Profi

Four loading shovels from Claas, JCB, New Holland and Volvo: Four in action

With all of the measurements and specifications boxed off in part one, we can now switch our test attention to what these machines are like to use and live with. Our comparison is not just a 'what’s good and what’s bad', but we also delve into what different agricultural end users will find important. After all, an ag contractor wanting a clamp climber will have different needs to an AD plant, whose loader requirement is more lift, shift and dump.

Getting to work

In most cases on a farm you are going to be hopping on and off several times during the day, so reasonable steps and handles are a must. Access to the cab is very convenient on the Volvo: the lowest step is tilted out 15°, offering an easy climb and surefootedness. Three steps lead up to the cab, and there are good handrails.

The steps on the Claas Torion are nice and wide with proper handrails. The journey to the seat on the JCB is too steep, and the door restricts the space on the left side. The New Holland cab is easily accessible, the climb is not too steep, and it has good handles.

Once seated, it is time to get to grips with the controls, especially those constantly used for the boom and the shuttle.

Claas: precise modulation

The Torion 1611P has a slim joystick that falls pleasantly to hand. On the stick there are two buttons, a small cross lever with proportional control and a toggle switch on the front that looks after direction changes. The various functions can be precisely modulated and mixed to good effect.

The hydraulic headstock locking and unlocking actions are from a button that is flicked in

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Profi

Profi4 min read
Claas Atles 936 RZ Versus Axion 960 Terra Trac: Rugged And Strong In Vs. State-of-the-art Spring Green Dress Tracked Counterpart
We start with a little history lesson: Claas had been pursuing the idea of having its own tractor since the late 1950s – launching the Jumbo or the HSG Trac before finally having success with the first Xerion system tractors and distributing the Cate
Profi1 min read
Entry-level Cataya
Rounding off the lower end of the Amazone harrow-mounted seed drill range, the Cataya 3000 (3.0m) Special EcoLine succeeds the long-standing AD 3000 Super, the last off which left the production line at the end of 2023. The larger opening of the 650l
Profi8 min read
Seven ISObus Systems Compared, Part 2: Tasks With Many Hurdles
Some ISObus-compatible precision drills such as the Grimme Matrix 1800 used in this test, not only do section control but also variable rate along the row. The latter utilises application maps that are pre-prepared in the office and then downloaded t

Related