 24, 2022

      IDA B WELLS American Heroine
      8 min read

    • Article

      The Problem With Patriotism

      May 6, 2021

      The Problem With Patriotism
      5 min read

    • Article

      How We REMEMBER

      Jun 16, 2021

      How We REMEMBER
      10 min read

    • Article

      Letters

      Sep 4, 2018

      Setting aside much of Sandra M. Gilbert’s problematic cover article in the summer issue, “In the Labyrinth of #MeToo”), I would like to focus on three paragraphs. In the middle of her piece, soon after describing the rape of an unconscious woman behi

      6 min read

    • Article

      Who’s A Daughter Of The American Revolution? Answer Grows More Diverse.

      Oct 5, 2021

      The Daughters of the American Revolution has broadened its membership and historical research, leading to a more accurate, inclusive view of history.

      5 min read

    • Article

      On Safari in Trump's America

      Oct 23, 2017

      On Safari in Trump's America
      16 min read

    • Article

      Making ‘Necessary Trouble’: A Historian Rises Above Her Roots

      Aug 22, 2023

      Drew Gilpin Faust’s memoir is both a moving personal narrative and an enlightening account of the transformative political and social forces that impacted her as she came of age in the 1950s and ’60s. It’s an apt combination from an acclaimed histori

      3 min read

    • Article

      My Father’s Voice

      Dec 1, 2021

      My Father’s Voice
      13 min read

    Related categories

    Reviews for The Indicted South

    2.5/5

    5 ratings2 reviews

    What did you think?

    Tap to rate

    Review must be at least 10 words

    • 2/5
      History of the reaction-formations induced in white Southerners as a result of criticisms of the South (or really of its whites). Maxwell argues that “southern white identity has allied itself with the unifying sense of inferiority,” leading to positions that go beyond explicit racial and gender commitments to rigidity on religion (conservative Christianity/creationism), education, science, and government’s role. Intriguingly links the New Criticism to other reaction-formations (the Scopes monkey trial and its aftermath including hardening of fundamentalism, as well as Massive Resistance after Brown), deeming New Criticism fundamentalist in its insistence on the primacy of the text over the text’s history and context and in its elevation of the feelings of critics over other forms of knowledge.The book seemed to attribute responsibility to the South’s critics for making the things they criticized worse, which I don't think is either fair or a pointer to useful alternatives. E.g., “Public criticism of southern racial practices had sparked the fire [of Massive Resistance to desegregation].” Or maybe it was … being ordered to stop segregating? Like, I’ll accept that scorn doesn’t work on many racists, but I do note that the least contemptuous person in public life, MLK Jr., was assassinated for asking for justice without H.L. Mencken’s vitriol. Maxwell identifies him as one of the critics who spurred backlash by pointing out that the civil rights movement was in favor of justice, thus (shockingly/insultingly) implying that its opponents were against justice, which of course they in fact were. Also, Maxwell notes the existence of Southern white self-criticism, but doesn’t blame them for sparking backlash or investigate what gave those whites more self-doubt/moral clarity. She spends no time on unpacking the “no true Scotsman” denunciations of white Southerners who supported at least some reforms. As she notes, Roy Carter Jr. found that, though segregationists constantly denounced the biased media as never presenting the “Southern” [white] perspective, in 12 Southern papers, 27% of the coverage was of pro-integration stories, 12% was “progradualism,” 30% prosegregation, and 31% neutral. The “[p]erception [of