BBC Music Magazine

Chamber

ChaminadePoulencR Schumann

Poulenc: Cello Sonata*; R Schumann: Papillons; Violin Sonata No. 1 in A minor†; Chaminade: Piano Trio No. 1*†

Martina Consonni (piano), †Sarah Jégou-Sageman (violin), *Jeein You (cello)

Erato 5419764269 70:09 mins

Gautier Capuçon’s foundation for emerging young musicians is an admirable initiative which includes the opportunity to record an album; this instalment presents three graduates of the 2022 programme. Bringing them together is Chaminade’s Piano Trio No. 1, a substantial and dramatic work in the Brahmsian mode which shows off their virtuosity to the full, and shows what Chaminade might have achieved in larger forms had she not been diverted into (albeit highly successful) miniatures.

Here it’s the leaping arpeggios of the first movement and the brightly dancing scherzo that give the work its character; cellist Jeein You intones the melody of the Andante sonorously, but sometimes gets overwhelmed in the busy exchanges for violin and piano. Martina Consonni’s luminous piano playing is outstanding, as it is throughout the recording, accompanying You in Poulenc’s witty but rather thin Cello Sonata, and Jégou-Sageman in the much more substantial Schumann Violin Sonata No. 1, strongly driven and articulated by both players.

Consonni comes across as the highly promising star of this trio, especially in her solo work, Schumann’s ever-fresh Papillions. She has a delightful flow and momentum to her playing, though with a tendency to pause slightly over the first beat of the bar. Schumann’s characters here are vivid and well sculpted.

A doubtless unintended consequence of this waltzdominated set is a slight excess of triple-time! Nicholas Kenyon

PERFORMANCE

RECORDING

GrimeC SchumannR SchumannWatkins

Helen Grime: Whistler Miniatures; R Schumann: Six Studies in Canonic Form; Huw Watkins: Piano Trio No. 1; C Schumann: Piano Trio in G minor

Odysseus Piano Trio

Ty Cerdd TCR041 75:13 mins

This is a vivid programme from an expressive British ensemble. The Odysseus Piano Trio have matched works

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from BBC Music Magazine

BBC Music Magazine1 min read
Bonang Goes Pythagoras’s Theory Of Numerical Harmony
Did Pythagoras get it wrong? In the 6th century BC, the great polymath showed that certain numerical ratios between sounds are what makes music sound pleasant to us – and dissonance occurs when there’s a deviation from such ratios. But scientists in
BBC Music Magazine2 min read
Three Other Great Recordings
There’s something immensely organic about the way René Jacobs unfolds the narrative’s ineluctable trajectory in his version recorded in 2000. And for a conductor so often associated with a certain operatic flamboyance, some of the ‘agitato’ moments p
BBC Music Magazine3 min read
Ibiza Spain
Headphones adjusted, the conductor raises his arms. Strings twist and turn, the sound swells; electronic vocals ride the crest of the wave. The beat drops. Then, as lights flash across the Royal Albert Hall, glockenspiels duet over a keyboard motif.

Related