New Zealand Listener

Faulty thinking

The cover story “Stuck in a fault line” (March 9), misses one fundamental question:

Why is so much money being asked of owners of established buildings for improvements that will make only a negligible change to the long-term risk of earthquake survival, compared with other risks in life? The cost-benefit ratio is out of all proportion to the actual risk.

Consider the past 100 years and the total number of deaths and serious injuries from earthquakes in New Zealand over that time. This total is not influenced by the recent building code adjustments. Now compare that total with the annual road toll and related serious injuries. The annual figure and the once-in- 100-years figure are not too far apart. Yet people still make the choice to travel on our roads knowing this high risk. How about giving people the same choice to enter an earthquakeprone building that has far less risk of harm compared with road travel?

Ross Corbett (Hastings)

The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment seems of the same mindset as the US major who, during the Vietnam War, was quoted as saying, “It became

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener7 min read
Tuesday April 30
Hamish McLaren has already been the subject of a podcast by the Australian newspaper called Who the Hell Is Hamish? and now his exploits are the subject of this doco that features some of the many people McLaren (real name Hamish Watson) targeted ove
New Zealand Listener7 min read
Fast Track To Destruction
What exactly is meant by red and green tape (Politics, April 20)? A favourite term used by our prime minister in his commentary on our democratic processes. Red tape in the past referred to the binding around administrative files. Perhaps the referen
New Zealand Listener3 min readCrime & Violence
Branching Out
Alexander Hamilton described the courts as the least dangerous branch of government. They had neither soldiers nor money to enforce their decrees. Like all public institutions, the courts rely for their continued acceptance and legitimacy on the trus

Related Books & Audiobooks