lack of media support] mattered,” she says, despite the reality. But Maxwell doesn’t address the fundamental issue surfaced by this mismatch: to this group of whites, any criticism was too much criticism.Her project is very much to understand people who wrote things in 1928 like “There were people in New England who wanted to destroy democracy and civil liberties in America by freeing the slaves. They were not very intelligent people; so they didn’t know precisely what they wanted to destroy. … These privy-to-God people were sending little pamphlets down South telling the Negroes, whom they had never seen, that they were abused.” I would like to spend just enough time learning about them to know how best to fight them politically and rhetorically, and yeah, contempt probably won’t convince them (though it seems to be working fine for Trumpists’ attitudes towards us). But the fact that segregationists have lifeworlds too does not to me provide a justification for blaming their radicalization on people who disparaged the South (truthfully) as having more lynchings than universities, even if those condemnations were often issued by whites with racism problems of their own (looking at you, Mencken). And I wonder why it’s important to understand these guys without contrasting them to the people engaged in the violence that they only tacitly approved—formally disavowing violence but blaming Emmett Till’s murder on civil rights activists. Without comparison to their more integrationist or more violent white counterparts, Maxwell gives us no understanding of what the alternatives were for these semi-polite racists.Maybe the most sympathetic reading is that she’s showing how backlash worked in practice: Hardened views meant a consolidation of antigovernment, fundamentalist, antieducation, antiscience, antiprogress views in a white Southern identity that admitted no nuance in things like constitutional interpretation. Despite being released before this round of white moral panic, the book definitely makes clear that the current hysteria over “critical race theory” is the same renamed racial anxiety that has stalked the US—including the white Michiganders who now embrace the Confederate traitor flag their forbears died to fight—for a long time, both as an undercurrent in the Scopes trial/bans on teaching evolution and in Civil War apologism taught in schools. And the historical links with the New Criticism reinforce my conviction that anti-“CRT” legislation embraces the idea of the objective correlative—that simply teaching particular things will create shame and guilt in white students—in excitingly racist ways. (One of the Virginia segregationists she writes about said that the worst thing about the fight over desegregation was how it generated guilt in whites. Also, today’s right-wingers are furious over any attempt to show that racism was integral to American history, whereas yesterday’s were furious that liberals portrayed racists as un-American in their racism and that liberals also portrayed Brown as the realization of the authentic American ideal, so there’s that bit of irony as well.)
    • 3/5
      5771. The Indicted South Public Criticism, Southern Inferiority, and the Politics of Whiteness, by Angie Maxwell (read 21 Dec 2021) This is a 2014 book linking the Scopes trial of 1925, the 1930 book by 12 Southern writers on Agrarianism, and the 1954 Brown v. Board of Education decision. Each is discussed at length and the author strives to show they exhibit Southern cultural traits listed in the book's subtitle. Much of the discussion is a mite heavy-going and did not arouse much interest in me. I presume many Southerners would disagree with the author, though much of what she says I tend to accept. And I have a less bleak take on what she sees, since one cannot help but see much improvement from the days of Massive Resistance which flared up after the Brown decision

