This Week in Asia

Singapore's welcome of future Aukus submarines underscores 'friends-to-all' policy

Comments by Singapore's leader welcoming a future "visit" by Australian nuclear submarines may ruffle feathers in Beijing, but the island republic is also seen to be merely being consistent in its stance amid escalating tensions in the region, analysts said.

Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong on Tuesday said at the ongoing Asean-Australia Special Summit in Melbourne that "when the new Australian submarines are ready, we welcome them to visit Changi Naval Base".

He was referring to the nuclear-powered submarines being produced under Aukus, a trilateral alliance between Australia, Britain and the United States established in 2021 in response to growing Chinese influence in the region.

Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.

Analysts told This Week in Asia that Singapore was simply recapitulating its long-standing role as "a military access point" for Australia and the US in Southeast Asia, and Lee's latest comments marked its more open stance to Aukus compared with its neighbours.

"This will fit into a long-standing pattern of cooperation between Australia and Singapore, let alone Singapore and any range of other regional partners, including China," according to analyst Tom Corben.

"Singapore also provides access to Chinese assets regularly," said Corben, a foreign policy and defence research fellow at the University of Sydney's United States Studies Centre.

Several members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) are engaged in territorial disputes in the South China Sea, a resource-rich waterway claimed nearly in full by Beijing. In particular, the Philippines has repeatedly accused China of committing aggressive acts inside the maritime boundaries of its exclusive economic zone and targeted its fishermen.

While the Philippines and Vietnam have been more vocal in denouncing China's increased footprint in the disputed waters, some of its Asean partners have been less keen to do so.

Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim said at the summit on Monday that he was seeking more friendly relations with China.

"If [other countries] have problems with China, they should not impose it upon us. We do not have a problem with China," he said.

At a press conference on Tuesday, Singapore's Lee said Asean states had a common stance in producing a South China Sea code of conduct with Beijing. While negotiations had gone on for two decades, Lee said more time was needed still.

Asked about the differing positions within Asean on Beijing, he said the bloc had a "common position on the South China Sea, [but also has] different national perspectives".

"Some Asean countries like Singapore do not have claims in the South China Sea, but we have an interest in freedom of navigation and the application of international law," Lee said.

"There are four Asean members ... who are claimant states in the South China Sea. And these claims overlap with each other, and overlap with claims by China. And so the positions we take on those claims are different depending on where we stand."

Analysts said Singapore's reiteration it would host Australian submarines was likely to provoke China.

"Beijing has very vociferously voiced its opposition to Aukus from the start and alleged that Australia, the US and the UK are somehow destabilising the strategic situation in the Indo-Pacific through this cooperation on nuclear-powered submarines," Corben said.

"Because of the controversial nature of Aukus, and notwithstanding Singapore's long-standing role as a friends-to-all access facilitator for regional militaries, it will be interesting to see if Beijing says anything about this, specifically with Singapore in the firing lines," he added.

According to Collin Koh, a research fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore, the premise of Lee's statement was to "underscore the consistency of Singapore's policy".

"This policy should have been something Singapore's Asean neighbours are aware of. It made clear this stance right from the beginning, even when Indonesia and Malaysia were vocally speaking out against Aukus," he said.

Singapore has been receptive to the Aukus alliance, and supported Australia's plan to deploy the submarines from its early stages. In contrast, Indonesia and Malaysia had initially been critical of Aukus' presence in the region, raising concerns that it signalled furthered militarisation in the region and heightened risks of nuclear proliferation.

But observers say Canberra has been reaching out to its partners within Southeast Asia to allay such concerns, and to make sure they are "suitably briefed on what Australia is doing on this front".

"The Philippines went on record fairly early in the piece to say that it supported Australia's decision ... Vietnam has also done so quietly," Corben noted.

"You have also seen a bit of a change in the way that Indonesian diplomats speak about Aukus ... they're less hostile about it," he added. "Their public position is not exactly of acceptance, but a willingness to work with these agreements to ensure that the region remains stable."

However, Singapore welcoming Australia's nuclear-powered submarines should not be "misinterpreted" as a signal that the city state would become a formal part of the Aukus agreement, Corben said, also pointing out that Australia was several years away from acquiring the fleet.

Koh concurred, saying that Singapore's position was "simply in line with its policy to welcome port calls by friendly partners, Australia being one".

"This reiteration is aimed at underscoring Singapore's agency on Aukus, based on [its own] national interests," he added.

Additional reporting by Bloomberg

This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (SCMP).

Copyright (c) 2024. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.

More from This Week in Asia

This Week in Asia8 min read
Malaysia Urges Thailand To Revive Pan-Asia Rail Links Instead Of Chasing Land Bridge Dream
The last train rolled across a steel bridge spanning the banks of the Golok River between Malaysia and Thailand 18 years ago. Now, the approaches at either end are sealed - rust and floodwaters have gnawed away at the rails alongside the decaying woo
This Week in Asia4 min read
South China Sea: Philippine Admiral At Centre Of 'New Deal' Saga Breaks Silence On Alleged Pact With Beijing
A top Philippine navy official has broken his silence about an alleged phone call he had with a Chinese embassy official but denied accusations he had compromised national security by making a secret deal regarding conduct in the South China Sea. Fol
This Week in Asia5 min readInternational Relations
Myanmar's Rohingya Youths Abducted And Forced To Fight As 'Human Shields' By Junta And Insurgents
A group of 10 to 12 men, some carrying guns, appeared in a Rohingya refugee camp in the coastal town of Cox's Bazar in Bangladesh. In a swift action, they rounded up three local youths with an alleged plan to send them to Myanmar for conscription by

Related Books & Audiobooks