The Critic Magazine

Time for realpolitik in Israel

APRIL 7 MARKED SIXTH MONTHS SINCE Hamas’s blood-curdling attack on Israel and its people, a shocking act of violence which served as a sobering reminder of how brutal life can still be in the twenty-first century. Since then, six months of intense fighting in Gaza has resulted in tens of thousands of civilian deaths, with thousands more unaccounted for. Despite some early cooperation on hostage releases, signs of a realistic diplomatic conclusion have been few and far between.

Such a grave situation deserves a reasoned, mature response from policymakers here in Britain. Unfortunately, our national debate on the situation in the Middle East has been characterised by petulant moralising on both sides. Too many pundits have abandoned realpolitik altogether, preferring to retreat into sweeping narratives about the ethical righteousness of their respective positions.

Much ink has already been spilled about the swivel-eyed mobs which take to the streets of the capital every Saturday to decry the Jewish state, variously calling for a ceasefire, sanctions or the destruction of the Zionist project. For many comfortable, middle-class liberals, these demonstrations have been the first tangible sign of Britain’s failure to integrate millions of people into the fabric of polite society. Rightly so — these marches have too often played host to Islamists and their sympathisers.

THE PRO-ISRAEL CAMP, INCLUDING RIGHT-OF-centre commentators such as Douglas

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Critic Magazine

The Critic Magazine2 min read
Nova’s Diary
“I can’t decide,” says Rishi. “What do you think?” “The blue socks are nice, darling,” says Akshata. We are in the flat. Rishi has been a bit down lately. There has been some voting happening in local places, but not very much of it was for him. Jame
The Critic Magazine6 min read
The Future Is Blue
SIR KEIR STARMER HAS SOME ambitious objectives for when he takes power: he wants to bring back sustained economic growth, achieve net zero by 2030, restore public services, and devolve power to local government. It would be wrong to fault Labour for
The Critic Magazine4 min read
The Final Lap
THE SAN MARINO GRAND PRIX, 1994. THIRTY years ago this May Day. AYRTON SENNA sits on the start line and removes his helmet, which he never usually does. “The helmet hides feelings which cannot be understood,” he once said. Today, he doesn’t bother to

Related Books & Audiobooks