      1 person found this helpful

    Book preview

    The Indicted South - Angie Maxwell

    *ebook_preview_excerpt.htmlێG%+>TIJR4H&)1%ކIOp%!U0pmP5}0O?їfn4Ō7˾}?>'o>)^}Y:|囧o/_¯o?|z?WOv/veWxm諸oTe]oֳQ޴ j8]/Y[ 7m=6ŷmoMŷg~*N]?|u,v_)*c/ծ uqujy]x;ujU?aۻ//7o//.^,ݿ|7?.O sxuۧ/^M]l:?0߿7W|S8_c∰}gg/>z.7Mj8xvî(x݅>;n |_]\we9๶uxQ6CWqS'rQc('B  쁪/m{]CL8v8~/zQ6b=v岪}EWB2Tjo<[YU5}^-L&حB;02K,cS%* VWÇ]/ǃ(nU}P5^ۨ=7 u lUXhUV:vĴ,Xu˪7k b8.\/u;lÉW_W]?B3L:[jop[.zR@z?*O^6z\e9ۮ<~mDI5}W_؁|=xO|^N,W؄.IFy HiRl+9ap<|Q݀ *mq9m j PƚYCzϊOM B9~}?jWqgٌApVԫ8:Dh ߱h@GQb&\k"g/>d>hGO?yǟ"kj݄#ܮF}W]IjC\z *)?-:_]7m[XF)o/_}ڽF^ymy7ճ'Q\]z-`Qk]u]fooy0X6 HkoMXC^SvO.(?\HPcR_W+x[^SP&8_0>xA2_ͺ䆊꾆_CruJuUo1|!.|XMq~Lq[QS-m~b0K瀓>@wM ! ~!lPJqx_/(/:8|t؄&t` P4) ˋ'\C/ `591H^IHjC ԦC //8־+iVQ`s_`W#t~Kd\GIAھg"O__>OLf%D Q_tASQ _ZSC =) ]RWNA_|ջO|b&^ r He5)(`a P`~1mYkukHЕUB*<Hʾ7eE)hx1fW{0a; ?| v{mAЬ{Mj(^k̂ R2؎E҆?j7cI\ Y~npn%k$6]uKt_-q" -k] \HsK`Nߎ_ >Ǟԏ0 PjkTwx܇|hOB}Lhpu;zIySt[z$*7%4;ݛT> 3N{I&O` qIMoZ [)ex2 _[ 8 vmyQV=f Qbo mo+i j_b˱qXY5v~Y~*/0r]eP{v߂JHzxp\ ȡ? @Ƹ-Lb\ ,˵.HuzsX=!j-ݵuЀ=?0}g_*a'p (־ %rSc5b N,=p֎mZ8 (` 0Pɒ^'7Ţ6v Z YK("3^"iuw$`K]ipeWi?,_`YaoBO<d'mCYRз y$8@,qG/[˄VgR1E.,g |=K 0UM=˦/i $DIX1P=N$hLwzwM0i/<짙o`W72O»v(/9qDW 5vǾ}V<=+^a/Zp/z~!pzne5m{KmIoޅ$TA̕M|~z7i>]bRI*=2˪?WH,NW~3U— >1y4|$s )UD%L2snL_RM0+9Q_HxPu+_ PN?X~WI\(a4'qֺ@G+x2&Nڅ`Es-(+!n6B]z|Ǧqa-!apP"E:zjOLcxx]w8T2jWbW A/z"V._Wj";~=u!a 媝|BϚѪkh뱃؀c5$- Z`fP>oǪ]Fٿ0 =mjۃdFEoO.<|ic-;`hd,(:Ұreg %؁7%)!J%=ƵI+8AbBG ?`*yYVm-Kp1g '!? Yk8p?[h'Bw ckSmC`fN4/߾zPSJ&9ͼ~ ȋ-y@->%8 ǚFһj@"btx!y̞oo+~A*z"pbv@nW5-ɂi8!j>(ޯeܖ@+z^0;1oi9|suJ߸lƟCW>-gF [oiI&]栢 $xY Hv)pm<>Y2tXwT'SqUutv 8LaFsG%=aXlPiCitPtîZyM]uyG)`W<4 C|@n*5OH3 %ZA}XbO3b(NJ6,Hf Cr:*I^5Q!hl*q$鴪%8_q9YzLXκs- #7[ *V(Dw0N%u?t_ĮSo-$08-Ht l*br\IsZq;bK:ӄ@f%O ` &-*TJa⦕ RG(k&z-g t&`;tmf6/qeiآ` X4?0陪I{X~ÍX67[3+oT=ĕ|Vr Z-sc£ \zӲyR 2ے^CR& h'~(1w#==y_N>/]O3utX])< eq v-/9]6nzŧ!