History Scotland

Annie Grey and Marjory Kennedy-Fraser: professional women singers in the late Victorian and Edwardian eras

CLICK HERE TO WATCH a harvest reel by Marjory KenedyFraser played by Yuki Negishi

Marjory KennedyFraser’s autobiography reflects that, in 1887, marriage was regarded as ‘the end of a professional woman’s career’. Too often we assume that late Victorian and Edwardian women led sheltered lives, going unnoticed among an army of ambitious men. However, although it required determination, women with talent certainly could make their way as musical performers. Marjory was this kind of woman. Starting her career at an early age as a pianist and singer, her name lives on in a multitude of copies of Songs of the Hebrides and From the Hebr ides hiding in pianostools and music cabinets.

If you were an amateur singer wanting to perform classy arrangements of highland songs in the early 20th century, then Marjor y Kennedy-Fraser’s books would have been your go-to anthologies. They have been controversial, because her albums were certainly based on Gaelic folksongs, but they had been arranged, combined and generally turned into drawing-room artsongs, far removed from the original songs that she would have recorded and transcribed.

However, I have been researching another Scotswoman who had much in common with Kennedy-Fraser, but who is now entirely forgotten: the contralto superstar, Madame Annie Grey. Newspapers and magazines document a busy, active career for this ‘queen of Scottish minstrelsy’ and ‘foremost exponent of Scottish song’, giving recitals and lecture recitals; a Balmoral royal command performance boosting an already promising start; an anticipated trip to South Africa; and a documenteded seven-month trip to America, as well as her teaching practice running in parallel with the performing activities.

Childhood and early adulthood

The two were born just a year apart – Annie in Edinburgh in 1856, and Marjory Kennedy in Perth the following year. Music was in their blood: Annie’s mother was a capable pianist, whilst Marjory was born into a family which was without doubt the Von Trapps of the 19th

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from History Scotland

History Scotland2 min read
Spotlight On… Clydebank Local History Society
Clydebank Local History Society was formed in 1977, thanks to the energy of a group of Clydebank local historians, led by the late Wallace McIntyre. Elizabeth Pitts is the current Chair. The local area of West Dunbartonshire has an outstanding and co
History Scotland1 min read
Welcome...
This issue of History Scotland marks an important milestone for the magazine. A bi-monthly publication since its inception in 2001, we are now moving to a quarterly format, with new issues appearing each February, May, August and November. Since thes
History Scotland3 min read
Stirling’s ‘lost’ Roman fort
The Roman empire made at least three attempts to conquer what would become Scotland, and their successive failures to hold onto our wee bit hill and glen dominated their impressions of this most north-westerly corner of Europe. We were indomitable, a

Related Books & Audiobooks