The Critic Magazine

KEIR’S WOMAN PROBLEM

IN JULY THIS YEAR, KEIR STARMER UTTERED the words many a left-wing uterus-haver has been longing to hear. “A woman is an adult human female,” he told Nicky Campbell on Radio 5 Live, “so let’s clear that one up.”

Yes, let’s! Not that anything needed clearing up to begin with. It’s not that this truth had become unknowable, so much as unsayable.

In recent years, defining women in a way that everyone knows to be true has become an act of transgression (or, as Pink News reported it, “a transphobic dogwhistle”). Meanwhile, asking a politician to define “woman” is deemed a “gotcha”; that is, a question that shouldn’t be asked because it’s too challenging (if not linguistically then at least politically).

Hence we ought to be grateful for Starmer’s act of bravery. Indeed, like many a would-be Labour-supporting feminist, I’m relieved that the man who looks set to become our next PM seems to have abandoned making idiotic claims such as “99.9

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Critic Magazine

The Critic Magazine6 min read
Was The Bible Written By Slaves?
IN THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND, THE GOSPEL reading for Good Friday is John 18:1–19:42, the narrative of Christ’s betrayal, arrest and passion. The reading is relatively long, at least for Anglicans, and temptation abounds to drift off as the familiar story
The Critic Magazine2 min read
Nova’s Diary
“I can’t decide,” says Rishi. “What do you think?” “The blue socks are nice, darling,” says Akshata. We are in the flat. Rishi has been a bit down lately. There has been some voting happening in local places, but not very much of it was for him. Jame
The Critic Magazine3 min read
Put The Money Back Into Politics
IT’S AN ELECTION YEAR, so political finance is back in the headlines. We have had the tawdry tale of Yorkshireman Frank Hester, the £10 million Conservative donor who said Diane Abbot makes you “want to hate all black women”. Then there was the hulla

Related Books & Audiobooks