`_ߴ-M$7>;ˁMolZ{7l 04mwPx~\_F@C.z7^2L=C\mepxk-JõiG_|)'>*G4c-]>hMU 7a[KQڰ,͞ kۡ'Xh6뽉:!Ϳx̼ ,c[7d'lk t<}7Wn;a&:UoF:EN$uqxHT+6? g*U7tC`o `ܡُw4q84?-g| W-cbW$Ăq;Yںwr=L򂠧 t`zޔ5 g,L"w^:CVWmg* Zm %8ܦSh<)q+?MCi`ϸ"%3Қsm 5r3: }Vinkm;Me`g@=Hϗ%;}Rza`L:e+nC,iS E-M˜0GN&bٶa>8HDd AAlF Yz"jyT? ^4,cHDduIJ,dڇ/frMk 4݀h矺sܶ%a#܍jÈ5p8-cyvLRG/F4<-ʆ1awR0)ט!xf7r!"LCGlɱKio7#''!Ž%Y$|iն1#oc3mh2#k֔Ax#X_*Y dnyoar' h3cT"V`$@m;'{=mm }0NxQrB;{~Km2 \og-l ڄ$h[+. 8ߘ4YBƆY9Xu+GIpJ5ww;I$ufRD,2ߘ'ؾK[Av0M m9DeBi"Vr2/ir8C)!r<;l1ۯ.av 3$3d!FpD[:qtR_@r'Du `f󢺔\( dACB/ZzÜ&)yro\&I&(^~z{1!ܷ8UFţO.>|=0x(=ӟ(׿K՟ɩc+J̎uHJ(mxk RVF *pFfʘAbLbIty`"ʯAljoD ab"mx 꾩1(V.7QW=jT`ji=%'Ax_B嚸e/o"ڐF _bV]C%qʭO\xTͦ{F 8!jw¬hQ1BYYBt"=G_$oꘆx^՛$6eelnZ?ՓWm3 \j z|Gx  &uH"co~ӏ=WXg'*_ 0døOp#ړ{u7va"!2[MD@LI!9,Efb P;ޢԤx'MlwMM%ziLLA507-찁1_\$c2~2 ̞19v+b HIk-{z" &0N~vইRj]=,n53GMO1/$f%RNWaxnpP RZS<.,Gt?#_394Wt%W'A$"sRxFԳu.e1~uZA*z{N쾃̄uV̼ =KIҁi1)]x4$!W=|+Cns:{hh79zOdńtC Jl[Z/~_.,?Ulپ1BTo* Ri C,UAXs6L!(\4!!J:juPTʖ@bjу%0k# -єv~cL#xZNj%_<(XH`:SLr~Q%x̫5 }oe?`T3e0)Ř&?J Z?+u#S)hXde\ɠ$0(0Sk0PY9UN5D2ٴw6}>C"E`~]0ߗ'{y_^MU-ΨM-2aMjЂ^&ŕr58sdu`$JCN)4x~TcF ٚy݊b ]bãN_PJ~xH>9  8ss%d{KfR:T5n hp.C4.~`Uu'$jOZxYOfU鶻,-`0 kf/-s*|\j^0f4`{cZ]l4'9HOף]0'X5ymc\9NX{~-Q(͗᫧ [Y%No -k2_+4j0#P[,*8?93dZp.sGf T)"9S!@1Mt藬x- H %hqB-A*RiB؛;cɸ-lSۙdHxlwJ4 钊"#C)exBt1!uБҥ"SlTi>k{e?L]&lTAUGyv&:+a!]&UMUޓP~Z'?AU6ͽ1lgYz bÙX.kh@^OF vw FIB䕻ewX &Gm8ȞR>G=X]ʻI:#O B\z퉪w@Y[$)ǡ8=?,. %=!'rZl;IS'(o~!ֿ*U7Ir'Td1mh_2Z2?w=Cuw=b9HDLڹ^1{3noPrL:}ZD '$4'_t`)s$$dgѺJsc2fqZSQ}~SETSdb=a70o`M匡}Y=1@Mw#LޘRy1*-H 1=[/R~@2}BNNzFqS(yO[O)$hneWLY799@-Z+)Ғ,#glLsg먲~N:D kdX$C{1Sމk-P;aj4߂gzߗ+[Z;ђزaB^Y1EG(T2Ō !ɑC- -[`dI`xIEGos9K۹pk%` bҌ7=0<U=ԥ 76 Oc7f:ԷlD \މ3l[h)Ol+7HAW<|v$މ0xO%c iR^H@/{$ :S+:\W盼9((1EL\3[aZ}$?v`S&{jf'DMeUۓOBdžW* 3qˡPࣩVQճ7gȨLR2cMhZdD@UDj]PxdPv{6n8&NCxTj%0՜ȣw3ԕM9mJ;Jyxd/5ΉU;ɥ<'d5LQt }Al &ĶuvE :FS KBscpȉXlVw uqbV::,#egx;#֦&Y_Znϔ}W-n9 ߱JI4]RYfRf2YYTvsB)g L¬+zRPㇿ7Y:KOUY:Ƨc{`!c7nLЁlnP+ j8c5OjZa67=@g&z4w!&^[i=,p"f@xkp{$ ,Iyʓqjh{^y*\ԅ=a>rhiw),J6T]ķ> t]F6tXZ*IU 1 anz҉, ܪ)ˆon)yvcQs[[F*$GXtͫWo>TST5IMB0'K);jPwxe;ʭX1^9C[ӝd6KYjDtRy2XmG߲E="f4ܳ|SkT70Yay;15q1IX>97U/??6HΜ|9YR II [0Z17#چE! _Bu6mL c Ԇ*Bf#uG_(OFuyj^hL4qԠ#zIgL:E_]<?C0SBكIhVR.`!$XE\7ZOz<;"2p۫ꦜޠL?G_e#*e3>bNh}R3KU_y3}G慠_k%68V>T=ׂ%̠Jk&)1>%%[lWDbg`E) );Eľ |gIl%@qle6nﲖia1yn*KMQ0fn0 R6+X+ٓr:f$S " X; gB#Dp -Ɔ.l#}Μ}khSk( oP<] Sz\T}!Jxm, rGa.cI-q?T)ψ*͉vSw0c!^vvw$艾C28dMm:'.bY|QV[/us )ouYs^|V<wәi$+}*  Eoso„XlN5 !\K'% eM%r,! ]B^] ¨,b7p{`><+ RQNcT4:2.lƭEͽ;(=PrC H6 :\q^;c][ZR=4-~q=[ƃYtReC#7#}m\ځ%_54Ie=:~%3be5嘳 8s+]fK!Q*8һNy9՟H,ʂ-;.:Օao-+f2cW07V%,?8&ŸMSUg6ZRi:hdS5QnL,w'sm<Ǭ0lfL6x(La8V\DHY ǃ2i1;l@V50ö-Mc$OPzב%UFKc:25 vtFhjxrN2 D~Y'9fRDϝ髬brh(92k-}ϮkOɯd1:/S yػ04}cF~8SGŝTF7 -+o(yJN_%Q)=\ L KE@k,L)r4y؎6[vdY'|}> ?XZmr;e%)3,Ma*eV07ֺ5Qm7ڡ%Me([FkCqGϫ Ͽ*;*iU4KHL"k rLJ1dUXu*wRF &镇Jmjbn0r̲p+<-#ÈJ d{1cY9"z=*Ԫ84똫 d&UnPiHt-˺x`1\d]͵:v, ݰ+x8_^ufR4HHЍotKCa!uvGQ[C-mU}RW/mefI?g5XrR9K_kǧkQڅcN:7\GŎ2 o`* TK2Scݳ;JH cD>g#}U׮yG~7\2|;LnzW**&g($&?kR촴h'wP/+k^~B?#̯^@ht rkN\췐rXdo +b~Z6i87GXl^ƻ{ v]X^* nU~*#)&Ľ%]f. ĽM-6 ȺU4?j?^xD5+No< K,:n}J*]3ԃeey#EVL\;;/;r"kǩ<_x_ζa昊C(z8W^ %wUU<ᙻ>EqL1j,EQ?U gXwnq߶D'k,e!4#kEV?i-e[uY$5NLaїo*J,KbuXܶ8)=& o[EǼu]ky>ݘa h.N_/ʴ{?ƸJT.!Fe(LfweДMrK&P|' ,= XP 9TD 3|Y9ly)LU:S3Fc"U;Uû`7!d45t-t[9kM'O[>3cr ,z @m1fl,wY;`A`M$d|:]Y183z[υaV۠0U=฼jT1٤O 6>|B^VNo_5shx+J S}z`V틗8Cv*heQ*^[=:z-;7*LSL0'H-tFS̍8igx+/w?<~~B 6{O.Y<9qW16xsC=p3HY5 yף7`9Svy3ebpj_Y6elMeYBM@|(&,TX7G{o&㇄֣Kr8n=4wye==2ZuٻSbҳԜW^֬Yڬpd,&lveFAjtG,l mk=-71P PdC.y%5- Բmf\7[:wm#=Q,XLVZ0¼ 5 lL5пɮ]\/u{Df?K ?Yb $[ȧ>nW;r,`2fޟ=E"xIXJ?;4d]' c^>|սxd)"ydn/YEa$s1ݿU^)< 襜J/v/`YxF}ruufB3P8S,fʞ8*Ҋ}LY\eWq,X3mta_oniwQ6T cQoBo9u"+;&`xO/\
    Enjoying the preview?
    Page 1 of 1